Influence by Robert Cialdini is a book that I always keep face out on my bookshelf. Not a month goes by when I don’t pick it up and thumb through random chapters. Cialdini first published his book in early 1980s and it’s still revered as the bible of human psychology by many including Charlie Munger.
You couldn’t start with a better book than Cialdini’s ‘Influence’, writes Munger, “Academic psychology has some very important merits alongside its defects. I learnt this eventually, in the course of general reading, from this book, ‘Influence’, aimed at a popular audience. I immediately sent copies of Cialdini’s book to all my children. I also gave a share of Berkshire stock [A share] to thank him for what he had done for me and the public.”
Today, a single class-A share of Berkshire stock is valued at over $300,000. On another occasion, Munger wrote –
Fairly late in life I stumbled into this book, Influence, by a psychologist named Bob Cialdini.. Well, it’s an academic book aimed at a popular audience that filled in a lot of holes in my crude system. In those holes it filled in, I thought I had a system that was a good-working tool.
Cialdini opens the first chapter with a story of his friend who had a jewelry store. The story involved a certain turquoise jewelry that she was finding hard to sell. In spite of a busy tourist season and an overcrowded store her customers were ignoring the turquoise pieces. She experimented with few standard sales tricks like displaying them prominently and even asking the sales staff to push the turquoise jewelry items hard. But no luck. She was unable to move them.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Finally, she gave up and decided to get rid of the turquoise jewelry at loss. She sent a note to her sales staff — “Everything in this display case, price × ½.” Few days later when she returned, first she was relieved to find that every turquoise jewelry article had been sold. The shock came little later when she was told that her employee had read the “½” in her scrawled message as a “2,” and the entire allotment was sold out at twice the original price!
It was pretty strange behaviour by the jewelry-store customers. Why did they ignore the turquoise pieces earlier when they were priced reasonably? What made them swoop for the items when they had been mistakenly offered at double their original price?
Makes no sense, right?
Well, you wouldn’t say that if you knew about Veblen Effect.
The economic theory of Law of Demand says that as the price of a good increases there would be less takers for it.
In microeconomics, the law of demand states that, “conditional on all else being equal, as the price of a good increases (↑), quantity demanded decreases (↓); conversely, as the price of a good decreases (↓), quantity demanded increases (↑)”.[1] In other words, the law of demand describes an inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded of a good. Alternatively, other things being constant, quantity demanded of a commodity is inversely related to the price of the commodity. For example, a consumer may demand 2 kilograms of apples at Rs 70 per kg; he may, however, demand 1 kg if the price rises to Rs 80 per kg. This has been the general human behaviour on relationship between the price of the commodity and the quantity demanded.
(Source: Wikipedia)
But we are not talking about commodities here. Turquoise jewelry is not a commodity. It’s a luxury good. An aspirational product.
Cialdini deconstructs the customer behaviour beautifully in his book. He writes –
The customers, mostly well-to-do vacationers with little knowledge of turquoise, were using a standard principle—a stereotype—to guide their buying: “expensive = good.” Thus the vacationers, who wanted “good” jewelry, saw the turquoise pieces as decidedly more valuable and desirable when nothing about “them was enhanced but the price. Price alone had become a trigger feature for quality; and a dramatic increase in price alone had led to a dramatic increase in sales among the quality-hungry buyers.
We humans are terrible in estimating value of things when we don’t have anything else to compare it with. No wonder most investors in the stock market find it easy to look at the rise and fall of stocks to assess the value of the underlying business. The absolute intrinsic value is maddeningly hard to estimate. Relative valuation methods are more popular and widely accepted as compared to objective valuation.
When there is no benchmark to anchor we intuitively fall back on the rule which says “You get what you pay for.” And then it doesn’t take long to go from “I don’t know how to value this” to “if it’s expensive, it must be good.”
Since in our experience we’ve seen that normally the price of an item goes up along with its worth. A higher price typically indicates higher quality. So “expensive = good” is a reasonable rule of thumb to use in daily life. However, like most behavioural biases, this “expensive = good” heuristic can lead us to bad decisions.
This effect, where people tend to associate the value of a product to its price, is known as Veblen Effect. And things — mostly luxury items — which exhibit this effect are called Veblen Goods.
Veblen goods are named after American economist Thorstein Veblen. Thorstein was first to identify the idea of conspicuous consumption as way to signal one’s financial status. The idea of conspicuous consumption says that people buy stuff in order to look good by displaying their purchased goods in social settings.
