If there is one legendary investor who not just beat the market but destroyed it, it is Peter Lynch. Lynch ran Fidelity’s Magellan Fund in the US for 13 years, from 1977 to 1990. During this period, he beat the US stock market index S&P 500 in 11 years. His average annual return during this period stood at a mind-boggling 29%. It means that every US$ 1 invested in his fund in 1977 grew to more than US$ 27 by 1990.
Lynch was not only a great investor, he had a wonderful way of getting across the secrets of his success in everyday language, exemplified by this warning of the perils of putting money into businesses that you don’t understand. His most famous investment principle is simply – Invest in what you know.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Fortunately for us, Lynch has laid down his secrets in two great books that every investor must own and read several times – – One Up on Wall Street, and Beating the Street. In fact, apart from Benjamin Graham’s The Intelligent Investorthere is no better book to get started for beginners than Peter Lynch’s One Up.
There’s something else about Peter Lynch which stands him apart from many other successful investors. Where most legendary value investors have compounded their investors’ money for several decades, Lynch decided to hang his boots very early. At the age of 46, he departed from the money management scene to spend more time with his family. But in spite of his relatively shorter career, the investing principles that he espoused remain timeless.
So here are few lessons from this super-investor.
The Crayon Test
Peter Lynch fondly calls his investing insights as Peter’s principles. One such principle states – “Never invest in any idea you can’t illustrate with a crayon.” Lynch writes…
A class of seventh graders at an American primary school did a social studies project on stocks, the kids had to do their own research and dig up stocks for a paper portfolio. They sent their picks to Lynch, who later invited them to a pizza dinner at the Fidelity executive dining room, illustrating their portfolio with little drawings representing each stock. Lynch just loved this because it illustrates the principle that you should only invest in what you understand, the kids’ portfolio consisted of toy manufacturers, makers of baseball swap cards, clothing manufacturers and outlets, Playboy Enterprises (a couple of boys chose that one), Coke, and other stocks of that ilk.
With a portfolio notably lacking in glamorous technology ventures and entrepreneurial risk taking they went for solid stocks with excellent profits, their portfolio returned 69.6% against a background of a 26.08% gain in the S&P500 in 1990/91.
Now, this is a great idea if you are searching for some great businesses to invest in for the long run. Of course, you must buy such businesses only after you research the ideas well, and only when they are available at reasonable prices as compared to the growth they promise.
Don’t Diworsify
Having adequate diversification is a must for every investor. However, after a point, research pegs that number at 30, diversification doesn’t reduce the risk. Lynch recommends…
Owning stocks is like having children—don’t get involved with more than you can handle. The part-time stock picker probably has time to follow 8-12 companies.
The time in any given day, week etc. is a zero sum game. If you work at a day job and you have a life, only so much time is left to follow stocks and bonds. It is better to be a mile deep in understanding 8-12 companies than an inch deep on many more.
And there is a lesson here for business executives too. Most diversifications (acquisitions of companies in the same area or a different one altogether) are done to satisfy the egos of promoters, and not for real business reasons. And most of the diversifications end up as diworseifications. So, watch out for companies that are blazing guns in this space.
Insider Buying
Quoting the example of Exxon, Lynch writes…
When a company buys back shares that once paid a dividend and borrows the money to do it, it enjoys a double advantage. The interest on the load in tax-deductible, and the company is reducing its outlay for dividend checks, which it had to pay in after-tax dollars. A few years ago, Exxon’s stock was so depressed that it was yielding 8-9 percent. At the time, Exxon was able to borrow money at 8-9 percent to buy back millions of these dividend-paying shares Since the interest on the loan was tax-deductible, Exxon was really paying only about 5 percent to save 8-9 percent on dividends. This simple maneuver increased the company’s earnings without its having to refine an extra drop of oil.
I was impressed by the fact that General Hosts’ stock price had fallen far below the price at which the company had recently bought back shares. When you or I can guy part of a company for less than the company itself has paid, it’s a deal worth examining. It’s also a good sign when the “insiders,” executives and so forth, have paid more than the current price. Insiders are hardly infallible (those at numerous Texas and New England banks were madly acquiring more shares all the way down) but there are smart people in business who often know what they’re doing and aren’t inclined to squander money on a fool’s errand.
