• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

The Illusion of Free Will

July 20, 2018

How many times have you stepped into a public bathroom and felt disgusted by puddles of spilled over liquid around the porcelain urinal?

We all know that it’s the result of men relieving themselves carelessly. When people know they aren’t required to clean their own mess, they’re least bothered about aiming properly to minimize the spillage.

Maybe putting up notices like – Please piss responsibly – would help. But we know most people don’t heed to such requests. So the architects of Schiphol Airport in Amsterdam came up with a brilliant strategy. They put a fly in each urinal.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Yes. You heard it right. A fly. Not a real one albeit. What they did was that they put a sticker inside the urinal. The sticker gave an impression of a real fly.

Now, what do men do when they spot an unexpected foreign object in their urinal? They feel compelled to shoo it away by aiming at it with …ahem… you know what. It’s an urge that’s hard to fight. And by the time one realizes that it’s a fake fly, the job is already done.

This simple trick reduced the spillage in the airport urinal by 80 percent. Pretty remarkable, isn’t it?

It is an excellent demonstration of how intelligent design can gently nudge people’s behaviour towards the desired direction. In his book Nudge, Richard Thaler, a behavioural scientist who won the Nobel Prize in Economics last year, wrote –

No piece of choice architecture has received as much attention as the now famous fly in the Amsterdam airport urinals. Entrepreneur and engineer Dough Kempel turned the fly experiment into a small business selling fly stickers online. ‘My goal is nothing less than to save the world, one urinal at a time,’ he told us. ‘I truly believe that this simple product can keep restrooms cleaner and safer. Less cleaning means less harmful cleaners being used. It doesn’t hurt that it makes people laugh.’ Kempel said his flies have sold particularly well in the united kingdom, and he has shipped them to bars, restaurant, schools, churches, and yes, airports.

Do you think men would feel manipulated if they were told about the fly? Perhaps not. It’s a harmless trick to make people do the right thing.

However, leveraging the knowledge of human psychology to maneuver people’s action is a double-edged sword. People can be nudged to make decisions which may not be best for them. And to add insult to the injury, people would think they made those decisions out of their free will.

For example, in the fly experiment, within few seconds men could guess that it wasn’t a real fly. So, would they give the credit of their responsible pissing to the fly? I don’t think so.

Let me walk you through a simple guessing game that explains the illusion of free will. If you’ve seen this game before, please be a good sport and play along one more time.

Step 1. Think of a number between one and nine.
Step 2. Multiply your chosen number by 9.
Step 3. Take the result of step 2 and add its digits. For example, if the result of the multiplication step was 78, then do 7+8, so you’d get 15.
Step 4. Take the result of step 3 and subtract 5 from it.
Step 5. Now select an alphabet which corresponds to the number that you got in step 4. For example, A = 1, B = 2, C = 3, D = 4, E = 5 etc.
Step 6. Now think of a country name which starts with the letter that you got in step 5.
Step 7. Select the last letter of the country name that you got in step 6 and think of an animal name that starts with that letter.
Step 8. Select the last letter of the animal name that you got in step 7 and think of a colour name that starts with that letter.

Now let me read your mind. Aren’t you thinking about an orange kangaroo? The trick works for most people.

If you couldn’t figure how I read your mind, let me deconstruct the magic. The secret is in step 2. Any number that you multiply with 9 will yield a result whose digits will always add up to 9. It’s a mathematical principle. So no matter what number you imagine, step 3 will always leave you with 9. Which mean I know that in step 5 you’ve got to have the alphabet D. Now, there aren’t many countries which start with the letter D. Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (aka North Korea), Democratic Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Djibouti, Dominica, and Dominican Republic. The most popular among them (and easily recallable) is of course Denmark. The last letter of Denmark is K and the only well-known animals starting with K are Kangaroo, Koala, and Kiwi. Most people think of Kangaroo. The last letter of Kangaroo is O. Again, there aren’t that many colours starting with O. So a majority of people think of Orange.

Don’t get fooled by the triviality of this guessing game. Look beyond. The point I am trying to make is that there are situations where you think you’re making a free choice – an independent decision – but in reality aren’t. By exploiting the loopholes in human behaviour, we can be lead to bad choices without even realizing that it’s a subtle manipulation.

The modus operandi of many entertaining street magicians is nothing but an intelligently designed trick.

Famous behavioural scientist Dan Ariely describes a baffling experiment. He asked a bunch of people to write down the last two digits of their phone numbers on a piece of paper. So the numbers could have been anywhere from 00 to 99. Then he asked people to estimate the population of a relatively unknown country. He supplied them with a clue – the answer was between 10 million and 100 million.

Surprisingly, Ariely found an unusual correlation between people’s answer and the phone number they had written. People who had their phone numbers closer to 99 estimated the population which was closer to 100 million. And people who had their phone numbers closer to 00 estimated the population closer to 10 million.

Ariely concluded that making people write their phone number distorted their estimates. But as usual, people denied having any influence on their estimate. They believed that their estimate was completely independent and chosen out of free will. They didn’t know that their subconscious mind was primed by an unrelated piece of information (their phone numbers) and tilted their estimates.

Marketing professional, salespeople and persuasion experts exploit the illusion of free will all the time. For example, do you know red color primes your subconscious and incites hunger? That’s why Coke and many other fast food brands (McDonald, Dominos, Pizza Hut) use red colour generously in their logos and advertisements.

Hypnotism is an extreme case of priming. The degree to which people’s subconscious mind can be manipulated varies from person to person. Some have a more suggestible mind and some don’t. But no one is 100 percent immune to priming.

In a fascinating episode of Nat Geo’s Brain Games (a must watch for students of behavioural economics), they demonstrate how a hypnotist convinces his subject to forget about number 4. You’d be amused and even doubt the authenticity of the experiment when the subject starts counting from one to ten and forgets about four altogether. But it’s a scientific fact. Priming is a powerful weapon of influence.

In another experiment, the guys at Brain Games offered movie-goers two options for popcorn buckets. A small one priced at $3 and a large one priced at $7. Most people chose the first option. When asked they argued that $7 was too much for popcorn. In the second part of their experiment they added a third option. A medium sized bucket priced at $6. Surprisingly, in this group, most people went for the large $7 bucket. This time they justified that there wasn’t much difference in price between medium and large, so they went for large. When asked, most people denied that their decision was skewed by the presence of the medium size bucket.

Of course, people would like to think that they chose based on their free will. But the results of the experiment tell a different story. Although no one took the $6 bucket, its presence nudged people towards the $7 option. The medium bucket was a decoy.

In light of this experiment, I am sure you can recall many instances from your life where you made decisions in a similar manner where your choice was elbowed towards an option which you wouldn’t have taken otherwise.

Priming and the decoy effect are just two of the many ways in which manipulators exploit illusion of free will.

So in investing, how does the illusion of free will come into play?

The talking heads on the TV, the incessant noise bombarded by financial newspapers, the stock tips by self-proclaimed fly by night gurus, professional market manipulators, unscrupulous promoters, etc.

In other words, the way an investor consumes information is guaranteed to make him fall for this illusion.

So how small investors save themselves from the onslaught of free-will exploiters?

By developing an independent thought process. By being rational. By deliberately staying away from the sources which can distort our worldview. By not taking advice from people who have their incentives misaligned to ours.

Next time your broker calls you to buy or sell a stock, remember, you’re free to choose. And that means you are free to choose an option which your broker deliberately hide from you, i.e., doing nothing.

Doing nothing is also an option.

You’re free to do nothing.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members

 

  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe

[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India