There are strong parallels between Tupperware parties and the stock market investing. A Tupperware party is a whirlpool of psychological forces that suck the partygoers into making unnecessary purchases. A stock market isn’t much different.
In 1938, Earl Tupper developed a technology for air-tight plastic containers. His patented “burping seal” design distinguished his product from the competitors. However, despite being a revolutionary product, Tupperware sales did not pick up for first ten years.
Then in 1949, one of Earl’s sales representative, Brownie Wise, began selling Tupperware products through home parties. The idea was that housewives would invite friends and neighbours at home and the party would be a combination of social event and sales presentation.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] Soon she established a social network marketing system with the help of dealers and sellers, and her sales started exceeding Tupperware store sales. Wise’s success caught the attention of Mr. Tupper. He promptly offered Wise to become the vice-president at his company.
The concept of sales through home party was an offshoot of direct marketing strategy but it focused only on housewives. Its appeal was in giving women an option to earn without leaving home.
Wise’s methods turned out to be very successful and Tupperware sales and popularity exploded in the 1950s. Today, Tupperware is sold in about 100 countries with a revenue of more than US$ 2 billion. Every 2.7 seconds, a Tupperware party starts somewhere.
The modus operandi of a Tupperware party is very interesting. The party is run by a Tupperware “consultant” for a host who invites friends and neighbours into his or her home to see the product line. Tupperware hosts are rewarded with free products based on the level of sales made at their party.
So why are we discussing Tupperware parties? Because of Charlie Munger. In his 1995, Munger delivered a lecture at Harvard University titled The Psychology of Human Misjudgment. In his talk, he said –
Tupperware . . . developed what I believe to be a corrupt system of psychological manipulation. But the practice . . . worked and had legs. Tupperware parties sold billions of dollars of merchandise for decades.
The conventional definition of the word lollapalooza is something outstanding of its kind. When Charlie Munger uses the word lollapalooza, he often attaches the word “effects” (as in “lollapalooza effects”) which means that multiple factors are acting together in ways that are feeding back on each other.
A Tupperware party, according to Munger, is the best example of lollapalooza effect because multiple psychological biases work in the same direction and push people towards irrational decisions.
Famous psychologist Robert Cialdini, in his book Influence, has written extensively about how the structure of Tupperware parties is designed to exploit many of the human biases. In his research, Cialdini found that in spite of all the so-called popularity of Tupperware products, most people don’t like getting invited to such parties. One woman told Cialdini –
It’s gotten to the point now where I hate to be invited to Tupperware parties. I’ve got all the containers I need; and if I wanted any more, I could buy another brand cheaper in the store. But when a friend calls up, I feel like I have to go And when I get there, I feel like I have to buy something. What can I do? It’s for one of my friends.
(A Tupperware party in the 1950s. Source: Wikipedia)
A Tupperware party takes advantage of four weapons of influence, i.e., reciprocity, liking bias, social proof and confirmation bias.
When someone does you a favour, you have this deep feeling to reciprocate. This feeling of obligation to repay is what’s known as reciprocation bias. Even if we didn’t need the initial favour in the first place, it’s extremely difficult to shake off the feeling of returning the favour in some form which may lead us to do things which we wouldn’t have done otherwise.
People like to do business with people they like than people they don’t like. Who do we like? People who are like us, who compliment us, cooperate with us especially our friends and neighbours. We find it hard to refuse a request that comes from such people. This is liking bias.
In the face of uncertainty, we tend to make decisions by observing the decisions of others. Humans find great comfort in social validation. Following others usually serves well under normal circumstances but social proof can lead us astray when making crucial decisions.
Once we have decided, and especially if we’ve validated that decision through public affirmation, we hate to change our views. The more we affirm our past decisions the stronger we believe in them. Once we’ve taken a stand on something, it’s cognitively tough to change it even if we’re presented with valid evidence against our original beliefs. Cialdini calls it commitment and consistency bias.
The invite for the Tupperware party comes from someone you like — a friend, a colleague, a neighbour or a relative. That’s the first YES that you would say, thanks to liking bias, in a series of upcoming YESs.
The Tupperware party starts with a quiz game that allows the partygoers to win prizes; anyone who doesn’t win prize gets to reach into a grab bag for hers so that everyone has received a gift before the buying begins. Winning “prizes” invokes the dormant forces of reciprocation. You want to pay back those who gave you the free items.
Each participant is also encouraged to describe publicly the uses and benefits of the products she already owns — that triggers the commitment bias. Once the buying starts, each transaction demonstrates builds the social validation — since other similar people want the product; it must be good. Moreover, the purchase request comes not from a stranger, but rather a friend – liking bias again.
