Compare two of the largest sources of news in the world today – New York Times (NYT) and Twitter. The former has market capitalization of US$ 2.3 billion, and the latter is 10-times bigger at US$ 23 billion.
This is despite that, in 2014, NYT earned US$ 1.6 billion in sales while Twitter earned lesser at US$ 1.4 billion. What is more, the former ended with a net profit of US$ 33 million, while the latter closed with a net loss of US$ 575 million.
So, what explains the huge premium that smaller-sized, loss-making Twitter commands over the long-standing and profitable NYT?
The answer is cash flows.
Now, this seems bizarre at first because NYT is profitable and has a history of generating positive cash flows, while Twitter remains loss making and continues to burn a lot of cash year after year.
But then, go back to security analysis text books, and a great business is defined by its ability to generate cash flows in the future.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
So it seems that investors putting their faith in Twitter expect the company to do much better in the future than NYT, as far as cash generation is concerned.
This seems a reasonable assumption given that while Twitter seems to be growing magnificently (and that’s why it’s burning a lot of cash now), the monopoly days of print media in general and NYT in particular seem to be getting over.
As such, investors seemingly assume that the discounted value of all cash flows that Twitter will make in the future is much greater today than that of NYT. And thus its 10x market valuation as compared to the latter.
Stock Market Rewards the Future
That is how the stock market really works – it rewards the future, not the past. And people who rely a lot on the past may create a lot of heartburn for themselves as far as their future stock returns are concerned.
Please don’t get me wrong here. I am not denying the importance of studying a business’ past while making an assessment about its future. It’s of great importance because the past gives a great amount of hints on how the business has done across economic cycles, and how the management has driven performance.
But more important than studying the past is assessing where the business stands in the present and whether it has the abilities to remain strong long-term in the future, at least over the next 10 years.
Again, instead of focusing on near-term growth above all else, you should be asking – Will this business still be around a decade from now?
Numbers alone won’t tell you the answer; instead you must think critically about the qualitative characteristics of the business.
So the question you must ask is – What does a company with large cash flows far into the future look like?
Of course, the usual answer would be – It would be a business that has created a moat around itself, maybe helped by a strong brand, or network economics, or economies of scale, or a combination of these.
But the real question is – How does a business get these moat characteristics to work?
My experience in investing in such businesses (and, of course, missing a lot of them) and readings and interactions with successful investors suggests there are three important ingredients for sustaining a moat long term into the future –
1. Simplicity
• Simple to operate business
• Dominates one or few markets
• Free of all kinds of government and industry regulations and strictures
2. Scalability
• Sells a product/service that may have huge demand in the future.
• Sells a product/service that is and will continue to be consumed across various markets/regions.
• Sells a product/service with inelastic demand – things that people need or desire almost regardless of price.
• Can expand with minimal incremental capital requirements.
• Needs low or negligible debt to expand (scaling up with debt has great dangers).
• Management capable to handle growth and scale it sensibly, instead of one that falls for institutional imperatives.
3. Security
• Business not prone to disruption, and thus remains largely secured against major shifts.
• Low cyclicality of demand and/or supply, leading to low volatility in product pricing.
• Has enjoyed positive cash flows, or at least the future cash flows look promising.
• Has low or zero debt on balance sheet.
• If some debt exists, the regular business earns enough pre-tax profits to repay interest charges many times over.
I’m sure there are many more such factors that may create sustainable moats. But the facts remains that such businesses are rare. In a lot of situations, moats that look sustainable are, in reality, fleeting. And the above checklist can be a good starting point in determining the same i.e., whether a moat is sustainable or fleeting…especially when you are considering emerging moats that don’t have much track record to boast of (like Twitter, for example).
Pat Dorsey, the author of amazing book The Five Rules for Successful Stock Investing, writes that a moat or competitive advantage can come about due to –
• Real product differentiation through superior technology or features;
• Perceived production differentiation through a trusted brand or reputation;
• Being a low-cost producer;
• Locking in customers by creating high switching costs; and/or
• Locking out competitors by creating high barriers to entry or success.
