On October 12, 1980 Steve Titus, a restaurant manager in Seattle, was pulled over by a police officer. Titus was on his way home with his girlfriend.
The officer informed him that his car resembled a car that was driven earlier in the evening by a man who raped a female hitchhiker. So they took Titus’ picture and put it in a photo lineup which was later shown to the victim. She pointed to Titus’ photo and said, “That one’s the closest.”
Based on this, Titus was put on trial. In the court, the rape victim confirmed, “I’m absolutely positive that’s the man.” That was enough to convict him. The judge pronounced him guilty and sent him to prison.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
But Titus didn’t give up. He hired an investigative journalist Paul Henderson who actually found the real rapist, a man named Edward Lee King, who ultimately confessed to this rape. The decision on Titus’ conviction was overturned and he was released from the jail.
Henderson won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative journalism for his reporting on this case.
Sadly, this wrongful episode changed Titus’ life forever. He lost his job and his fiancée. The ordeal left him so bitter that he sued the police department and burnt all his life savings fighting the case. A few years later, at the age of 35, Steve Titus died of stress-induced heart attack.
Unfortunately, Steve Titus is not the only person to be convicted based on somebody’s false memory. A study was done on 300 defendants who were convicted of crimes they didn’t do. These were the people who had spent 10, 20, 30 years in prison before DNA testing proved their innocence. In 75 percent of these cases, the injustice was attributed to faulty eyewitness memory.
Elizabeth Loftus is an American cognitive psychologist and expert on human memory. She is best known for her work on eyewitness memory. In her TED talk, Elizabeth explains —
Like the jurors who convicted those innocent people and the jurors who convicted Titus, many people believe that memory works like a recording device. You just record the information, then you call it up and play it back when you want to answer questions or identify images. But decades of work in psychology has shown that this just isn’t true. Our memories are constructive. They’re reconstructive. Memory works a little bit more like a Wikipedia page: You can go in there and change it, but so can other people.
…when you feed people misinformation about some experience that they may have had, you can distort or contaminate or change their memory.
False memories are so common that you’ve certainly experienced them. For example, you might remember a childhood event in some detail and learn later that it happened to your sibling, not you. A significant part of human memories are mostly fiction. We form false memories quite easily.
False memory is a special case of wider phenomenon called memory bias — a cognitive bias that either enhances or impairs the recall of a memory (either the chances that the memory will be recalled at all, or the amount of time it takes for it to be recalled, or both), or that alters the content of a reported memory.
We’ve all heard of stories of people who claim to remember their past life. They’d name places where they were born in earlier life and even have elaborate narratives of how they died etc. Some of these are soon revealed as intentional acts of fraud and scams. But in cases where the claimant seems to genuinely believe in his reincarnation, it can always be explained by memory bias.
If I’ve learned anything from these decades of working on these problems, says Elizabeth, “it’s this: just because somebody tells you something and they say it with confidence, just because they say it with lots of detail, just because they express emotion when they say it, it doesn’t mean that it really happened.”
Here are a few well-known memory biases.
- Choice-supportive bias: Remembering chosen options as having been better than rejected options.
- Cryptomnesia: A form of misattribution where a memory is mistaken for imagination, because there is no subjective experience of it being a memory
- Source confusion: Misattributing the source of a memory, e.g. misremembering that one saw an event personally when actually it was seen on television.
- Suggestibility: A form of misattribution where ideas suggested by a questioner are mistaken for memory. This is what possibly happened in the case of Steve Titus where the investigating police officers leading questions made the victim believe that Titus was the offender.
- Memory inhibition: Being shown some items from a list makes it harder to retrieve the other items
- Von Restorff effect: An item that sticks out is more likely to be remembered than other items.
- Zeigarnik effect: that uncompleted or interrupted tasks are remembered better than completed ones.
You can get the complete list from Wikipedia.
When it comes to investing, false memory is potentially big source of errors. Our brain fools us and presents a distorted picture of the circumstances under which we made the decision which leads to wrong conclusion about why a stock turned out to be a mistake or success.
So how do you deal with this problem? Here’s a suggestion from Danny Kahneman —
…go down to a local drugstore and buy a very cheap notebook and start keeping track of your decisions. And the specific idea is whenever you’re making a consequential decision, something going in or out of the portfolio, just take a moment to think, write down what you expect to happen, why you expect it to happen and then actually, and this is optional, but probably a great idea, is write down how you feel about the situation, both physically and even emotionally. Just, how do you feel? I feel tired. I feel good, or this stock is really draining me. Whatever you think.
When you’ve got a decision-making journal, it gives you accurate and honest feedback of what you were thinking at that time. And so there can be situations, by the way, you buy a stock and it goes up, but it goes up for reasons very different than what you thought was going to happen. And having that feedback in a way to almost check yourself periodically is extremely valuable. So that’s, I think, a very inexpensive; it’s actually not super time consuming, but a very, very valuable way of giving yourself essential feedback because our minds won’t do it normally.
This brings us to another fascinating topic. False memories are disturbing because our present living and future planning is largely a function of our past experiences. And when you’re told that your past is malleable, you’d be left unsure of everything that you believe in.
To add insult to the injury, we all have another faulty layer on top of inaccurate memory — the layer of misplaced interpretation of what we remember about our past.
The decision journal addresses the issue of false memory. One possible solution for the faulty interpretation is to keep upgrading your mental software by learning and becoming a little bit wiser every day. Reading a good book or learning a new idea improves this software. You download new features and fix old bugs.
And when you revisit your past with a high fidelity lens of a more rational brain, it becomes easier to triangulate and hunt down some of those false memories.
Learning is like a software update for your brain. This updated version of the software can give you a new way to view your life experiences — present and past.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years