• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Peltzman Effect

October 10, 2017

As human activities are made safer, it tends to make us overconfident and take higher risks. This unintended consequence of increased safety has vast implications including, but not limited to, adventure sports, road safety, and stock markets.

Question for you. How many parachutes does one need to try skydiving? One, two?

Technically, none. That is if you want to jump only once. To do it more than once you need the parachute. Don’t you?

Well, I agree this was a weak attempt of starting this post with humour. But on a serious note, I am sure you know that every skydiver jumps with a reserve parachute. And what if the both the chutes don’t open? Well…so much for skydiving!

Instead of wondering about the number of parachutes, a more interesting question to ask here is this: does an additional chute make skydiving safer? “Of course! It should,” most people will argue, “When a skydiver knows that there’s a backup for the emergency, wouldn’t he feel safer? Isn’t that the reason skydiving, as a sport, has become so popular that hundreds of thousands of people indulge in it every year?”

But if you dig deeper into above statement, you’d realise that there lies the paradox of safety. Statistics reveal that even though skydiving equipment has made huge leaps forward for improving reliability, the fatality rate has stayed roughly constant when adjusted for the increasing number of participants.

The backup parachute and other safety measures seem to reduce the risk only for a short while until the skydivers start feeling safer and, unfortunately, overconfident. This overconfidence promotes the skydivers to attempt even riskier manoeuvres which defeats the purpose of having the additional safety.

Skydiving pioneer Bill Booth observed – “The safer skydiving gear becomes, the more chances skydivers will take, in order to keep the fatality rate constant.”

This phenomenon isn’t limited to skydiving alone. Take skiing for example. Recent studies indicate that skiers wearing helmets go faster on average than non-helmeted skiers, and that overall risk index is higher in helmeted skiers than non-helmeted skiers. Moreover, while helmets may help prevent minor head injuries, increased usage of safety headgear has not reduced the overall fatality rate.

So, am I arguing that people should stop wearing helmets and jump with a single chute only? No. That would be a defeatist view. My intention is to draw your attention to a less known behavioural bias called Peltzman Effect.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] In 1975, the University of Chicago economist Sam Peltzman studied the impact of seatbelt laws on automobile death rate. He reasoned that regulations designed to improve automobile safety had failed to result in a significant reduction in highway fatalities. Peltzman’s argument was that drivers compensated for the perceived increase in safety by taking more risks. While the use of seat belts increased the safety inside the vehicle, it also made people drive recklessly. As a result, the frequency of accidents increased causing more fatalities outside the cars. In the end, safety measures merely transferred the risk from one set of people to another. The overall risk in the system, as Booth claimed, remained the same.

Apart from adventure sports and road safety, Peltzman effect has been demonstrated in a wide range of areas. Martin Ford, in his book Rise of the Robots, writes –

Children’s playgrounds, for example, have become much safer. Steep slides and high climbing structures have been removed and cushioned surfaces have been installed. Yet, studies have shown that there has been no meaningful reduction in playground-related emergency room visits or broken bones.

If you’re a cricket lover, you might remember the unfortunate accident involving Australian cricketer Phil Hughes. On 25 November 2014, Hughes was hit in the neck by a bouncer, during a cricket match, causing a fatal blow to his brain. Huge was wearing a helmet but while attempting a hook shot, the ball struck the unprotected area just below his left ear. Two days later he succumbed to the injury, having never regained consciousness.

Immediately after Hughes incident, Economist published an article on cricket safety. It said –

Facing express bowlers of the past, whether Harold Larwood, Andy Roberts or Malcolm Marshall, helmet-less batsmen were less inclined to play the hook—a shot that involves swatting a short-pitched ball from in front of your nose—because of the danger of getting it wrong. They were also more likely to keep their eye on a threatening ball and sway out of the way at the last moment, as the coaching manual demands. Today, with greater protection, there seems to be more of a propensity for batsmen to flinch and turn their backs on anything nasty. Those with exposed heads were more likely to play back-foot shots, which give batsmen extra time to follow the flight of the ball.

