When you go wrong about something and you feel the spotlight is on you because you blabbered about it in the past, it’s very painful to change your mind even when a significant part of your wealth is at stake.
In a survey, people were asked about their greatest fear. Can you guess what was the number one fear for most people? It wasn’t fear of death.
Fear of public speaking topped the list. Death was second. My guess is that the third one on the list would be a combination i.e. ‘dying while public speaking’. Jokes apart, the act of standing up in front of a crowd and saying something meaningful, for most people, is terrifying.
I remember my first experience. The moment I stood up on the stage, my legs started shaking uncontrollably. Within few seconds my throat went dry as the desert and I was sweating like a pig. I could barely utter a single syllable. I behaved like a deer who suddenly finds itself in front of a hungry and ferocious lion.
The underlying cause of this fear is our intense urge to not look like a stupid. A man would do everything to avoid being in embarrassing situations. This tendency comes from the basic human need to belong to a group, to fit in and not stand out like an odd man out. Social proof is an important behavioural bias which explains why we behave irrationally.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
This fear of looking like a fool isn’t limited to public speaking. Even when we are not on stage, we’re always conscious of the fact that others are watching us and judging our actions. This causes discomfort and makes us behave in a way which may not be consistent with our true self. The irony is that, when everyone is overly focused on themselves, they aren’t really watching others.
While it’s true that anyone behaving or looking starkly different will attract the attention but not as much as he thinks. This fallacy is known as The Spotlight Effect. It is the phenomenon in which people tend to believe they are being noticed more than they really are.
The spotlight effect was first reported in 1999, when Thomas Gilovich and Kenneth Savitsky coined the term. The reasoning behind the spotlight effect comes from innate tendency to forget that although one is the center of one’s own world, one is not the center of everyone else’s. This tendency is especially prominent when one does something atypical.” (Source: Wikipedia)
Richard H. Thaler, in his book Nudge, describes Gilovich’s experiment which demonstrated Spotlight Effect –
In a typical experiment, Gilovich’s team started by doing some research about which entertainer would be most unhip to display on the front of a –shirt. This research was conducted in the late 1990s, and the winner of this dubious honor was the singer Barry Manilow. When a student arrived for the experiment, he was told to put on a T-shirt with Barry Manilow’s picture prominently displayed on the front. The student was then asked to join another group of students who were busy filling out questionnaires. After a minute or so, the experimenter returned, told the student wearing the T-shirt that he now realized he wanted him to participate in a different study. The students and the experimenter then left the room. At this point the student was asked to guess how many of the other students in the room would be able to identify who was on his T-shirt. The average guess was a bit less than half, 46 percent. In fact, only 21 percent of the group could say who was pictured on his T-shirt.
So unless you’re a celebrity, most people tend to give you a passing attention. It’s not that nobody notices anything about you. It’s just that they notice far less than you think they do. Thaler argues –
One reason why people expend so much effort conforming to social norms and fashions is that they think that others are closely paying attention to what they are doing. If you wear a suit to a social event where everyone else has gone casual, you feel like everyone is looking at you funny and wondering why you are such a geek. If you are subject to such fears, here is a possibly comforting thought: they aren’t really paying as much attention to you as you think.
If you’re always concerned about what others would think of you, chances are that you aren’t making the best use of your talents. Scott Adams, the creator of wildly popular cartoon strip Dilbert, wrote this in his autobiography –
A lack of fear of embarrassment is what allows one to be proactive. It’s what makes a person take on challenges that others write off as too risky. It’s what makes you take the first step before you know what the second step is. I’m not a fan of physical risks, but if you can’t handle the risk of embarrassment, rejection, and failure, you need to learn how, and studies suggest that is indeed a learnable skill.
In Investing
Warren Buffett illustrates this point brilliantly by asking a very thought provoking question, “Would you prefer to be considered the best lover in the world and know privately that you’re the worst—or would you prefer to know privately that you’re the best lover in the world, but be considered the worst?”
What Buffett is essentially saying that if he’s asked to choose between following two options –
1. Being a smart investor but known as a dumb investor.
2. Being a dumb investor and still known as a smart investor.
He’ll choose the first one. Always. Buffett doesn’t care how others view him. Instead, he remains true to himself and never compromises his own values. The spotlight is essentially a metaphor for what others think of you. When someone behaves in a way to justify the spotlight, he or she is driven by, what Buffett calls, an outer scorecard. “It’s very important,” says Buffett, “always to live your life by an inner scorecard, not an outer scorecard.”
