If you are familiar with the terms ‘value investing’ and ‘behavioural biases’ then chances are that you have heard about ‘checklists’ too. The idea of checklist has been made popular in recent times by Dr. Atul Gawande.
A surgeon by profession, Dr. Gawande is also a prolific writer and deep thinker. He is a staff writer at ‘The New Yorker’. Charlie Munger was so impressed with one of his article that he mailed him a $20,000 cheque as a thank you.
[Update: Dr. Gawande was recently appointed as the CEO of a healthcare venture formed by Amazon, J.P. Morgan and Berkshire Hathaway.]
Atul Gawande has written three other books chronicling his experience in medical surgery. Checklist Manifesto is his latest book which has resonated quite well with world of stock market investing and business analysis.
Atul Gawande is a master storyteller and his books are nothing less than medical thrillers. He uses his experience in surgery to tell riveting stories of interesting medical cases and what goes on inside an operation theatre.
Medical profession (just like any other field of work in this world) faces the limitation of ‘Necessary Fallibility.” Gawande says:
…some things we want to do are simply beyond our capacity. We are not omniscient or all-powerful. Even enhanced by technology, our physical and mental powers are limited. Much of the world and universe is – and will remain – outside our understanding and control.
But he discovered that many a times surgeons commit mistakes which are mentioned in every textbook. And the problem was that these mistakes couldn’t be attributed to lack of skill or absence of knowledge.
So the first insight that I found in his book is the important distinction between errors of ignorance and errors of ineptitude:
We have two reasons that we may fail – The first is ignorance – we may err because science has given us only a partial understanding of the world and how it works. The second type of failure is because we fail to apply correctly the knowledge that exists.
For nearly all of history, people’s lives have been governed primarily by ignorance. But in the modern world science has filled in enough knowledge to make ineptitude as much our struggle as ignorance…Knowhow and sophistication have increased remarkably across almost all our realms of endeavour.
The complexity of modern world has made us more prone to mistakes which are potentially avoidable.
Defeat under conditions of complexity occurs far more often despite great effort rather than from a lack of it …The capability of individuals isn’t proving to be our primary difficulty, whether in medicine or elsewhere. Training in most fields is longer and more intense than ever. People spend years of sixty-, seventy-, eighty-hour weeks building their base of knowledge and experience before going into practice on their own – whether they are doctors or professors or engineers. Yet the failures persist despite remarkable individual ability.
The problem of extreme complexity
Through a series of fascinating examples Dr. Gawande shows how it has become too easy for an otherwise competent doctor to miss a step, forget to ask an important question (under stress) or fail to plan for an unexpected emergency.
Medicine has become the art of managing extreme complexity. Medicine and other fields have grown so far beyond the usual kind that avoiding daily mistakes is proving impossible even for our most super-specialized.
In US the number of deaths following surgery is 150,000 per year which is three times the number of road accident fatalities. The failure rate is disproportionately high and can’t be ignored.
…research has consistently showed that at least half our deaths and major complications are avoidable.
So how do you approach this problem ? The answer comes from a totally unrelated place – the airline industry.
The Checklist
In 1930’s the airline industry was manufacturing more powerful and better planes but flying these sophisticated machines became too complicated. Relying on any one person (however expert) to deal with all the complexities invited disaster. To address this, a pilot’s checklist was created. It was simple, brief and to the point – short enough to fit on an index card. And it worked wonders.
How could something as simple as a checklist be of substantial help ? Dr. Gawande explains –
In a complex environment, experts are up against two main difficulties. The first is the fallibility of human memory and attention, especially when it comes to mundane, routine matters that are easily overlooked under the strain of more pressing events….A further difficulty is that people can lull themselves into skipping steps even when they remember them…Checklists remind us of the minimum necessary steps and make them explicit. They not only offer the possibility of verification but also instill a kind of discipline of higher performance.
The researchers have found that simply having the doctors and nurses in the ICU create their own checklists for what they thought should be done each day improved the consistency of care to the point that the average length of patient stay in intensive care dropped by half.
This was a remarkable discovery and a brilliant example of cross pollination of ideas across unrelated disciplines.
Checklists in Building Construction
Just like any other tool checklists too have limits. To be able to use checklist effectively, we need to understand which situations they work and in which they don’t. Can checklists be helpful in dealing with situation where the outcome is highly uncertain?
Many of you remember the 9/11 terrorist attack and the horrifying pictures of collapsing twin towers. But have you ever wondered about millions of other buildings and skyscrapers which continue to stand strong for decades.
Consider this statistics – in US there are more than 10 million high rises and commercial buildings. The “building failure” rate is less than 0.00002 percent. And checklists play very important role in achieving this remarkable feat.
To deal with uncertainties associated with the construction, the builders trust on the power of communication. So they maintain two types of checklists. First they have a set of checklists to ensure that stupid but critical stuff is not missed and second they have another set of checklists to ensure people talk and coordinate and accept responsibility.
Gawande was surprised to discover the frequent use of communication checklist in some unusual places – like award winning restaurants.
Checklists and Investing
I feel this chapter is unarguably the most important and interesting part of the book. When Dr. Gawande came to know about Mohnish Pabrai and Guy Spier and their success at using checklists, he interviewed them.
When you find a promising new investment idea with a prospect of making a lot of money, it triggers the emotion of human greed which is the enemy of a rational mind. Guy Spier calls it cocaine brain (his book Education of Value Investor is a must read). According to him –
You go into the greed mode …Neuroscientists have found that the prospect of making money stimulates the same primitive reward circuits in the brain that cocaine does.
How do you deal with a cocaine brain ? It requires a dispassionate analysis to safeguard against both irrational exuberance and panic. Author tells Pabrai’s story:
Before going into investment, he built a successful informational technology company of his own. All this is to say he knows a thing or two about being dispassionate and avoiding the lure of instant gratification. Yet no matter how objective he tried to be about a potentially exciting investment, he said, he found his brain working against him, latching onto evidence that confirmed his initial hunch and dismissing the signs of a downside. It’s what the brain does. You get seduced. You start cutting corners.
Or, in the midst of a bear market, the opposite happens. You go into “fear mode,” he said. You see people around you losing their bespoke shirts, and you overestimate the dangers.
He also found he made mistakes in handling complexity. A good decision requires looking at so many different features of companies in so many ways that, even without the cocaine brain, he was missing obvious patterns. His mental checklist wasn’t good enough.
Mohnish deviced a written checklist based on his personal mistakes and also mistakes by other investors like Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger. His checklist allowed him to move faster and systemically through investment decisions.
A research project revealed that even venture capitalist found checklists very useful in making decisions about investing in early startups.
Without question, technology can increase our capabilities. But there is much that technology cannot do: deal with the unpredictable, manage uncertainty, construct a soaring building, perform a lifesaving operation. In many ways, technology has complicated these matters. It has added yet another element of complexity to the systems we depend on and given us entirely new kinds of failure to contend with.
Conclusion
Unlike airline failures there are many other areas where we don’t study the failure – like government programs, financial industry, teaching law etc. We falsely believe that by working harder we can improve our performance but we forget to learn from our failures.
It’s difficult to accept that such a humble tool like a checklist can be so effective at improving the results but this book has numerous examples and case studies which support the premise that checklist do work.
In the end, checklist is not a mere formula but a means of self awareness. So nobody can create a checklist for you. You have to come up with your own checklist and then improve it constantly by analysing failures.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years