This is the Part-2 of the Peter’s Principles series. To read Part-1 click here.
Peter Lynch managed Fidelity’s Magellan Fund from 1977 to 1990 and stacked up a CAGR of 29.2%. “Invest in what you know” is Lynch’s mantra and he is of the opinion that individual investors have the edge over the fund managers, because they can spot good investments in their day-to-day lives before any Wall Street analyst.
In the previous post, I wrote about the first seven principles. In this, I’ll skip the 8, 9 and 10th because I feel they may not be very relevant today. So let’s jump to principle number 11.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Peter’s Principle # 11
The best stock to buy may be the one you already own.
During the first half of 1985, writes Lynch, “Fannie Mae was one of my typical minor holdings, but then I rechecked the story and discovered it had improved dramatically. I elevated Fannie Mae to 2.1 percent of the fund.”
Reminds of a joke that Warren Buffett wrote in his annual letter in 2010.
Customer: Thanks for putting me in XYZ stock at 5. I hear it’s up to 18.
Broker: Yes, and that’s just the beginning. In fact, the company is doing so well now, that it’s an even better buy at 18 than it was when you made your purchase.
Customer: Damn, I knew I should have waited.
Buffett tells this joke in the context of their acquisition of GEICO. Berkshire paid $47 million to buy 50% of the company during the late 1970s. And in 1996, they spent a whopping $2.3 billion in cash to acquire the remaining 50% of GEICO. What made Buffett pay almost 50 times more for the same portion? He realized that GEICO’s business had improved a lot.
Once the stock price of our holding rises, it becomes mentally tough to justify buying more of it. Our own purchase price becomes a hard anchor and a severe block. What if the increase in the price is because the business has become even better. Maybe some unexpected positive development has happened which was never part of your initial investment hypothesis but now it warrants a re-look.
Peter’s Principle # 12
A sure cure for taking a stock for granted is a big drop in the price.
Lynch —
Before the Great Correction (Oct 1987 crash), Magellan was up 39 percent for the year, and I was mad about it because the S&P 500 was up 41 percent. I remember Carolyn saying, “How can you complain about lagging the market by 2 percent when you’ve made thirty-nine percent for your shareholder?” As it turned out, she was right and I shouldn’t have complained, because by December I was down 11 percent.
Having a reasonable expectation from your investment portfolio is important. Of course, beating the broader index is a reasonable expectation to have as far as an informed investor is concerned else why would someone take the efforts to make an investment decision for he could put that money into passive, low-cost index funds. What’s unreasonable is to expect to outperform the index every year.
Any significant correction in the stock market serves as a good reminder of the possible downside.
Peter’s Principle # 13
Never bet on a comeback while they’re playing “Taps.”
There were hundreds of losers in Magellan’s portfolio, to go along with the winners. Fortunately, they weren’t my biggest positions. This is an important aspect of portfolio management — containing your losses.
There is no shame in losing money on stock. Everybody does it. What is shameful is to hold on to a stock, or, worse, to buy more of it, when the fundamentals are deteriorating. That’s what I tried to avoid doing. Although I had more stocks that lost money than I had 10-baggers, I didn’t keep adding to the losers as they headed for Chapter 11 [bankruptcy].
When the stock price of a fundamentally sound business drops, it’s an opportunity to accumulate more. But when the price drop is because of business becoming worse, then it’s a mistake to average down. One might argue — what if the company turns around? Warren Buffett once observed, “Turnarounds seldom turn.”
Peter’s Principle # 14
If you like the store, chances are you’ll love the stock.
This technique is far from foolproof, argues Lynch, “but I’d put it far ahead of buying stocks because Uncle Harry likes them.”
Buying the stock of a company just because you like its product isn’t really an intelligent way to invest. But it’s a good strategy to shortlist stock ideas, especially for a small investor. If you’ve used a particular product then the chances are that your knowledge about it is far superior to someone else who has never heard of the product. This gives you an edge in analyzing the business and the industry.
Here’s a piece of advice for a new investor: Before you go to any stock screener, sit back in your house and look around. Observe closely if you can spot products/brands. Here’s an eye-opening illustration that Vishal drew a few years back.
Click here for bigger image.
Peter’s Principle # 15
When insiders are buying, it’s a good sign — unless they happen to be New England bankers.
I was impressed by the fact that General Host’s stock price had fallen far below the price at which the company had recently bought back shares. When you or I can buy part of a company for less than the company itself has paid, it’s a deal worth examining. It’s also a good sign when the “insiders,” executives and so forth, have paid more than the current price. Insiders are hardly infallible (those at numerous Texas and New England banks were madly acquiring more shares all the way down) but there are smart people in business who often know what they’re doing and aren’t inclined to squander money on a fool’s errand. They are also willing to work extra hard to make their own investments pay off.
No reason on its own can be the deciding factor for buying a stock. So insider buying alone cannot be the only reason one should buy stocks. But when the insiders — promoters, management, employees, directors — start buying shares, usually it’s considered as a good sign.
Presence of such signs tilts the odds of making a profit in a stock in your favour.
Peter’s Principle # 16
In business, competition is never as healthy as total domination.
I’m always on the lookout for great companies in lousy industries. A great industry that’s growing fast, such as computers or medical technology, attracts too much attention and too many competitors. As Yogi Berra once said about a famous Miami Beach restaurant, “It’s so popular, nobody goes there anymore.” When an industry gets too popular, nobody makes money there anymore.
As a place to invest, I’ll take a lousy industry over a great industry anytime. In a lousy industry, one that’s growing slowly if at all, the weak drop out and the survivors get a bigger share of the market. A company that can capture an ever-increasing share of a stagnant market is a lot better off than one that has to struggle to protect a dwindling share of an exciting market.
The greatest companies in lousy industries share certain characteristics. They are low-cost operators, and penny-pinchers in the executive suite. They avoid going into debt. They reject the corporate caste system that creates white-collar Brahmins and blue-collar untouchables. Their workers are well paid and have a stake in the companies’ future. They find niches, parts of the market that bigger companies have overlooked. They grow fast—faster than many companies in the fashionable fast-growth industries.
Competition is good for the society for it moves the frontiers of development. But competition is bad for a capitalist and bad for the investor. As an investor, your job is to find such markets where there is either no competition or where the market leader has an impregnable moat.
Peter’s Principle # 17
All else being equal, invest in the company with the fewest color photographs in the annual report.
An annual report is the most authentic and reliable communication from the company to its shareholders. The first duty of any such communication is to inform rather than to impress. Having colorful charts and photos in the annual report isn’t bad but when such images are used to hide or distort the real facts — which is often the case — then it’s a red flag.
In the last 50+ years, Warren Buffett has never included any chart, bar graph, or fancy photos in any of his annual letters. And I don’t need to remind you about the speed and consistency with which Berkshire has compounded its shareholder wealth in the last few decades.
At the end of his book, Beating the Street, Lynch offers 25 golden rules of investing. Each rule packs a punch. Here are five of them —
- Investing is fun, exciting, and dangerous if you don’t do any work.
- Behind every stock is a company. Find out what it’s doing.
- Owning stock is like having children — don’t get involved with more than you can handle.
- Everyone has the brainpower to make money in stocks. Not everyone has the stomach.
- If you can’t find any companies that you think are attractive, put your money in the bank until you discover some.
In the next part of this series, we’ll pick up few more Peter’s Principles.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
