• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Spotlight: Understanding the Risk-Taking Cycle

February 8, 2016

History has a way of repeating with greater shocks in the financial markets and it shows up in the risk-taking cycle that investors go through.

I tend to collect the best quotes I read on various subjects in print or on the Internet in a document. As I was glancing through that document a few days back, searching for inspiration for my future posts, I found a few on the subject of history and how it repeats itself so often, especially in the financial world.

The philosopher Santayana stressed the penalty for failing to attach sufficient importance to history –

Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.

Then, humourist and author Mark Twain talked about the
relevance of the past thus –

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme.

And then, economist John Kenneth Galbraith described the shabby way investors treat history and those who consider it important as –

Contributing to…euphoria are two further factors little noted in our time or in past times. The first is the extreme brevity of the financial memory. In consequence, financial disaster is quickly forgotten. In further consequence, when the same or closely similar circumstances occur again, sometimes in only a few years, they are hailed by a new, often youthful, and always supremely self-confident generation as a brilliantly innovative discovery in the financial and larger economic world. There can be few fields of human endeavor in which history counts for so little as in the world of finance. Past experience, to the extent that it is part of memory at all, is dismissed as the primitive refuge of those who do not have the insight to appreciate the incredible wonders of the present.

Warren Buffett said –

What we learn from history is that people don’t learn from history.

And here’s Charlie Munger’s version –

There is no better teacher than history in determining the future…

String together these three pearls of wisdom and you get a pretty accurate picture of investment reality. Past patterns tend to recur. If you ignore that fact, you’re likely
to fall prey to those patterns rather than benefit from them. But when markets get euphoric, the lessons of the past are readily dismissed. Investors start to say and believe in the “this time it’s different” theory, and completely forget the pain that such theorizing and subsequent actions had caused people in the past.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] As we revisit such painful times when people, who went overboard with their stock picking and were trying to ride the heady momentum, it’s time to also revisit these eternal principles, which I have quoted above. Their collective message was, and remains indispensable.

From Past to Future

While history serves a great lesson for investors, investing consists of exactly one thing: dealing with the future. And because none of us can know the future with certainty, risk is inescapable. Thus, dealing with risk is an essential – okay, the most essential – element in investing.

It’s not hard to find investments that might go up. If you can find enough of these, you’ll have moved in the right direction. But you’re unlikely to succeed for long if you haven’t dealt explicitly with risk. The first step consists of understanding it. The second step is recognizing when it’s high. The critical final step is controlling it. And all this is not easy.
One concept that helps greatly in understanding risk is that of ‘cycles’. Now, what is a cycle? Dictionaries define it as “a series of events that are regularly repeated in the same order” or “any complete round or series of occurrences that repeats or is repeated.” A business cycle, thus means recurring and fluctuating levels of economic activity that an economy experiences over a long period of time.

Risk-Taking Cycle

In his memo to clients in January 2013, the legendary Howard Marks wrote about the concept of risk-taking cycle in concept of investing. Marks outlines in an amazing manner the cycle, which I produce verbatim below.

If only we can carefully identify where in the cycle we lie at any given point in time, investment decision making would become much easier.

1. When economic growth is slow or negative and markets are weak, most people worry about losing money and disregard the risk of missing opportunities. Only a few stout-hearted contrarians are capable of imagining that improvement is possible.
2. Then the economy shows some signs of life, and corporate earnings begin to move up rather than down.
3. Sooner or later economic growth takes hold visibly and earnings show surprising gains.
4. This excess of reality over expectations causes security prices to start moving up.
5. Because of those gains – along with the improving economic and corporate news – the average investor realizes that improvement is actually underway. Confidence rises. Investors feel richer and smarter, forget their prior bad experience, and extrapolate the recent progress.
6. Skepticism and caution abate; optimism and aggressiveness take their place.
7. Anyone who’s been sitting out the dance experiences the pain of watching from the sidelines as assets appreciate. The bystanders feel regret and are gradually sucked in.
8. The longer this process goes on, the more enthusiasm for investments rises and resistance subsides. People worry less about losing money and more about missing opportunities.
9. Risk aversion evaporates and investors behave more aggressively. People begin to have difficulty imagining how losses could ever occur.
10. Financial institutions, subject to same influences, become willing to provide increased financing. In the words of Citibank’s Chuck prince, when the music’s playing, they see no choice but to dance. Thus they compete for market share by reducing the return they demand and by willing to finance riskier deals.
11. Easier financing – along with the recent gains – encourages investors to make greater use of leverage.

Borrowed capital increase their buying power, and they move to put it to work.
12. Leveraged investors report the greatest gains, consistent with the old Las Vegas maxim: “the more you bet, the more you win when you win.” This causes others to emulate them.
13. The market takes on the appearance of a perpetual-motion machine. Appreciation accelerates, possibly leading to a mania or bubble. Everyone concludes that things can only get better forever. They forget about the risk of losing money and fixate on not missing opportunities. Leveraged buyers become convinced that the things they buy with borrowed money are certain to appreciate at a rate above their borrowing cost.
14. Eventually things get as good as they can get, the last skeptic capitulates, and the last potential buyer buys.

That’s the way the cycle of attitudes towards risk ascends. The skeptic in times of moderation becomes a true believer at the top.