It’s the same with scarcity. When products are rare or scarce, owning them gives a feeling of exclusivity. Just by creating artificial scarcity in luxury goods (limited edition products) allows businesses to price their products unrealistically high.
Veblen effect is typically associated with luxury items and services such as art, jewelry, clothes, cars, fine wines, hotels, and luxury cruises. As you can see this effect exploits one of the 7 sins inherent in human behaviour, i.e., vanity — the human desire for prestige and social status.
This effect is highly pronounced in the wine industry. There is an organization called American Institute of Wine Economics. They do extensive research on the perception of the quality of wines. They have repeatedly found in their research that except for 5-10% of knowledgeable wine experts, there is absolutely no correlation between the quality and the enjoyment of the wine. That means more than 90% of the people enjoy wine when they’re told it’s an expensive wine.
Sometimes you can find Veblen Effect being exploited at unusual places like in university admissions. In their remarkable book Universal Principles of Design, the authors write —
The Veblen effect is potentially applicable when a good or service is plainly visible to others, strongly associated with status or affluence, distinguishable from competitors and knockoffs, and priced high relative to competitors. For example, many universities have learned the hard way that parents and students equate the quality of education with the price of tuition. To increase enrollment and address complaints about the rising costs of education, many boards of trustees reduce tuition. This, however, invariably results in a decrease, not an increase, in student enrollment. Reducing the price of tuition decreases both the perceived quality of the education offered by the school and the prestige of the school itself, which correspondingly decreases demand. Conversely, when universities increase the price of tuition, student enrollment increases. However, this increase creates a perception problem of price gouging and a practical problem of affordability. The solution adopted by many schools is to simultaneously increase the price of tuition and the availability of hardship discounts and financial aid. This permits an institution to increase enrollment, increase its patina of quality and prestige, and appear benevolent by offering increased student discounts and assistance. Note that tactics such as these must be employed carefully as overly abundant discounting or assistance programs will undermine the effect.
Today the world has gone all gaga over electric vehicles (EV) and people can’t stop raving about Elon Musk’s brilliance. Tesla doesn’t just allow you to show off your environmentally conscious self. It’s more than that. It’s a cool toy to own. The electric vehicles have been in existence for more than a century but they never came into mainstream commercial use because no one was ready to invest in developing the technology to bring down the cost of EV manufacturing. It was a chicken and egg problem. There weren’t many customers who were ready to buy expensive EVs just to boast that they cared for environment.
That’s where Musk’s stroke of genius comes. He launched Tesla as a luxury car with little emphasis on environment friendliness factor and energy efficiency. Historically, electric cars had been slow, ugly, and uncool. Musk changed that image when he launched Tesla Roadster.
Roadster was fast, sexy, expensive, and exotic car. Tesla released the car in limited numbers, associated it with people of status such as celebrities, politicians, and executives, and charged a monstrous premium for it. It was Veblen Effect on steroids.
Don’t believe it? On Aug 2, 2006, Elon Musk wrote a post titled The Secret Tesla Motors Master Plan. Here’s an excerpt –
Roadster is designed to beat a gasoline sports car like a Porsche or Ferrari in a head to head showdown. Then, over and above that fact, it has twice the energy efficiency of a Prius. Even so, some may question whether this actually does any good for the world. Are we really in need of another high performance sports car? Will it actually make a difference to global carbon emissions?
Well, the answers are no and not much. However, that misses the point, unless you understand the secret master plan alluded to above. Almost any new technology initially has high unit cost before it can be optimized and this is no less true for electric cars. The strategy of Tesla is to enter at the high end of the market, where customers are prepared to pay a premium, and then drive down market as fast as possible to higher unit volume and lower prices with each successive model.
By now you must have figured out that Veblen Effect is dangerous for investors. Unfortunately, it’s rampant in investing. People use price as the proxy of value all the time in the stock market.
Every multibagger stock goes through a period where it’s available for cheap in spite of it being clearly evident that the underlying business is of high quality. But the only thing that attracts the attention of the wider investing community is when the price rises. It’s like whenever Mr. Market wants to promote a stock all it has to do is to bring a temporary jump in the price and suddenly everyone starts viewing it as a value stock and a future multibagger.
Your job as an investor is to estimate the value independently and not let the price of the stock distort your perception about the business.
So, dear investor! Beware of the Veblen Effect. Stocks are not the objects for conspicuous consumption. To be in the stock market for the opportunity to boast about one’s multibagger picks is choosing to be in the wrong game. If you want to do that, you better buy the turquoise jewelry or the Tesla Roadster.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years