Great Companies in Lousy Industries
Having a fierce competition in an industry is a good thing for consumer but not so good for investors. As investors, you want a monopoly so that the leader in the industry can remain profitable and keep growing the earnings as the industry expands. Lynch argues …
I am always on the lookout for great companies in lousy industries. A great industry that’s growing fast, such as computers or medical technology, attracts too much attention and too many competitors. When an industry gets too popular, nobody makes money there anymore.
As a place to invest, I’ll take a lousy industry over a great industry anytime. In a lousy industry, one that’s growing slowly if, at all, the weak dropout and the survivors get a bigger share of the market. A company that can capture an ever-increasing share of a stagnant market is a lot better off than one that has to struggle to protect a dwindling share of an unexciting market.The great companies in lousy industries share certain characteristics. They are low-cost operators, and penny-pinchers in the executive suite. They avoid going to debt. They reject the corporate caste system that creates white-collar Brahmins and blue-collar untouchables. Their workers are well paid and have a stake in the company’s future. They find niches, parts of the market that bigger companies have overlooked. They grow fast – faster than many companies in the fashionable fast-growth industries.
Stay Away from Flashy Annual Reports
Another of Peter’s Principle says, “All else being equal, invest in the company with the fewest colour photographs in the annual report.”
The best example of this Berkshire Hathaway’s annual reports which Warren Buffett himself handcrafts without using any pictures. Buffett’s reports paint a picture with simple words in such way that even a new investor can understand Berkshire’s business easily.
Want to know what does a flashy annual report look like? Read this.
Avoid Weekend Thinking
but the bestselling item on financial media’s offerings. During the weekend, when the markets are closed, most investors bury their nose in news and world events, trying to predict how those events will affect the markets on Monday morning. Peter Lynch calls that weekend thinking. He warns …
There is always something to worry about. Avoid weekend thinking and ignore the latest dire predictions of the newscasters. Sell a stock because the company’s fundamentals deteriorate, not because the sky is falling.
Nobody can predict interest rates, the future direction of the economy, or the stock market. Dismiss all such forecasts and concentrate on what’s happening to the companies in which you’ve invested.
Tip Vs Tipper
Separate all stock tips from the tipper, even if the tipper is very smart, very rich and his or her last tip went up.
Even if I love my fund manager for his stellar track record in managing my money, toeing all his stock ideas without doing my own research would be fraught with extreme risks. The stock he is recommending on CNBC might form just 0.001% of his total portfolio. I might be so enamoured by his story on the stock, that I may buy it in bulk and it forms around 10% of my small portfolio. Now when this stock crashes, the fund manager would appear smart for taking a very small risk with it. I might lose my shirt.
For many new investors, stock research has become equivalent to following renowned investors on Twitter and blindly coat tailing their trades. Nothing can be riskier than this.
The lesson is to always do an independent research on a stock before you even think of buying it.
Product Vs. Company
One of the risks of following Peter Lynch’s approach is that an investor can get too influenced by a company’s product and forget that the product may be just a small part of company’s business.
You might say, “I love Maggi! In fact, everyone loves Maggi. So Nestle must be a very good stock!”
But what if Maggi is just 1% of Nestle’s total sales, and the products that contribute the remaining 99% aren’t that great?
Does Nestle still sound like a great investment just based on one great product that contributes just 1% of its sales?
Companies selling products or services that everyone loves or is talking about is worthy of “considering” as a potential investment. But, as an investor, the greater task for you is to know how much of that great product or service means to the company. If it does not contribute meaningfully to the company’s sales and profits, it can’t be the core reason for buying that stock.
So, don’t forget to consider the size of a company if you expect it to profit from a specific product.
Conclusion
Lynch helps you discover that he is a normal guy (like you and me) who thinks rationally, believes in doing his own independent research on companies, asks plenty of questions, and gets caught off guard by the market at times, just like anyone else.
“I stumble on to the big winners in extracurricular situations,” he said. “Apple computers – my kids had one at home and then the systems manager bought several for the office. Dunkin’ Donuts – I loved the coffee.”
Peter Lynch got many of his best ideas at home or when wandering around shopping malls, rather than by poring over company accounts. And this is something that any small investor can do and should do to generate a superior investment returns over a long term.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years