At the beginning of the First World War, 27-year-old British soldier Henry Tandey was serving with the 5th Duke of Wellington’s Regiment. On September 28, 1914 a weary German soldier wandered into Tandey’s line of fire. The German soldier was wounded and did not even attempt to raise his own rifle. Tandey chose not to shoot. The German soldier saw him lower his rifle and nodded his thanks before wandering off.
The German soldier was Adolf Hitler.
Historical research throws serious doubts on whether the incident actually ever occurred. Question is how do you even prove or disprove it? And that’s the dilemma every historian faces — what to accept as historical facts and what to discard as apocryphal account.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
While reading history, it’s devilishly hard to separate the fact from interpretation. It won’t be an understatement if I say that all historical information is pretty much fiction because it’s just one possible interpretation of what happened. Isn’t it?
Our knowledge of any past event, writes Will Durant in his book The Lessons of History, “is always incomplete, probably inaccurate, beclouded by ambivalent evidence and biased historians, and perhaps distorted by our own patriotic or religious partisanship. Most history is guessing, and the rest is prejudice.”
Trying to find truth in history is a futile exercise. However, one should still read history. Why?
Unlike physics or economics, writes historian Yuval Harari, “history is not a means for making accurate predictions. We study history not to know the future but to widen our horizons, to understand that our present situation is neither natural nor inevitable, and that we consequently have many more possibilities before us than we imagine.”
Will and Ariel Durant spent their lives studying civilization. They distilled their four decades of work into the ten monumental volumes of The Story of Civilization. Very few people have the patience to read the ten-volume set. So to make their accumulated store of knowledge available to everyone, Durants wrote a 100–page book called “The Lessons of History.”
Durants’ book presents an overview of the themes and lessons observed from 5,000 years of world history, examined from 12 perspectives: geography, biology, race, character, morals, religion, economics, socialism, government, war, growth and decay, and progress.
The present is the past rolled up for action, and the past is the present unrolled for understanding.
There are about seven billion people alive on earth today. Now contrast that figure with the number of people who have ever lived on earth in the entire human history – 107 billion. Not learning from history would be akin to discarding the accumulated experience of that dead majority of humanity which outnumbers the living by fifteen to one.
Now, every single human has lived a unique life. And each life was a product of a unique set of situations, abilities, cultural conditioning, and a hundred other context-specific factors. Trying to fit their learnings to our life may not work most of the time.
We must operate with partial knowledge, and be provisionally content with probabilities.
You’d agree with me when I say that though human behaviour has changed throughout history, what has remained unchanged is human nature.
Actually, human nature also changes, but the pace of change is incredibly slow. It would be a reasonable assumption that human nature has been virtually unchanged in the last 2,000 years. Perhaps far longer than that. Biology plays a key role in defining human nature and the process of evolution is very slow when it comes to altering biology.
The most important lessons from history, writes Morgan Housel, “are things that are so fundamental to the behaviors of so many people that they’re likely to apply to you and situations you’ll face in your own lifetime.”
So without further adieu, here are a few interesting insights from the book.
Historian Always Oversimplifies
Imagine a historian from the future gets access to the details of the life of a 30-year-old software engineer living in Bangalore. He cannot say that the life of this guy was the way every 30-year old in Bangalore lived during the 21st century. But most historians do just that. They try to generalize the typicality of an era from a tiny sample size.
The historian always oversimplifies, and hastily selects a manageable minority of facts and faces out of a crowd of souls and events whose multitudinous complexity he can never quite embrace or comprehend.
Freedom and Inequality are Inseparable Twins
People in a democracy often demand both freedom and equality. But history teaches us that freedom and equality are always at odds with each other.
Freedom and equality are sworn and everlasting enemies, and when one prevails the other dies. Leave men free, and their natural inequalities will multiply almost geometrically, as in England and America in the nineteenth century under laissez-faire. To check the growth of inequality, liberty must be sacrificed, as in Russia after 1917. Even when repressed, inequality grows; only the man who is below the average in economic ability desires equality; those who are conscious of superior ability desire freedom; and in the end superior ability has its way.
Equality doesn’t exist in nature.
We are all born unfree and unequal: subject to our physical and psychological heredity, and to the customs and traditions of our group; diversely endowed in health and strength, in mental capacity and qualities of character. Nature loves difference as the necessary material of selection and evÂolution; identical twins differ in a hundred ways[I can vouch for that as a father of identical twins], and no two peas are alike.
Inequality is not only natural and inborn, it grows with the comÂplexity of civilization. Hereditary inequalities breed social and arÂtificial inequalities; every invention or discovery is made or seized by the exceptional individual, and makes the strong stronger, the weak relatively weaker, than before. Economic development specializes functions, differentiates abilities, and makes men unequally valuable to their group.
The concentration of wealth is natural and inevitable and is periodically alleviated by violent or peaceable partial redistribution. In this view, all economic history is the slow heartbeat of the social organism, a vast systole and diastole of concentrating wealth and compulsive recirculation.
Great Ideas Thrive on Resistance
So the conservative who resists change is as valuable as the radical who proposes it-perhaps as much more valuable as roots are more vital than grafts. It is good that new ideas should be heard, for the sake of the few that can be used; but it is also good that new ideas should be compelled to go through the mill of objection, opposition, and contumely; this is the trial heat which innovations must survive before being allowed to enter the human race. It is good that the old should resist the young, and that the young should prod the old; out of this tension, as out of the strife of the sexes and the classes, comes a creative tensile strength, a stimulated development, a secret and basic unity and movement of the whole.
Today most of our information intake comes from the social media feed — Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Tic Tok — which is less than 24 hours old. What value addition can a piece of information bring to you that hasn’t even survived even a day?
Ideas worth pursuing are the ones which survive the resistance and opposition. They get refined. And an idea which has survived for long outlives the minds that produced it.
Life has no inherent claim to eternity, whether in individuals or in states. Death is natural, and if it comes in due time it is forgivable and useful, and the mature mind will take no offense from its coming. But do civilizations die? Again, not quite. Greek civilization is not really dead; only its frame is gone and its habitat has changed and spread; it survives in the memory of the race, and in such abundance that no one life, however full and long, could absorb it all. Homer has more readers now than in his own day and land. The Greek poets and philosophers are in every library and college; at this moment Plato is being studied by a hundred thousand discoverers of the “dear delight” of philosophy overspreading life with understanding thought. This selective survival of creative minds is the most real and beneficent of immortalities.
It’s a 100-page book but it packs the wisdom of centuries. I hope I’ve convinced you enough to spend an evening with Durants.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years