Randomness in itself is not risky when it comes to investing in the stock market. But how you manage that randomness is what matters in the final outcome of your investment process.
Imagine you are offered to play a betting game with a regular dice. The deal is that if your chosen number turns up, you win and get back double the amount you bet. Would you play this game?
Using simple probabilities, we can see that the expected value of this wager is negative. How? The probability of each number on the dice (with six faces) is 1/6. So expected value = 2 x (⅙) – 1 x (⅚) i.e., -(1/2).
If someone agrees to play this game, he’s blindly speculating. Isn’t he? He obviously doesn’t understand probability. The outcome of a dice throw is pretty random and you can’t hope to make money from randomness. But hang on. The game is about to get little more interesting and profitable.
If you’re informed (by reliable sources) that the dice is completely loaded (unfair) and number 6 turns up on every throw, would you bet your money now? Of course. The game is no more random for you. But for a person who doesn’t have this specialized information about dice, the game is still plagued by randomness.
Which means randomness could be subjective. It is not absolute – the same event is more random to one person than to another. Notice that the extent of randomness decreases with the knowledge we obtain (the dice is loaded and favours the number 6). Which simply translates to the idea that the better we understand the business we are exposed to, professionally or through a stock purchase, the less random the environment is to us.
The dice example might look very obvious and uninsightful but if you could draw a parallel in investing, the lesson learnt can turn a losing investment strategy to a winning one. Because there is strong correlation between randomness and risk.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
If it weren’t for randomness, we’d have 100 percent predictability in our forecasting, we’d know a precise outcome for every decision, and investing would be without risk. But that never happens.
Most people fail in investing because either they don’t acknowledge the role of randomness in investing or they don’t understand how to mitigate the risk by reducing the randomness. So that’s what we are going to do today – explore the relationship between risk and randomness and how it plays out in the world of stock market investing. But before that, let’s revisit some of the well-known definitions of risk which most of us have seen before.
One of the most popular measures of risk is volatility. Volatility is the movement in stock price on day to day basis which usually is the subject of more than 90 percent of the charts and graphs that are circulated in the investment community. How does volatility give rise to risk? It’s a risk for someone who can’t wait out the period of volatility. But if you are armed with a long-term time horizon, volatility is merely an inconvenience.
There is another important, although less tangible, issue with volatility. It impacts our emotions and makes us do the wrong things – buy high and sell low. For a very rational, computer-like decision maker, volatility is not an issue. But we are not computers. Therefore, you shouldn’t ignore the emotional element of volatility.
The second, less commonly known but more relevant, source of risk is permanent loss of capital. If you are investing for the long run (at least five years) a permanent loss of capital is the risk that you should be concerned with the most. This type risk usually arises from the possibility of investing in a bad business or at a bad price or both.
Notice that the key that differentiates the two types of risk – risk from volatility and risk of permanent loss of capital – is time horizon.
Risk from Randomness
To understand the equation between randomness and risk, you first need to wrap your head around two important and distinctive properties of randomness –
1. Level of uncertainty – How much unpredictability is present in a given environment?
2. Significance of impact – How deadly could that unpredictability be for the final outcome?
In the dice example, the level of uncertainty is approximately 16 percent (when you don’t know that the dice is loaded). And what about impact? That would depend on your bet size. If you have Rs 10 lakh in bank and you are betting only Rs 1,000, the impact (if you lose it) isn’t much i.e., in spite of high level of uncertainty, the risk is pretty low. Put simply, randomness by itself is not risky.
If the discussion on randomness seems very theoretical then let me remind you that we prepare for randomness on a daily basis – but often don’t realize that we are actually doing it. For example, when you decide to leave early for office in the morning, what you’re essentially doing is minimizing the unpredictability of your commute time (by avoiding the rush hour traffic). And by wearing seat-belt/helmet (I hope you do) and driving slow you’re reducing the exposure (severity of injury) to the impact of randomness (an accident).
Heard of the Crocodile Hunter?
The event, no matter how rare, that has a severely harmful outcome is the risky one. Consider the case of Steve Irwin, the famous Australian crocodile hunter.
Mr. Irwin spent most of his time making TV shows in very close proximity to dangerous predators (crocodiles, snakes, spiders, etc.) whose behavior is very unpredictable (random) and potentially lethal. The chance of a significant impact (dying) resulting from being close to a crocodile for an ignorant, inexperienced person like you and me is very high. But Mr. Irwin by dint of his skill, knowledge, and experience reduced that probability for himself to something like 1 out of 1,000. In spite of that he couldn’t escape from the deadly claws of randomness.
On 4 September 2006, while filming a documentary in Batt Reef, Queensland, Australia, Steve approached an 8 feet wide stingray from behind. Much to his surprise and shock – this had never happened before — the fish reacted as if a shark was attacking, striking him several hundred times in his body with its tail spine in a few seconds. Steve initially believed he only had a punctured lung but the tail spine had pierced his heart. Forty-four year old Steve bled out and died.
His producer said: ‘‘If ever he was going to go, we always said it was going to be in the ocean because there is another element …. On land he was agile, quick-thinking, quick-moving. The ocean puts another element there that you have no control over.’’ Irwin was adept at handling the land based animals but the randomness inside the ocean was still too much for him to handle. That was his first mistake – venturing out of his circle of competence.
So the first lesson that we learn here is that randomness can be managed by staying inside our circle of competence.
Randomness is Invisible
In the very first issue of Value Investing Almanack (Feb. 2015), we had discussed the idea of ‘alternate histories’ in the Behaviouronomics section. Alternate history is the set of all possible outcomes of an event that could have transpired. Since, only one of those possibilities actually happen, the others usually remain hidden from us. This makes us prone to hindsight bias. The hindsight means ‘‘understanding the nature of an event after it has happened.’’ Hindsight bias hides the randomness and hence the risk associated with.
