• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Super Investor: Philip Fisher on Four Dimensions of Investing – Part 3/4

March 30, 2017

This is the third leg of the “Four Dimensions of Investing” series. The first two were discussed as part of Value Investing Almanac’s special reports (previous issues). It’s recommended that you read the first two parts before reading this.

Philip Fisher’s investment classic Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits ranks pretty close to Benjamin Graham’s The Intelligent Investor and for many years, it has been part of the curriculum in the investment class at the Stanford Graduate School of Business. Fisher is also known for his scuttlebutt approach. In the book’s introduction, Kenneth Fisher, Philip Fisher’s son, describes the Scuttlebutt approach thus –

Scuttlebutt means avoiding malarkey mills and seeking information from competitors, customers, and suppliers, all of whom have a vested interest in the target company, and few of whom have any reason to see the firm unrealistically. It means talking to the sales representatives of a company’s competitors, who inherently have a basis to see the target company negatively but typically don’t if the target is great. It means talking to the research people and management people of competitors as well. If all those folks see reality and strength in the target’s operations and respect it and even fear it, well, simply said, it isn’t Enron. You can count on it.

Today we’re going to look at the third dimension of conservative investing that Fisher has discussed in this lesser known book – Conservative Investors Sleep Well – about which Kenneth writes, “It is simply the best treatise I know on how to buy and hold growth stocks without taking much risk.

<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

The third dimension is about investing in those companies which have long term prospects of creating wealth by virtue of some structural advantages in the business.

Before we get into that, it’s important to understand the unintended consequences of profitability. Everyone wants to invest in a company which shows above average profitability especially those companies that have found the secret sauce of unusual profits and are yet to be noticed by Mr. Market. Such companies are, according to Fisher, like an open jar of honey.

Honey Jar of Profitability

Imagine a castle which houses a thriving kingdom. The news of the kingdom’s prosperity is soon going to grab the attention of the invaders. What should the king do to ward off the invaders? Fisher writes –

…obtaining well-above-average profit margins or a high return on assets is so desirable that, whenever a company accomplishes this goal for any significant period of time, it is bound to be faced with a host of potential competitors. If the potential competitors actually enter the field, they will cut into markets the established company now has. Normally, when potential competition becomes actual competition the ensuing struggle for sales results in anything from a minor to a major reduction in the high profit margin that had theretofore existed. High profit margins may be compared to an open jar of honey owned by the prospering company. The honey will inevitably attract a swarm of hungry insects bent on devouring it.

In ancient times, a king used to protect his castle by digging a deep ditch around the castle and filling it water. This was called a ‘moat’. Warren Buffett uses moat as a metaphor to describe the competitive advantage that certain businesses have that makes it harder for the swarm of competitors to eat into the profitability of these businesses. Like a real moat around a castle, the protection comes not from the king’s (management) ability to drive away the invaders but from the structural feature of the castle i.e. the water filled ditch around it.

So, certain businesses have such design, a moat, that they have high odds of remaining unusually profitable for long periods of time, in spite of the competition. People factor, the second dimension of investing that we discussed in the previous part of this series, contributes very less to the profitability of such businesses i.e., the management doesn’t need to be extraordinarily talented for the business to remain profitable. Fisher writes –

The third dimension deals with something quite different: the degree to which there does or does not exist within the nature of the business itself certain inherent characteristics that make possible an above-average profitability for as long as can be foreseen into the future.

Economies of Scale

The first among those structural advantages is economies of scale. To understand the idea of economies of scale, one needs to remember the difference between fixed and variable costs. A manufacturing company or a traditional retail operation are businesses that have large fixed costs and relatively smaller variable costs. These businesses benefit immensely from economies of scale because they can spread their fixed cost on a large volume of production i.e., smaller per unit fixed cost.

How do you find companies with economies of scale? Look for industry leaders. Fisher suggests –

…when a company clearly becomes the leader in its field, not just in dollar volume but in profitability, it seldom gets displaced from this position as long as its management remains highly competent…There is a school of investment thinking that advocates acquiring shares in the number-two or -three company in a field because “these can go up to number one, whereas the leader is already there and might slip.” There are some industries where the largest company does not have a clear leadership position; but, where it does, we emphatically do not agree with this viewpoint.

However, it’s important to understand that it’s the relative size, not absolute size, that turns economies of scale into a structural advantage. Pat Dorsey, in his wonderful book, , The Little Book That Builds Wealth, argues –

When you’re thinking about cost advantages that stem from scale, remember one thing: The absolute size of a company matters much less than its size relative to rivals. Two massive firms that dominate an industry – for example – Boeing and Airbus – are unlikely to have meaningful scale-based cost advantages relative to each other…even a company that is pretty small in absolute terms can have quite a solid moat if it is much larger than its competition.

In other words, being a big fish in a small pond is much better than being a bigger fish in a bigger pond.

So how does a company create economies of scale? Fisher writes –

..getting there first with a new product or service that meets worthwhile demand and backing this up with good enough marketing, servicing, product improvement, and, at times, advertising to keep existing customers happy and coming back for more. This frequently established an atmosphere in which new customers will turn to the leader largely because that leader has established such a reputation for performance (or sound value) that no one is likely to criticize the buyer adversely for making this particular selection.

A Caveat on Idiot Proof Business

Almost all legendary value investors have, in one way or another, acknowledged the merits of investing in businesses that have strong moats.

Warren Buffett added another interesting twist when he said –

“When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact.”

Notice how intelligently Buffett inverted the problem. Instead of looking for the moat, he suggests one should avoid a business which has no moat, irrespective of how brilliant the management is. Put simply, some businesses are structurally so poor that despite a brilliant manager at the helm the profits are short lived.

Peter Lynch, the legendary fund manager, expressed this idea succinctly when he said –

Invest in a company that any idiot can run because sooner or later an idiot will run it.

In short, look for ‘idiot proof’ businesses. But Lynch’s statement must be read in proper context. The lesson is not to completely ignore the idiot running the business. The focus should still be to find such strong businesses that are well managed, i.e., being run by a reasonably smart and honest manager. But when the ‘idiot’ enters the scene, the business should be resilient enough to give the conservative investor enough time to realize (and exit) that the manager is no longer an able operator.

In other words, when a structurally poor business run by a brilliant manager is suddenly transferred to a bad manager, the decline in profits is relatively sudden and doesn’t leave much time for a conservative investor to exit the scene on time.

Conclusion

To summarize the third dimension of conservative investing Fisher writes –

It is necessary not just to have the quality of personnel discussed in the second dimension but to have had that personnel (or their predecessors) steer the company into areas of activity where there are inherent reasons within the economics of the particular business so that above-average profitability is not a short-term matter. Put simply, the question to ask in regard to this third dimension is: ‘What can the particular company do that others would not be able to do about as well?’

“If the answer is almost nothing, so that, as the business gets more prosperous, others can rush in to share in the company’s prosperity on about equal terms, the evidence is conclusive that while the company’s prosperity on about equal terms, the evidence is conclusive that while the company’s stock may be cheap, the investment fails to qualify as to this third dimension.

Structural soundness, i.e., an economic moat, can provide a natural shield against competition for companies, helping them earn above-average profits for a long time, and therefore making them ideal investment candidate for conservative investors.

In the final part of this series, we’ll look at the fourth dimension which pertains to the price that is paid for a business.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Special Report

Handcrafted with in India