A lot of times investors continue to hold on to a stock because they secretly want to look consistent with their earlier decision. It’s possible that they may have spoken about it in public and discussed their reasons for buying a stock. So when they find out that the stock was a mistake, they might be afraid of correcting the mistake because of fear of looking like a stupid. They think that admitting their mistake would throw the spotlight on them and they would look like a fool who doesn’t know how to pick stocks.
So instead of accepting the fault, we do something even more stupid. After having made an embarrassingly stupid mistake, to avoid being seen as a moron, we even justify our act as intentional.
This not only takes away our chance to learn from that mistake but compounds the negative consequences of the mistake because of our stubbornness to accept it.
This is particularly true for those who are excessively vocal about their investment decisions on public forums. The social media has made this effect more severe because now you can tweet about your stocks and potentially the whole world can know about it. This makes it even harder for someone to accept their mistake.
The truth is, no one cares. If you are an independent investor and don’t manage money professionally then there’s hardly anybody who is bothered what you said on twitter last year. Moreover, don’t fall into the trap of remaining consistent with your thought process all your life. If your thinking is not changing as new information becomes available, you’re not growing.
Here’s an interesting anecdote about George Soros from the book Inside the Investor’s Brain –
A trader, Jean-Manuel Rozan, “once spent an entire afternoon arguing about the stock market with Soros. Soros was vehemently bearish, and he had an elaborate theory to explain why, which turned out to be entirely wrong. The stock market boomed. Two years later, Rozan ran into Soros at a tennis tournament. ‘Do you remember our conversation? Rozan asked. ‘I recall it very well,’ Soros replied. ‘I changed my mind, and made an absolute fortune.’ He changed his mind!
That brings us to a very important insight for investors. I discovered this in Max Gunther’s extremely useful book How to Get Lucky. He writes –
Talk can tie you up, lock you into positions that seem right today but may be wrong tomorrow. A statement that seems safe today may become dangerous in the changed circumstances of tomorrow…Avoiding excessive communication frees from the need to explain and justify actions to other people. If you talk too much about a venture this year, you may find you’ve given away your freedom when you want to get out of it next year…In life you can never predict what actions you will need to take, it is best to say as little as possible about what you are doing and thinking. Then, when action is required, the only person you must argue with is yourself.
Of course, to be a good decision-maker one needs to be open to contradicting views and have a devil’s advocate who can find flaws in your hypothesis. But that kind of sounding board should be restricted to a very small set of people who you look up to for advice and ideas.
When you go wrong about something and you feel the spotlight is on you because you blabbered about it in the past, it’s very painful to change your mind even when a significant part of your wealth is at stake.
Conclusion
Spotlight effect is quite closely related to Social Proof bias. In fact, my guess is that spotlight effect is what causes the Social Proof bias, i.e., our tendency to conform to what our society believes in.
The moral is that people are paying less attention to you than you believe, writes Thaler, “If you have a stain on your shirt, don’t worry, they probably won’t notice. But in part because people do think that everyone has their eyes fixed on them, they conform to what they think people expect.”
Before we close this discussion let’s refresh our knowledge about behavioural biases and why they exist.
Amygdala is that portion of our brain which is responsible for making quick decisions based on emotions, instincts, and reflexes. This part of the brain hasn’t changed much in 2.5 million years. Among psychologists, it’s also referred to as the lizard brain. The lizard brain (reflexive brain) is the mother of all the behavioural biases. An interesting way to think about these behavioural bias is to compare it with the automatic spelling correction feature in our smartphones. In most cases, it works great but sometimes it can get you into serious trouble. The auto spell correction has put me in very embarrassing situations many times. These days, before clicking ‘send’, I always make it a point to read it again. In a similar vein, while making important decisions, you need to make sure that your lizard brain hasn’t committed a serious mistake. And you can only do that if you are aware of all the behavioural biases that your brain is highly prone to.
What saves us from Amygdala’s slip ups is the prefrontal cortex. It is the front portion of our brain which is responsible for making human race intelligent and superior to all the other animals. This prefrontal cortex (reflective brain) is the dude who helps in rational thinking.
Most humans are born with a default setting for the usage of reflective brain. However, this default setting is not sufficient for making rational decisions because the lizard brain has a tendency to intrude and occlude the reflective brain’s vision. Tweaking this default setting and raising the volume of the reflective brain requires mental effort and it is exhaustive. So most people ignore it and then suffer its consequences.
We hope that Behaviouronomics series is exposing these behavioural mistakes and equipping your decision-making muscle with strong defence against serious errors. Take care and keep learning.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
