• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Behaviouronomics: Benjamin Franklin Effect

February 10, 2018

Doing a favour to someone, as per reciprocity principle, is a great persuasion tool. However, can asking for a favour turn a hater into a fan? Yes, it can. And this trick was pioneered by the famous eighteenth-century statesman, Benjamin Franklin.

It was a hot Sunday afternoon and I was experimenting with “diffused mode of thinking.” It’s a learning technique where you read for a while, then keep the book aside and let your mind drift aimlessly. In other words, I was dozing off in my tattered beanbag with a book on my face.

My experiment was interrupted by the doorbell. It was a young salesman.

During those days, I had recently read Robert Cialdini’s book – Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. Cialdini, a professor of Psychology, argued that expert salespeople use many persuasion tricks to convince their customers and the best way to counter is to not give them a chance to talk to you at all.

[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’] So, before that young man could start his sales pitch, I made up a quick excuse and started closing the door. When he saw that, he said, “Sir! Can I please have some water?”

“Sure,” I mumbled.

He gulped the water and thanked me with a smile.

Thirty minutes later, he left after having sold me a dictionary and an encyclopaedia, both of which I didn’t need. Even Cialdini’s advice couldn’t save me. I had no idea that the salesman had used another rare persuasion trick on me. It’s called the Benjamin Franklin Effect.

Benjamin Franklin was a scholar, scientist, entrepreneur, statesman, musician, author, and a publisher. And that’s just a small sample of activities he got himself involved in. If you don’t know much about Ben Franklin, then know this – Charlie Munger considers Franklin as his ideal. Well, that’s a good enough reason to believe that Franklin was a genius.

In his autobiography, Franklin talks about one of his political adversary who was also his biggest critic. However, this man, according to Franklin, was a gentleman of fortune and education. Making this man an ally was a better strategy than tussling with him.

Being an astute politician and a successful businessman, Franklin had mastered all the persuasion skills. So, to turn this hater into a friend, he pulled out his secret persuasion weapon. Franklin hasn’t disclosed this person’s name in the autobiography, so let’s call him Mr. X.

The story goes, Franklin wrote a letter to Mr. X asking if he could borrow a specific book from his library. Mr. X was flattered and sent the book right away. Franklin promptly returned the book a week later with a thank-you note. The next time the legislature convened, Mr. X took the initiative and approached Franklin. It was the first time they spoke to each other in person. Franklin writes, “the man ever after manifested a readiness to serve me on all occasions, so that we became great friends, and our friendship continued to his death.”

This trick later came to be known as the Benjamin Franklin Effect. Let’s try to unpack this persuasion weapon and see how it works.

If you go by the principle of reciprocity, the Benjamin Franklin Effect seems counterintuitive. Reciprocity principle says that we try to repay, in kind, what another person has provided us. We are obligated (not by some external force but an internal urge) to the future repayment of favours, gifts, invitations, and the like. Cialdini has done extensive research Reciprocity Bias. According to him – the rule for reciprocation is one of the most potent weapons of influence around us.

But in Mr. X’s story, Ben didn’t extend the favour. Instead, he demanded it. So, what’s going on there?

We would need to investigate through the lens of a different mental model called Cognitive Dissonance.

Sometimes we can’t find a logical, moral, or socially acceptable explanation for our actions. “In those moments, we often wonder, “Why did I do that?” It’s a discomforting mental state, isn’t it? In Psychology circles, it’s known as Cognitive Dissonance.

We had written about it earlier. Here’s a quick recap.

Behavioural scientists define cognitive dissonance as the feeling of mental discomfort or tension produced by the combined presence of two thoughts, ideas, beliefs, attitudes, or opinions that are psychologically inconsistent. The greater the discomfort, the greater the desire to reduce the dissonance of the two cognitive elements. Dissonance theory suggests that if individuals act in ways that contradict their beliefs, then they typically will change their beliefs to align with their actions.

