• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Fundamental Attribution Error

April 10, 2016

Most people believe that other people’s behavior is the reflection of their personality. But the truth is that it is more the result of the situation than their disposition.

First impression is the last impression. This is what I have been told repeatedly by so called “communication skill experts.” But the more I have read about psychology, stronger is my belief that it’s a naive generalisation. First impression being the last impression – is mostly incorrect.

Had I gone with my first impressions about some of the strangers I met in my life, I wouldn’t have found my best friends. If you look back in your life and trace the history of your relationships with your best buddies, many of you would tend to agree with me on this.

Whenever we meet a person for the first time we have a natural tendency to attribute his behaviour to his personality. If that stranger’s behaviour is cold and unresponsive, you immediately conclude that the person is either shy or introvert or perhaps arrogant. Whereas someone who seems warm and lively makes you believe that the person is an extrovert.

Sometimes you are right, but often you are falling for what is known as the fundamental attribution error, a phrase coined by Lee Ross, a social psychologist at Stanford University. It is the tendency for people to place an undue emphasis on internal characteristics (personality) to explain someone else’s behavior in a given situation rather than considering the situation’s external factors.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] In other words, we explain behavior based on an individual’s choices and disposition and not the situation. When you don’t know much about a person, when you haven’t had a chance to get to know him or her, you have a tendency to turn the person into a character. That is, we associate bad behaviour with the person and not the situation. Unless, of course, we’re talking about ourselves.

If you have known a person for sometime and familiar with his usually calm behaviour, you would assume that his sudden temper tantrum or outburst is more a result of some specific situation rather than his personality. But when you don’t have the benefit of knowing the personality of a stranger, you almost always end up creating a stereotype out of his recent behaviour. In other words, when you can’t check for consistency, you blame people’s behavior on their personality.

Isn’t it possible that this new guy is also a victim of some special situation and has been provoked by a recent stressful event?

Fundamental attribution error drives us to jump to conclusions. We see the person, and ignore his surroundings, and then cast blame on only the individual.
Why do we do that? Here’s one explanation.

Human mind is always struggling to make sense of the world. That’s how evolution has wired us. We love stories, especially those ones where the characters in the story are responsible for bringing twists in the tale. We are always aware of the minds of others and are always searching for an explanation as to why people are behaving the way they do. So it’s an unpleasant thought to imagine evil could be more the result of a series of terrible events and social pressures than the working of a deviant mind.

Movies and books with a cast of characters make sense to you because in life you tend to turn everyone into a character whose behavior is predictable. But in this way we commit the fundamental attribution error by believing other people’s actions originate from the sort of people they are and have nothing to do with the setting.

It is easy to ignore the power of the situation. It’s hard to grasp just how powerful a situation can be, how much it can influence the behavior of you and people you think you know pretty well.

Philip Zimbardo, a psychologist at Stanford University, did an experiment in 1971 that showcased just how powerful situations can be. Here’s an excerpt from Michael Mauboussin’s book, Think Twice, describing Zimbardo’s experiment.

To start, Zimbardo advertised for volunteers in a two-week-long prison experiment, offering $15 a day. He ran the seventy applicants through psychological and physical tests and ended up with twenty-four healthy, mentally stable, middle-class, male students from the Palo Alto, California, area.

By a flip of a coin, Zimbardo assigned half the volunteers to be prisoners and the rest to be prison guards. One morning, a Palo Alto police car picked up the prisoners, “charging” them with armed robbery and burglary. The guards were assigned to work one of three eight-hour shifts.

With the help of prison consultants, Zimbardo built a prison in the basement of the building that housed Stanford’s psychology department. On arrival at the jail, the guards and warden took steps to humiliate, dehumanize, and oppress the prisoners.

Although Zimbardo randomly designated the roles, the situation clearly shaped behavior. He noticed that the volunteers (and he himself) started to act out their assigned roles. The prisoners tried various tactics to gain advantage over the guards and tried to escape, while the guards schemed to keep the prisoners in check. Concerned that the guards were heaping too much abuse on the prisoners, Zimbardo questioned the situation’s morality and ended the study after only five days.

This experiment is a proof that one shouldn’t underestimate the role of the environment and the influence of the person’s peers, i.e. peer pressure, in defining human behaviour.

“Some of the greatest atrocities known to mankind,” Mauboussin writes, “resulted from putting normal people into bad situations.” That probably explains how Hitler’s Nazi army ended up massacring millions of people. Of course this is not an argument to justify the horrifying acts of Nazi army but it sure helps you understand that not everyone in the Nazi army was inherently an evil and heartless person.

