• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Special Report: A Few Thoughts on Reading and Retaining

September 30, 2018

A Safal Niveshak reader (let’s call him Mr. V) recently asked me a question. I am paraphrasing his words for brevity.

Hi Anshul,

In last few years, I have read more than 50 books and 300 blog posts on investing. I am very structured in my reading process. I don’t rush while reading. I diligently take notes. Plus, I record everything I read. Please see the excel that I attached. [He had kept a meticulous record of every book and blog post along with dates and remarks for each]

While I can comfortably recall the contents of a book, it’s not the same with blogs and articles. Looking back I was surprised that I don’t remember the contents of many of the older read blogs. I don’t even faintly remember. Hasn’t all the effort in reading these 300 articles gone waste if I am not able to use such readings when needed? [show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

So here are my questions for you —

What changes should I bring in my reading habits, i.e, in terms of how a blog is read, what blog do I read, the number of blogs I should read in a day, etc., to enable me to successfully recall the gist (or take-aways) from my reads to implement in a situation occurring in distant future?

Would there be a simpler (not easier) method to record the knowledge gained from such blog reading? Considering the reading universe, there could be easily a few thousand blogs. This volume is a challenge to record knowledge, isn’t it?

I was really impressed by this man’s diligence in logging everything he has read and preparing comprehensive notes. It reminded me how I used to keep a running list of books (read, reading, to-read) few years back. Although my list was nothing compared to what Mr. V has done.

It took me sometime to frame my answer. However, even after I had replied him, I didn’t stop puzzling over his question and kept adding to my answer. Here’s what I’ve come up so far.

Hi V,

Your first concern, as I understand, is that you’re not able to readily recall what you’ve read in hundreds of blog posts. And the recall is much better in case of books. Right?

Try this — open any of the books that you’ve read and browse through the table of contents. Chances are that you won’t be able to recall the insights chapter-wise. However, you do remember the big ideas discussed in the book, correct?

A typical non-fiction book is anywhere between 50,000 and 100,000 words. Now, most books, but not all, have just one big idea which wouldn’t take more than a dozen pages to communicate. Nevertheless, the author makes the reader go through hundreds of pages. That would mean repeating the central idea hundreds of times — from multiple angles. The author is literally making you wrestle with his insights.

Imagine you were made to read through a 2000-word blog post 50 times (that’s 100,000 words) and every re-read was slightly different, i.e., in terms of words, sentences, examples etc., but it was the same idea being talked about. I bet that you’d able to recall the central idea of that blog even after one year.

So that’s my hypothesis on why you feel that retention is better for books.

Now, coming to your next question. How to increase retention for blog posts? A simple answer based on the logic I gave above, is that you should read every blog post 50 times for a better retention. However, that’s not practical. So I wouldn’t recommend that.

Before we address the question of retention, let’s first answer a more important question. Do you want to retain everything you read? Put another way, is everything you read worth retaining?

In my case, I don’t want to retain everything I read.

A good book gets better at the second reading, write famous author Nassim Taleb, “A great book at the third. Any book not worth rereading isn’t worth reading.”

I take the liberty to extend Taleb’s observation for blogs also. Most blog posts don’t deserve a second reading. And this is not a judgement on the objective quality of any book or blog article. The value derived from a piece of writing is product of what the author has to offer and what the reader knows.

Popular bloggers have a large audience with a wide range of tastes and knowledge. To you and I, a post may seem a rehash of the old ideas but it would be refreshingly new for a young reader who has just started on the path of gaining worldly wisdom.

Let’s think about this using the mental model of Incentive Caused Bias, then you might see what I see. So, what are the incentives of a blogger?

Building an audience is the primary goal for most writers/bloggers. And consistent writing is the most important factor in achieving that goal. Moreover, in writing, quality is a byproduct of quantity. For a writer, it’s very tough to judge beforehand if he has a winning insight to blog about. Writing as it turns out is as much about discovering as creating.

A two-way process, writing is. It is not just an act of communicating what you know but also a process of figuring out ideas that are worth talking about. When I am getting the words out on the page, the new ideas jump out from nowhere.

As a blogger, I would honestly admit that not everything I write is of the quality I myself would want to read. And there’s is no shame in that because, as I explained above, it’s an inseparable part of the writing process.

Of course, my observation doesn’t apply to all the bloggers. For example, every single blog post by Morgan Housel is worth reading ten times. But there aren’t many like him. Similarly, Prof. Bakshi doesn’t write blog posts because he is actively looking to build an audience. But those examples are few and far between.

So you’d have to be brutally selective. Just because you like a writer doesn’t mean you need to read everything written by him. And how do you know which posts to skip? Well, you’ll have to skim through it to figure out if the post is worth re-reading deeply. If it’s not, forget about it.

Now, this may not be easy initially because you might feel that every blog post has something important to offer. But that’s how the FOMO bias (fear of missing out) makes a backdoor entry.

The more you read the better you become in filtering out what you should read next. Raise your bar. Gradually.

As a reader, my biggest enemy has been (and continues to be) the sunk cost fallacy. After 50 pages, it’s maddeningly hard to fight the urge to finish the book even if I am not enjoying the book anymore. For a few years, even I kept a log (although not as detailed as yours) of the books I was reading. And seeing an unfinished book in that list would prick me in the eye. So I stopped that practice. Instead, I started keeping a record of the ideas I learned.

The point is to become really skillful at selecting what to read without being affected by the Authority Bias. So, let me say it again. Not everything you read is worth retaining. Even if a book is good, you may not be ready for it. So toss it aside. Pick up the next book. Ditto for the blogs.

So let’s come back to the original question. How to retain what you read?

As I said, the straightforward answer could be to read the same thing again and again as it happens in a book. But that’s an inefficient strategy. As you’ve already figured, the best way to retain an insight is to implement it. But that’s a catch-22 situation. How can we implement something which we don’t remember and remembering well requires implementation.

Let’s peel one more layer. Why does implementation of an idea solidify it in our memory? The act of implementing forces your brain to wrestle with the idea. And there lies the trick. Wrestling with the idea.

So how do you wrestle with the idea without implementing it? Teach it. Teaching is the best hack for learning.

So start a blog. Start writing. Start teaching.

A few months back I read a book The Drunkard’s Walk. It profiles many philosophers and thinkers of the past few centuries. These stalwarts made ground breaking discoveries in the field of mathematics, probability, and statistics. I was surprised to discover that these people had varied interests. They were not limited by categorization of knowledge like biology, physics, chemistry, literature, etc. They were experts in many disciplines. In fact, I suspect that in their minds they didn’t segregate the bodies of knowledge in different compartments. And perhaps that was the secret sauce of their creativity. They were able to cross-pollinate ideas between different jurisdictions. Connecting the dots, finding relation between seemingly unrelated ideas — that was their superpower.

So based on that insight and an advice from Charlie Munger, the second suggestion that I can give you for better retention is this.

If the new knowledge doesn’t hang onto a bigger framework of interconnected ideas (the latticework), it’s quickly forgotten.

Whenever I find a new insight, I think hard and try to mentally reach out for related ideas. I may end up making some unfruitful connections leading to dead ends. But the process of reaching is more important than the end result. It tattoos the ideas deeper into your brain and increases the odds that they will strike you at the time when you need them.

I hope this helps.

Regards,
Anshul
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members

 

  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe

[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Special Report

Handcrafted with in India