Seth Klarman is not an investor you would read about much in business media. He is one of the more reclusive kinds out there. He rarely speaks in public or grants interviews.
Klarman is known for his very deep value investing style and willingness to pursue value where others get very nervous. Some people, in fact call him Warren Buffett of his generation.
Since founding his investment partnership in 1983, Klarman has not only produced unrivalled returns (in excess of 20% per year), but he has also from time to time offered wise and timeless commentary on markets and the craft of investing.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
In a financial world populated by fund managers running after bigger fund sizes, few years back, he returned US$ 4 billion cash to his clients (from a fund size of around US$ 30 billion). That speaks volumes about his integrity and unwillingness to compromise with his reputation.
He is the author of the seminal book Margin of Safety – Risk Averse Investing Strategies for the Thoughtful Investor, which became a value investing classic ever since it was first published in 1991.
Even though the book was written more than 20 years ago, Klarman’s ideas are perfectly suitable today.
Let’s take his help to think through one of the fundamental problems that every investor, especially an early investor, faces while investing their money in the stock market.
What Should be Your Investment Goal?
When it comes to life in general, it’s always recommended that you should set goals in every area, especially in your career. After all, they say, if you don’t know where you’re going, you will never reach there. Goal setting has many psychological benefits too. It’s said that the goal of setting a goal is to push yourself.
Having said that, let me warn you that investing is a different ball game.
The conventional goal-setting strategy can become counterproductive in stock market investing. For that matter, investing is an activity where a lot of generic success principles fail to apply, traditional goal setting being one of them.
Does it mean you should stop planning altogether for your investments? That’s not the right approach either. So how exactly should you go about planning your investment strategies and what kind of goals should be set?
Among hundreds of other gems of wisdom, Seth Klarman has provided two specific insights on goal setting in his book.
Before digging deeper into those ideas, it’s important to revisit the often ignored truth about future. What’s that truth? Listen to it straight from the horse’s mouth. Seth Klarman wrote in Margin of Safety –
One of the recurrent themes of this book is that the future is unpredictable. No one knows whether the economy will shrink or grow (or how fast), what the rate of inflation will be, and whether interest rates and share prices will rise or fall.
What I understand from above statement is that role of uncertainty and luck (good or bad) should always be kept in mind before making any decisions or formulating any strategies in stock market.
According to Klarman the first and primary goal of any sensible investor should be to…
Avoid Losses
Before we look at the insights offered by Mr. Klarman, let’s revisit the iron law laid out by Warren Buffett, who quipped – “Don’t lose money.”
It’s unfortunate that the conventional wisdom, in spite of parroting the above oft-quoted advice from Warren Buffett, is pretty much ignorant of the loss aversion strategy. Conventional wisdom says that you should always stay invested in the markets, which is true assuming you have deployed your money after accounting for the risk involved. Klarman writes –
I too believe that avoiding loss should be the primary goal of every investor. This doesn’t mean that investors should never incur the risk of any loss at all. Rather ‘don’t lose money’ means that over several years an investment portfolio should not be exposed to appreciable loss of principal…the avoidance of loss is the surest way to ensure a profitable outcome.
The notion of staying fully invested in the market shouldn’t be driven by the fear of missing out. This fear brings the risk because it forces you to enter into areas where you’re unsure of what you’re doing.
This brings us to the simplest definition of risk given by Warren Buffett –
“Risk comes from doing something which you don’t understand.”
So how do you avoid the risk? One easy but naive way to eliminate the risk is to invest all your money in fixed income assets like bonds or fixed deposits. This makes sense for the people who believe in the theory of ‘high risk equals high reward’. As Klarman points out –
“Another common belief is that risk avoidance is incompatible with investment success. This view holds that high return is attainable only by incurring high risk and that long-term investment success is attainable only by seeking out and bearing, rather than avoiding, risk.
Truth is that over a long term, investing money in bonds or similar instruments turns out to be riskier (because of inflation) than the risk of permanent capital loss from sensibly constructed stock portfolio.
