In theory there is no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is. That’s because, for human mind, insights do not pass well from one field to another.
Picture the following. You are led into a room with a table. On the table are three items: a box of tacks, a book of matches, and a candle. Your job is to attach the candle to the wall so the wax doesn’t drip onto the table. You can take as much time as you need. How do you proceed?
If you are like over 75 percent of the participants in the now-classic study by a psychologist named Karl Duncker, who created this experiment in 1945, you would likely try one of two routes. You might try to tack the candle onto the wall—but you’ll quickly find that method to be futile. Or you might try to light the candle and use the dripping wax to attach it to the wall. Again, you’d fail. The wax is not strong enough to hold the candle, and your contraption will collapse. What now?
No one sees the solution at once. Some people find it after only a minute or two of thought. Others see it after faltering through several unsuccessful attempts. And many others fail to solve it without some outside help.
Here’s a hint – think outside the box. Isn’t that a cliché? Thinking outside the box is a phrase which is being overused, rather over-abused, by a parade of creativity experts since ages.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
But in this candle problem, for the real solution, you literally have to think outside the box. Which box? The box that holds the tacks.
Here’s the answer. Take the tacks out of the box, tack the box to the wall, and light the candle. Soften the bottom of the candle with a match, so that the wax begins to drip into the box, and place the candle inside the box, on top of the soft pillow of wax. Secure. Go to page 7 to see the visual illustration of the solution.
The candle problem has been used by several psychologists in hundreds of different experiments to research the human behaviour. But I am going to use this idea today to explore a behavioural bias called domain dependence.
So back to the candle problem. Why don’t so many people see that alternative use of box? The majority of people in this situation do not see that something obvious—a box of tacks—might actually be something less obvious: a box and tacks. Scientists call this functional fixedness. We tend to see objects the way they are presented, as serving a specific function that is already assigned.
Our knowledge about the utility of the box gets frozen by its domain i.e. as a container to hold objects. In other words, the box containing the tacks gets us hooked into the domain of “box as a container” realm. We fail to think outside the box. This limitation of our ability to pass the knowledge from one domain to another is called domain dependence. “Domain” being an area or category of activity.
Put simply, insights do not pass well from one field to another. Nassim Taleb, in his book Antifragile, writes –
Some people can understand an idea in one domain, say, medicine, and fail to recognize it in another, say socioeconomic life…humans somehow fail to recognize situations outside the contexts in which they usually learn about them…Imagine someone capable in learning languages, but unable to transfer concepts from one tongue to another, so he would need to relearn “chair” or “love”, or “apple pie” every time he acquires a new language. He would not recognize “house” (English) and “casa” (Spanish) or “beyt” (Semitic). We are all, in a way, handicapped in a similar way, unable to recognize ideas when presented in different contexts. It is as if we were doomed to be fooled by the most possibly superficial part of things, the packaging, the gift-wrapping paper around the object.
In other words, because of the domain dependence of our reactions, our mode of thinking, our intuitions, depend on the context in which the matter is presented. What you master in one area is difficult to transfer to another. Especially daunting is the transfer from academia to real life—from the theoretically sound to the practically possible. The classroom is one do¬main; real life is another. Theory is one domain; practice is another. Yogi Berra famously said, “In theory there is no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is.”
We are simply too accustomed to thinking about things in our familiar ways to see the simple truth staring at us from the other side of the mirror. It gets worse as we gain more expertise in a specific domain. Expert knowledge becomes more and more domain-specific precisely because it’s very deep in one area.
Our brain lacks a central all-purpose computer that starts with logical rules and applies them equally to all possible situa¬tions, writes Nassim Taleb,
Our brain functions by “modules.” An interesting aspect of modularity is that we may use different modules for different instances of the same problem, depending on the framework in which it is presented…One of the attributes of a module is its “encapsulation,” i.e., we cannot interfere with its functioning, as we are not aware of using it.
For example, a chess player isn’t necessarily a good strategist in real life. In fact, most chess players aren’t. The module in their brain, that creates strategies for a game of chess, remains switched off while thinking about real life situations.
