It’s a common fact that people respond to incentives, but the real power of incentives is often unrecognized and underestimated. Incentives influence at the subconscious level, and thus it’s the main culprit behind the immoral behaviour.
2006 was a great year for Google. Two years after its IPO, earnings were growing at 35 percent per year. The company had just bought YouTube for $1.5 billion, and Gmail was quickly becoming the most popular email service in the world. The stock was up almost five times since the IPO and Wall Street loved Google.
However, in its data-center operations, some serious issues were brewing up. Google had not yet perfected the ability to seamlessly scale up and power multiple products that it would later become famous for. Teams struggled to get resources in the data centers.
Sam Schillace, co-founder of the Docs predecessor Writely, described the situation after Google acquired his company as – “They had this crazy hand-cobbled system where there was one guy in the middle doing the planning — it was, like, put a bottle of vodka on his desk, and you’d get your machines for the service.”
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
The company kept building new data centers, but when they asked a team like Google Docs to move their machines somewhere else, things would drag on. “Sure, next month,” the data center team would hear. Nobody wanted to go through the disruption of shifting.
Apart from innovation, Google is also known for its unique culture and radical organization hierarchy. Which technology company has a post for a chief economist? In 2006, Google had. Hal Varian, Google’s chief economist, proposed a solution for the data center problem by bringing in ideas from different fields, i.e., psychology and airline industry. He later explained –
I suggested we run an auction similar to what airlines do when they oversell a plane— they keep offering bigger vouchers until enough customers are willing to give up their seats. In our case, we offer more machines in exchange for moving. One group might do it for fifty new ones, another for a hundred, and another won’t move unless we give them three hundred. So we give them to the lowest bidder — they get their extra capacity, and we get computation shifted to the new data center.” (Source: In The Plex)
It worked. Varian was intelligent enough to realize that it wasn’t a technology problem. The problem was with incentives. In behavioural finance, this is known as incentive caused bias.
Google’s story isn’t much different from what happened in FedEx. Charlie Munger describes the FedEx case study in one of his talks –
The integrity of the Federal Express system requires that all packages be shifted rapidly among airplanes in one central airport each night. And the system has no integrity for the customers if the night work shift can’t accomplish its assignment fast. And Federal Express had one hell of a time getting the night shift to do the right thing. They tried moral suasion. They tried everything in the world without luck. And, finally, somebody got the happy thought that it was foolish to pay the night shift by the hour when what the employer wanted was not maximized billable hours of the employee service but fault-free, rapid performance of a particular task. Maybe, this person thought, if they paid the employees per shift and let all night shift employees go home when all the planes were loaded, the system would work better. And, lo and behold, that solution worked.
Google and FedEx case studies are examples of what Charlie Munger calls Reward and Punishment Superresponse Tendency. Don’t get bogged down by Munger’s nomenclature. Steven Landsburg, in his book The Armchair Economist, defines it in simpler words – “People respond to incentives. The rest is just commentary.”
Incentive Caused Bias
The power of incentives is often under-recognized. In his legendary lecture, The Psychology of Human Misjudgement, Munger said –
I place this tendency first in my discussion because almost everyone thinks he fully recognises how important incentives and disincentives are in changing cognition and behaviour. But this is not often so. For instance, I think I’ve been in the top five percent of my age cohort almost all my adult life in understanding the power of incentives, and yet I’ve always underestimated that power. Never a year passes but I get some surprise that pushes a little further my appreciation of incentive superpower.
Munger emphasized the point very strongly that incentives are superpower and there are numerous examples where its wise application yielded amazing results and its neglect caused great loss. So why does he say that power of incentives is underestimated?
What Munger is trying to tell is that while thinking about a problem, one should give first thought to the power of incentives and then look somewhere else for any other explanations. On another occasion he said –
Never ever think about something else when you should be thinking about incentives. Perhaps the most important rule in management is: Get the incentives right.
Have you heard of the cobra effect?
Before the independence, the British government in India was concerned about the number of venomous cobra snakes in Delhi. The government, therefore, offered a bounty for every dead cobra. Initially, this was a successful strategy as large numbers of snakes were killed for the reward. Eventually, however, enterprising people began to breed cobras for the income. When the government became aware of this, the reward program was scrapped, causing the cobra breeders to set the now-worthless snakes free. As a result, the wild cobra population further increased. The apparent solution to the problem made the situation even worse. (Source – Wikipedia)
It’s a classic example of how incentive caused bias can create unexpected and unintended consequences. Human beings have a strong tendency to game the system for their benefits and incentive caused bias is the root cause of this problem.
Incentive caused bias is rampant in every field of life. In business, in investing and most severely in the financial industry.
In Financial Industry
So we’ve learnt that incentives matter and people can be incentivized to do required things. But the real power of incentives lies in its ability to manipulate the cognitive process at a subconscious level. Yes, you read it right. Incentives are so powerful that they influence us at the subconscious level.
