While making an investment decision or while accepting or rejecting any bet, the important question to ask always is – “What’s the alternative?”
Warren Buffett, in his 2014 letter to shareholders, wrote…
We will never play financial Russian roulette with the funds you’ve entrusted to us, even if the metaphorical gun has 100 chambers and only one bullet. In our view, it is madness to risk losing what you need in pursuing what you simply desire.
Russian roulette is a game where the player is given the option to take a revolver, having only one bullet, put it on his own head and pull the trigger. If he survives, he stands to win a huge sum, say US$ 10 million. What’s the expected payoff for such bet?
In this game, the probability of surviving is 5/6 (assuming 6 chambers in the revolver) and the upside is US$ 10 million. Whereas probability of encountering the bullet is 1/6 and outcome of this event is the loss of one’s life. You can’t really calculate the expected payoff in this case for how do you put a loss amount on death? I guess it’s infinite.
So even if the payoff were to be in billions and even if the revolver had not six but 1000 chambers with only a single bullet, you still can’t calculate the expected value since the downside is infinite. Buffett was implying that if the downside of a bet is unacceptable to you, no matter how low the probability, you shouldn’t accept the bet.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Now, what’s the functional equivalent of playing Russian roulette in investing? It means not betting the farm on a single event. It means not risking something which you need for your survival. Not using your emergency fund for buying stocks, no matter how low the probability of losing money on it.
When I read about this idea for the first, it made a lot of sense. However, if you extend this logic then you could argue that one should never climb on an airplane too. Why? Although the probability of getting involved in an air crash is extremely, extremely low (akin to playing Russian roulette with a revolver Well, true but then you shouldn’t be driving your car too, neither should you dare to cross the road because all these activities are statistically riskier than air travel. However, avoiding the risk of these mundane activities would mean that you should better lock yourself up in a black box made up of reinforced steel (a black box is strong enough to survive even an air crash) and stay inside it for life. The question is how many people would want to live that kind of life? I guess not many, including me.
Which means the important question to ask while accepting or rejecting a bet, is – “What’s the alternative?” Let me take another example to add more strength to my argument.
Would You Jump?
Another thought experiment. If you’re given an option to jump from a plane (flying at 30,000 feet) using a parachute that opens only 99 percent of the time, will you jump? Extending the Russian roulette example, you would immediately say “No!”
But what if I told you that the aircraft’s both the engines are on fire and it’s going down. By all means, jumping with the parachute looks like a no-brainer, right? In light of this new information, the parachute option looks much-much safer.
So before accepting or rejecting any bet, the most important question to ask is – what’s the alternative? Let’s use a shortcode for this – WTA! A ticker symbol if you will.
Forgetting to ask WTA has serious implications in decision making.
John Doe goes to a doctor with a complaint of chronic pain in his throat. The doctor examines and prescribes a biopsy. Test results aren’t encouraging and reveal that John has throat cancer. The doctor proposes two options. A surgery to remove his vocal cord which will leave him speechless but increase his chances of survival. The second option is chemotherapy which is a long and quite an unpleasant line of treatment. What should Mr. Doe choose?
You’d be surprised to know that for most people, who find themselves in John’s situation, it never occurs to them that they can take a second opinion from a different doctor also and get their biopsy tests repeated. They forget to ask WTA. Many times we are so fixed on the two options given to us by others that we forget that there’s the third option too.
And sometimes the alternative is about not choosing anything i.e., not making any decision.
In Investing
Now, what’s the implication of this in investing? When it comes to investing, WTA is a very useful question.
Imagine one of your stocks has tripled from your buy price and seems overvalued. Should you sell it? There are many different frameworks for answering this question, WTA being one of them. If the quality of the underlying business hasn’t deteriorated, then selling it just because it looks overvalued creates a new risk. What risk?
Ask WTA – what’s the alternative use of the cash after selling the stock? Do you have any other promising idea where you can invest? If not, you are unnecessarily exposing yourself to reinvestment risk. The sudden availability of cash can create an urge to reinvest it in some other stock (Do Something Bias) which can lead you to make a mistake.
Another instance when people fail to ask the WTA question is while looking for “cheap” stocks – those priced cheaply, or those that have fallen from grace to now being priced at extremely low levels (note that I am not talking about value here, but price). This happens often, like it happened with many investors when the markets were at their bottom in 2009. A lot of ‘hot stocks’ of 2008 had fallen from their highs, and looked as ‘obvious’ bargains. I remember one of my distant relatives who actually sold a piece of land to average down on such stocks.