This is also true of businesses that are reasonably new and emerging. Consider examples like Twitter (product differentiation), or Uber (low-cost), or Airbnb (low-cost), or some Indian examples like Ashiana Housing (trusted brand) or Balkrishna Industries (low-cost), or AIA Engineering (customer switching cost).
Note that we are talking more from a business perspective here than just financial performance. Of course,
But even then, it’s important to look at how the business has done in whatever little past it has had, and how the people running the show have behaved during these times – have they been rational or reckless.
Look for Intelligent Fanatics + Simple Business Models
A lot of new, emerging businesses are individual-driven organizations. And as Prof. Bakshi says, they are businesses that are run by intelligent fanatics.
Now, how do you determine whether a fanatic is intelligent or not, or whether he/she is a fanatic or not? A discussion on Quora helped me in answering this question in some ways.
Someone asked this seemingly well-intentioned question on Quora – “Will I become a billionaire if I am determined to be one and put in the necessary work required?”
One of the responses to this came from Justine Musk, the former wife of one of the world’s most intelligent and most fanatic persons, Elon Musk. She answered (emphasis is mine) –
No.
One of the many qualities that separate self-made billionaires from the rest of us is their ability to ask the right questions.
This is not the right question.
(Which is not to say it’s a bad question. It just won’t get that deep part of your mind working to help you — mulling things over when you think you’re thinking about something else — sending up flares of insight.)
You’re determined. So what? You haven’t been racing naked through shark-infested waters yet. Will you be just as determined when you wash up on some deserted island, disoriented and bloody and ragged and beaten and staring into the horizon with no sign of rescue?
We live in a culture that celebrates determination and hard work, but understand: these are the qualities that keep you in the game after most everybody else has left, or until somebody bigger and stronger picks you up and hurls you back out to sea. Determination and hard work are necessary, yes, but they are the minimum requirements. As in: the bare minimum.
A lot of people work extremely hard and through no fault of their own — bad luck, the wrong environment, unfortunate circumstances — struggle to survive.
How can you *leverage* your time and your work?
Shift your focus away from what you want (a billion dollars) and get deeply, intensely curious about what the world wants and needs. Ask yourself what you have the potential to offer that is so unique and compelling and helpful that no computer could replace you, no one could outsource you, no one could steal your product and make it better and then club you into oblivion (not literally). Then develop that potential.
Choose one thing and become a master of it. Choose a second thing and become a master of that. When you become a master of two worlds (say, engineering and business), you can bring them together in a way that will a) introduce hot ideas to each other, so they can have idea sex and make idea babies that no one has seen before and b) create a competitive advantage because you can move between worlds, speak both languages, connect the tribes, mash the elements to spark fresh creative insight until you wake up with the epiphany that changes your life.
The world doesn’t throw a billion dollars at a person because the person wants it or works so hard they feel they deserve it. (The world does not care what you want or deserve.) The world gives you money in exchange for something it perceives to be of equal or greater value: something that transforms an aspect of the culture, reworks a familiar story or introduces a new one, alters the way people think about the category and make use of it in daily life.
There is no roadmap, no blueprint for this; a lot of people will give you a lot of advice, and most of it will be bad, and a lot of it will be good and sound but you’ll have to figure out how it doesn’t apply to you because you’re coming from an unexpected angle. And you’ll be doing it alone, until you develop the charisma and credibility to attract the talent you need to come with you.
Have courage. (You will need it.)
And good luck. (You’ll need that too.)
Wow, isn’t that some really brilliant advice?
The conclusion I can draw from this answer is that, when you are searching for companies that are emerging now, but may become great, sustainable moats in the future, you need to focus a lot on the big human problem the business is working to solve, and most importantly what drives the people running the show – money that they want, or solution to a deep problem the world wants.
And then, as Justine writes, to really succeed in the long run, you (the management of an emerging business here) has to be –
“…unique and compelling and helpful that no computer could replace you, no one could outsource you, no one could steal your product and make it better and then club you into oblivion.