The Tupperware handbook counsels the salespeople to use the “feel, felt, found” method, effectively encouraging similarity through empathy while still highlighting product features.
Combine these effects, and it’s not hard to see why many people try to avoid going to a Tupperware party in the first place, because they know that once they are there, they will buy something.
Lessons in Investing
There are strong parallels between Tupperware parties and stock market investing. Not necessarily in terms of the same psychological biases but in terms of lollapalooza effect.
Today, the environment in which a typical stock market investor operates is a hotbed for a number of psychological biases — all acting in the same direction.
Every time I see a call coming from my relationship manager or my stockbroker, I get tensed. They sound intelligent and articulate. They dress sharp and look confident. There’s no reason not to like them. In first few minutes of conversation, they’ve already primed you with liking bias. Then they offer you a free seat in an investor education seminar which unlocks the force of reciprocity.
Even after knowing about the power of persuasion principles, it’s hard to not acquiesce to the requests coming from these people. Can you imagine what a gullible investor, who has neither heard of Cialdini’s work nor the workings of Tupperware parties, gets sucked into?
The power of social media has given everyone an option to voice their opinions publicly. Irrespective of how many people listen to you, the mere fact that you’ve spoken about a stock openly, triggers the commitment and consistency effect.
The same social media becomes the source of social validation too. When you see hundreds of people talking about an obscure company, it’s difficult to shake off the urge to follow the herd. This effect is more pronounced during rapidly falling or rising stock prices. During these market extremes the diversity of the opinion breaks down and the crowd starts moving in the same direction.
Incentive bias is another mental model which explains the irrationality of Tupperware partygoers and those who flock to the stock market. Steven Landsburg in his book, The Armchair Economist, writes –
People respond to incentives. The rest is just commentary.
In Tupperware party, the hostess gets a percentage of every sale that happens at her home. Although the guests don’t pay it directly to the hostess it’s understood that she gets a profit from the sales.
Would the hostess really go through the pain of arranging the party frequently if she didn’t have any financial incentive for it? No, right?
Of course, the woman who has invited her friends believes herself that Tupperware products are a great deal and that’s why she is doing what she’s doing. However, the incentive bias operates at a subconscious level.
An otherwise decent man can act immorally because he is driven by incentives at both conscious and subconscious levels. Once this immoral behaviour starts and it pays this man well, he gets further inclined to repeat this kind of behaviour.
Charlie Munger once said –
I think I’ve been in the top 5% of my age cohort all my life in understanding the power of incentives, and all my life I’ve underestimated it. And never a year passes but I get some surprise that pushes my limit a little farther…Never ever think about something else when you should be thinking about incentives.
Financial industry runs on an engine called incentives. When the suit-tie wearing financial advisor recommends the next multi-bagger micro-cap stock or their new ULIP scheme, he is being driven by the commissions set by his employer.
All commissioned salesmen, said Charlie Munger in 1988 Wesco Financial annual meeting, “have a tendency to serve the transaction instead of the truth.”
When a new investor opens his demat account, his first point of contact stock market is usually stockbroker. So, when the amateur investor starts trading in and out of the stocks without having any clue about businesses and investing fundamentals, he can’t be blamed entirely for it.
The action-encouraging stockbrokers are the ones who advice these new investors what to buy and sell. What creates revenue for the stockbrokers? Trading volumes. So, they have a strong incentive to get their clients to trade frequently regardless of what’s in the best interest of the client.
Compared to any other time in the history, it’s never been easier for small investors to enter the stock market. But this convenience has side effects. The easier it is to do something the more people want to do it especially when there are some who get paid for the activity.
In one of his lectures in a Business school, Warren Buffett explained –
One of the ironies of the stock market is the emphasis on activity…Like the Doctor who gets paid on how often to get you to change pills. If he gave you one pill that cures you the rest of your life, he would make one sale, one transaction and that is it. But if he can convince you that changing pills every day is the way to great health, it will be great for him and the prescriptionists.
You won’t be any healthier and you will be a lot worse off financially. You want to stay away from any environment that stimulates activity…If you go to a dentist who gets paid by the number of teeth he pulls out, you better think ahead about what teeth you want to be pulled out.
As far as Tupperware is concerned, the good news is that you can always buy Tupperware from stores. This way you only buy what you need and when you need. In other words, you don’t buy when it’s being sold to you; you buy when you need it. It’s the same with stocks. Mr. Market, Benjamin Graham’s figment of imagination, is like the Tupperware hostess who would invite you every day to join the party. Remember, you don’t have to say yes.
When promised quick profits, quips Buffett, “respond with a quick no.”
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
