There is difference between how you believe you will act under certain circumstances and how you actually act when the time comes. When asked in the cold light of day how we will behave in the future, we turn out to be very bad at imagining how we will act in the heat of the moment.
Remember the mental model called Curse of Knowledge? I had written about in in Latticework series sometime back. If you can’t recall, let me refresh your memory. ‘Curse of knowledge’ says that better-informed people find it extremely difficult to think about problems from the perspective of lesser-informed people. In other words, the more knowledgeable you are about a subject, the more unnatural it becomes for you to communicate that knowledge in a simple and clear way. That’s why effective teaching is such a difficult task. Being knowledgeable about something doesn’t ensure that you can teach it effectively.
Curse of knowledge isn’t just limited to knowledge. It’s equally applicable to emotions. Being in a calm state, it’s not easy to relate to the actions of another person who is in an emotionally high state. That’s the genesis of the idea called empathy, which is the ability to relate to another person whose emotions are reaching a boiling point. However, putting yourself in other’s shoes is easier said than done. It’s a challenge and very few people possess the talent to practice empathy.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Now, in both the cases i.e., curse of knowledge and empathy, there are at least two people involved. There’s essentially a gap of knowledge or emotion which makes it hard for one person to predict the behaviour of another person. But is it possible that a person fails to empathize with himself or herself? How can one not relate to his or her own emotional experience? Well, if the emotional states i.e., cold state (calm and comfortable) and hot state (angry, hungry, frightened etc.) are separated by time, most people underestimate their own future actions. Not convinced yet?
When I am starving (hot state), I don’t doubt that I can finish a large pizza alone. But as I am halfway through my favourite pizza I realise the limit of my stomach. And then I wonder how in the world could I have imagined that a large pizza can be consumed by a single human being in one sitting. In fact, with a full stomach (cold state), I find it difficult to imagine how being hungry feels.
Emotional time travel isn’t our species’ forte, writes James Montier in his wonderful book Little Book of Behavioural Investing, “When asked in the cold light of day how we will behave in the future, we turn out to be very bad at imagining how we will act in the heat of the moment.”
The tendency to underestimate our own future attitudes, preference, or behavior under emotional strain is called an Empathy Gap. Put simply, empathy gap is the difference between how you believe you will act under certain circumstances and how you actually act when the time comes. As with the pizza example, empathy gap is quite common in day to day life.
Empathy gap explains why many people who are trying to get rid of an addiction, even after an initial success, get sucked back into the old habit. For example, several weeks after smokers withdraw from cigarettes, their urges dissipate. As a consequence, they overestimate their capacity to control these urges. Hence, they become less inclined to avoid environments in which smoking is rife. They might even smoke one or two cigarettes because they assume they can curb any subsequent urges. And before they know, they are back into their old routine of chain smoking. (Source)
Cold State Vs Hot State
Famous author and psychologist Dan Ariely and his collaborator George Lowenstein carried out a very unusual study. They wanted to understand the degree to which people can predict how their attitudes will change when they are in an impassioned or hot state. The hot state is a technical term for a mental state which is under the attack of intense emotions like greed, fear, anger, hunger, excitement, jealousy or even sexual arousal.
Most normal human beings experience these hot states hundreds of times during a year. I won’t go into nitty gritties of Ariely’s experiment but it’s worth reading about it in his book Predictably Irrational. The results of the experiment showed that when people are in cold state i.e., calm and comfortable, they think they understand themselves, their own preferences and what actions they are capable of. But as it turned out, they completely underestimated and failed to predict the degree to which passion (hot state) would change them. Ariely writes –
When he [a participant in Ariely’s experiment] is gripped by passion, his emotions may blur the boundary between what is right and what is wrong. In fact, he doesn’t have a clue to how consistently wild he really is, for when he is in one state and tries to predict his behaviour in another state, he gets it wrong…What happens, then, when our irrational self comes alive in an emotional place that we think is familiar but in fact is unfamiliar? If we fail to really understand ourselves, is it possible to somehow predict how we or other will behave when “out of our heads” – when we’re really angry, hungry, frightened, or sexually aroused? Is it possible to do something about it?
