• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Spotlight: It’s the Culture, Stupid!

June 3, 2015

A business’s long-term staying power is determined by its corporate culture. Despite this, most companies pay less heed to building a good one, and more to short term profit making. Let’s explore what you as an investor must look at while assessing how cultured or uncultured a company is.

I was recently travelling with my family in a luxury bus from Goa to Mumbai. I call it luxury because it had a working AC and the seats that adjusted a bit. That’s it!

It was a night journey, which began on a bad note (the bus was late), and ended in a nightmare (the bus broke down in the middle of night near a lonely place called Chiplun in Maharashtra). That we were travelling with four kids added to the nightmare. Twice, the bus got filled with smoke from a faulty electrical system, so twice we had to run out with kids and luggage in our hands.

The next bus was called for only after an hour of getting stranded, and this replacement bus was supposed to reach us only five hours later.

I called up a nearby hotel and the manager there was courteous enough to send a cab to pick us up and then arrange one to send us to Mumbai. In all, a journey that was supposed to take 10 hours, took 18. The cost of travel was higher by almost 75%.

“I want a refund for the breakdown of the bus and the harassment it caused the passengers,” I asked the customer service representative on reaching Mumbai. First, he did not have any information that his company’s bus had broken down, and then when he confirmed with his representatives, he agreed on a refund.

“We will refund you Rs 400 per passenger,” he told me. “Just 25% of the total fare?” I countered. “That’s less than half of what it costs to travel from Chiplun to Mumbai in a similar bus! And what about the trouble the entire episode has caused us?”

“This is what the head office has decided!” he replied and kept the phone down before I could say anything else.

I called up their head office, and got the same answer from their senior manager. And the casual way he and his team dealt with the entire situation was equally sad!

“I won’t ever travel with your bus!” I told him. “That’s fine!” he said, and banged the phone down.

“That’s what you get in the name of customer service,” I told my wife who was constantly asking me to calm down.

Well, the bus I was travelling in was from a company called VRL Logistics, a company that recently came out with an IPO, and which constantly talks about how they delight customers! They were in fact recognized as Service Provider of the Year 2013 by some World Travel Brand Awards (says a lot about how awards are won!)

Damn the Customer!
I am willing to bet my money on the fact that if I ask you to name 10 companies in India that have delighted you with great customer service, and 10 that have troubled you with a poor one, the second list will come out faster and the first would not get complete at all.

I am sure the situation is bad across countries, but the unprofessional way companies treat customers in a populated country like India truly deserves a case study (on how not to treat customers) at Harvard Business School.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] And I think I know the reasons for such mis-treatment handed out by most companies (Indians or MNCs) in this country –

• Most customers don’t/won’t complain;
• Most customers don’t know where to complain; and
• India is a highly populated country, so if they lose one customer, there are ten new ones in line; and
• Most business owners don’t understand customer service, and that flows through the organization.

Forget an Indian company like VRL, and just consider the way the management of Nestle has treated the Maggi controversy so far. Instead of coming out in the open and saying “We’re sorry!” to the mothers and kids whom they have been falsely selling the “Taste Bhi, Health Bhi” promise for long, they have kept quiet and have largely denied the controversy so far.

One, the Nestle India’s managers do not seem to understand the plight of its Indian consumers simple because they don’t have an Indian face to the management. Their Chairman in a Brazilian, and the Managing Director a French. When so many Indian managers have failed to align their cultures with that of their stakeholders, how would a team of foreigners truly understand the Indian culture and thus build their business’s culture in sync with the same?

The results are there for everyone to see. Agreed, Nestle has been a great business thanks to its products and market leadership built over a number of decades, but then the management seems to have not heard what Warren Buffett so often says…

It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. If you think about that, you’ll do things differently.

And even as far as their best-selling product Maggi is concerned, the dangers of consuming the same have been glibly hidden behind multi-million dollar ad campaigns over the years. Or how else do you sell an unhealthy combination of wheat flour (maida), vanaspati oil that is mainly trans-fat and which increases the shelf life and taste of the product, and excessive sodium (salt)? Plus, how do you make a product that’s cheaper than a humble dosa and yet so tasty and filling?

Maggi has always been poison…even if it is lead free…and especially for the young ones. My kids have never consumed Maggi (or a Cola), and they can finally see sense in mine and my wife’s efforts to keep them away from it.

Anyways, the Maggi incident also reminds me of the British Petroleum (BP) oil spill – the worst in the US history – that happened in 2010, which was led by the company’s culture of “every dollar counts”. During the spill that took 87 days to control, an estimated 4.9 million barrels of oil was spilled into the Gulf of Mexico. Now, what is instructive about this unfortunate disaster to those interested in the concept of corporate culture is the way BP leadership responded in the early days of the accident.

