Longtime readers of Value Investing Almanack know that I am a huge fan of Yuval Harari’s work. His first book, Sapiens, turned my world upside down. Technically, it was a book on human history but the insights were anything but ancient. It was jaw dropping from the first word to the last. Sapiens ranks among the five best books that I have read, ever!
His second book Homo Deus was equally gripping and lived up to the expectations created by his first masterpiece Sapiens. In Sapiens, Harari explained how homo sapiens came to be the planet’s dominant species. Homo Deus was a historian’s perspective of what the future could look like for humans.
The first and the second book covering the past and the future respectively, Harari’s reader were waiting to hear his views on the present state of the world. Fortunately, the wait wasn’t long. In his latest book — 21 Lessons for the 21st Century — Harari confronts today’s 21 big questions dedicating one chapter to each of those questions.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Bill Gates, in his review of this book, wrote —
The human mind wants to worry. This is not necessarily a bad thing—after all, if a bear is stalking you, worrying about it may well save your life. Although most of us don’t need to lose too much sleep over bears these days, modern life does present plenty of other reasons for concern: terrorism, climate change, the rise of A.I., encroachments on our privacy, even the apparent decline of international cooperation.
In his fascinating new book 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, the historian Yuval Noah Harari creates a useful framework for confronting these fears.
He offers some practical advice, including a three-prong strategy for fighting terrorism and a few tips for dealing with fake news. But his big idea boils down to this: Meditate. Of course he isn’t suggesting that the world’s problems will vanish if enough of us start sitting in the lotus position and chanting Om. But he does insist that life in the 21st century demands mindfulness—getting to know ourselves better and seeing how we contribute to suffering in our own lives.
Meditation
So in this post, instead of trying to sample a bit from each chapter, I thought of picking just one chapter (which even Gates confirmed is the big idea in this book) and sharing it with you.
Harari has been a student of Vipassana meditation since 2000. He learned it from S.N. Goenka who is credited for spreading the Vipassana technique all over the world. In fact, Harari had dedicated his second book Homo Deus to Mr. Goenka. The last chapter in the book is on meditation.
Harari writes —
When people ask the big questions of life, they usually have absolutely no interest in knowing when their breath is coming into their nostrils and when is it going out. Rather, they want to know things like what happens after you die. Yet the real enigma of life is not what happens after you die, but what happens before you die. If you want to understand death, you need to understand life.
That’s profound. I was so intrigued with Harari’s experience with Vipassana that I enrolled myself for the 10-day silent Vipassana meditation retreat last year.
The big idea I took from Sapiens was that a majority of our experience in the world is encumbered with imagined realities (money, religion, nation-state, etc.) But what’s really real? Your breath is real. You’re not imagining it. So to observe reality as it is, the best place to start is to observe your breath. That would train the mind to discriminate between the imagined and the real.
If you can understand what happens to you as one moment ends and another moment begins – you will also understand what will happen to you at the moment of death. If you can really observe yourself for the duration of a single breath – you will understand it all.
Harari practices 2 hours of vipassana meditation every day and he comes to India for a 60-day silent meditation retreat every year. He writes —
It is not an escape from reality. It is getting in touch with reality. At least for two hours a day I actually observe reality as it is, while for the other twenty-two hours I get overwhelmed by emails and tweets and cute-puppy videos. Without the focus and clarity provided by this practice, I could not have written Sapiens or Homo Deus. At least for me, meditation never came into conflict with scientific research. Rather, it has been another valuable tool in the scientific toolkit, especially when trying to understand the human mind.
Mind isn’t Brain
People often use the words brain and mind interchangeably. When a neurosurgeon opens his patient’s skull in the operation theatre, he can see the brain and the other smaller components that it’s made up of. However, can the doctor put his finger on that man’s mind?
Many people, including many scientists, tend to confuse the mind with the brain, but they are really very different things. The brain is a material network of neurons, synapses and biochemicals. The mind is a flow of subjective experiences, such as pain, pleasure, anger and love. Biologists assume that the brain somehow produces the mind, and that biochemical reactions in billions of neurons somehow produce experiences such as pain and love. However, so far we have absolutely no explanation for how the mind emerges from the brain. How come when billions of neurons are firing electrical signals in a particular pattern, I feel pain, and when the neurons fire in a different pattern, I feel love? We haven’t got a clue. Hence even if the mind indeed emerges from the brain, at least for now studying the mind is a different undertaking than studying the brain.
Advances in technology and medical research has given us sophisticated instruments that can peek inside the brain and even generate a detailed map of all the electrical activity happening inside the grey cells. But science is yet to trace the whereabouts of the mind. Consciousness is a big mystery that continues to baffle scientists and brain researchers.
Some compare the consciousness with pollution. Just like a fire creates smoke as a byproduct, while doing its own thing over millions of years mother nature perhaps ended up with consciousness as an accidental consequence.
Since scientists are yet to build a device which can investigate the mind, the only other means to research mind is to observe it directly. The catch is that the only mind one can investigate is his own.
As of 2018, the only mind I can access directly is my own. If I want to know what other sentient beings are experiencing, I can do so only on the basis of second-hand reports, which naturally suffer from numerous distortions and limitations…In science, when you investigate a particular phenomenon, it is best to observe it directly…whereas mind scholars developed many tools for collecting and analysing second-hand reports, when it comes to observing our own minds we have barely scratched the surface.
In the absence of modern methods for direct mind observation, we might try out some of the tools developed by pre-modern cultures. Several ancient cultures devoted a lot of attention to the study of mind, and they relied not on collecting second-hand reports, but on training people to observe their own minds systematically. The methods they developed are bunched together under the generic term ‘meditation’.
That’s perhaps the most convincing and logical argument I have ever read for meditation.
The world that we see outside is largely a projection of what goes on in our own minds. So if you go by the mental model of first principles, to make sense of the outer world, we first need to examine the inner world. Meditation is just a tool to take the focus from outward to inward.
In many ancient Vedic texts, the mind has often been referred to as the sixth sense. We don’t just perceive the world through our five physical senses. The mind is an additional input device because it can recreate the experiences that senses can do. However, unlike physical senses, the mind can observe itself.
Can an eye see itself? Can a point on skin feel itself? But a mind can mind itself. Isn’t that fascinating?
There are 20 more ideas in the book. I leave those for you to read and explore.
You may not agree with everything Harari writes. And you shouldn’t not. In fact, the beauty of Harari’s work lies in his ability to dazzle you with his deep insights and at the same time leave you with opened ended thoughts and unanswered questions.
I am sure you’ll love reading this book. [/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years