• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Diderot Effect

November 10, 2016

Obtaining a new possession often creates a spiral of consumption which leads you to acquire more new things. As a result, we end up buying things that our previous selves never needed to feel happy or fulfilled.

The manager of a superstore came to know that one of his salesmen sold stuff worth Rs 1 crore to a customer on a single day. He got curious and called the salesman in his office.

“How on earth did you manage to sell so much to a single customer?” asked the manager.

“Well, sir, the guy wanted to buy a smartphone so I showed a mobile that could function as a TV remote also. He liked the idea but he didn’t have a TV at home so I sold him a wide screen TV also. Then I suggested to him that a TV without home theatre would be useless so he bought that also. Of course, a wide screen TV and home theatre wouldn’t be of much use without an HD cable connection so he took that too. Then I explained to him how cool it would be to connect his TV to his home security system. He agreed and bought our latest state of the art home security system. The security system came with free gift vouchers. To use those vouchers I took him to our furniture store and he picked up a premium TV cabinet. Since his living room wasn’t big enough for the TV cabinet, we went down to our real estate department and he ended up booking a new house.”

“Wait a minute! So, you’re telling me that you sold a house to a guy who just came in to buy a smartphone?” the manager asked.

“No sir, he just came in asking directions to the nearest bus stop. I told him that if he had a good smartphone, he would never have to ask directions again,” explained the salesman. “And he’s going to come back next week when he moves into his new house since a living room with just a TV cabinet will look quite awkward. Isn’t it?”

[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Well, the anecdote is a good joke among sales professionals but it contains a cautionary message for common consumers like us. When this salesman’s customer bought that unneeded smartphone, it was the beginning of what’s known as Diderot Effect. As you can see that all his purchases were impulse buying. These reactive purchases have become known as the Diderot Effect.

No doubt the salesman deserves some credit for nudging the poor customer throughout the buying spree, but these days you don’t even need a salesman to do that. In the era of online shopping, the e-commerce recommendations are doing a job thousand times better than any salesman could ever do.

Diderot Effect

The Diderot Effect states that obtaining a new possession often creates a spiral of consumption which leads you to acquire more new things. Thus, we end up buying things that our previous selves never needed to feel happy or fulfilled. This behavioural anomaly is named after 18th-century French philosopher Denis Diderot, who first described the effect in an essay.


He tells how the gift of a beautiful robe sent him down into debt –

Initially pleased with the gift, Diderot came to rue his new garment. Compared to his elegant new dressing gown, the rest of his possessions began to seem tawdry and he became dissatisfied that they did not live up to the elegance and style of his new possession. He replaced his old straw chair, for example, with an armchair covered in Moroccan leather; his old desk was replaced with an expensive new writing table; his formerly beloved prints were replaced with more costly prints, and so on. “I was absolute master of my old dressing gown,” Diderot writes, “but I have become a slave to my new one … Beware of the contamination of sudden wealth. The poor man may take his ease without thinking of appearances, but the rich man is always under a strain.” (Source: Wikipedia)

Notice Diderot’s warning: “Beware of the contamination of sudden wealth.” The expensive robe, which Diderot neither needed nor desired, changed the way he thought about himself. Which soon led to harmful buying patterns.

Disposable Income is a Misnomer

For the previous generation, especially the middle class in India, the whole idea of disposable income didn’t exist at all. Whatever was earned was barely enough to cover the household expenses. But today the consumer class is known by its disposable income. The difference between income and necessary expenses, which ideally should be called as savings, has this new fancy name – disposable income. As if it’s meant to be disposed of like waste. And this has resulted in the culture of hyper-consumerism. Today a large part of consumer spending is driven by things that people don’t need.

In fact, consumerism is the result of a modern myth called economic growth. The word “myth” shouldn’t be interpreted in a negative sense but it’s a fact that every economy in the world collectively imagines that the answer to all the woes of society is economic growth. The relentless pursuit of this capitalist myth, at the individual level, translates to consumerism.

Yuval Harari, in his brilliant book Sapiens (which we have reviewed in this issue), writes –

The modern capitalist economy must constantly increase production if it is to survive, like a shark that must swim or suffocate. Yet it’s not enough just to produce. Somebody must also buy the products, or industrialists and investors alike will go bust. To prevent this catastrophe and to make sure that people will always buy whatever new stuff industry produces, a new kind of ethic appeared: consumerism…Consumerism sees the consumption of ever more products and services as a positive thing. It encourages people to treat themselves, spoil themselves, and even kill themselves slowly by over consumption…Consumerism tells us that in order to be happy we must consume as many products and services as possible. If we feel that something is missing or not quite right, then we probably need to buy a product (a car, new clothes, organic food) or a service (housekeeping, relationship therapy, yoga classes). Every television commercial is another little legend about how consuming some product or service will make life better.