Rolf Dobelli, author of a wonderful book – Art of Thinking Clearly, writes –

The fundamental attribution error is particularly useful for whittling negative events into neat little packages. For example, the ‘blame’ for wars we lazily push on to individuals: the Yugoslav assassin in Sarajevo has World War I on his conscience, and Hitler single-handedly caused World War II. Many swallow these simplifications, even though wars are unforeseeable events whose innumerable dynamics we may never fully understand. Which sounds a little like financial markets and climate issues.

Dexter Filkins, an American journalist known primarily for his coverage of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, wrote –

In war, people find themselves in extraordinary circumstances, and in those circumstances, they act in extraordinary ways. In war, you see people at their very best and their very worst, acting in ways you could never imagine. War is human drama at its most epic and most intense.

Many a times you’d hear stories of acts of heroism by ordinary people. Media usually sensationalizes these kind of stories and push those heroes into limelight. But if you look at such instances from the lens of fundamental attribution error mental model you would see that those acts of heroism were merely the result of an ordinary person being thrust into extraordinary circumstances which required him to rise to heroism. In fiction, there’s an archetype called Reluctant Hero which captures this idea.

Reluctant hero scripts end up getting made into blockbuster movies. Remember officer John McClane from the movie Die Hard?

So how did this strange behavioural quirk found its way into human psyche? Dobelli explains –

We shouldn’t judge those guilty of the fundamental attribution error too harshly. Our preoccupation with other people stems from our evolutionary past: belonging to a group was necessary for survival. Reproduction, defence, and hunting of large animals – all these were impossible tasks for individual to achieve alone. Banishment meant certain death, and those who actively opted for the solitary life – of whom there were surely a few – fared no better and also disappeared from the gene pool. In short, our lives depended on and revolved around others, which explains why we are so obsessed with our fellow humans today. The result of this infatuation is that we spend about 90% of our time thinking about other people, and dedicate just 10% to assessing other factors and contexts.

The attribution bias has another effect: It gives people the illusion of being better at what they do, which explains the findings that 80 to 90% of people think that they are above the average in many things. This translates into overconfidence bias too because people tend to attribute their success to their own personality, hard work and talent without giving due regard to the role situational advantage created by pure luck. You could say it’s the flipside of attribution bias – when considering our own missteps, we tend to blame the environment before we blame ourselves.

By acknowledging our propensity for this bias, we can also improve our relationships. One of the root cause of unhealthy relationships is the human tendency to find intentions behind other people’s mistakes. We fail to realize that many a times those mistakes were a result of an unfavourable environment.

In Investing

Whenever you see a growing and profitable business, fundamental attribution error will lead you to give the credit to the management and the person at helm. No doubt, CEO’s decisions and operating style makes a difference to business, but odds are always high that a business flourishes more because of the favorable economic environment, right timing, market and other macro factors rather than CEO’s talent alone. And same is true when a business fails.

Warren Buffett accurately captured this idea thus –

When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact.

The link between the skill of the CEO and the results of the company are tenuous.”, writes Nassim Taleb in his book Fooled by Randomness, , “By some argument, the boss of the company may be unskilled labour but one who presents the necessary attributes of charisma and the package that makes for good MBA talk. In other words, he may be subjected to the monkey-on-the-typewriter problem. There are so many companies doing all kinds of things that some of them are bound to make ‘the right decision’.

Malcolm Gladwell, in his book Outliers, , has filled in finer details about successful people like Bill Gates. No doubt Gates’ success was a result of his extraordinary talent, extreme hard work and smartness but what can’t be ignored is the series of fortunate circumstances that enabled him to capitalize on his inherited gifts. In 1968, when very few people had heard of the word computer, Gates’ elementary school was probably the only elementary school in the country which had a computer. He also got lucky to have access to University of Washington computer lab during night. So by the time he graduated from high school Bill Gates had benefitted from a string of coincidences that provided more time and exposure to computers and programming than perhaps any other teenager in the world.

Conclusion

The fundamental attribution error leads to labels and assumptions about who people are, but remember first impressions are mostly incorrect. Those impressions will linger until you get to know people and understand their situation and the circumstances in which their behavior is generated.

So to avoid the fundamental attribution error, consider the situation first and the individual second. Evaluate the decisions of others by starting with the situation and then turning to the individuals, not the other way around.

Like all other cognitive biases, this one isn’t easy to avoid. No matter how hard you try, you’ll find yourself falling for attribution bias, even after knowing about it. And every time you fight the natural force of behavioural bias, it’ll severely tax your mental resource. So it’s best to keep your guard on only for high stake situations and decisions.

I would like to close the discussion with this final thought-

There are no extraordinary men… just extraordinary circumstances that ordinary men are forced to deal with. That’s a very interesting insight and rhymes well with Nassim Taleb’s strategy of exposing oneself to positive black swan events. In other words, give luck a chance to find you.

 

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India