In investing, what feels comfortable is rarely safe. Read why independence of thought and not blindly mimicking the herd is a more sensible and profitable strategy for investors.
What feels safe is often risky, and what feels risky is often safe.
If there was one of the most contradictory statements about the evolutionary instinct we possess, this must be it.
Since ages, human beings have tried to seek safety and avoid risk whenever possible (well, we’re not talking about the stock market yet!).
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
A classic example has to be the instinct that (still) tells us we are safer staying with the group.
If members of the herd stray, they are easy targets for predators. Staying with the group has proved the best way to survive.
For generations, this principle was true at work, too. Many of our grandparents and parents had one job for many years, retired with a pension and lived happily ever after.
Things have changed…and all in a span of just one generation.
Seth Godin writes about the concepts of “safety zone” and “comfort zone” in his brilliant book, The Icarus Deception. Godin writes…
For a long time, the two (safety and comfort zones) were one and the same. The mountain climber who knows when she’s outside of her safety zone feel uncomfortable about it and stops – and lives to climb another day.
Your entire life has been about coordinating your comfort zone and your safety zone. Like the fox, we’ve been trained to stay inside the fence, because inside the fence is where it’s safe – until it’s too late.
We don’t have time to re-evaluate the safety zone every time we make a decision, so over time, we begin to forget about the safety zone.We assume that what makes us comfortable also makes us safe.
Look at investing. People who found comfort in Harshad Mehta stocks in the early 1990s, then dotcom stocks in 2000, and then real estate and infrastructure stocks in 2007, also found safety in them.
In all these instances, the need of the hour for most people was to make decision fast as they did not want to be left behind when others were making money. So, whatever looked comfortable (rising stocks) also looked safe.
Every time things turned upside down and the stocks crashed, those very people had to confront an obvious truth – What looked most comfortable wasn’t really safe.
But the biggest irony in the stock market is that people easily forget the lessons from history. That’s the reason they make the same mistakes again and again. If you consider the current times, you’ll find a lot of people are finding comfort in defensive stocks – the so called businesses with moats. And that is what they see as extremely safe. Try arguing with someone willing to pay the sky for the most loved consumption stocks of today, and be ready to get a barrage of abuses.
But as they say, in the stock market, the history doesn’t repeat, it rhymes. So, what may seem the most comfortable today may well be the most dangerous spaces to be invested in.
Now, of course, few decisions will feel riskier than making an investment choice that appears to contradict what everyone else is doing. Remember 2006 and 2007?
The herd was so confident that real estate and infrastructure stocks would only keep going up, it seemed crazy not to buy into that dream theme. Ironically, the very moment when it felt the safest, when everyone else was buying right at the top, was when it turned out to be the most dangerous. It demonstrates the fear and greed cycle perfectly.
The herd instinct is seen nowhere in more vigorously than in the fund management industry. Here is what Jason Zweig writes in his commentary for Chapter 9 of The Intelligent Investor…
…once a fund becomes successful, its managers tend to become timid and imitative. As a fund grows, its fees become more lucrative – making its managers reluctant to rock the boat. The very risks that the managers took to generate their initial high returns could not drive investors away – and jeopardize all that fat fee income.
So the biggest funds resemble a herd of identical and overfed sheep, all moving in sluggish lockstep, all saying “baaaa” at the same time.”
In Exhibit 1 below, look at the top ten holdings data of some of the largest Indian mutual fund schemes with assets under management. All have a lot of stocks in common. And, by the way, one of the schemes is named “Contra”! 🙂
If this isn’t herding, what is? By protecting their own fee income, fund managers compromise their ability to produce superior returns for their outside investor. They may have done well in the past, but their ability to do well in the future diminishes as they become more and more like the herd.
Pitfalls of Mimicking the Herd
Charlie Munger has “Independence” as an integral part of his Investing Principles Checklist. He says – “Only in fairy tales are emperors told they are naked.” He then outlines his idea of independence as an investor this way…
- Objectivity and rationality require independence of thought
Remember that just because other people agree or disagree with you doesn’t make you right or wrong – the only thing that matters is the correctness of your analysis and judgment
- Mimicking the herd invites regression to the mean (merely average performance)
But then, Keynes said, “Worldly wisdom teaches that it is better for reputation to fail conventionally than to succeed unconventionally.” That’s where the biggest constraint of going against the crowd lies (what Keynes called unconventional). And that’s why most investors and fund managers do – rather than going against the crowd and standing a chance to succeed unconventionally, it’s good to go with the crowd and fail with them. After all, when everyone’s wrong, no one’s wrong.
Michael Mauboussin captures the essence of independence in a different light in his paper titled – Contrarian Investing: The Psychology of Going Against the Crowd. He writes…
…the goal is not to be a contrarian just to be a contrarian, but rather to feel comfortable betting against the crowd when the gap between fundamentals and expectations warrants it. This independence is difficult because the widest gap (like in 1999, or 2007) often coincides with the strongest urge to be part of the group. Independence also incorporates the notion of objectivity – an ability to assess the odds without being swayed by outside factors. After all, prices not only inform investors, they also influence investors.”
