A few weeks back I surprised myself by doing something I thought I would never do. I sold my position in a stock that had been the largest holding in my portfolio for a long time.
I first started buying this stock almost a decade back and had never sold a single share of this company. I continued to accumulate it through its ups and downs in this period. At one point, this company constituted more than 40% of my entire stock portfolio. I don’t need to tell you that it was my high confidence stock.
So what made me exit it all of a sudden?
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Before I reveal my reasoning for selling the most favourite idea of my entire investing career (9 years so far), let me tell you the story of one of the finest flying machines that humans have built and why it ironically didn’t fly for long in spite of being the fastest and safest commercial aircraft ever built. The most interesting part of this story isn’t that this super-plane was grounded. No. One must ask what made it stay operational for more than 25 years in spite of being massively uneconomical.
Concorde was a supersonic passenger airliner developed by the joint effort of French and Britain aircraft manufacturers. For a regular commercial jet, it took eight hours to fly from New York to Paris. Concorde covered that distance in just under 3.5 hours flying at an average speed of 2140 km/h, i.e., twice the speed of any conventional transatlantic flight. To cruise at that velocity, Concorde had to climb to an altitude of 60,000 feet. That dwarfs the flying altitude of a normal long haul commercial airplane — 40,000 feet.
British Airways and Air France were the only two airlines to purchase and operate Concorde. Now, one counterintuitive thing about the business of flying is that cutting down the time of travel by a few hours doesn’t always help the airlines to get more customers. So, just like the Jaguars and Bentleys of the world, the Concorde was supposed to serve only the wealthy passengers who could afford to pay a high price in exchange for the aircraft’s speed and luxury service. For example, it cost $12,500 (adjusted for inflation) to do a round-trip ticket in Concorde from New York to London in 1997. That was more than 30 times the cost of the cheapest option available on that route.
If you have studied the dynamics of commercial aviation or heard about Warren Buffett’s thoughts on airlines, you’d know that it’s an industry with terrible economics. In his 2007 letter to investors, Buffett wrote —
The worst sort of business is one that grows rapidly, requires significant capital to engender the growth, and then earns little or no money. Think airlines. Here a durable competitive advantage has proven elusive ever since the days of the Wright Brothers. Indeed, if a farsighted capitalist had been present at Kitty Hawk, he would have done his successors a huge favor by shooting Orville down.
When the wheels came up on the first Concorde commercial flight in 1976, the project — which was initially estimated to cost £70 million — was already plagued by prohibitive cost overruns exceeding £1.3 billion. Given those facts, it shouldn’t be a surprise that Concorde never went mainstream. Although British Airways and Air France were able to operate the supersonic flights at a profit, in spite of very high maintenance costs, because they were able to find enough customers who would buy the exorbitantly expensive tickets. But running the plane profitably wasn’t enough because the initial investment into the project eclipsed the present value of all projected operational profits.
Eventually, in 2003, Concorde flew for the last time before it was sent to the museum.
So the question that begs to be asked is — Why did it take 25 years for the airlines to admit that Concorde would never be a commercial success?
Paradoxically, the £1.3 billion investment which destined the Concorde for commercial failure from the beginning was also the reason why it continued to remain in service for over two decades. It was a classic case of throwing good money after bad money, also known as the sunk cost fallacy — a decision making error when an activity is continued solely based on how much effort and resources have already gone into it and the facts about the economic viability are ignored.
Concorde — the poster child of Anglo/French financial misadventures — became a metaphor for the act of perpetuating one’s mistake.
Charlie Munger often says, “When you find yourself in a hole, the first thing you should do is stop digging.”
The Concorde project was conceived in 1956 — 20 years before the concord actually became a reality — and it’s hard to argue that the English and the French didn’t realize that they were in a hole during this period. Some people claim that political and legal issues made it impossible for either government to pull out. Or perhaps the sovereign pride of the English and French governments caused them to embrace irrationality willingly. But four decades (20 years of research and 27 years of operations) is too long a time to justify any excuses.
The two highest costs many companies face, writes Morgan Housel, “are employee compensation and an attachment to sunk costs. Sunk costs are so entrenched that it often takes a disaster to wipe them away. Part of the reason the German military was so powerful in the early years of World War II is because it had to forfeit every gun, tank, ship, and plane to the Allies after World War I, which meant it rearmed in between wars with brand new, state-of-the-art supplies while other armies used outdated equipment. Having everything taken away from them in 1917 was a counterintuitive competitive advantage.”
Not letting sunk costs affect your decisions is a superpower. Reminds me of what Housel mentioned about Nobel Laureate Daniel Kahneman. He writes —
When writing his book, Thinking, Fast and Slow, Daniel Kahneman could tear up entire chapters and start over. Jason Zweig, who helped Kahneman write the book, explains:
The first time this happened, I was thunderstruck. How did he do that? How could anybody do that? When I asked Danny how he could start again as if we had never written an earlier draft, he said the words I’ve never forgotten: “I have no sunk costs.”
Jason described what he learned from this. “Danny taught me that you can never create something worth reading unless you are committed to the total destruction of everything that isn’t.”
So coming back to the story of why I sold my favourite stock, I realized that many of the reasons for which I had bought the stock were no longer valid. However, owning the stock for so long meant I had a significant amount of mental effort invested in it.
Unlike stock prices, the changes in the business environment are usually slow. Because of ignorance arising out of slow contrast effect (also known as the boiling frog syndrome), many investors fail to notice big changes happening right under the nose. Sometimes those changes in your long-held positions are for the good and being unaware of them turn out to be a blessing but that’s not always true because the competitive nature of the market ensures that no business remains strong forever. The combined effect of slow contrast and sunk cost (psychological and emotional) drive the investor to stay married to their favourite stocks.
When I saw the subtle trick my mind was playing owing to the Concorde Fallacy, I knew it was time to press the reset button.
On one hand I was able to deal with the sunk cost in investing, I gave into it when it came to writing this post. I had almost completed this post when I accidentally deleted it and found no way to retrieve it. Hours of work lost in a second. Thinking rationally, it gave me a clean slate to rewrite the entire post or even choose a totally different topic. But I couldn’t fight the urge of sunk cost and I am no Kahneman.
[/show_to]
[hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years