Randall Monroe has an incredible mind. Even if his name doesn’t ring a bell, I am sure you’ve seen his work. He’s the creator of XKCD comic strip. Monroe, a physicist, was working for NASA before he became a full time cartoonist.
Monroe had a significant fan following among nerds because of the XKCD but he shot into fame when his book The Things Explainer caught the attention of Bill Gates. Monroe’s genius is revealed in his book where he takes up the challenge to explain complicated things using a vocabulary of only one thousand simple words.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Being an internet celebrity, Monroe is always bombarded with questions from his audience. And those comments from his readers generate a lot of fodder for creating more interesting work. One of his readers sent him this question —
If every person on earth aimed a laser pointer at the moon at the same time, would it change the moon’s color?
What a silly question, isn’t it? Why would someone waste his time answering a hypothetical question which even if answered correctly would be utterly useless to anyone? But Monroe did.
A few days back, I stumbled upon one of his talks where he takes you through his process — step by step — how he tried to figure out the answer to the above question.
First of all, how do you even begin answering such an absurd query? Even if you assume that every human being on earth had access to a laser pointer, how would they manage to point it at moon considering that the earth is round and people are housed in more than 200 countries spread across several continents, and none of them face the moon at the same time?
But that’s what separates a genius like Monroe from an average thinker. His curiosity never lets him forego an opportunity (even if it comes wrapped as an absurd question) for discovering something interesting.
What I learned from Monroe’s talk is that the path between a question and its answer can be more interesting than the two endpoints. And it’s up to us to make that journey rewarding. Interestingly, he figured out the answer to the original question pretty quickly (which was a no) but he didn’t stop there because he wanted to have more fun with the process. So he deliberately expanded the scope of the original question and kept going down the rabbit hole.
Monroe made his own assumptions which unearthed many more interesting (and useful) facts. For example, when the moon is over the Arabian sea, it’s visible to about 5/7th of the world population simultaneously.
The great thing about following your curiosity is that no one can stop you and you can keep going. The beauty of Monroe’s work is that he doesn’t stop marching on the trail left by his curiosity. If you could step into his mind, you will get a feeling that he’s not interested in the answer at all. The answers are all by-products of the process. And the process is — keep scratching the itch of a probing mind and never letting the fire of inquisitiveness to die down.
Every time he figured he had found the answer he quipped, “I couldn’t resist, so I kept going.”
Don’t be afraid to ask stupid questions, says Randall, “Sometimes it can be a lot of fun.”
One of my biggest takeaway from Monroe’s talk was not to get bogged down by limitations imposed by what can not be known. We’re anyway living in a universe which is a soup of uncertainty and we routinely make hundreds of assumptions and base our actions on incomplete information.
The moment you stop looking for answers because it seems hard or impossible, you’ve given up on an opportunity to discover unique insights. The world is immensely complex and deeply interconnected which means there are ample opportunities for those who are willing to dig deeper.
Put simply, it doesn’t matter what question you begin with. What matters is —
- How rigorously you chase the clues,
- What assumptions you make to simplify a complex problem and transform it into a more useful one, and
- How long you’re willing to remain discontent with your discoveries.
What does all this have to do with investing?
A lot.
What is investing if not an attempt to answer uncertainties related to a business you’re evaluating? If everything was known about a company, no one would invest— either because it’s a bad company or it’s good but already priced to perfection with no room for further appreciation in its price.
This uncertainty about the future of a business is what creates inefficiencies in the pricing of security by Mr. Market. If you think about it, the uncertainty isn’t always risk and the deeper one goes into studying a company’s operations, its financials, the industry and the competitors, greater is the chance to find something interesting which can reduce the uncertainty (you can never eliminate it though).
In 2016, Manpasand beverages was doing 550 cr in revenue with 50 cr of profit. Between 2011-2015, the company raised 116 cr from private investors. In July 2015, they went public with a 400 cr IPO. In one year, Manpasand’s stock delivered a 90%+ return over its IPO price. The stock was being recommended by several well-known research firms.
But Amit Mantri got curious. He asked a few stupid questions.
How could a small company from Baroda gain significant market share in a fiercely competitive industry with incumbent brands being decades old — Frooti and Maaza?
He wrote —
In FY16, Parle Agro (Frooti owner) and Manpasand generated 1270 crs and 550 crs in revenues respectively from fruit juice. Considering Manpasand’s higher trade margins (35% vs Parle Agro’s 25%), it was already 50% the size of Parle Agro in FY16 (in volume terms). It also has a negligible presence in South India which accounts for ~25% of the fruit juice market. So essentially, in North, West and East India, Manpasand was 60%+ of Frooti’s scale in volumes.
This is a phenomenal achievement considering Parle Agro’s Frooti is a 30-year old brand with a large advertising budget and extensive distribution reach. On the other hand, Manpasand spends precious little in terms of advertising and has a limited retail reach. How then did this company achieve such a large scale in such a short time?
Why is management compensation so less?
Mantri observed —
Building a large business is rarely a one-man show. While the company can be led by a visionary CEO, it still needs a strong management team to execute the CEO’s plans. Compensation ends up playing the most important part in hiring and retaining a good senior management team. This does not seem to apply to Manpasand which has abysmally low senior management compensation.
In FY15, Manpasand’s median senior management compensation was 4.6 lakhs!! Such low compensation for senior management of a company of this scale is completely unheard of. At these compensation levels, how could Manpasand retain these executives who have led a 6x growth in revenues over the last 4 years? Given their performance, wouldn’t competitors look to hire them for even 4-5 times their current compensation? We are unable to comprehend why that hasn’t happened yet.
Asking stupid (and obvious) questions can be very rewarding in investing. The outcome is always positive. For new investors, the stupid questions lead to obvious answers which is good for learning. For not so new investors, stupid questions — if you care to persist — will almost always lead to intelligent questions.
The stupidest investment question ever, is the one that never gets asked.
To expect to begin your quest with only intelligent questions could be overwhelming and you may never get started.
So, start small, start stupid and let your curiosity take you places.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years