Initially, the company downplayed the incident. Its CEO Tony Hayward told the media…

The Gulf of Mexico is a very big ocean. The amount of volume of oil and dispersant we are putting into it is tiny in relation to the total water volume.

He then made an atrocious statement…

We will fix it. I guarantee it. The only question is we do not know when.

The company and its management ended up acting like a child that doesn’t want to clean up its mess and drags its feet, which was strange, given the monumental risk to the company.

Cut to another crisis of equally great proportions – Johnson & Johnson (J&J) and the Tylenol (J&J’s pain reliever) disaster that led to death of some of its customers in 1982. But here, the way J&J reacted by way of massive, and immediate, recall was unprecedented and set the standard for corporate behavior in the face of existential threats to a business.

So two almost similar incidents – BP and J&J – and two different reactions, and both suggesting the difference in cultures within the respective companies.

One culture, very cost focused and financially driven with all eyes on share price and productivity, with visible behaviours of blame and executive arrogance. The other, guided by a fundamental set of shared beliefs and leadership behaviours putting the welfare of the users of their products first, and profits last.

From these two events, it is easy to see that culture matters, big time! And “compromising on culture,” as the HubSpot Culture Code reads, “is mortgaging the future.”

On the other hand, companies that focus on building a sound, solid culture have a great staying power. As Prof. Sanjay Bakshi wrote in a recent post, from the vantage point of corporate culture, a company’s staying power comes from –

• Willingness to cede market share when irrational competition drives down potential returns – and in the extreme case exiting a businesses.
• Refusal to invest in a business which deserves to die – i.e., not throwing good money after bad – and conserving it for productive uses.
• Unwillingness to bet the bank on a single idea – intelligent risk management as part of the DNA of the firm (including avoidance of gambling in the garb of risk management through derivatives).
• Willingness to make multiple small bets to grow the business so that no single bet or a group of bets, if they turn bad, can destroy the business.

To this, I will add the willingness to delight the customer, even the smallest one, instead of taking her for a ride. After all, the structure of a business stands on its customers. And their trust and continued business is what creates real staying power.

While books and journals may not write about it, great customer service is one of the best and most impregnable sources of moat a company can have. And a great customer service is a result of a great culture within the company. And a great culture is what determines the long-term success of a business, the sustainability of its moat, and the returns it generates for investors

It’s the Culture, Stupid!

Culture is defined as the sum of shared values, beliefs, and norms of behavior. (Bossidy and Charan)

“Culture, more than rule books, determines how an organization behaves,” wrote Warren Buffett in his memo to Berkshire’s managers in 2010. He wrote…

As I’ve said in these memos for more than 25 years: “We can afford to lose money – even a lot of money. But we can’t afford to lose reputation – even a shred of reputation.” We must continue to measure every act against not only what is legal but also what we would be happy to have written about on the front page of a national newspaper in an article written by an unfriendly but intelligent reporter.

Sometimes your associates will say “Everybody else is doing it.” This rationale is almost always a bad one if it is the main justification for a business action. It is totally unacceptable when evaluating a moral decision. Whenever somebody offers that phrase as a rationale, in effect they are saying that they can’t come up with a good reason. If anyone gives this explanation, tell them to try using it with a reporter or a judge and see how far it gets them.

If you see anything whose propriety or legality causes you to hesitate, be sure to give me a call. However, it’s very likely that if a given course of action evokes such hesitation, it’s too close to the line and should be abandoned. There’s plenty of money to be made in the center of the court. If it’s questionable whether some action is close to the line, just assume it is outside and forget it.

Somebody is doing something today at Berkshire that you and I would be unhappy about if we knew of it. That’s inevitable: We now employ more than 250,000 people and the chances of that number getting through the day without any bad behavior occurring is nil. But we can have a huge effect in minimizing such activities by jumping on anything immediately when there is the slightest odor of impropriety. Your attitude on such matters, expressed by behavior as well as words, will be the most important factor in how the culture of your business develops.

Culture, more than rule books, determines how an organization behaves.

In fact, a company’s culture might be the only trade secret that can’t be copied or commoditized. And the very fact that most companies would rather worry about short-term profits than long-term culture building gives companies that focuses on the latter an advantage of sorts.

Consider the phenomenal long-term success of Southwest Airlines in the US, which is often ascribed to its unique culture in combination with its sound business strategy. Despite being in an industry that is known to burn great amounts of cash and destroy capital, Southwest celebrated 40 consecutive years of profitable operation in 2012, an unmatched record in the world of airline transportation. So, maybe, there’s a linkage between culture and performance.

Then, consider the example of Zappos.com, an online shoe and clothing shop that John Childress writes about in his book Leverage: The CEO’s Guide to Corporate Culture…

In 1999, would you have invested money in an online, Internet-only shoe retailer? Probably not, especially in retail industry where everyone knows how important it is to physically try on the product, see how it looks and feels, and to be helped by a knowledgeable, experienced shoe salesperson. Besides, in 1999 the Internet and Internet-retailing was still in its infancy, and very few people were comfortable giving up their credit card details over the phone, let alone through a computer keyboard. Not many Wall Street analysts and business gurus gave Zappos.com a snowball’s chance in hell.