Notice the last sentence. To resolve cognitive dissonance, our mind realigns the belief with the action. For example, when a person finds himself doing something which goes against his current beliefs (the action could have resulted because of situational imperative), then the person would modify his beliefs to rationalize his action.

Like all other behavioural biases, cognitive dissonance is invisible to the person experiencing it. All the attempts by the mind to resolve the cognitive dissonance are subconscious.

Cognitive dissonance is a common phenomenon among cigarette smokers. They rationalize their smoking habit with crazy sounding justifications. In their mind, those justifications look perfectly rational but to outside observers, it all sounds nonsensical.

Scott Adams, in his book Win Bigly, writes –

The first “tell” for cognitive dissonance is the absurdity of the rationalization. For example, you might be friends with a cigarette smoker who claims smoking won’t hurt him because he knows someone who smoked a pack a day and lived to be a hundred years old. The person who makes that sort of argument is simply addicted to smoking but doesn’t like to think of himself as being unwise or unable to quit. That would violate the person’s self-image. To keep his self-image intact, the smoker generates a personal illusion in which he is one of the few people in the world who are immune to lung cancer and somehow know it.

So, Benjamin Franklin put Mr. X in a situation that created cognitive dissonance. Benjamin Franklin didn’t ask for an ordinary favour. He crafted his request keeping two things in mind.

First, it was a very specific type of favour. Mr. X was aware of Franklin’s reputation as someone with a great literary taste. Second, the book which Franklin wanted to borrow was, according to him, a “very scarce and curious book.” Since, Mr. X was the only one in possession of that rare book (and Franklin, of course, knew it), he couldn’t refuse.

In this situation, by giving in to Ben’s request, Mr. X found himself doing an unintended positive act for his enemy. Now, human beings don’t normally do favour to their enemies. That’s just how mother nature has wired our brains. Doing a favour to someone means he’s a friend.

Imagine Mr. X’s mental state. He must have been torn between two competing believes – Do I hate Ben or is he my friend?

The theory of cognitive dissonance says that Mr. X ended up changing his belief. He must have unconsciously rationalized that Franklin must be a nice fellow, after all.

David McRaney, in his book You Are Now Less Dumb, writes –

That’s the cycle of cognitive dissonance; a painful confusion about who you are gets resolved by seeing the world in a more satisfying way.

As Festinger said, you make “your view of the world fit with how you feel or what you’ve done.” When you feel anxiety over your actions, you will seek to lower the anxiety by creating a fantasy world in which your anxiety can’t exist, and then you come to believe the fantasy is reality, just as Benjamin Franklin’s rival did. He couldn’t possibly have lent a rare book to a guy he didn’t like, so he must actually like him. Problem solved.

Franklin, in his autobiography, summed it up artfully. He wrote –

This is another instance of the truth of an old maxim I had learned, which says, ‘He that has once done you a kindness will be more ready to do you another, than he whom you yourself have obliged.’ And it shows how much more profitable it is prudently to remove, than to resent, return, and continue inimical proceedings.

Although, Franklin used this persuasion trick for his own benefit, in hindsight it turned out to be harmless. Franklin spent his life doing good things. Had he been someone like Hitler, Benjamin Franklin effect would have gone down in history as an evil manipulation tactic.

So, what can an investor learn from this?

As investors, we are participants in an industry that’s notorious for being the breeding ground for situations that are designed to manipulate people into doing things which can sabotage their own long-term financial future.

Majority of the finance professional have their incentives misaligned with that of their clients. To add insult to injury, these professionals have the advantage of being trained in all sorts of persuasion skills.

Next time when you interact with a trained finance expert who is looking to sell you something, look for the signs of persuasion principles.

The six principles that Cialdini has described in his book – Reciprocity, Commitment and Consistency, Social Proof, Liking, Authority, and Scarcity – are regularly deployed by persuasion experts.

Benjamin Franklin’s is an unusual trick and perhaps not known to many. However, I have seen it being used against me so many times that I am convinced that when a salesman asks for water, the chances are that he’s not thirsty.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Behaviouronomics

Handcrafted with in India