The breakneck developments in technology is making our life more comfortable and safer. But the instinct to seek risk is an evolutionary trait which we humans find hard to control. The commute, particularly air travel, has become so extraordinarily safe that people are statistically safer inside a plane than their own home. However, with the advent of unmanned aviation, the overall risk associated with aviation industry is going to increase. This Quora thread offers a fascinating insight into how Peltzman effect can affect the aviation industry.

Unmanned aviation represents a newly affordable and more broadly accessible means of obtaining an aerial perspective on something. The reason it’s cheaper and readily accessible is because it doesn’t require an aircraft big enough, complex enough, reliable enough and safe enough to carry a human occupant. Bonus: since a pilot’s life isn’t at risk based on what’s done with the unmanned aircraft, it’s tempting to put the unmanned aircraft into situations and domains where it’s at greater risk… including in the path of manned aircraft performing other flying activities, or over the heads of an unsuspecting public. So, unmanned aircraft pilots can do things with unmanned aircraft that would be unthinkable with manned aircraft (in many cases because it would be stupid or dangerous to do so), but also such that people on the ground or manned aircraft can be put at risk by the unmanned aircraft’s operation without risk to the unmanned aircraft pilot. In other words, a UA pilot can go out and do things inherently dangerous to others without incurring personal risk. They can act less cautiously not because of safety precautions, but because of personal distance from a threat that negates the need for safety precautions.

In Investing

So, what can an investor learn from Peltzman Effect? A few decades back, investing in stock markets in India was ridden with a lot of risks. For one, SEBI didn’t exist so the primary threat was absence of regulations. Small investors were routinely taken for a ride by greedy promoters and unethical brokers. There was no way to guarantee that the stock certificate one got was a fake or genuine one. An investor had to do a lot of due diligence, apart from studying the business fundamentals, before buying a stock. Moreover, the process of buying and selling stocks was slow earlier. It took few days, even weeks, to get the delivery of a stocks and then similar time to sell it. Put simply, the capital markets were heavily rigged against small investors.

An excellent book to read on this subject is Santosh Nair’s Bulls, Bears and Other Beasts. It chronicles the events (from the late 1970s to the present day) that shaped the Indian Stock market. The book does a terrific job of reminding us how sterile today’s investing environment is as compared to the 1980s and 1990s. Today, with SEBI, dematerialisation and electronic trading, all the risks cited above don’t exist. The rules and regulations of SEBI are making the safety net stronger and wider for retail investors. But is it translating into less risk? Peltzman effect would predict that the risk associated with stock market investing hasn’t reduced. The nature of the risk might have changed but the overall risk remains same. The retail investor stands to lose less money because of unscrupulous promoters and brokers and more money because of an individual’s tendency to go out on a limb. The increased ease of investing in the stock market has attracted millions of new investors who view markets as a way to get rich quick. Discount trading, instant stock price alerts, easy credit, frictionless access to derivatives and abundance of stock tips on internet ensures that overall the retail investor loses more money than what he did 25 years ago.

Martin Ford writes –

The Peltzman effect is typically invoked by conservative economists in support of an argument against increased government regulation. However, I think there is every reason to believe that this risk compensation behavior extends into the economic arena. People who have a safety net will be willing to take on more economic risk.

Peltzman effect is a close cousin of another mental model called Red Queen Effect. We wrote about Red Queen Effect in the March 2016 issue of VIA. You might want to revisit that post. Prof Sanjay Bakshi has also written a wonderful article on the same subject. Again, the intention of studying Peltzman effect is not to question the importance of having safety in the systems. However, it’s very useful to imagine what kind of behaviour those safety measures can result eventually. Peltzman effect reminds us that we need to make appropriate provision for the possible surprise that future holds.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India