As the saying goes, the true character is revealed only in the face of adversity. Adverse situations create high-intensity emotions and can make us do things which we never imagined in our wildest dreams.
So how do you deal with it? No matter what strategy you devise, it would still be a product of the cold state. How can you be so sure that you’d be able to deploy that strategy when you are in the hot state? I am sure you’ve heard of this anger management trick. “When you’re fuming with anger, count to ten before saying anything or doing anything.”, my grandmother used to tell me. But I would conveniently forget about the counting advice when the anger actually arrived. So the best strategy is to avoid such situations which can put you in the hot state.
In Investing
How does this behavioural bias manifest itself in investing? When you first read about value investing and start investing your money in stock market, you think you would simply follow Warren Buffett’s advice – “Be greedy when others are fearful and be fearful when others are greedy.”
So, you wait for a market correction. You think when the market crashes and everyone starts panicking, you would be able to hold your nerves and buy stocks at dirt cheap prices. You can guess what happens next. When a market correction happens, you panic and are not able to muster the courage to buy any stocks. In fact, often you may even sell off some of your stocks, because everyone else is doing so. So, you completely failed to predict your own behaviour under emotional stress. That’s when you realize that Buffett’s advice was simple but not very easy to practice.
What can investors do to prevent themselves from perils of empathy gap? One simple answer is to prepare and pre-commit, writes James Montier –
Investors should learn to follow the seven P’s – Perfect planning and preparation prevent piss poor performance. That is to say, we should do our investment research when we are in a cold, rational state – and when nothing much is happening in the markets—and then pre- commit to following our own analysis and prepared action steps.
Sticking to a process is the best way to overpower the effect of empathy gap in investing. Every value investor fantasizes about the market crash but very few realise that in the face of 40-50 percent market correction, the crowd panic rubs offs very easily and maintaining the discipline to follow a rational process becomes next to impossible. The legendary investor Sir John Templeton was very much aware of this cognitive bias. Here’s an excerpt from the book, The Templeton Way, about how he dealt with it –
There are clear psychological challenges to maintaining a clear head during a sharp sell off. One way [John] used to handle this was to make his buy decisions well before a sell off occurred.
During his years managing the Templeton Funds, he always kept a “wish list” of securities representing companies that he believed were well run but priced too high . . . he often had standing orders with his brokers to purchase those wish list stocks if for some reason the market sold off enough to drag their prices down to levels at which he considered them a bargain.
The idea is to commit to a process and not rely on willpower. Empathy Gap says that hoping to exercise one’s will power to take tough decision while experiencing emotional strain is a poor strategy.
Conclusion
Empathy gap in most simple words is a failure of imagination. It showcases our tendency to underestimate the power of urges and feelings on our own actions.
In his book Ariely writes –
Looking from one emotional state to another is difficult…But to make informed decisions we need to somehow experience and understand the emotional state we will be in at the other side of the experience. Learning how to bridge this gap is essential to making some of the important decisions of our lives. It is unlikely that we would move to a different city without asking friends who live there how they like it, or even choose to see a film without reading some reviews. Isn’t it strange that we invest so little in learning about both sides of ourselves? Why should we reserve this subject of psychology classes when failure to understand it can bring about repeated failures in so many aspects of our lives? We need to explore the two sides of ourselves; we need to understand the cold state and the hot state; we need to see how the gap between the hot and cold states benefits our lives, and where it leads us astray.
If you have been following the Behaviouronomics series for some time, I am sure you must be feeling overwhelmed reading about so many cognitive errors that grip our brains. From the point of view of making sound and rational decisions, these behavioural biases seem like internal demons that we must fight every day. But understand that these biases are what make us human.
It’s a design from nature and trying to get rid of these biases permanently would turn us into cold, unemotional, robot-like creatures. On one hand, these biases make us vulnerable to making wrong decisions but on another hand the very same biases help us enjoy the small moments of our lives. So, the idea is to strike a right balance. The intelligent thing to do is to be extremely cautious while dealing with high stake situations like investing money and then let go when dealing with insignificant matters.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years