Then the down cycle begins…

15. Once the last potential buyer has bought, there’s nobody left to take prices higher.
16. A few unemotional, disciplined and foresighted investors conclude that things have gone too far and a correction is in the cards.
17. Economic activity and corporate earnings turn down, or they begin to fall short of people’s irrationally expanded expectations.
18. The error of those expectations becomes obvious, causing security prices to start declining. Perhaps someone is daring enough to point out publicly that the emperor of limitless growth has no clothes. Sometimes there’s a catalyzing event. Or sometimes (see early 2000) security prices begin to fall of their own accord, simply because they had moved too high.
19. The first price declines cause investors to rethink their analysis, conclusions, commitment to the market and risk tolerance. It becomes clear that appreciation will not go on ad infinitum. “I’d buy at any price” is replaced by “how can I know what the right price is?”
20. Weak economic news takes the place of positive reports.
21. The average investor realizes that things are getting worse.
22. Interest in investing declines. Selling replaces buying.
23. Investors who sat out the dance – or who just underweighted the depreciating assets – are lionized for their wisdom, and holders start to feel stupid.
24. Giddy enthusiasm is replaced by sober skepticism. Risk tolerance declines and risk aversion is on the upswing. People switch from worrying about missing opportunity to worrying about losing money.
25. Financial institutions become less willing to extend credit to investors. At the extremes, investors receive margin calls.
26. Investors who borrowed to buy are heavily penalized, and the media report on leveraged entities’ spectacular meltdowns. Forced selling in response to margin calls and covenant violations causes price declines to accelerate.
27. Eventually we hear some familiar refrains: “I wouldn’t buy at any price,” “There’s no negative case that can’t be exceeded on the downside,” and “I don’t care if I ever make another penny in the market; I just don’t want to lose any more.”
28. The last believer loses faith in the market, selling accelerates, and prices reach their nadir. Everyone concludes that things can only get worse forever.

Amazing description of our risk-taking attitude’s cycle, isn’t it? Well, as Marks writes, we humans will never change and our attitude towards risk-taking will move in a similar cycle always. But he also outlines a way you can cope with this risk cycle – this is by being contrarian.

When We Forget Rule Number One

When in school, I used to participate in our annual 6-KM cross-country race. Just the idea of “running away from school” was exciting for me, and thus I participated every year.

And every year, there was this classmate of mine, Anshul (not Safal Niveshak’s Anshul) who won the race, beating all of us by at least half a kilometre and more.

While I did not look much into the reason then why Anshul was consistently winning the race every year, I now know why it was so. Here is the speed chart of me and most of my other friends vs Anshul running that 6-KM race –

You know the reason now, don’t you? The reason why we lost and Anshul won every year was because we focused on high speed alone, while he focused on consistency at a decent speed.

In other words, while we were the Shahid Afridis (Pakistan’s flamboyant batsman) of those races, Anshul was Rahul Dravid…and that made all the difference in the end.

Speed Vs Consistency

“Speed has never killed anyone. Suddenly becoming stationary, that’s what gets you,” said Jeremy Clarson, an English broadcaster, journalist and writer who specialises in motoring.

Consider investing. Every bull market creates a lot of new investors with 40-50% 5-year CAGR under then belts. And these people inspire others into making such kind of killing from stocks. Some of these guys are really smart, while most are just a product of the bull market.

So, a lot of new investors, who like I did at my school race, get inspired by others making fast returns in quick time and start the investing game at high speeds. And thanks to the bull market and beginner’s luck, they do make some good returns in the first 2-3 years of their career.

The going looks very easy, and the future looks very bright for these investors. And this causes them to raise their bets, and try things like –

• Overpaying (not paying up, but overpaying) for high quality stocks because “the story remains exciting” and in the hope these stocks will continue to rise like they have done in the past (your long term returns are dependent on the price you pay for a business, and the probability of losing money by overpaying for stocks is high)
• Buying low quality businesses with mediocre or low return on capital (mistake) that appear cheap, and holding on when these stocks fall so as to get their money back (bigger mistake), and averaging as these stocks fall further (even bigger mistake).
• Moving outside their circle of competence and buying businesses they don’t understand but just because a few others have recently made money in them (surprisingly, I suddenly see a lot of people wanting to learn about the pharma business now, seemingly because some of these stocks have done very well in the recent past).
• Changing their investment philosophy abruptly to go with the flavour of the season (like I see some people now seeking comfort in buying average or bad businesses that are trading cheap because they have nothing to buy among good businesses that are trading expensive)
• Blindly cloning investors who has been successful in the recent past, ignoring that those cloned may have not seen more than one bad cycle and that some of them could be talking up their books

Here is a chart I would like to share on how most of these investors – who choose speed over consistency – fare when the race is run over a long distance (not 3-5 years but 15-20 years or more) –

This brings me back to the two basic rules of compounding –

1. The longer you let it work, the bigger will be its effect – time, not rate of return, is the most important variable in the compounding formula; and
2. If you lose big money even few times in your compounding journey, you will not receive its benefits, even in the long run.

So, like Clarson said, it’s not chasing the 25% CAGR speed that will kill you in the stock market, but the speed bumps you will meet along the way (losing big money, thanks to the mistake you may make in your need for high returns) that will get you.

Losing a 6-km race in school is still fine because the stakes are not high. But losing your wealth can be disastrous, because here your financial future is concerned. And once you trip over badly (due to the need for speed and the missteps it can lead you to take), it can be really difficult to come back into this game.

This, I believe, is why the most important words ever spoken in investing were – “Rule No.1: Never lose money. Rule No.2: Never forget rule No.1.”

And to modify this a bit – “Never lose money. But if you still lose some money out of your mistakes, never lose the lesson.”

Also Read:
• Howard Marks’ Memo to Clients – January 2013
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Spotlight

Handcrafted with in India