Now, this was despite the fact that most other stocks – including most of all good and great businesses – had also fallen with the broader markets…and thus there were a lot of alternatives available for people to invest their money at cheap prices and cheap valuations.
So those who failed to ask the WTA question while looking at just the cheap prices (like those of Suzlon whose chart I show on the next page) are down another 60-80% from the lows of 2009. And those who asked this question – What’s the alternative to averaging down on these bad businesses? – and ended up buying high quality stocks, have done extremely well.
WTA and Cash
Let’s say you have a portfolio of 10 stocks and you get a good bonus from your employer. Now you intend to invest this bonus in stocks. So you start looking for businesses and you find that those you like are all overvalued. Ask WTA. What’s the alternative to investing in new stocks? The alternative is your existing portfolio. We forget that the stocks we have already bought continue to remain an option to invest more provided they are still available for an attractive price. Some of your stocks have run up from your purchase price? Still, it’s quite possible that the quality of the underlying business has improved a lot and even at higher price the stock continues to remain a good buy.
Now cash is a very interesting thing in investing. In itself, cash is a depreciating asset because of inflation. Even if I assume that cash means bank fixed deposit or debt/liquid funds, the effective return is negative since the inflation is much higher. So any sensible investor would be very uncomfortable sitting on cash. But don’t let this cash-discomfort fool you. Again, ask WTA. What’s the best alternative to cash? In other words, what’s the opportunity cost of cash? Sometimes you would find that the answer is – the opportunity cost of cash is cash itself.
Having an emergency fund is the simplest example. Investing your emergency fund in stocks has a huge opportunity cost. Your emergency fund is like your parachute. Would you use your parachute to put out the fire on your airplane? Never.
One Fundamental Filter in Investing
As investors, we are constantly thinking of allocating capital towards our best ideas. However, with limited capital to allocate, and several alternatives, the idea of opportunity costs arises. An opportunity cost is defined as the value of the second-best opportunity that we forgo when we make a choice. It’s like asking the WTA question.
Simply put, in a world where alternatives are mutually exclusive, and we must choose A over B, or B over A, my opportunity cost would be the potential gain of B, if I choose A and vice versa. Luckily, Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger have touched upon this subject with more fluency and important insights.
Like, here is what Munger said in the past…
I would argue that one filter that’s useful in investing is the idea of opportunity costs. If you have one idea that’s available in large quantity that’s better that 98% of the other opportunities, then you can just screen out the other 98%. With this attitude you get a concentrated portfolio, which we don’t mind. That practice of ours which is so simple is not widely copied, I don’t know why. Even at great universities and intellectual institutions. It’s an interesting question: If we’re right, why are so many other places so wrong.
At another occasion, he said…
I just wanted to do the best I could reasonably do with the talent, time and resources I had available. That’s what I was doing then and now. Everything is based on opportunity costs. Academia has done a terrible disservice: They teach in one sentence in first-year economics about opportunity costs, but that’s it. In life, if opportunity A is better than B, and you have only one opportunity, you do A. There’s no one-size-fits-all. If you’re really wise and fortunate, you get to be like Berkshire. We have high opportunity costs. We always have something we like and can buy more of, so that’s what we compare everything to. All of you are in the game of taking the lot you have right now and improving it based on your opportunity costs. Think of how life is simplified if you approach it this way.
Asking the WTA question or thinking about opportunity costs reduces over-diversification. A good question you must ask every time before making an investment is – “If in this investment I can achieve something that I will not achieve with other options, why should I continue allocating capital to the rest of them? Wouldn’t it make more sense to remain fully invested until a better, or at least equal return opportunity appears?”
Not only investing but whenever we’re making important decisions in life, we should think hard in terms of that decision’s opportunity cost. Munger says….
The right way to make decisions in practical life is based on your opportunity cost. When you get married, you have to choose the best spouse you can find that will have you. The rest of life is the same damn way.
In you work, every hour spent in the office, has an associated opportunity cost. The hour could have been spent in doing something else like spending more time with your kids, with your spouse, with your parents. Every minute that one spends staring on his or her Facebook feed or WhatsApp stream has an opportunity cost.
Every hour spent on consuming financial news and marvelling at the dance of green and red colour on your portfolio tracker is time taken away from reading a good book or meditating. I don’t really know. The opportunity cost of every action is very subjective. You are the best person to put a price tag on the opportunity cost of your time and money.
Of course, you don’t want to become like a robot calculating the opportunity cost of every small thing for that will ruin the quality of your life. But when it comes to making important decisions, it helps to take a step back and ask – What’s the alternative?
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years