Robert Heinlein hit the nail on the head when he said – “Man is not a rational animal, he is a rationalizing one.” And this tendency to rationalize the incentive-driven acts is the most significant problem of the financial industry.
The 2008 mortgage crisis was primarily a result of misplaced incentives. The people who sold toxic mortgage-backed securities had their annual bonuses attached to the size of the business they do. So they went ahead and created complex financial products and peddled them to unsuspecting investors. The 2008 financial meltdown is a very recent and vivid example of what happens when the incentives are skewed and are asymmetrical.
Brokers aren’t evil. They’re all usually good people. Just their incentives aren’t.
Similarly, the fee structure for the majority of the money managers (mutual funds and PMS) is directly tied to the size of the fund they manage. This results in most money managers running after collecting bigger AUM and the fund performance takes a back seat.
In Business
Like Google and Fedex, the world of business is full of stories where incentives explained a lot of unexpected outcomes. Early in the history of Xerox, the management was stumped by weak sales of their new machine in relation to their older and inferior machines. On investigation, they discovered that the commission arrangement with the salesmen gave a large and perverse incentive to push the inferior machine on customers.
In the corporate world, the most common way to incentivize the CEO and the top management is to issue them ESOPs in large quantities. This invariably guides the management’s focus towards those activities which can boost the company’s stock price in the short run. As soon as the stock price experiences a short-term spike, management can cash out their ESOPs. Those short-sighted decisions usually hurt the long-term health of the company.
That’s why ESOP is a fundamentally flawed incentive tool. It creates a severe misalignment between the management’s incentives and the shareholder’s incentives.
Overcoming Incentive Bias
The solution, of course, is that nobody should be in a position to have the upside without sharing the downside, particularly when others may be harmed. This remedy, being exposed to both negative and positive consequences of your activities, is known as having your skin in the game.
Most incentive structures are one dimensional in their design. And that’s a big problem. Promoting the good behaviour through incentives isn’t enough. What about discouraging the bad behaviour? Nassim Taleb calls them “dis-incentives.”
He gives an interesting example of the implementation of what was called Hammurabi’s code. Romans used this to create disincentives for the engineers to avoid cutting corners and cheat while construction of the bridge. The idea was simple; the engineer who builds the bridge was made to spend few nights under the bridge. Simple and powerful!
An otherwise decent man can act immorally because he is driven by incentives at both conscious and subconscious levels. Once this immoral behaviour starts and it pays this man well, he gets further inclined to repeat this kind of behaviour. Hence, it’s terribly important to incorporate these disincentives/ negative incentives/ punishments.
It’s better to miss rewarding a desirable behaviour than to produce an incentive system which promotes cheating behaviour because bad behaviour once rewarded is habit-forming.
Here are some thoughts on how one can avoid being a victim of incentive caused bias.
First, be skeptical about what you hear from others and what you are told. You never know what incentives are driving that viewpoint. It’s especially true when you are watching the news. To take everything at face value can be dangerous. Even if you find it to be objective enough, you should always seek views from other sources.
Second, when you seek advice from someone, always ask what the incentives are for that person. If the opinion is specifically beneficial for the advisor, take it with a pinch of salt. As Buffett says, “Never ask a barber, whether you need a haircut.”
While investing in a particular company, always give importance to the incentive structures of the senior management. A lot of bad investments can be avoided by looking at the compensation structures of the top management.
So as an investor when you’re analyzing a business, follow Munger’s advice, i.e., always ask what are the incentives of the people involved. If the stock came as a recommendation, what could be the recommender’s incentive? If the MD of the company is making specific claims in the annual report, what incentives could be driving his actions?
When it comes to doing business with others, Guy Spier has a bizarre but effective rule.
The Rule: If the seller has a self-interest in me buying, I ain’t buying.
He describes the rationale behind this rule in his wonderful book The Education of a Value Investor –
I adopted a simple rule that has proved extraordinarily beneficial. When people call to pitch me anything at all, I reply in as pleasant a manner as possible, “I’m sorry. But I have a rule that I don’t allow myself to buy anything that’s being sold to me.”
I may miss out in the short term. But over a lifetime I have no doubt that I’ll benefit much more by detaching myself from people with a self-interest in getting me to buy stuff.
I even apply this rule if I’m at a cocktail party and someone starts telling me about a great stock they own or a private company in which they’d like me to invest. I may listen. I may be impressed. I may even be tempted. But I won’t buy it if they would gain something from my doing so. In some cases, this might not be a sales commission or any other financial benefit: it might simply be that they derive psychological validation from successfully selling their idea. Either way, this is a no-go zone for me because the provenance of the idea is wrong since it stems from the seller’s personal agenda.
Whose bread I eat his song I sing, goes an old saying. This adage kind of captures the essence of incentive caused bias.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