Here’s an unsettling insight on domain dependence from Nassim Taleb –
Another expression of domain dependence: ask an U.S. citizen if some semi-governmental agency with a great deal of independence (and no interference from Congress) should control the price of cars, morning newspapers, and Malbec wine, its domain of specialty. They would jump in anger, as it appears to violate every principle the country stands for, and call you a communist post-Soviet mole for almost suggesting such a thing. OK. Then ask him if that same government agency should control foreign exchange. Same reaction, this is not France. Then very gently point out to him that the Federal Reserve Bank of the United States is in the business of controlling and setting the price of another good, another rate, called lending, the interest rate in the economy. The libertarian presidential candidate Ron Paul was called a “crank” for suggesting the abolition of the Federal Reserve, but he would also be called a crank had he suggested the installation of a new governmental agency for controlling and “managing” foreign exchange, mainly the rate of the dollar against the Euro and the Mongolian Tugrit. You can only become intellectually an adult, so to speak, if you break through domain dependence.
In Investing
So how does domain dependence plague the decision making process in the world of business and investing?
Many newly appointed CEOs falter at the most important task i.e., capital allocation because they find themselves unable to transpose their success in other fields to the domain of efficient capital allocation. As Warren Buffett has observed in his 1987 letter to shareholders, very few CEOs come prepared to overcome this domain dependence –
The heads of many companies are not skilled in capital allocation. Their inadequacy is not surprising. Most bosses rise to the top because they have excelled in an area such as marketing, production, engineering, administration, or sometimes, institutional politics. Once they become CEOs, they now must make capital allocation decisions, a critical job that they may have never tackled and that is not easily mastered. To stretch the point, it’s as if the final step for a highly talented musician was not to perform at Carnegie Hall, but instead, to be named Chairman of the Federal Reserve.
Charlie Munger’s favourite quote, “To a man with hammer, everything looks like a nail” is a clever way to describe domain dependence.
Sometimes people make the mistake of blindly applying ideas from one domain to another without really understanding the context and the characteristics of the domains in which they are operating. Prof. Bakshi quotes one such example in his blog –
In the past, and even now, people talk about the Kelly Formula to think about position sizing in equity portfolios. In my view, that’s a flawed idea taken from one domain (the casino where all outcomes are known and follow a bell curve distribution) and applied in another domain (the stock market where all outcomes are not known and often there are huge outlier effects).
Overcoming Domain Dependence
As we get more and more focused on one area of work it gets harder and harder to look outside our own domain for solutions to the problems we are working on. But for innovation and creativity that’s exactly where we need to look – outside of our own domain.
In the candle problem the box and tacks go together as a box of tacks. The box holds the tacks; it does not have another function. To go past that and actually break the object into two component parts, to realize that the box and matches are two different things, takes an imaginative leap.
And imagination is about making connections that are not obvious at first. It requires creativity and knowledge of basic building blocks (mental models) across several disciplines. And that’s why Charlie Munger urges us to learn all the big ideas from major disciplines and create a latticework of those big ideas. This latticework lets you build the mental muscle which cuts through different disciplines and domains while thinking about a problem. You gain interesting vantage points to see a situation or a problem.
Some problems we can understand in their applications but not in textbooks; others we are better at capturing in the textbook than in the practical application.
Conclusion
So the central idea is that if you can’t recognize the forces at play outside of the system in which you learned about them, you are domain dependent.
In simpler words, we put blinders on and fail to recognize familiar patterns in unfamiliar situations. Because of domain dependence our mind doesn’t recognize simple solutions in other places.
One consistent source of innovation has been the transfer of ideas from one field to another. People who could overcome the limitations imposed by domain dependence have not only made a breakthrough in hard problems but many of them have gone ahead to pioneer remarkable discoveries in diverse fields.
Don’t let domain dependence become a handicap for you. Expand your area of learning. And the simplest way to do that is to follow your curiosity.
Isaac Asimov is considered to be the father of scientific fiction of this era. He’s been the inspiration for many of the present generation tech billionaires who grew up reading his books (Asimov wrote more than 400 of them). His imagination was unparalleled. Asimov starts his book “Asimov’s New Guide to Science”, with the words: “Almost in the beginning was curiosity”.
Let your curiosity be the reason for learning. That’s how you’ll go to bed smarter than you woke up.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

