Archimedes — a Greek mathematician — was born in 287 BC in the seaport city of Syracuse, Sicily. Some consider him as the greatest mathematician of all time. Although he’s known for the discovery of Archimedes Principle, his often quoted for his famous saying —
Give me a lever long enough and a fulcrum on which to place it, and I shall move the world.
While Archimedes did not invent the lever, his did extensive work on the usage of levers. Archimedes designed block-and-tackle pulley systems, allowing sailors to use the principle of leverage to lift objects that would otherwise have been too heavy to move.
A lever is a simple machine that amplifies an input force to provide a greater output force, which is said to provide leverage. There isn’t a single mechanical device in the world which doesn’t use the laws of the lever.
When people realized that leverage could magnify the effect of non-physical things too the first thing they tried it on was money. In the last few decades, the world of finance has taken Archimedes’ words literally.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
In finance, leveraging means borrowing money in order to invest it. The more one borrows relative to the amount of capital, the higher the leverage ratio. Potential gains are amplified by leverage. So are the losses. It applies not only to companies but to individuals as well.
Mohan and Aryan both guess that the housing market is on the upswing. So they buy houses with an intention to sell them after five years. Each has Rs. 1 lakh to invest. Mohan buys one house for that sum. Aryan buys ten houses by employing debt. He uses Rs. 10,000 as down payment and borrows Rs. 90,000 from the bank for each house. Bank charges an interest rate of 5 percent on loan. Aryan is using leverage, while Mohan isn’t. Aryan’s leverage ratio — the amount of debt divided by the capital one actually owns — is nine times.
If both Mohan and Aryan are right about the upswing and five years later the houses sell for Rs. 2 lakh each. Mohan walks away with a profit of Rs. 1 lakh. But Aryan hits the jackpot. After adjusting for loan and interest payments, Aryan’s profits are more than fifteen times as compared to Mohan’s. And if we count the rental income, Aryan would’ve collected ten times more rent also.
Leverage seems like a great idea. But only if the forecasts come true. What if the housing market swings in the other direction?
Imagine another scenario where the price of the houses falls by 20 percent. After five years Mohan loses Rs. 20,000. Not a lucrative transaction but he at least has no debts. Aryan, however, has to pay back the money borrowed plus the interest, which amounts to Rs. 11.25 lakh. He gets Rs. 8 lakh from the sale of the houses, and thus ends up Rs. 3.25 lakh in debt. Assuming a rental yield of 3 percent, Aryan would still have to file for bankruptcy.
It’s an oversimplified example but it demonstrates that the game of leverage can quickly turn a potential fortune into debilitating financial disaster.
In his 2011 letter to shareholders, Warren Buffett wrote —
Unquestionably, some people have become very rich through the use of borrowed money. However, that’s also been a way to get very poor. When leverage works, it magnifies your gains. Your spouse thinks you’re clever, and your neighbors get envious. But leverage is addictive. Once having profited from its wonders, very few people retreat to more conservative practices. And as we all learned in third grade—and some relearned in 2008—any series of positive numbers, however impressive the numbers may be, evaporates when multiplied by a single zero. History tells us that leverage all too often produces zeroes, even when it is employed by very smart people.
Mention debt and it might arouse caution. Call it leverage and it’s easy to sell it as the most lucrative business strategy for rapid growth.
In his excellent blog post titled Casualties of Your Own Success, Morgan Housel draws a striking analogy between bigger size among species and leverage in investing. He writes —
Body size in biology is like leverage in investing: It accentuates the gains but amplifies the losses. It works well for a while and then backfires spectacularly at the point where the benefits are nice but the losses are lethal. Size is nature’s leverage. Sought after for its benefits straight up to the point that it ferociously turns against you. The same thing applies to companies and investments.
Citigroup almost went out of business ten years ago because it sold products with liquidity puts. That meant that if debt Citi sold to other investors became illiquid, those investors had the right to sell them back to Citi at face value. When debt markets froze, liquidity puts cost Citigroup $25 billion in losses in 90 days, at a time when it had less than $90 billion in equity.
Warren Buffett gave one of the best analogies to think about debt. Talking about 1980’s junk bond crisis, Buffett wrote in his 1991 letter —
The disciples of debt assured us that this collapse wouldn’t happen: Huge debt, we were told, would cause operating managers to focus their efforts as never before, much as a dagger mounted on the steering wheel of a car could be expected to make its driver proceed with intensified care. We’ll acknowledge that such an attention-getter would produce a very alert driver. But another certain consequence would be a deadly— and unnecessary— accident if the car hit even the tiniest pothole or sliver of ice. The roads of business are riddled with potholes; a plan that requires dodging them all is a plan for disaster.
Some argue that the presence of debt creates a vigilant debt holder. But that’s a lopsided argument. It’s possibly the greed speaking, disguised as an advocate of discipline and alertness. Debt removes options. It leaves little room for error.
What’s true for biology and investment is true for business and life also. Leverage amplifies both the good business and the bad business. Reminds me of Buffett’s words. He said —
Time is the friend of the wonderful company, the enemy of the mediocre.
Given a sufficiently long period, an unfavorable economic environment is inevitable. As the business cycle turns and a rough economic patch arrives, the dagger of debt starts slashing the veins and leaves the leveraged company bleeding to death.
Leverage doesn’t just wipeout. It can create a severe double whammy. A wipeout erases every opportunity to get back in the game at the very moment opportunity is ripe. Imagine you’re playing a card game and have been dealt with a winning hand. All you need is to stay in the game until the end. All of a sudden the card dealer snatches the cards from your hands and declares — time is up. That’s what debt does. It forces an early and untimely fold up. It takes away your staying power.
Housel writes —
A homeowner wiped out in 2009 had no chance of taking advantage of cheap mortgage rates in 2010. Lehman Brothers had no chance of investing in cheap debt in 2009.
The combination of leverage and momentum, wrote Housel on another occasion, “can make ordinary people look extraordinarily talented.” In the first scenario of our example, Aryan came out as business savvy and intelligent capital allocator. If he were a business manager for a large company they would probably award him as the businessman of year and the shareholders would recite poems in his praise during AGM.
No one would know that Aryan was swimming naked in a high tide.
When it comes to personal finance, leverage has equally devastating consequences when the good time is over and the bad time rolls by. The large financial institutions that cater to retail customers have strong incentives to promote debt. Whether it’s for buying consumer goods or for commons stocks. Open a demat account and the first thing that they market to you is the wonders of using margins for stocks.
Using debt to finance the purchase of shares creates both financial and psychological stress. Unfortunately, the stress is initially invisible because it only rears its head during difficult times.
The problem with leverage isn’t just the risk of getting wiped out. Even if one manages to survive, what are the chances, especially for new investors, that they would dust their clothes and come back to the game? Housel again —
One study I remember showed that young investors should use 2x leverage in the stock market, because – statistically – even if you get wiped out you’re still likely to earn superior returns over time, as long as you dust yourself off and keep investing after a wipeout. Which, in the real world, no one would actually do. They’d swear off investing for life. What works on a spreadsheet and what works at the kitchen table are ten miles apart.
That’s the second order risk which no one thinks about.
Don’t call leveraged buyouts private equity, says Charlie Munger, “that’s like a janitor calling himself chief of engineering. There is an army of people in finance and shadow banking who are leveraging these deals with liberal leverage and of course they pay very high prices and they get part of the upside and they don’t take any of the downsides and they get fees off the top. So it is fee driven buying and it is very extreme.
If you visualize debt as a dagger, you’d start investing very differently.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years