The famous game of Russian roulette is a great example to illustrate this concept. Nassim Taleb, in his book Fooled by Randomness, explains –
Imagine you are offered $10 million to play Russian roulette, i.e., to put a revolver containing one bullet in the six available chambers to your head and pull the trigger. Each realisation would count as one history, for a total of six possible histories of equal probabilities. Five out of these six histories would lead to enrichment; one would lead to a statistic, that is, an obituary with an embarrassing (but certainly original) cause of death……in time, if the roulette-betting fool keeps playing the game, the bad histories will tend to catch up with him. Thus, if a twenty-five-year-old played Russian roulette, say, once a year, there would be a very slim possibility of him surviving until his fiftieth birthday – but, if there are enough players, say thousands of twenty-five-year-old players, we can expect to see a handful of (extremely rich) survivors (and a very large cemetery)
Thus, in case of Steve Irwin it was just a matter of time before he paid that price for his high exposure to a very random and dangerous environment.
So the second lesson is that hindsight bias hides the randomness from you. The hindsight of knowing how things transpired provides false clarity and teaches you a wrong lesson. It also creates an illusion of control i.e., it makes you think you know more than you do, and so you think you control more than you do.
History provides only one (though definitive) version of what could have taken place and makes us blind to all the other possible paths which could have proved to be extremely bad for your health, especially financial health. Always be looking out for hidden risks and understand that a good outcome doesn’t necessarily prove that the process followed was also sound.
This is why, for most investors, it is useful to focus on businesses that have at least 10-year history of operation and have seen at least one bear market so that you can see how resilient the business is under adverse economic environment i.e., when randomness is showing its ugly face.
The third lesson is that the real world randomness is not easy to measure unlike the game of dice. Reality is far more vicious than Russian roulette, writes Nassim Taleb –
First, it delivers the fatal bullet rather infrequently, like a revolver that would have hundreds, even thousands, of chambers instead of six. After a few dozen tries, one forgets about the existence of a bullet, under numbing false sense of security.
According to one CNN report, the chances of Steve Irwin dying by a stingray on any specific day while swimming in Australia was about 1 in 794 million – not a statistic one would pay a great deal of attention to. But randomness is, after all, random.
Randomness in Investing
In reality it’s not easy to pinpoint the sources of randomness, for one everything is random and the degree of randomness varies from one place to another, from one industry to another, from one asset class to another etc. But there are certain things which may not increase the randomness but don’t decrease it either. Those are the things you need to watch out for.
Debt is one such thing. Debt increases the severity of impact of random events. So in spite of the low uncertainty of an adverse outcome, presence of debt increases the risk manifold. That’s what happened in case of LTCM disaster. It was a fund managed by Nobel laureates who used complex mathematical equations to predict the price movement of Russian bonds. When they calculated the odds of Russian default to be infinitesimal, it was an error on their part. But what magnified their mistake was the level of debt they were using to play the game. When Russians defaulted, LTCM’s 4-year record of 40 percent CAGR return was transformed into permanent loss of capital. The risk of randomness wiped them out, and also their investors.
Consider some listed Indian companies like IVRCL, Jaiprakash Associates, Unitech, Adani Enterprises, and Jindal Steel and Power. All these were hyped up during the boom of 2006-07, they built huge debt on their balance sheet to fund “unlimited growth”, and see what transpired over the next few years. All these businesses are into deeper mess today, and shareholders in them have lost tons of money over the years.
Anyways, the second source of randomness is the nature of business. For example, any business where the future earnings depend on the oil prices, is in the soup of randomness. To predict future oil prices, one has to accurately forecast the future demand and supply of oil and answer a lot of complex questions. In short, commodity type of businesses have high degree of uncertainty hence the risk is higher in such ventures.
Managing Risk of Randomness
“All of life is a management of risk,” writes Walter Wriston, former chairman of Citicorp, “not its elimination.” Randomness is the fabric that weaves the interaction of everything around us. Since you can’t remove randomness from our affairs, you can’t get rid of the risk also. Peter Bernstein in his book Against the Gods writes –
The essence of risk management lies in maximizing the areas where we have some control over the outcome while minimizing the areas where we have absolutely no control over the outcome and the linkage between effect and cause is hidden from us.
What does that mean to you as an investor? It means you need to avoid the game of regular dice and look for the loaded dice. In other words, you should own those stocks where your knowledge (in-depth research) and expertise make the environment less random.
Once you have taken care of randomness, the second and more important thing to remember is to minimize the impact, should randomness strike. Which means building a margin of safety. The greater the potential impact, the larger the margin of safety you may need.
Here’s Warren Buffett explaining the idea in very simple words –
If you understood a business perfectly and the future of the business, you would need very little in the way of a margin of safety. So, the more vulnerable the business is, assuming you still want to invest in it, the larger margin of safety you’d need. If you’re driving a truck across a bridge that says it holds 10,000 pounds and you’ve got a 9,800-pound vehicle, if the bridge is 6 inches above the crevice it covers, you may feel okay, but if it’s over the Grand Canyon, you may feel you want a little larger margin of safety.
Conclusion
The bottomline is, all of us have a circle of competence, and therefore we have a circle of incompetence as well. Knowing you circle of incompetence, your limitations, is the only way you can reduce the risk of randomness.
Warren Buffett is probably world’s greatest simplifier. There couldn’t be a simpler and more profound definition of risk than what Warren gave –
Risk comes from not knowing what you’re doing.
I hope you understand what you’re doing. If not, have you at least figured out the downside yet? If your answer is still no, then all I can say is you’re a sitting duck and it’s just a matter of time when the randomness of markets will make a mincemeat out of you.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
