Once upon a time, there were two merchants. Jaggeryman and Oilman. As the name suggests, they used to sell jaggery and oil, respectively. Doing business in their village was simple. People would come to their shops, buy the stuff, pay cash and leave.
But humans get impatient with simple things. So our merchant duo decided to move their shops to a city, rented shops next to each other and hoped that their products would start flying off the shelf. But when sales didn’t pick up even after a few weeks, during a brainstorming session, Oilman suggested that they should do a simulation — a customer-shopkeeper role-play — to figure out if they’re missing something obvious.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
“Okay, you come to my shop pretending to be a customer.” Said the Jaggeryman to the Oilman.
So the Oilman sauntered into the Jaggeryshop and asked, “One litre jaggery, please”
“Dude!” frowned the Jaggeryman, “Jaggery is sold by kilos, not by litres. Try again.”
So the Oilman repeated his stroll and enquired again, “Please give me one kilo Jaggery in a bottle.”
“What’s wrong with you? What bottle? Jaggery is not oil.” Squirmed the Jaggeryman.” I think we should switch roles. You sit here at my place, and I’ll show you how to be a customer.”
“Alright” The Oilman shrugs.
To make it more real, the Jaggeryman goes all the way to the end of the road and pretends to walk past the Jaggery shop absentmindedly. Then, as if noticing something late, he turns back and enters the shop.
“I would like to buy some good quality jaggery. What’s the rate?” Jaggeryman chooses his words carefully.
“Rupees 100 per kg, Sir.” Oilman replies.
“Sounds good. Give me 2 kgs.”
“Sure, Sir! Where’s your bottle?”
Now, before you roll your eyes at my lame attempt to narrate a humorous story, allow me to explain where this is going.
You see, the Oilman looked at everything from the oil-colored glasses. In other words, his world view was strongly dictated by his years of experience dealing with oil. As he tried to fit everything into an oil bottle, he didn’t notice that his cognition was skewed by a behavioural bias called the Mind Projection Fallacy — a tendency when someone thinks that the way they see the world reflects the way the world really is, going as far as assuming the real existence of imagined objects.
For example, someone who enjoys the taste of chocolate might erroneously think that the chocolate has the inherent property of tastiness, and therefore everyone else must like its taste too.
It’s an understandable bias because the only person who knows my mind best is me. True with everybody. We have direct access to our thoughts, but for others, we can only guess why they’re behaving a certain way. And even in our guessing, we’d like to give a very low weightage to whatever reasoning we think others have for believing their beliefs.
For that matter, as depicted in the sci-fi movie The Matrix, the whole world is nothing but a projection of my mind.
You could argue that your actions can affect other people. But you could then ask, “who sees and validates” that there was an effect on others? Who acknowledges the existence of others?
I. Me. My mind. Isn’t it?
A dream is also a projection of the mind. Has it ever happened to you that while dreaming, you realized that you were in the middle of a dream? Similarly, it’s hard to deny the possibility that the thing you call reality is one long uninterrupted dream.
Elon Musk, who is considered to be super smart, reasons that we’re all probably trapped in a “Matrix”-like pseudo existence.
Eliezer Yudkowsky writes –
In the dawn days of science fiction, alien invaders would occasionally kidnap a girl in a torn dress and carry her off for intended ravishing, as lovingly depicted on many ancient magazine covers. Oddly enough, the aliens never go after men in torn shirts.
Would a non-humanoid alien, with a different evolutionary history and evolutionary psychology, sexually desire a human female? It seems rather unlikely.
Apparently we instinctively represent Sexiness as a direct attribute of the Woman object, Woman.sexiness, like Woman.height or Woman.weight.
If your brain uses that data structure, or something metaphorically similar to it, then from the inside it feels like sexiness is an inherent property of the woman, not a property of the alien looking at the woman. Since the woman is attractive, the alien monster will be attracted to her—isn’t that logical?
So how do we overcome this bias?
Folks at the Lesswrong blog recommend –
Overcoming the mind project fallacy requires realizing that our minds are not transparent windows unto veridical reality; when you look at a rock, you experience not the rock itself, but your mind’s representation of the rock, reconstructed from photons bouncing off its surface. Sugar in and of itself is not inherently sweet; the sugar itself only has the chemical properties that it does, which your brain interprets as sweet.
When you look at the world acknowledging that what you see is not the entire truth and what others do is not out of ignorance of stupidity but because they’ve had different experiences than yours.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