But because of uncertainty and ambiguity associated with stock performance, controlling risk in stock portfolio asks for different kind of measures. Klarman explains –
…the actual risk of a particular investment cannot be determined from historical data. It depends on the price paid. If enough investors believe the argument that equities will offer the best long-term returns, they may pour money into stocks, bidding prices up to levels at which they no longer offer the superior returns.
Blindly relying on past data – that’s what creates the risk. Things that have never happened before are bound to occur with some regularity. You must always be prepared for the unexpected, including sudden, sharp downward swings in markets and the economy. Whatever adverse scenario you can contemplate, reality can be far worse.
So thinking hard about severity and probability of worst case is the foundation of risk control while dealing with equities.
Compounding money is the premise on which principles of value investing are constructed. And most people have seen the compounding tables, cataloguing the long-term snowballing effects of compounding even with modest rates.
However, what they forget to notice is that even a single bad year in that table can create a severe dent in the final performance results. Seth warns –
A corollary to the importance of compounding is that it is very difficult to recover from even one large loss, which could literally destroy all at once the beneficial effects of many year of investment success.
In other words, an investor is more likely to do well by achieving consistently good returns with limited downside risk than by achieving volatile and sometimes even spectacular gains but with considerable risk of principal. An investor who earns 16 percent annual returns over a decade, for example, will, perhaps surprisingly, end up with more money than an investor who earns 20 percent a year for nine years and then loses 15 percent the tenth year
But it’s ironical that most investment managers prefer the second pattern of returns than the first because it showcases a better strike rate in spite of an eventual poorer performance. Klarman adds –
There is an understandable, albeit uneconomic, appeal to the latter pattern of returns, however. The second investor will out-perform nine years out of ten, gaining considerable psychic income from this apparently superior performance.
If both investors are money management professionals, the latter may also have a happier clientele (90 percent of the time, they will be doing better) and thus a more successful company. This may help to explain why risk avoidance is not the primary focus of most institutional investors.
Anyways, as per Klarman, the second goal of a value investor should be to…
Avoid Chasing Specific Returns
It’s easy for early investors to confuse between a sensible investment goal and achieving a specific rate of return. He writes –
Setting a goal, unfortunately, doesn’t make that return achievable. Indeed, no matter what the goal, it may be out of reach. Stating that you want to earn say, 15 percent a year, does not tell you a thing about how to achieve it.
Investment returns aren’t a direct function of how long or hard you work or how much you wish to earn…An investor cannot decide to think harder or put in overtime in order to achieve a higher return. All an investor can do is follow a consistently disciplined and rigorous approach, over time the returns will come.
In fact the focus for people, who set out to achieve a specific rate of return, naturally gravitates towards the upside potential and the analysis of downside risk takes a backseat.
Klarman explains the irony of the situation –
Stocks do not have the firm mathematical tether afforded by the contractual nature of the cash flows of a high-grade bond…the potential profit from owning a stock is much more ambiguous….Investors thus tend to predict their returns from investing in equities by predicting future stock prices.
Since stock prices do not appreciate in a predictable fashion but fluctuate unevenly over time, almost any forecast can be made and justified. It is thus possible to predict the achievement of any desired level of return simply by fiddling with one’s estimate of future share prices.
Conclusion
Rather than targeting a desired rate of return, even an eminently reasonable one, investors should keep risk at the centre of their conscious forethought. And here is how, Seth Klarman advises, you can brace yourself against risk –
Investors intent on avoiding loss consequently must position themselves to survive and even prosper under any circumstances. Bad luck can befall you; mistakes happen. The river may overflow its banks only once or twice in a century, but you still buy flood insurance on your house each year. Similarly we may only have one or two economic depressions of financial panics in a century and hyperinflation may never ruin the U.S. economy, but the prudent, farsighted investor manages his or her portfolio with the knowledge that financial catastrophes can and do occur. Investors must be willing to forego some near-term return, if necessary, as an insurance premium against unexpected and unpredictable adversity.
Margin of Safety is a classic super-text by a super-investor. Although it’s out of print now but if you can find a copy, cherish it and re-read it at least once every year.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