But to Tony Hsieh, the guiding force and CEO of Zappos.com, the strategy was simple: build a strong corporate culture that will deliver excellent customer service. The definitive task would be execution, not marketing or product pricing strategies. And the challenge was how to sell lots of different brands of shoes directly to customers through the Internet while giving world-class customer service.

While Tony and the team believed with all their body and soul that corporate culture needed to be the foundation of the company, they also know they needed robust business processes that matched that unique culture in order to deliver consistent, world-class customer service.

With those two principles in place, Zappos.com went from $0 in 1999 to $1 Billion in revenue in 2009, at which time they were bought by Amazon.

Culture, in alignment with robust business processes designed to fit the business strategy, create a potent competitive advantage.

Coming back to Buffett, he first used the word culture in his letter for 1982 (remember, this is when he was still coming over from being a 100% Graham to 80-20 Graham-Fisher, and thus was starting to focus more on business quality and competitive advantages), wherein he wrote this about a couple of managers at his insurance businesses…

They maintain a passionately proprietary attitude toward their operations and have developed a business culture centered upon unusual cost‐consciousness and customer service. It shows on their scorecards.

Then, in his 1985 letter, he wrote…

…I want to emphasize that some managers whom I admire enormously – and whose operating records are far better than mine…have built corporate cultures that work…By their leadership and example….these managers have taught their colleagues to think like owners. Such a Culture is rare and when it exists should perhaps be left intact…

In 2002, he wrote this while talking about companies Berkshire acquires…

It’s not our style to tamper with successful business cultures.

And then, in 2007, he wrote…

…I’ve taken the easy route, just sitting back and working through great managers who run their own shows. My only tasks are to cheer them on, sculpt and harden our corporate culture, and make major capital-allocation decisions. Our managers have returned this trust by working hard and effectively.

In his 2010 letter, he wrote what may be his definitive thoughts on corporate culture…

…Our final advantage is the hard-to-duplicate culture that permeates Berkshire. And in businesses, culture counts.

…Cultures self-propagate. Winston Churchill once said, “You shape your houses and then they shape you.” That wisdom applies to businesses as well. Bureaucratic procedures beget more bureaucracy, and imperial corporate palaces induce imperious behavior. (As one wag put it, “You know you’re no longer CEO when you get in the back seat of your car and it doesn’t move.”) At Berkshire’s “World Headquarters” our annual rent is $270,212. Moreover, the home-office investment in furniture, art, Coke dispenser, lunch room, high-tech equipment –you name it–totals $301,363.”

In his latest 2015 meeting with shareholders, he’s supposed to have said this…

Culture is everything at Berkshire. Culture has to come from the top. It has to be consistent. It has to be part of written communications and rewarded when followed and punished when not.

Buffett and Munger, two of the world’s most consummate profit making capitalists, deliver enviable shareholder returns by living and breathing the culture ethos in their corporate and personal lives.

Most other senior executives globally, including in India, talk a big game on setting culture. Far fewer constantly reinforce it and devote the adequate resources to turning the cheap talk into reality.

Spotting the Un-Cultured

When it comes to making profits, except for e-commerce companies who don’t understand this word at all, it’s an easy choice for most companies out there. Most of them can really lose their conscience when it comes to profit making. And most of them anyways don’t care about servicing customers well – forget thinking about building the right culture that can serve them as their best source of sustainable moat.

For such businesses and their managers, it would be good to take Carl Jacobi’s advice of “Invert, always invert.”

Don Keough did this in his book The Ten Commandments for Business Failure that described ten things sure to make a company fail.

When creating effective cultures, it is helpful for managers to think about what one would do if you were trying to create a very poor company culture. And you as an investor can also look at these things while screening for and analyzing companies.

Look for these enemies of effective company cultures, and then avoid companies that possess them –

• Inconsistent leadership behavior (Opto Circuits, Satyam, Geodesic)
• Arrogance borne of pride and success (Kingfisher, Reliance, most banks, real estate and construction companies)
• Focus completely on competition than on customer
• Too rapid growth (Suzlon, e-commerce companies)
• Too little growth
• Bureaucracy (PSUs)
• Acquisitions-led growth (Suzlon, 3i Infotech)
• Complex language used in corporate communication (annual reports of most companies)

When you are building your company’s culture, these are all things to avoid. And so it is true when you are looking to invest in companies. Avoid the ones that show signs of the presence of any or a combination of these factors that are all signs of a bad corporate culture.

Now, which are the companies you need to focus on that have great corporate cultures?

