• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Impact Bias

July 10, 2016

Human beings are generally terrible at predicting their own future emotional states which leads them to overestimate how extreme positive or negative events would affect their long term happiness.

Let’s say there was a way to quantify the mental state of a human being in terms of how happy and content he is feeling at certain moment. Now I invite you to contemplate following two different futures for two persons, given that their present mental state measures 1,000 units each.

The first person has just won US$ 10 million lottery. The second person had a terrible accident and both his legs had to amputated. Can you make a guess about each person’s mental state 1 year down the line after the above two events have happened? In first case would his mental state be less than or more than 1,000? Of course, it would be more than 1,000. Isn’t it? After all he’s a very rich man now.

What about the second case? In fact, most people talk about how devastating it would be. Some people even say they would rather be dead than never be able to walk again. And what would be your prediction about the reading on victim’s mental-state-meter? Isn’t it obvious it would be far less than 1,000? May be even less than zero.

Before we start discussing the answer to this question, take a moment and think about what your brain is doing to generate an answer for above question. You brain is imagining the state of mind of each person i.e. it’s simulating each scenario by putting itself in the situation and doing a rough evaluation about how it will feel. Right?
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

This ability to simulate future scenarios is a remarkable ability which only human beings are capable of doing. Although you may take it for granted but among all the species, only human brain has something called pre-frontal cortex, which is capable of simulating experiences. For example, if I ask you to try out a new flavour of ice-cream which contains pepper, salt and tastes like burnt milk, you don’t really have to put it in your mouth to conclude “Yuck”. You just simulated the taste in your mind and decided quickly that you don’t want that kind of ice cream.

Just like pilots practice in flight simulators so that they don’t make real mistakes in planes, human beings have this marvellous adaptation that they can actually have experiences in their heads before they try them out in real life.

It turns out that our simulator isn’t that reliable because a year after losing the use of their legs, and a year after winning the lotto, lottery winners and paraplegics are equally happy with their lives. Yes, you read that correctly. And this is not a speculation of my own faulty simulator, it’s actually based on numerous studies conducted on real people including those who had won millions of dollars in lottery and others who had become paraplegics. This seems like good news for negative events, but not so good for positive events.

Daniel Gilbert’s, a psychologist and author of Stumbling on Happiness, research reveals some counterintuitive insights about what actually make us happy. What really makes us happy and what we think makes us happy (simulation) can differ a lot. The simulator makes you believe that different outcomes are more different than in fact they really are. Gilbert calls it the Impact Bias, which is the tendency for the simulator to work badly.

The Impact Bias is one example of affective forecasting, which is a social psychology phenomenon that refers to our generally terrible ability as humans to predict our future emotional states.

Gilbert says –

From field studies to laboratory studies, we see that winning or losing an election, gaining or losing a romantic partner, getting or not getting a promotion, passing or not passing a college test, on and on, have far less impact, less intensity and much less duration than people expect them to have. This almost floors me — a recent study showing how major life traumas affect people suggests that if it happened over three months ago, with only a few exceptions, it has no impact whatsoever on your happiness.

When we think about some emotional event, we tend to over-estimate how strongly we will feel, how long this will last and other factors that impact us. This applies to both negative and positive events. The fact is that whatever our emotions, we tend to return to a neutral ‘home’ position within a relatively short time. As short as three months, according to Gilbert’s studies.

So why do we overestimate the impact of emotional events, especially the negative ones?

Scientists attribute it to something called ‘focalism’. It says that while making a prediction of the impact of an event people focus too much on the event in question and not enough on other future events. They ignore the fact that with the passage of time, other events will occur that influence happiness. So when we think about the future happiness of a paraplegic, we tend to forget that other events in his life, as well as his general ability to recover from trauma will mitigate the negative feelings associated with his physical disability. Gilbert calls this ability to recover the ‘psychological immune system’. These psychological immune systems promote our brain’s ability to deliver a positive outlook and happiness from an inescapable situation. This is the opposite of what we would expect when we imagine such an event.

As Gilbert says,

People are not aware of the fact that their defences are more likely to be triggered by intense rather than mild suffering. Thus, they mis-predict their own emotional reactions to misfortunes of different sizes.

