• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Spotlight: Avoid Multiplying by Zero

December 5, 2017

Most real-world systems are multiplicative in nature. Multiplicative systems are counterintuitive because human brain tends to think in terms of averages. In this post, we explore the connection of mathematics, through the study of multiplicative systems, with Charlie Munger’s idea of avoiding serious mistakes for ensuring superior performance over the long term.

The story of this fund manager is fascinating, instructive and true.

For fifteen consecutive years (1991-2005) Legg Mason Capital Management Value Trust fund, run by Bill Miller, outperformed the S&P 500 index. Not just the overall fifteen-year performance but for every single year in that period. In a world where less than twenty-five percent of the fund managers beat the market in a given year, doing it for 15 calendar years in a row is noteworthy. Even legendary investors like Peter Lynch couldn’t achieve this feat, i.e., consistently doing better than the broader market for such a long time.

Let’s put Miller’s performance in a more tangible form. If you invested $10,000 with Mr. Miller fund at the beginning of 1991, you would have $98,000 at the end of 2005. That’s a 10-bagger in fifteen years, i.e., close to 15 percent CAGR. Not bad. Not great either. However, what’s remarkable was the consistency of market outperformance. The returns came like clockwork. Year after year.

Could it be the case of survivorship bias? Pure luck? Michael Mauboussin, a very successful money manager and author of numerous useful books on investing, estimated that the probability of beating the market in the 15 years ending 2005 was 1 in 2.3 million. Conclusion – it wasn’t luck. Bill Miller was smart and knew his game.

Jason Zweig, a noted financial journalist and official editor of Benjamin Graham’s classic The Intelligent Investor, wrote this about Bill Miller in one of his articles –

Steadfast in his convictions and imperturbable under pressure, Mr. Miller was the ultimate iconoclast. He ran a fund with “value” in its name that feasted on technology

He bought Amazon.com during the Internet bubble. He bought Google in its initial public offering, when it was considered insanely overvalued by many. Your garden-variety fund manager studied economics in college, got an MBA and went straight into money management. Mr. Miller, by contrast, worked as an Army intelligence officer, pursued a Ph.D. in philosophy and was chairman of the Santa Fe Institute, a think tank devoted to the study of complexity in nature and society.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Ask Mr. Miller what he did for a living and he would tell you, “We think about thinking.” A discussion with him might cover astrophysics and ant colonies, meteorology and baseball, the science of poker playing, and “enantiodromia,” or the restoration of balance. Warren Buffett isn’t Mr. Miller’s only intellectual hero; he also reveres philosophers Ludwig Wittgenstein and William James. As Bruce Greenwald, a professor of value investing at Columbia Business School puts it, Mr. Miller “was always more interested in being the smartest person in the room than the richest.

Come 2008, and the story takes an unexpected turn. In a single year, Miller loses 55 percent of his investors’ funds. Before I reveal what became of Bill Miller, here’s a question for you.

Following are the annual returns of two money managers who start out with initial fund size of Rs 50 crore each –

So, who do you think would be left with more money at the end of five years? A outperforms B by a significant margin in all years except one (year 3). So, most people jump to a quick conclusion that manager A is better. However, if you sit down and do the calculations, you’d figure that manager A ends up with approximately Rs 80 crores versus manager B who closes the five-year period with a final sum of little more than Rs 102. Which means manager B trounces manager A. Hands down.

This is counterintuitive because human brain, when dealing with yearly percentage returns, tends to think in terms of averages. Manager A’s numbers give an average return of 20 versus manager B’s average of 15.6. That’s a wrong way to think about percentage returns. A normal tendency is to add up the percentage return and then compare the total. However, the percentage returns are multiplicative, not additive.

Multiplicative Systems

Two academicians were debating on the superiority of their respective fields of study. The history professor pounded his fist on the table with his final challenge, “What would you do if I brought Alexander the Great’s army in front of you?”

The mathematics professor rolled his eyes and replied, “That’s easy! I’ll just enclose the army in a bracket and multiply by zero.”

Agreed! The joke isn’t hilarious, but it delivers a very important truth about multiplicative systems.

Additive systems and multiplicative systems behave very differently. Like a Greek emperor’s army, additive systems are linear. In an additive system, each component adds on to one another to create the outcome. Such systems are unaffected when they encounter a zero. Add a zero to a large number, it continues to remain a large number.

Multiplicative systems, on the other hand, are non-linear because anything times zero must still be zero, no matter how large the string of numbers preceding it. A zero can wreak havoc on multiplicative systems. Like it did to Alexander’s army.

In Business

Shane Parrish, on his excellent blog, explains the functional equivalent of multiplicative system in the world of business –

Most businesses, for example, operate in a multiplicative system. But they too often think they’re operating in additive ones: Ever notice how some businesses will add one feature on top of another to their products but fail at basic customer service, so you leave, never to return? That’s a business that thinks it’s in an additive system when they really need to be resolving the big fat zero in the middle of the equation instead of adding more stuff… General Motors, founded in 1908 by William Durant and C.S. Mott, came to dominate the American car market to the tune of 50% market share through a series of brilliant innovations and management practices, and was for many years the dominant and most admirable corporation in America. Even today, after more than a century of competition, no American carmaker produces more automobiles than General Motors. And yet, the original shareholders of GM ended up with a zero in 2008 as the company went into bankruptcy due to years of financial mismanagement. It didn’t matter than they had several generations of leadership: All of that becomes naught in a multiplicative system.

