• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: The Peak End Rule

August 25, 2018

What does the future look like for an eighteen-year-old student who finds himself on a hospital bed wrapped up in bandages? My guess is that life careening off course would have been the least of concerns when he was fighting for his life.

In his senior year of high school, Dan was an active member of an Israeli youth movement. On a Friday afternoon, while preparing fireworks for a traditional nighttime ceremony, a large magnesium flare accidentally exploded near him causing third-degree burns over 70 percent of his body.

The next three years found me wrapped in bandages in a hospital, recalls Dan, “and then emerging into public only occasionally, dressed in a tight synthetic suit and mask that made me look like a crooked version of Spiderman.”
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Being cut off from the society, Dan needed something to keep his mind distracted from the agony of being driven in and out of the burn department. So he began to notice and record things.

What troubled him the most about his treatment was the daily soaking in disinfectant solution. He wrote –

When there is little or no skin – as in my case because of my extensive burns – the disinfectant stings unbearably, the bandages stick to the flesh, and removing them hurts like nothing else I can describe.

Why am I telling you this horrific tale of a young Israeli student? Because Dan’s full name is Dan Ariely. Today he is the professor of behavioral economics at Duke University and author of wildly popular books like Predictably Irrational and The Honest Truth About Dishonesty.

Ariely believes that it was this painful period in his life that inspired him to study human behavior and make a career in it. Inspiration can sometime strikes in the middle of adversity, isn’t it? Ariely wrote –

The nurses would routinely grab hold of a bandage and rip it off as fast as possible, creating a relatively short burst of pain; they would repeat this process for an hour or so until they had removed each of the bandages. The nurses had theorized that a vigorous tug at the bandages, which caused a sharp spike of pain, was preferable (to the patient) to a slow pulling of the wrappings, which might not lead to such a severe spike of pain but would extend the treatment, and therefore be more painful overall.

The nurses had also concluded that there was no difference between two possible methods: starting at the most painful part of the body and working their way to the least painful part; or starting at the least painful part and advancing to the most excruciating areas.

To Ariely, nurses’ assumptions felt wrong. After all, he was at the receiving end. Much later in his career as an empirical psychologist, he designed experiments to prove that he was right. Specifically, Ariely had two crucial insights about the way nurses treated him.

First was the intensity of the pain. Ariely argues that people would rather endure a lower amount of pain for a longer period than a very high amount of pain for a shorter time. And the second insight was the order in which the pain was experienced. In other words, did his daily treatment end on a high note (treating more painful part of the body) or a low note (treating the least painful part of the body)?

Chip and Dan Heath explain it beautifully in their book – The Power of Moments. They call it the Disney Paradox.

When asked, people would claim that the days when they visited Disney theme park were the most memorable days. However, if you were to sample a couple of dozen moments over the course of their day in the park, they would actually be happier sitting on their couch at home. Because a majority of time in a Disney park is spent waiting in long queues for the ride, buying exorbitantly priced food items, navigating your way through a sea of people and feeling uncomfortable in the humidity.

In spite of that, when we reflect on our Disney visit, we forget all those ordinary moments and only remember the exhilaration of fast rides, the parade and the happy moments with the family. Why is that?

Psychologists have figured that the quality of our life is largely determined by our ability to enjoy a moment and most of the times those moments are created by our mind remembering the past, i.e., memories. In other words, it’s not the experience but the memory of the experience that determines our happiness.

Unfortunately, our memories of the experiences are very unfair, says Dan Heath, “We don’t just take the average of our moment by moment sensations when we reflect on our experiences. Rather we remember snippets, scenes, and special moments. And in particular, there are two moments that we disproportionately remember. The peak of the experience, which is either the best or the worst moment, and the ending.”

Neither Ariely nor Heath brothers were the first ones to discover this. It was Daniel Kahneman, a Nobel Laureate and the father of behavioural sciences, who first coined the term Peak-End rule. Kahneman argued that we remember most clearly the peak of an episode, i.e., the moment of greatest intensity, and the end.

Put simply, you remember the high point and the endpoint of your holiday, but the rest is forgotten.

Daniel Kahneman has systematically studied the flaws in the human memory and uncovered various biases arising out of it. So according to peak-end rule, duration of an episode is not registered in our memories. In other words, when we give our brain the task of judging a three-week holiday, the data that’s available is only the peak and end of the holiday.

Similarly, what you remember most about a movie is how it ends. A great movie with a disappointing climax goes in our memories as a bad film. And it’s not different for a lot of other things like parties, concerts, books, lectures, homes and even relationships.

Rolf Dobelli, in his wonderful book The Art of the Good Life, describes an experiment that demonstrates this effect –

Students held their hand in cold 14-degree F [equivalent to -10 degree celsius] water for one minute—a rather unpleasant experience. In a second test, they held their hand in cold 14-degree water for one minute, then cold 15-degree water for thirty seconds. Immediately afterward they were asked which version they’d like to repeat. Eighty percent opted for the second. That makes no sense, because viewed objectively the second version was worse—all the pain of the first go-round plus the relative unpleasantness of the second.

…the peak experience was identical in both versions—the cold 14-degree water. The ends, however, were different. The end of the first version (14 degrees) was more unpleasant than the end of the second (15 degrees), which is why the test subjects’ brains recorded the latter as more pleasant, even though from the perspective of the experiencing self (and objectively speaking) it was less so.

Not even duration matters. The students didn’t factor in the length of the experiment at all, whether it lasted sixty or ninety seconds. This holds true more generally: whether you’re on holiday for one week or three, your memory of it will be roughly the same. Likewise, whether you’re in prison for a month or a year, it makes no difference to your memory—the specific amount of time spent behind bars will be forgotten.

Think about it. Is that the reason why Fast Food restaurants are usually associated (and marketed) as a happy place? Instead of focusing on the food quality, taste, etc., they try to appeal to the fact that the customer should feel happy when they leave the place. That’s one of the reasons they charge customers first and serve them later.

I prefer to pay for hotels in advance, writes Rolf Dobelli, “That way I won’t spoil a romantic weekend in Paris by being confronted with the bill at the end. If the end of the trip is a big fat bill, presented to you like marching orders by a snooty French receptionist, your memory of the romantic getaway will be forever tarnished.”

How does this behavior bias affect the investors?

The first thing an investor can learn from this is to be always skeptical about personal memories. Our memory isn’t a reliable source of data to make future decisions.

Imagine an investor who has been in the stock market for decades and who trades very frequently. Now if you interview him about his overall satisfaction with his experience in the stock market, the chances are that his estimate will be heavily influenced by how many profitable trades he’s executed in the recent past. He would also make it a point to highlight the best and the worst transactions of his investing career.

Maybe he has had one 100-bagger in his investing career. He might feel happy on his deathbed for his winning trade but did he ever question himself about how his overall investment performance stack up against the benchmark returns? Very few people question that, and that’s a big mistake. That’s the recipe of fooling ourselves.

Maintaining an investment journal is the best way to overcome this bias. This simple practice – logging each transaction and also noting down why you made that investment and what information was available to you when you bought or sold that stock- will go a long way in improving the quality of the decisions in the future.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members

 

  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe

[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India