• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

📚 Summerhill

June 24, 2020

What’s your favourite book?

I found one of the best ways to answer this question is to recall which book you have gifted the most.

I always have three copies of Summerhill sitting on my bookshelf waiting to be gifted. The book came as a recommendation from Naval Ravikant — a silicon valley entrepreneur.

The methods suggested in the book will make you uncomfortable because few parents have the courage and independence to care more for their children’s happiness than for their success.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

The book resonated a lot with my worldview, for it talks less about what should be done with children and more about what shouldn’t be done — the Via Negativa approach.

There are no problem children, writes the author A.S. Neill, “but only problem parents and problem humanity.”

Summerhill is an intriguing book on child psychology. Unlike most popular parenting books that conveniently gloss over sensitive topics, Summerhill boldly discusses many taboo issues and how parent’s misplaced understanding of those aspects messes up the child’s mind (and life). Caveat emptor: The book will make you uncomfortable but will still make a lot of sense.

First, a little backstory of Summerhill.

After teaching in many ordinary schools, A.S. Neill decided to start a school where children could be just as they are. He began Summerhill in 1921 in Germany and shifted it to a village near London in 1924. For the next 40 years, Neill turned Summerhill school into the world’s greatest experiment in bringing up children with unstinted love and approval.

The book Summerhill is based on Neill’s experience from his time teaching (and learning). Neill presents his perspective on issues like self-discipline, etiquette, self-study, work, play, drama, music, religion, sex, fear, inferiority complex, the world of fantasy, lying, obedience, punishment, toilet training, toys, money, homosexuality, masturbation, stealing and many such things that trouble children’s parents.

What is Summerhill Like?

Well, for one thing, lessons are optional. Children can go to them or stay away from them — for years if they want to. There is a timetable — buy only for teachers.

The children have classes usually according to their age, but sometimes according to their interests. We have no new methods of teaching, because we do not consider that teaching in itself matters very much. Whether a school has or has not a special method for teaching long division is of no significance, for long division is of no importance except to those who want to learn it.

The Free Child

There’s no freedom without fear.

Fear can be a terrible thing in a child’s life. Fear must be entirely eliminated — fear of adults, fear of punishment, fear of disapproval, fear of God. Only hate can flourish in an atmosphere of fear.

As I was re-reading this book, I tweeted a line from this book — The absence of fear is the finest thing that can happen to a child. This attracted a few raised eyebrows after all, fear is an evolutionary mechanism bestowed by mother nature to improve our survival odds. In fact, every human child is born with two primal fears — fear of loud noises and fear of falling.

Neil is talking about the psychological fear, which is acquired through social conditioning. He reasons —

Fear of a tiger is natural and healthy. Fear of being driven in a car by a bad driver is also natural and healthy. If we had no fear, we should all be run down by buses. But fear of a spider or a mouse or a ghost is unnatural and unhealthy. That kind of fear is merely anxiety. It is a phobia. A phobia is an irrational, exaggerated anxiety about something. In a phobia, the object that excites terror is a comparatively harmless one. The object is only a symbol, although the anxiety it causes is real enough.

In Australia, fear of a spider is rational, for a spider can be death dealing. In England and the United States, fear of a spider is irrational and therefore a phobia.

Destructiveness

Adults find it very hard to realise that young children have no regard for property. They do not destroy it deliberately — they destroy it unconsciously. Things as personal property are simply not real to them as yet. The fact that adults are possessive about things of value and children are not. Any living together between children and adults must therefore result in conflict over material things.

For a child, any object’s function is seen through only one metric — its utility in a play. And if vandalising that object becomes an interesting play, a child will do it. She is not evil. She is just playfully curious.

My view is that a child should arrive at a sense of value out of his own free choice. As children leave the stage of pre-adolescent indifference to property, they become respecters of property. When children have freedom to live out their indifference to property, they have little chance of ever becoming profiteers and exploiters.

Moral Instruction

One useful mental model to look at the world is to follow the dictum of Halon’s Razor which says — don’t ascribe a behaviour to malice if it can sufficiently be explained by ignorance.

When we look at an infant, we know there is no wickedness in him — no more than there is wickedness in a cabbage or in a young tiger. The new born child brings with him a life force; his will, his unconscious urge is to live. His life force prompts him to eat, to explore his body, to gratify his wishes.

There is no case whatever for the moral instruction of children. It is psychologically wrong. To ask a child to be unselfish is wrong. Every child is egoist and the world belongs to him. When he has an apple, his one wish is to eat that apple. The chief result of mother’s encouraging him to share it with his little brother is to make him hate the little brother. Altruism comes later — comes naturally — if the child is not taught to be unselfish. It probably never comes at all if the child has been forced to be unselfish. By suppressing the child’s selfishness the mother is fixing that selfishness forever.

Conclusion

You may not agree with everything Neill writes and you shouldn’t. Many of his ideologies are based on German psychologist Sigmund Freud’s work and many of Freud’s theories have already been invalidated. However, once you finish reading this volume, you’d agree that Neill knows far more about child psychology than us and his insights have a lot of merits.

Neill says —

Years of intensive work in child training has convinced me that I know comparatively little of the forces that motivate life. I am convinced, however, that parents who have had to deal with only their own children know much less than I do. The difficult child is the child who is unhappy. He is at war with himself; and in consequence, he is at war with the world.

At first, the book seems to be about parenting and child psychology. So those who aren’t parents and don’t have a plan to become one might feel like skipping this book.

It would be a mistake.

There’s a pretty high probability that most of us were raised by our parents who were largely ignorant about issues described in this book. Summerhill will give you deep insights into your own childhood experiences.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Book Worm

Handcrafted with in India