• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Priming

October 10, 2016

Every perception, no matter if you consciously notice, sets off a chain of related ideas in your neural network. It happens to you all the time, and though you are unaware, it changes the way you behave.

Has it happened to you to that you reached home and while turning off the engine of your car/bike you suddenly realized that you can’t recall when you took the turn right before your house? It’s as if you drove the whole way without consciously realizing. It felt as if someone else was driving while you were lost in your own thoughts.

Some call it ‘muscle memory’. Scientists believe that it’s your subconscious that did the driving while your conscious mind was lost in daydreaming and thinking about other things. The autopilot in you was being controlled by your subconscious. We can pull off tremendous feats in spite of being unaware of how we did it. That’s how powerful our subconscious minds are. But with great power comes great vulnerability too. On one hand, our subconscious serves us so well in carrying out the mundane stuff without taxing our brains and requiring our conscious attention, on the other, it is very suggestible too. Which means your subconscious mind absorbs all sorts of information from your surroundings without your permission and realization. And this information that bypasses your conscious attention and enters your mind from a backdoor, can change the way you make decisions and perceive the world around you.

Don’t believe it?

[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Psychologists have done numerous experiments to prove this hypothesis. Here is one such experiment that Jason Zweig mentions in his book Your Money and Your Brain…

In the early 1970s, psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman asked people to spin a wheel of fortune that was numbered from 0 to 100 —and then to estimate whether the percentage of total United Nations membership made up by African countries was higher or lower than the number they had just spun. The spins of the wheel made a big difference, even though such obviously random (and totally irrelevant) numbers should have had no influence on people. On average, people who spun a 10 guessed that only 25% of U.N. members were African nations, while people who spun a 65 guessed that 45% were African.

The number on the fortune wheel seeped into people’s subconscious and skewed their estimates. This is called priming. David McRaney, in his bookYou Are Not So Smart, defines priming as…

When a stimulus in the past affects the way you behave and think or the way you perceive another stimulus later on, it is called priming. Every perception, no matter if you consciously notice, sets off a chain of related ideas in your neural network. It happens to you all the time, and though you are unaware, it changes the way you behave.”
The conscious mind is usually oblivious to the influence of your unconscious mind. So if you think only your conscious brain is in control, think again!

Priming and Persuasion

Scientists have discovered that red colour primes your subconscious and incites hunger. No wonder Coke and many other fast food brands (McDonald, Dominos, Pizza Hut) use red colour generously in their logos and advertisements. So priming is a powerful weapon of persuasion used by clever marketers. McRaney writes –

Grocery stores noticed an increase in sales when the smell of freshly baked bread primed people to buy more…Production companies spend millions of dollars to create trailers and movie posters to form first impressions so you are primed to enjoy their films in a certain way right up until the opening titles. Restaurants decorate their interiors to communicate everything from fine dining to psychedelic hippie communes in order to prime you to enjoy their cheese sticks. From every corner of the modern world advertisers are launching attacks on your unconscious in an attempt to prime your behavior to be more favorable for the bottom lines of their clients.

Real estate agents use priming as a manipulation tool all the time. It’s a common practice for them to start by showing you a poor property with an expensive price tag which primes your subconscious. Subsequently, when he shows you a relatively better place with a similar price tag, your subconscious gets fooled into thinking it as a good deal.

Priming with Numbers

One day a professor asked his students to write down the last two digits of their mobile numbers in their notebooks. Immediately after that he took out a bottle of wine from his bag and asked his students to write down the price they were willing to pay for the wine bottle. Knowing what you know about priming, it shouldn’t be difficult for you to guess that students with higher numbers bid nearly twice as much as students with lower numbers. The mobile number digits worked as an anchor—albeit in a hidden and misleading way. In his brilliant book, Thinking Fast and Slow, Kahneman explains…

If you are asked people whether Gandhi was more than 114 years old when he died you will end up with a much higher estimate of his age at death than you would if the anchoring question referred to death at 35. If you consider how much you should pay for a house, you will be influenced by the asking price. The same house will appear more valuable if its listing price is high than if it is low, even if you are determined to resist the influence of this number; and so on—the list of anchoring effects is endless. Any number that you are asked to consider as a possible solution to an estimation problem will induce an anchoring effect.