Warren Buffett was talking about multiplicative systems when he said, “In looking for people to hire, you look for three qualities: integrity, intelligence, and energy. And if you don’t have the first, the other two will kill you. You think about it; it’s true. If you hire somebody without [integrity], you really want them to be dumb and lazy.”

High energy and high intelligence multiply the output of an organization but the moment you add a factor of low integrity to the equation, it creates an outcome akin to multiplication by zero.

Russian roulette is my favorite thought experiment. It’s played with a revolver with six chambers and a single bullet. You get $1 million to point the gun at your head and pull the trigger once. There are six equally likely possible outcomes when you pull the trigger. To make it fair, the chambers are rotated randomly after every try. Would you play this game? How about if you’re offered $10 million for every try? One billion dollars?

No matter how lucky or skilled a player is, a zero (death) patiently waits at the end of a string of consecutive wins. Famous physicist and Nobel Laureate, Richard Feynman said, “When playing Russian roulette, the fact that the first shot got off safely is little comfort for the next.”

The lesson is to not increase the size of the win ($1 million versus $1 billion) but get rid of that one bullet. This ties back soundly to the idea of why it’s so important to avoid serious mistakes in investing.

Jim Paul, a trader and the author of What I Learned Losing A Million Dollars, writes –

Just as there is more than one way to deal blackjack, there is more than one way to make money in the markets. Obviously, there is no secret way to make money because the pros have done it using very different, and often contradictory, approaches. Learning how not to lose money is more important than learning how to make money.

In Investing

Anything times zero is zero, said Warren Buffett, “and I don’t care how good the record is in every other year if one year there’s a zero…Charlie and I have seen guys go broke or close to it because 99 of 100 of their decisions were good, but the 100th did them in. “

Buffett uttered these words in Berkshire’s 2007 annual meeting which was a year before Bill Miller blew up his investor’s money.

Benefit of looking at the downside or what can go wrong is efficiency, writes Bevelin in his book, “Take investments as an example – If you first eliminate what doesn’t work or what won’t achieve what you want, you don’t have to spend a lot of time and attention of analyzing the company.

If there is a huge downside – for example a catastrophe risk of the key factors that are needed for success aren’t there or any other disqualifying factors like no sustainable advantage, bad and untrustworthy management of something else – just say ‘no thank you.’”

Howard Marks is one of most respected investors and his admirers include likes of Warren Buffett. In 1990 Marks wrote –

The best foundation for above-average long-term performance is an absence of disasters. There will always be cases and years in which, when all goes right, those who take on more risk will do better than we do. In the long run, however, I feel strongly that seeking relative performance which is just a little bit above average on a consistent basis – with protection against poor absolute results in tough times – will prove more effective than ‘swinging for the fences.

So, the important mantra of sensible investing is – If I avoid the losers, the winners will take care of themselves.

In Life

Peter Bevelin, in his wonderful book “All I Want To Know…” tells the story of Napoleon’s mother, Letizia. She couldn’t understand why Napoleon should take on the British since things were going so well. So, she sold all her French holdings and exchanged them for British pounds. Why? She reasoned, if her son won, she should have a good life in the victorious nation. But if Napoleon lost, she would not be wiped out but still be ok since she had the pounds. She hedged against the possibility of facing a zero. Letizia’s story is the perfect example of how to arrange our affairs in life to protect against the downside.

Conclusion

I stranded you in the middle of Bill Miller’s story. So, here’s what happened. With massive losses in 2008, Bill Miller’s 15-year outstanding record turned ordinary. What had worked for him brilliantly in technology and industrial stocks over the previous two decades failed dismally during the 2008 crisis. Mr. Miller was blindsided by the financial crisis, writes Zweig, “The more his financial stocks went down, the more shares he bought.” A $10,000 investment in Miller’s fund at the end of 2006 shrank to just $4,800 by the end of 2011. In those five years, Miller’s fund size collapsed by eighty percent. Bill Miller’s 15-year winning streak was made irrelevant by one loss.

It might look like I am trying to make a villain out of Bill Miller. Trust me, that’s not my intention. According to recent reports, Miller has done exceedingly well in the stock market in recent past. And he continues to remain an outstanding multidisciplinary thinker. The point of this discussion wasn’t to pick on Miller but to use his story as an example to hammer hard Munger’s teaching, i.e., avoid serious errors and stupidities instead of focusing on trying to hit a home run.

I’ll leave you with this instructive quote from Warren Buffett. He said, “The fundamental principle of auto racing is that to finish first, you must first finish.”
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Spotlight

Handcrafted with in India