Of course, a lot of emerging businesses that are disrupting existing ones also stand the risk of disruption. So, as an investor, I won’t be a lot enthused about businesses like Uber or Airbnb (if I am not a private equity investor, that is), but ones that I don’t see facing a big risk of getting disrupted in the future.
Of course, capitalism would create more competition for such businesses…but then it’s not competition that kills a business or shareholder returns, it’s the business itself that stops providing unique value to its customers that kills itself (and is thus not able to sustain its moat).
So look for what makes the business truly special for its customers. And look at the management’s intentions – making quick money or creating long term value.
Also Look at Numbers…
Well, when I use the term emerging moat, I am not necessarily talking about a business that is very new and has no past performance to show for (like Flipkart, for instance). Of course, I am also not talking about a turnaround here (like Symphony, for instance), because it is a rarity that people can spot such turnarounds before that actually turn around.
But it’s important for a business to either have some reasonably good past performance to show for (Ashiana, Balkrishna, AIA), or it is showing an improving performance that, your analysis suggests, may improve even further in the future (like Relaxo).
If the company is widening its moat, even if it’s an emerging business, it should show up in the financial ratios.
For instance, the gross margin and the core return on equity – provided the company has low debt – should be improving rise over time. The company should also be showing signs of generating positive and higher free cash flows.
As far as the business characteristics are concerned, it’s important for you to ensure that the business is either already mature or is headed towards scalability and maturity that will ensure capital protection (a lot of emerging moats may not emerge at all and thereby cause you capital destruction).
How to Research Emerging Moats?
Well, the same rules apply while searching for emerging businesses that apply to the already emerged. Just that you need to work a bit harder here, and then pray even harder that you don’t end up with a pebble that initially looked like a diamond. Anyways…
• Read up all the publicly available information – annual reports, company websites and presentations, competitors’ documents, industry publications, Internet search, etc.
• Kick the tyres. Talk to suppliers and customers, if possible, instead of starting with the company’s management. If you can get access to the management, meet it last after having worked your way through suppliers and customers.
• Keep your eyes and ears open for new, emerging information on the industry and company. Set up Google Alerts on the company and the industry, so that the relevant information comes to you as soon as it’s available.
Conclusion
While I am still in the early evolution stages of my thoughts on emerging moats, for whatever little I understand as of now, an ideal combination of characteristics you may consider while searching for such businesses are –
• Business that solves a key human problem – like selling a unique product/service that would do an essential job better, cheaper, and/or faster than before, or provide a new product/service with prospects of great and long-continued increases in volumes and unit prices;
• Small/medium size of operations – as compared to the opportunity ahead;
• Capability to scale up and achieve critical mass (potentially decent market share or revenue base);
• Large existing profit pool i.e., the absolute level of profit of all players in an industry put together, which gives the company an opportunity to claim a rising share of this pool. Such businesses can grow fast, which causes P/E expansions and ultimately high shareholder returns.
• Business that doesn’t need lots of capital to scale up;
• Industry less/not prone to big disruption that the business may not be able to adapt to;
• Managers who are intelligent, fanatic, and honest…and at the same time not prone to take dumb risks (pursue reckless growth, acquisitions, debt etc.)
Overall, I am looking for an honest management capable of good capital allocation and running an efficient business that has the capability to grow stronger into the future. That would give me a great margin of safety against potential capital destruction.
And then, I am looking for whether I can buy such a business cheaply or at a reasonable price that provides me a good expected return of around 18-20% per annum.
But now, the next question is – How do I value such an emerging business? And are the rules similar to valuing an established one?
Well, let me try and provide some approximate answers to these questions in the next issue.
Statutory Warning: I, Vishal Khandelwal, am a registered Research Analyst as per SEBI (Research Analyst) Regulations, 2014 (Registration No. INH000000578). This is NOT an investment advice to buy or sell shares. Please make your own decision, as blindly acting on anyone else’s research and opinions can be injurious to your wealth. I may hold some shares discussed in the above report.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years