He then adds…
Investing is inherently a probabilistic exercise, where process should be the focus versus short-term outcomes. Contrarian investors acknowledge that it may take some time for the market to revise expectations. This problem is compounded by myopic loss aversion, the idea that the more frequently you assess your portfolio, the more likely you are to see losses and hence suffer loss aversion.”
So, two things worth nothing here –
- Don’t go against the crowd just for the sake of it. Rather, first be objective in your analysis and then decide whether to go contrarian.
- Focus on the process instead of short-term results that are largely a result of luck. Don’t watch your portfolio frequently, as that may lead you to act in the direction stock prices are heading.
But now, an interesting point worth considering is that most people believe that going with the herd is a dangerous thing to do, while not realizing that they may already be part of the herd.
Are You Part of the Herd Too?
You do not need a degree in psychology to understand that, in the short run, the price of a stock can deviate substantially from its basic value. This is because market participants may betray a herd instinct in their behaviour.
This is probably the most important concept that you need to know about market psychology. When people do not understand a company well, they follow the crowd. They chase the winners and dump the losers indiscriminately.
Because of this herd mentality, individual stocks – and the entire market – may go up or down dramatically.
Now, do you know whether you have the herding instinct? It’s a good idea to find that out if you can. The most common phenomenon I have observed is that people feel like buying a stock when its price has recently gone up or when the market has gone up. If you do so without evaluating the company, you are probably herding.
Do you evaluate the price increase in a logical manner? You are probably not herding if you estimate a stock’s intrinsic value and factor in margin of safety before you make a buy or sell decision.
Investors often extrapolate evidence from recent trends and then decide to buy or sell. If it were easy to pick stocks based on recent price trends alone, most mutual fund managers would be able to beat the market indices. But most of them don’t. For every trend that continues, there is probably another one that does not.
The best antidote to herding lies in knowledge and in focusing on the long run. Buffett’s suggestion of buying only what you know may help you avoid following the herd. In addition, concentrate on fundamentals. Peter Lynch has captured this idea in the chapter “Earnings, Earnings, Earnings” in his book One Up on Wall Street.
He explains, “What you’re asking here is what makes a company valuable, and why it will be more valuable tomorrow than it is today. There are many theories, but to me, it always comes down to earnings and assets. Especially earnings.”
Reading Peter Lynch or Warren Buffett was a good start to me, but not enough. I understood them better only after I delved into learning behavioural finance and evaluating my decisions. And it took me several years to understand that I had a herd mentality. To avoid herding, I now try to zero in on the long term. I follow Plato’s centuries-old wisdom – “Know thyself.”
The Most Important Thing is…Contrarianism
Sir John Templeton said, “To buy when others are despondently selling and to sell when others are euphorically buying takes the greatest courage, but provides the greatest profit.”
Then, this is what Warren Buffett says, “The less prudence with which others conduct their affairs, the greater the prudence with which we should conduct our own affairs.” In other words, Buffett is urging us to do the opposite of what others do: to be contrarians.
“Buy low; sell high” is the time-honoured dictum, but investors who are swept up in market cycles too often do just the opposite. Here is what Howard Marks writes in The Most Important Thing –
The proper response lies in contrarian behavior: buy when they hate ’em, and sell when they love ’em. “Once- in- a-lifetime” market extremes seem to occur once every decade or so— not often enough for an investor to build a career around capitalizing on them. But attempting to do so should be an important component of any investor’s approach.”
Now, of course, being a contrarian is not going to be a profitable strategy at all times. After all, much of the time there aren’t great market excesses to bet against. And even when an excess does develop, it’s important to remember that “overpriced” is incredibly different from “going down tomorrow.”
What is more interesting, it can appear at times that “everyone” has reached the conclusion that the herd is wrong. What I mean is that contrarianism itself can appear to have become too popular, and thus contrarianism can be mistaken for herd behavior.
But then, the best investments I’ve witnessed for myself and others usually have these three characteristics – contrarian, challenging and uncomfortable (though being a true contrarian also feels comfortable). You have to catch falling knives. As Howard Marks writes in The Most Important Thing…
It’s our job as contrarians to catch falling knives, hopefully with care and skill. That’s why the concept of intrinsic value is so important. If we hold a view of value that enables us to buy when everyone else is selling – and if our view turns out to be right – that’s the route to the greatest rewards earned with the least risk.
To put it finally, we can learn a lot by watching the people around us. It’s how we evolved and reached the top of the food chain. But just maybe we should think very carefully about doing the same thing as everyone else. In investing, what’s comfortable is more often unsafe.
Further Reading:
- Contrarian Investing: The Psychology of Going Against the Crowd (Michael Mauboussin)
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years