In all these experiments when people were asked if the initial anchor had any effect on their answers, everyone denied. They insisted that priming had no effect on their responses and they would start offering a host of made up reasons to further support their argument. But, as you can see, the evidence in the experiment is too strong to deny the role of priming. The famous 20th-century sci-fi fiction writer Robert Heinlein, in his novel Assignment in Eternity, observed…

“Man is not a rational animal; he is a rationalizing animal.”

He couldn’t have been more right. Anyone who isn’t aware of the science of behavioural biases would be extremely resistant to the idea that his or her thinking process is vulnerable to such useless and irrelevant anchors.

In Business

Rolf Dobelli, in his book The Art of Thinking Clearly, cites a great example of how priming (and false anchor) is routinely used in business negotiations. He writes…

In my early years, I had a quick stint at a consulting firm. My boss was a pro when it came to using anchors. In his first conversation with any client, he made sure to fix an opening price, which, by the way, almost criminally exceeded our internal costs: “I’ll tell you this now so you’re not surprised when you receive the quote, Mr. So-and-So: We’ve just completed a similar project for one of your competitors and it was in the range of five million dollars.” The anchor was dropped: The price negotiations started at exactly five million.

That’s a great example of how first mover advantage works in any kind of negotiations.

In Investing

This anchoring bias is one the biggest culprit in causing investors to make poor buy and sell decisions. We look at the recent stock prices and our mind, unknowingly, assumes the price as a proxy for the intrinsic value of the business. Similarly, the 52-week high and low price numbers prime our brains and create illusionary benchmarks to judge the attractiveness of current prices. Many times a new investor reads a positive news about a company and that primes his mind in a positive way which may unconsciously lead him to look for evidences which confirm his initial hypothesis about the stock. On the contrary, it may also happen that an adverse news about a company becomes the introduction point for the investor and he stays sceptical about the prospects because of the negative priming created by that initial piece of news.

Looks like there’s a whole lot of truth in the old saying – First impression is last the impression. In the context of priming the adage can perhaps be upgraded to – The first impression is the lasting impression.

Overcoming Priming

As you can guess, priming being a business of subconscious, it’s extremely difficult to counter its force. You can never guess which object, idea, or random number is going to become the anchor in your mind. Still, there are few typical situations where the effect of anchors can be negated. Kahneman suggests –

My advice to students when I taught negotiations was that if you think the other side has made an outrageous proposal, you should not come back with an equally outrageous counter-offer, creating a gap that will be difficult to bridge in further negotiations. Instead you should make a scene, storm out or threaten to do so, and make it clear—to yourself as well as to the other side—that you will not continue the negotiation with that number on the table.

Similarly, when it comes to investing, wise investors avoid looking at the stock price when they start evaluating a business. They understand the insidious effects of priming on our final decisions.

Conclusion

Kahneman concludes his discussion on priming by raising an unsettling question…

The main moral of priming research is that our thoughts and our behavior are influenced, much more than we know or want, by the environment of the moment. Many people find the priming results unbelievable, because they do not correspond to subjective experience. Many others find the results upsetting, because they threaten the subjective sense of agency and autonomy. If the content of a screen saver on an irrelevant computer can affect your willingness to help strangers without your being aware of it, how free are you?

But if you think about that question a little more you’d realize that priming is a double edged sword. Once you understand the power of priming it gives you a tremendous edge in maintaining good human relations. How? When you greet someone with a sincere smile it primes the other person in a positive way. The chances of you having a fruitful and pleasant interaction with that person increase manifold. I agree many salespeople use a fake smile to exploit this idea but our subconscious is too smart to differentiate between a genuine and an insincere smile. So use smile, not as a manipulation tool, but as a way to show your appreciation for others and then see what wonders it creates. A smile not only primes the other person but it has an unintentional side effect on your own mental state too. It’s called reverse priming. Where the smile fools your subconscious into thinking that you’re feeling good even though you may be in a bad mood, to begin with. For centuries the wise have known the power of priming and have exploited it in some form. Why do you think the walls in their houses are always adorned with pictures of their own heroes?

I hope you’re priming your subconscious with the ideas, people and things that you want in your life.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India