Imagine you’re on the board of a fairly large company. The business has three verticals — IT services, Investment Advisory, and Organic farming. The CEO is making a presentation to the board about next year’s plan for investing additional capital in each business vertical.
After rushing through a dozen slides on broader industry trends and macroeconomics, the CEO comes to the slide which shows that the company generated a revenue of Rs. Five hundred crores in the recent financial year which translated to a bottom line of Rs. One hundred crores. A decent 20 percent profit margin.
“This year I propose that we put all our focus and investment capital for growing the Investment Advisory vertical.” argues the CEO.
“I understand that you’ve worked for several years in the finance industry,” interjected a senior board member, “and that may give you the confidence about the future prospects of money management business. But do you have any other data to support your argument especially in the context of our company’s business?”
“As a matter of fact, I do.” quips the CEO. “And I am glad you asked that, sir.” It was evident that the CEO was prepared for this question. In fact, he was saving up a special slide just for this.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
As the new slide animates its way on the screen, the confidence rises in the CEO’s voice.
“As you can see, with a profit of Rs. Seventy crores, Investment Advisory arm has the lion’s share of our net profit. Focusing on a vertical that contributes 70% to the profits is a no-brainer. Isn’t it? With that I rest my case.” the smile on his face confirms that the CEO was feeling triumphant.
As the wave of consensus begins sweeping through the boardroom, an elderly and wise-looking director doesn’t look convinced. He keeps staring at the powerpoint slide.
After a few minutes of suppressed murmur in the room, the elderly director raises his hand and says, “Your numbers tell a powerful story but you’re making the same mistake that Bill Clinton did. And if your mistake is unintentional then I don’t blame you because even The Economist is guilty of committing the same error.”
“Care to explain?” the CEO asks with a furrowed brow.
“I have been reading a fascinating book — How Not to be Wrong,” the elderly gentleman replies calmly. “It’s written by a mathematician named Jordan Ellenberg. In fact, I have the book in my bag right now. Let me take it out and read out something from it.”
Jordan Ellenberg —
A recent working paper by economist Michael Spence and Sandile Hlatshwayo painted a striking picture of job growth in the United States. Between 1990 and 2008, the U.S. economy gained a net 27.3 million jobs. Of those, 26.7 million, or 98%, came from the “nontradable sector”: the part of the economy including things like government, health care, retail, and food service, which can’t be outsourced and which don’t produce goods to be shipped overseas.
The numbers painted a convincing story about American industrial history and this research and its conclusions were widely repeated by many including The Economist and Bill Clinton in his latest book.
But you have to be really careful about what it means. Ninety-eight percent is really, really close to 100%. So does the study say that growth is as concentrated in the nontradable part of the economy as it could possibly be? That’s what it sounds like — but that’s not quite right.
So coming back to our company’s business, let me ask you this, said the old man, “How much profit did the Organic farming business generate last year?”
“It’s in red. Organic farming is a loss-making business.” replied the CEO.
“So we’re dealing with negative numbers here and that distorts the calculations. One has to be very careful talking in percentages when you’re dealing with negative numbers. Let me read more from Jordan’s book.” continued the old man.
Jobs in the tradable sector grew by a mere 620,000 between 1990 and 2008, that’s true. But it could have been worse — they could have declined! That’s what happened between 2000 and 2008; the tradable sector lost about 3 million jobs, while the nontradable sector added 7 million. So the nontradable sector accounted for 7 million jobs out of the total gain of 4 million, or 175%!
The old man lifted his head and set his eyes on the CEO.
You’re telling the truth but not the complete truth, Mr. CEO, he said. “I have kept track of all the numbers. The organic farming business, as you said, has posted losses. And they are quite large — 80 crores. But the more important fact that you failed to highlight was the profits generated by the IT services business. One hundred ten crores. And if I go by your way of presenting numbers, IT services operations contributed 110% of the total profits. That sounds ridiculous, isn’t it?”
This imaginary boardroom discussion may seem like a lame example. No CEO would be so dumb to make such a blunder and even if he did, anybody with 8th-grade math knowledge would have caught his mistake. In the real world, you don’t get the opportunity to call out blunders so easily the way old-wise-man did.
I have used this example to explain how simple ideas like proportions and percentages can mislead us if we’re not careful. And these tricks are used all the time by conmen and shrewd accountants in fooling educated and smart investors.
Don’t talk about percentages of numbers, writes Jordan, “when the numbers might be negative.”
Keeping this law in mind will save you from making a specific class of mistakes that arise from a psychological bias known as Innumeracy. Innumeracy is lack of numeracy which is the ability to intuitively understand numbers, their magnitude, their relationships, and how they are affected by operations. Unfortunately, innumeracy is far more widespread and socially accepted than illiteracy. To avoid poor decisions in money and investments, it’s supremely important that one understands the language of numbers and develops a sense of numeracy.
Today, a child learns about negative numbers in 5th or 6th standard but the discovery of negative numbers came very very late in human civilization. In fact, even the 15th-century mathematicians found it maddeningly hard to wrap their heads around the idea of negative numbers.
Jordan again —
Negative numbers are numbers, and as such they can be multiplied and divided like any others. But even this is not as trivial as it first appears. To our mathematical predecessors, it wasn’t even clear that negative numbers were numbers at all—they do not, after all, represent quantities in exactly the same way positive numbers do. I can have seven apples in my hand, but not negative seven. The great sixteenth-century algebraists, like Cardano and François Viète, argued furiously about whether a negative times a negative equaled a positive. But they weren’t wrong that there’s something about the combination of negative quantities and arithmetic operations like percentage that short-circuits one’s intuition.
In a typical financial statement, there aren’t many negative numbers. And whatever is present get combined or merged with other figures. But this combination of positive and negative sometimes makes it easy to tell a fake story. And if you’re not careful, the story can be very convincing. Add to the mix a great storyteller — a charismatic CEO or business leader — most people forget to spot the discrepancies.
The title of this post — More Pie than Plate — comes from chapter 5 in Jordan’s book.
Mathematical literacy or numeracy is an essential skill that every investor needs to have to make better decisions and become better thinkers. Numeracy isn’t natural to the human brain because evolution never got enough time to equip the human brain with a natural feel for numbers.
In the 2.5 million years of human evolutionary history, homo sapiens never had to deal with numbers until about 12,000 years ago when complex societies began to appear and the Agricultural Revolution forced humans to become acquainted with an entirely new type of information, i.e., numbers.
Like many other modern skills — driving, typing, or using a computer — numeracy is a skill to be learned deliberately. And the way maths is taught in the schools and colleges today does a poor job in developing numeracy in a useful way.
That’s why the onus is on us to become numerate so that we don’t get taken for a ride by conmen peddling fake stories supported by the numbers that don’t add up.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years