Post the second world war, when the western economies experienced a massive boom, the number of people living and working in high rises increased exponentially. These tall establishments became more convenient with the wide adoption of elevators.
In spite of elevators saving time and effort (that would’ve gone in climbing the stairs), people started complaining about delays and the slowness of elevators.
We, humans, are inherently discontent with what we have, aren’t we? Instead of feeling grateful for the fact that elevator saves us from the pain of trudging up floors on the foot, we get frustrated about having to wait a few extra minutes. Such is the human nature. However, it’s not the waiting that bothers us. It’s boredom.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Forget minutes, sometimes after entering the lift, if the automatic closing doors take more than a few seconds, people start hammering the buttons in the panel. I have been guilty of that impatient behaviour several times.
This means no matter how fast and efficiently the elevators run, people will always complain.
So, a clever elevator designer came up with an ingenious way to address this waiting problem. He installed mirrors in the elevator lobby and inside the elevators. The complaints dropped to zero. It turns out that mirrors make the waiting space feel bigger and offer most people something they like to look at, i.e., themselves. They help people straighten their ties, fuss with their hair, or secretly examine someone else’s reflection rather than ogle openly.
Today, mirrors in elevator lobbies and even on elevators in tall buildings are commonplace.
The real issue wasn’t an engineering problem (tardy elevator), it was a behavioural problem arising from the quirks of human perception. Our world is full of such problems which are begging to be solved by such cost-effective behavioural hacks.
Rory Sutherland’s book Alchemy is about such hacks. As Vice-Chairman of Ogilvy in the UK, Sutherland is an ad-man. He’s one of those thinkers who are gifted with abilities to cross disciplines and deploying theories from one area into others. He calls himself a student of behavioural economics, evolutionary psychology and complexity economics. No wonder why he churns out remarkable insights about consumer behaviour.
Eurostar is an international high-speed railway service connecting London with many other prominent cities in Europe. A bunch of engineers were asked to improve the journey for the Eurostar. They spent six billion pounds shortening the travel time from London to Paris by 40 minutes.
Rory suggested a better and cheaper solution. Install free Wi-Fi in the trains for about 0.01% of the cost. Alternatively, hire all of the world’s top supermodels and pay them to hand out complimentary champagne for the entire duration of the journey. These suggestions would not only have made the trip far more enjoyable; it would have saved them a whole lot of money. The chances are that the passengers would have wanted the train to go slower.
“Alongside the inarguably valuable products of science and logic, there are also hundreds of seemingly irrational solutions to human problems just waiting to be discovered, if only we dare to abandon standard-issue, naïve logic in the search for answers…The models that dominate all human decision-making today are duly heavy on simplistic logic, and light on magic – a spreadsheet leaves no room for miracles.
The alchemy of this book’s title is the science of knowing what economists are wrong about. The trick to being an alchemist lies not in understanding universal laws, but in spotting the many instances where those laws do not apply. It lies not in narrow logic, but in the equally important skill of knowing when and how to abandon it. This is why alchemy is more valuable today than ever.”
Here are Rory’s Rules of Alchemy
- The opposite of a good idea can also be a good idea.
- Don’t design for average.
- It doesn’t pay to be logical if everyone else is being logical.
- The nature of our attention affects the nature of our experience.
- A flower is simply a weed with an advertising budget.
- The problem with logic is that it kills off magic.
- A good guess which stands up to observation is still science. So is a lucky accident.
- Test counterintuitive things only because no one else will.
- Solving problems using rationality is like playing golf with only one club.
- Dare to be trivial.
- If there were a logical answer, we would have found it.
Let’s look at one of them in more detail.
Don’t Design for Average
Most people, while designing products and solutions, often keep the average user in mind but innovation happens at extremes. You are more likely to come up with a good idea, argues Sutherland, “focusing on one outlier than on ten average users.”
He explains:
“When Lieutenant Gilbert S. Daniels, a physical anthropologist, was hired by the US military to design a better cockpit for high-speed aircraft in the early 1950s, the assumption he had to challenge was that you should design a cockpit for ‘the average man’. The idea was that if you took an average of many pilots’ bodily dimensions, you would have a template around which you could design a cockpit – with the instruments visible to most people, and with the controls within easy reach of all but the most unusual physical specimens…When you designed a cockpit for an average man you were designing a cockpit not for everyone, but for a surprisingly rare, or even non-existent, body-type. Not a single pilot of the 4,000 measured was within the average range on all ten bodily measures.
Weird consumers drive more innovation than normal ones. By contrast, it is perfectly possible that conventional market research has, over the past fifty years, killed more good ideas than it has spawned, by obsessing with a false idea of representativeness.”
On Being a Little Less Logical
If you’ve been a student of behaviour science, it’s not hidden from you that irrationality is an integral trait of the human psyche. Which means, expecting a rational and logical response from ourselves and others is being too naive.
“A strictly logical approach to problem-solving gives the reassuring impression that you are solving a problem, even when no such process is possible; consequently the only potential solutions considered are those which have been reached through ‘approved’ conventional reasoning – often at the expense of better (and cheaper) solutions that involve a greater amount of instinct, imagination or luck.”
Allow me to rerun this quote from Einstein —
“Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited, whereas imagination embraces the entire world, stimulating progress, giving birth to evolution.”
Einstein probably arrived at this conclusion after following Neil Bohr’s (a Nobel Laureate himself) advice. Bohr once told Einstein, “You’re not thinking; you are merely being logical.”
Like rationality, logic has its place but finding creative solutions often requires one to be less logical and more imaginative.
“This pseudo-rational approach, with its obsession with following an approved process, excludes counter-intuitive possible solutions and restricts solution-seeking to a small and homogeneous group of people. After all, not even accountants or economists use logic to solve everyday domestic dilemmas, so why do they instinctively reach for calculators and spreadsheets the moment they enter an office? The conventional answer is that we deploy more rigour and structure to our decision-making in business because so much is at stake; but another, less optimistic, explanation is that the limitations of this approach are in fact what makes it appealing – the last thing people want when faced with a problem is a range of creative solutions, with no means of choosing between them other than their subjective judgement. It seems safer to create an artificial model that allows one logical solution and to claim that the decision was driven by ‘facts’ rather than opinion: remember that what often matters most to those making a decision in business or government is not a successful outcome, but their ability to defend their decision, whatever the outcome may be.”
Sutherland’s three-decade career in advertising has placed him in a position from where he can expose the strange aspects of the world of decision making. His insights are filled with surprising lessons for all aspects of life and business.
Rory’s book will feature in the top-5 books that I read this year. I hope you’ll also wrap up 2019 with this wonderful volume on secrets of human behaviour.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years