Consider this speech that the Chairman of Hawkins Cookers Mr. Brahm Vasudeva gave at the company’s AGM in 2009, where he talked about the “Hawkins Culture” by defining its seven core principles –

1. Follow the Golden Rule – “Do unto others as you would that they do unto you.”
2. Ends and Means – “We are not so results-orientated that we will use any means to achieve them. All our people are instructed time and again that the results have to be achieved and the means have to be right.”
3. Seek the Best – “From the choice of materials and machines to the selection and promotion of our people, we choose to work with the best we can get or create.”
4. Hot Focus – “We are a stay-close-to-the-knitting kind of company.”
5. Be Prudent – “This principle applies to our financial operations as well as general expectations. We are conservative to the point of being stodgy. We do not issue ‘detailed guidance’ to investors. We do not seek out analysts or journalists. We don’t “Bet the Company” on anything, no matter how exciting the prospect is.”
6. Where an Important Principle is Involved, Be Bold, Brave, and Resolute – “There have been a few occasions when we have faced situations fraught with consequences. It may be a hugely important customer or a state government or even the Government of India who has in some matter treated us unjustly to the extent that it hurts us in a major way or involves important principles which would prejudice us in the future. In such cases, we have never shied away from representing our case directly to the party concerned or, if all else fails, taking the matter to the appropriate court.”
7. Do Your Best and Leave the Rest to God – “This most important principle prevents us from developing an exaggerated view of our own importance and allows us to sleep soundly at night. It also enables us to enjoy our work without undue anxiety.”

Here is a company that makes as simple a product as pressure cookers, but its management believes in creating a culture that even a biotech firm can conform to and succeed in the long run.

Then, consider the Owner’s Manual outlined by Buffett from time to time, which conceives Berkshire as a partnership whose focus is on shareholders.

In Berkshire Beyond Buffett: The Enduring Value of Values where he profiles Berkshire’s corporate culture, Lawrence Cunningham writes –

The company treats its shareholders not merely as temporary holders of its equity, but as business partners in an endless venture. Such a value is one of the most prevalent at Berkshire, as its subsidiaries — including many family businesses — are seeking a permanent home for their company, and Berkshire prides itself on holding its subsidiaries permanently. They are owners for whom Berkshire’s managers,including Buffett and those of the subsidiaries, are stewards. The principles also stress that Berkshire’s chief executive and controlling shareholders will treat fellow shareholders loyally as partners, rather than as mere sources of capital.

How I wish more and more companies can adopt such practices where they act – not just in letter but in spirit – as true stewards of shareholders’ capital rather than thinking the latter as mere sources of capital.

Cunningham writes in his book –

Corporate culture matters because it translates into business performance. For example, a company whose management and shareholders embrace a long-term outlook can better weather financial volatility. Companies with reputations for thrift and conservatism are less likely to default and therefore enjoy higher credit ratings and lower borrowing costs, and the stock prices of such companies tend to be less volatile, attracting investors.

A business known for integrity — treating suppliers, employees, and customers as the business would like to be treated if the positions were reversed — will usually win more interest and cooperation among such groups than rivals who are chiselers. Such a reputation for excellence — in merchandising, manufacturing, services, or other business activities — can manifest in better terms of trade at the outset of relationships and more flexibility to cope with periodic adversity.

Culture Isn’t a Value Statement

A lot of annual reports showcase, on glossy pages, what the organization stands for. This is grandly titled the Mission / Vision Statement. Even Enron and Satyam had grand value statements that promised integrity, respect for stakeholders, and excellence in business practices.

In fact, the grandest and glossiest value/mission/vision statements would come from companies that have the worst of cultures, given that they need to mask their wrongdoings well. So, that’s a subtle hint for you to be careful when a company or its managers use a lot of grand words to explain what they stand for, and what their culture is.

In most cases, they must have been advised by their high-cost consultants to create such ‘culture statements’. Culture statements can be interpreted in many ways. Behaviours are much more binary and easy to observe.

So, observe how managements/companies behave, and especially when no one is watching them. But don’t ignore a company’s culture while analyzing its underlying business.

A great culture, after all, is one of the most potent sources of competitive moats a company may have.

Financial numbers may not give you a lot of indication on culture, but these when combined with how the management has behaved all these years may serve you a great reference point in whether you should research a company deeper, or simply junk it.

For some solid corporate cultures in India, read through the businesses of companies like Hawkins Cookers, Infosys, Bajaj Auto, Pidilite, Asian Paints, Wipro, Ashiana Housing, and the Murugappa Group.

Further Reading

  • Berkshire Beyond Buffett: The Enduring Value of Values by Lawrence A. Cunningham
  • The Seven Strands of DNA of Hawkins
  • The HubSpot Culture Code
  • Zappos’s 2014 Culture Book
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Spotlight

Handcrafted with in India