Upgrading lifestyle is never ending process and the upgrade doesn’t move you forward. It’s like trying to climb on an escalator which is going down. That’s why it’s called the hedonic treadmill. There’s no end to it. It’s a trap.

In Business and Investing

Do you know what’s the fastest growing product category for Apple Inc? No, it’s not the iPhones, although they still sell like hot cakes. It’s not the new Apple watch either. iPad? Macbooks? No.

It’s the accessories like chargers, connectors, cables, earphones (you can’t use a normal 3.5 mm earphone in iPhone 7) etc. One intentional design decision that Apple took for its products was to make them incompatible with any other hardware. So, when you buy one Apple product, it’s just the start of ensuing purchases that you’d have to make to keep using it. From a business point of view, it could be a good strategy because you get an ongoing business even after selling the primary product.

And don’t forget the whole business of matching accessories and the constant upgrade cycle of software/hardware. In fact, it’s ironical that most consumer durable products are turning into FMCG i.e., fast moving consumer goods. The shelf life of electronic goods has come down drastically. Most mobile handsets become outdated in less than one year of their launch. And within two years most of the apps stop supporting your old hardware. You have no choice but to upgrade and then the cycle repeats with the new device.

Diderot’s essay was meant to be a warning about consumerism, but, as we have seen above, it can also be a powerful marketing tactic.

In investing, especially in personal finance, Diderot Effect has huge implications. Every rupee that you choose to save and invest, instead of spending, immediately goes to work for your future. Every single paisa in your investment kitty is like a worker toiling hard to ensure a financially secure future for you. Giving in to the temptation of unnecessary consumption is akin to killing your workforce. And thanks to Diderot Effect, getting started on the path of sacrificing your diligent workers can start a chain reaction and soon you find that whole of your army of workers has been massacred by a monster called consumerism.

Fighting the Diderot Effect

The inspiration for this article came from post by James Clear on his blog. He writes –

There will never be a level where you will be done wanting things. There is always something to upgrade to…Our natural tendency is to consume more, not less. Given this tendency, I believe that taking active steps to reduce the flow of unquestioned consumption makes our lives better…Personally, my goal is not to reduce life to the fewest amount of things, but to fill it with the optimal amount of things.

Every habit is initiated by a trigger or cue and Diderot Effect is no exception. For the customer of the salesman we talked about at the start of this post, the smartphone was the trigger. For you, it could be the marketing mailer from popular e-commerce website promoting their Christmas or Diwali sale. Even if there’s no occasion those frequent reminders from Amazon are extremely tempting but they are the triggers which will start the avalanche of Diderot Effect.

Planning to meet your friends? Skip the shopping mall and sit on a park bench.

You don’t have to start from scratch each time you buy something new, suggests Clear, “When you purchase new clothes, look for items that work well with your current wardrobe. When you upgrade to new electronics, get things that play nicely with your current pieces so you can avoid buying new chargers, adapters, or cables.”

Diderot Effect holds the clue to the question, “How should one deal with newly acquired wealth?” In other words, is there an advice for someone who suddenly becomes rich? I recently found an insightful answer to this question in a post written by Nassim Taleb. In his article, Taleb describes how Ed Thorpe, a mathematics professor, author, hedge fund manager, chose to live a stress free and independent life –

Many successful speculators, after their first break in life, get involved in large scale structures, with multiple offices, morning meeting, coffee, corporate intrigues, building more wealth while losing control of their lives. Not Ed. After the separation from his partners and the closing of his firm, he did not start a new mega-fund. He limited his involvement in managing other people’s money. Most other people do reintegrate in the comfort of firms and leverage their reputation by raising monstrous amounts of outside money in order to collect large fees. But such a restraint requires some intuition, some self knowledge. It is vastly less stressful to be independent – and one is never independent when involved in a large structure with powerful clients…True success is exiting some rat race to modulate one’s activities for his peace of mind. Thorp certainly learned a lesson…

You can detect that the man is in control of his life. This explains why he looked younger on the second time I saw him, in 2016, than he did the first time, in 2005. [Emphasis mine]

Conclusion

Diderot Effect severely afflicts those who are overly concerned about their so called “status” in the society. Someone rightly decoded the meaning of status – it’s buying things which you don’t need, to impress people whom you don’t like, using money which you don’t have (debt).

“Let my example teach you a lesson. Poverty has its freedoms; opulence has its obstacles,” warned Diderot in his essay.

My take away from Diderot’s tale is to exercise caution while acquiring things. The primary purpose of wealth is to give you the independence of pursuing what you love doing. If you forget that, a surplus of money, in no time, can pull you down the whirlpool of mindless consumption.

So, beware of the shiny robe. It could come in any form – a sudden promotion at work, an unexpected profit in stock market, a large inheritance cheque, a lottery. Accept it happily but don’t let it become the trigger for financial ruin or loss of mental peace.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India