That’s the reason why most people, even after a loss of a loved one (parent, sibling, spouse or children), return to their normal life with in few months. It’s not that the loss of loved one won’t hurt when we think about it but at the same time it will still feel nice to relax on the porch and watch the sunset. May be there is some truth to the age old saying – Time heals all wounds.

To a large extent our present state of mind is determined by the thoughts pertaining to what’s going on in our life currently. A person is usually more worried about an upcoming work assignment than the divorce he had last year, unless he actively starts thinking about the divorce. Similarly, I would be more excited about the new book that just arrived from Amazon than a new house that I bought last year. In other words, nothing in life is as important as you think it is when you are thinking about it.

How about positive events? Why do we fail to estimate the impact of positive events on our future happiness?

People have created cultural theories and had experiences that greatly influence beliefs of how an event will affect us. For example, our culture has emphasized a correlation between wealth and happiness, however despite this belief; money does not necessarily bring happiness.

The ability of our five senses to derive pleasure out of materialistic things has obvious limitations. However, there is no limitation to the pleasure our mind can imagine or simulate. In other words, when predicting how an experience will impact us emotionally, events which have not been experienced are particularly difficult. Often how we think an event will turn out to be does not relate to how the experience is actually like.

Don’t forget that many other things wouldn’t change if you suddenly won a truck-load of cash. You probably wouldn’t be ecstatic for long because the other 99 percent of life will remain more or less the same. You’ll still feel grumpy if you don’t get enough sleep. You’ll still have to wait in rush hour traffic. You’ll still have to work out if you want to stay in shape. And you’ll still have to pay your taxes every year.

Someone aptly said, “Becoming a millionaire won’t make you as happy as you think it will and poverty will not bring as much misery as you think it will.” Put simply, extreme positive and extreme negative events don’t actually influence our long-term levels of happiness nearly as much as we think they would.

So how does this bias help us understand the world of business and investing?

Consider the recent news of Brexit. People who have voted in favour of it are clearly overestimating the positive impact of it and people who have opposed it are overestimating the negative consequences of Brexit. No doubt there will be consequences, both negative and positive, of Brexit but their impact will be much lower than what people have imagined it to be.

Stock market is another place where the short term stock prices movements (including the occasional bear or bull markets) are the result of impact bias. Any news of interest rate cuts, new budget, change in government etc. cause people to overestimate the consequences and their expectations are reflected in form of stock market volatility.

So how do you deal with impact bias?

Firstly, think twice when considering your emotional response to events. Know that we are better able to cope than we sometimes give ourselves credit for. Second, when thinking about how long you will feel about something, include the possibilities of other events changing how you feel now.

Imagine the change, but we forget the things that stay the same. The traffic and the pleasant sunset, the unfair taxes and the surprise gift – are the things that form the fabric of our day to day life.

Charlie Brown (from “Peanuts”) has a great philosophy –

This philosophy would actually work because your mind won’t be able to discount the things that will happen in your more-distant future life.

Here’s an interesting philosophical interpretation from Daniel Gilbert about how impact bias affects our life –

We should have preferences that lead us into one future over another. But when those preferences drive us too hard and too fast because we have overrated the difference between these futures, we are at risk. When our ambition is bounded, it leads us to work joyfully. When our ambition is unbounded, it leads us to lie, to cheat, to steal, to hurt others, to sacrifice things of real value. When our fears are bounded, we’re prudent, we’re cautious, we’re thoughtful. When our fears are unbounded and overblown, we’re reckless, and we’re cowardly.

Celebrating festivals with friends and family, reading a good book, eating a tasty meal – these are all pieces of the good life you can enjoy with or without a leg. Mobility issues represent but a small fraction of the experiences available to you.

Negative events can create task-specific challenges, but the human experience is much bigger and varied than that. There is plenty of room for happiness in a life that may seem very undesirable to your current imagination.

So the lesson I want to leave you with, is that our longings and our worries are both to some degree overblown. And the four words that beautifully capture the essence of impact bias are – This too shall pass.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India