We all take pride in claiming that humans are the most intelligent creatures on planet earth. That’s ironic because the definition of intelligence is also created by us. In other words, we’re giving ourselves high ranking on a scale created by us.
But the irony doesn’t end there.
Inspite of wearing our intelligence as badge of honour, we all make errors which our “so-called intelligence” classify as dumb mistakes. That’s because no matter how hard we try, we can’t fight mother nature — the traits deeply ingrained in our behaviour by millions of years of evolution.
In the popular rationality blog Less Wrong, while explaining the thoughts behind the blog’s odd name, Ruby writes —
-
A humble recognition that no human is ever going to attain perfectly true beliefs and be right about everything. We should always believe that some of our beliefs are mistaken, we just don’t know which ones.
-
A bold recognition that notwithstanding the impossibility of being perfectly right, there is still the possibility of being less wrong. Everyone believes false things, but some believe a lot fewer wrong things than others.[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
And so the aspiration of LessWrong is that by dedicating ourselves to learning how to think in ways which more systematically lead to truth (what we succinctly call rationality), we can meaningfully reduce our mistaken notions and have far more accurate models of reality.
One cannot learn rationality. The way to rationality is to be less wrong.
Which brings me to the apt title David McRaney chose for his book — You Are Now Less Dumb. In the introduction, he writes —
You assume you are intelligent, capable, rational, and full of the same glorious reason that invented calculus and ginger snaps…The truth is that the human brain generates a mind that is deeply flawed. There are some things you just aren’t very good at and never will be. Evidence of your dumbness is everywhere. Calculators, notepads, to-do lists, checkbooks, alarm clocks—there are hundreds of inventions and applications for sale in every marketplace to make up for your shortcomings. Entire fields of expertise exist to make up for a gulf in your abilities.
Learning about human biases prepares us for two things —
- To look at our own actions with more honesty.
- To learn to be kind towards other people’s mistakes.
There’s no shame in acknowledging our dumbness. But once we see it, not doing anything to remedy that is pretty close to shamelessness. We can never dial down our dumbness-meter to absolute zero but striving every day to be less dumb is possible.
That’s what David’s book is about. How to recognize the patterns of dumbness in our behaviour and then minimize them — one by one.
The Common Belief Fallacy
We’ve all heard of social proof bias — our tendency to imitate others when we’re uncertain about what to do. It’s usually harmless in most human affairs. But the modern tools of communication especially social media has injected steroids to this social proof effect.
Receiving a piece of news in ten different WhatsApp groups creates the effect of ten different people telling you the same thing over and over again. When we see all our friends and neighbours endorsing a particular piece of information, belief, or news, we assume that it must be true. That’s how this monster called fake news has gripped our country.
Every culture harbours beliefs that have a little scientific grounding but they continue to persist because a lot of people believe in it. For example, fan death is a widely held belief in Korean culture. It’s thought that running an electric fan in a closed room with unopened or no windows causes death. This idea is so deeply ingrained in Korean people’s minds that fan manufacturers include a safety switch (which automatically turns off the fan after a certain time) to soothe the irrational fears of most consumers.
McRaney —
Your natural tendency is to start from a conclusion and work backward to confirm your assumptions, but the scientific method drives down the wrong side of the road and tries to disconfirm your assumptions. If you eliminate your suspicions the outline of the truth begins to emerge. Once your forefathers and foremothers realized that this approach generated results, in a few generations your species went from burning witches and drinking mercury to mapping the human genome and playing golf on the moon.
The antidote to common belief fallacy is to do your own investigation. And if the topic doesn’t interest you then avoid becoming a mindless propagator of information just because a lot of people have told you and it aligns with your prior beliefs.
Deindividualization
In Sept 2008, Shaun Dykes, a 17-year-old boy leaped from the top of a city center car parking in England. Falling from the height of 60 feet, he died instantly. The saddest part of the event was a crowd of 300 people who had gathered underneath, with a few shouting abuses at him and urging him to jump. One teenager even yelled: “How far can you bounce?”
The police negotiators spent 3 hours trying to talk him down while the crowd clicked photos and recorded video. As soon as the drama was over, the crowd dispersed as if an evil spell had broken. Those who had shouted at the victim wondered what had come over them.
We’d like to believe that people who riot and loot are inherently evil and are just looking for an excuse to steal and be violent. But if you look at the track record of individual people in a violent crowd, you’d find that most of them are law-abiding citizens with no history of violence. But the moment they become part of a crowd, something strange happens — deindividualization.
Under the right conditions, you are prone to losing your individuality and becoming absorbed into a hive mind.
McRaney —
Police and firefighters are well aware of this tendency for crowds to gather and taunt. This is why they tape off potential suicide scenes and get the crowd out of shouting distance. It takes only one person to get a crowd going. If you lose your sense of self, feel the power of a crowd, and then get slammed by a cue from the environment, your individuality may evaporate.
This is going to be hard to believe, but this sort of behavior could be inside you as well. Under the right circumstances, you, too, might yell, “Jump!”
The modern man’s history is an unnoticeable blip in the millions of years of animalistic human history. When a child is born, it comes wrapped with the violent fighting genes from our pre-historic forebears. The civilized world today doesn’t allow this violent side of our genes to vent out.
Every time you wade into a crowd or don a concealing garment, you risk deindividuation, and it often brings out the worst in you. When you step back and see yourself as the perpetrator, you act as though your reputation and position in society were at stake. When you have no identity, when you are nameless, faceless, and free from retribution, the chains of inhibition fall from your brain.
What hides inside you, held back by inhibition, and how would it manifest itself if freed? Would you yell for someone to jump to her death while tweeting about it and taking photos? Sitting there now, you think there is no way you could do such a thing, but right now you are an individual with social chains binding both the darkest evil and the brightest good in your heart. You can’t truly predict what would happen if the three ingredients of deindividuation were added to your consciousness: anonymity, group size, and arousal.
How do you save yourself from the devastating consequences of deindividualization?
Keep in mind how prone you are to deindividuation and in what situations you are most susceptible to it, suggests the author, “Anything from binge drinking to singing hymns can decrease your awareness of self. Add to this the diffusion of responsibility and anonymity that comes from being within a group, living in a large city, sitting in a darkened room”
Conclusion
In the previous issues of VIA, I’ve already reviewed David McRaney’s first book — You’re not so smart. This second book is equally good, an entertaining mix of psychology and trivia with lots of real stories and examples. As you turn the pages you’d find yourself laughing, learning, and looking at your own behaviour in new ways.
[/show_to]
[hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years