In 1969, Warren Buffett decided to close down his 100-member investment partnership and offered to return the money to the investors. However, for those who wanted to stay invested in stock market, Buffett advised them to take their cash to Sequoia Fund run by Bill Ruane.
Warren Buffett recognizes Ruane as one of the Superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville. He wrote, “When I wound up the Buffett Partnership, I asked Bill Ruane if he would set up a fund to handle all of our partners, so he set up the Sequoia Fund…Bill was the only person I recommended to my partners.”
Bill Ruane and Buffett knew each other from the time they studied under Benjamin Graham at Columbia University. Ruane was also Buffett’s stock broker in the 1960s.
Ruane is one of his generation’s most successful money managers. Sequoia fund has recorded one of the best long-term track records on Wall Street since its inception. In the 45-year period from its inception in 1970 to 2015, the fund earned an annualized return of 14.7% versus the S&P 500’s annualized return of 10.9%. It’s one of the very few funds which has managed to outperform the S&P 500 for four decades.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
As Ruane’s fund grew in size he realized that bigger it became the harder it was to achieve better performance. So he closed his fund for new investors in 1982. In an industry where everyone is in a race to gather more assets under management, how many fund managers have the courage to do something so unconventional? Buffett wasn’t wrong when he said, “I consider Bill to be an exceptionally high-probability decision on character and a high-probability one on investment performance.”
Ruane espoused the same value investing techniques and plain speaking as his friend Warren Buffett.
There are great many things we can learn from the life and experience of Ruane. Here are just six of them.
1. Do the Right Thing
Because of Sequoia’s outstanding performance, the money started flowing in real fast which made Ruane uncomfortable. As the amount of investments under the management of Ruane grew, he felt the need to protect the rate of return for his existing investors. It’s a known fact that the size of the portfolio is a drag on performance. The bigger the fund the harder it is to outperform.
“Staying small is simply good business. It wouldn’t be fair to our customers if we had to spread our ideas too thin.” explained Ruane. “There aren’t that many great companies.”
The act of making Sequoia a closed fund was as bold as Buffett’s decision to liquidate his partnership in 1969.
When Sequoia closed its doors for new investors, some shrewd financial advisers started purchasing shares directly from people who had gotten in during the open days. The demand for Sequoia shares created a thriving underground market for it. At one time a Sequoia share was even listed for US$ 1,000 on eBay so investors who wanted to acquire one share could join the fund, then qualify to invest additional money.
Experts can’t think of any other closed fund that developed that kind of black market. But this is what happens when you decide to do the right thing. Ruane’s strength was not just his investment returns, but also a knack for doing the right things when no one else seemed to care. It was the picture of honest communication with shareholders, first class governance and setting an example of low-cost, low-turnover investing.
2. Maintain A Focused Portfolio
Ruane at Sequoia ran a highly focused portfolio. At most times the top five holdings represented two-thirds of total assets, and the fund usually owned just 15 companies in all. In fact, at one time up to 30 percent of Sequoia fund was composed of Berkshire’s stock. What’s even more remarkable is that fact that Ruane’s fund (as of 1998) owned a whopping 3 percent of Berkshire.
I have more success managing a portfolio of 10 stocks that I know in depth than one that contains 100 stocks in which I only have a surface knowledge,” said Ruane. Concentration puts your money behind your best ideas and allows you to more intensively follow the company.
This reminds me of Peter Lynch’s advice about diversification. He said, “Owning stocks is like having children. Don’t get involved with more than you can handle.
Many studies have shown that 25-30 stocks are a good number to have in a diversified portfolio. Adding more than that doesn’t decrease the risk but does dilute the returns a lot. So someone with 50 stocks in his/her portfolio is in effect ‘diworsifying’, as Lynch would call it, his or her portfolio.
Diversification is a mechanism to account for any possible errors in judging the quality of the business. But over-diversification states that the investor has very little confidence in his analysis, in which case he shouldn’t be investing in the equities directly and consider investing through mutual funds.
3. Minimize Mistakes
At the 2005 Sequoia Fund shareholders’ meeting, Ruane offered two rules of investing, borrowed from his friend Warren Buffett: Rule No. 1: Don’t lose money. Rule No. 2: Don’t forget rule number one. In essence, Ruane’s rule was to be extremely risk averse. In a letter to Fortune magazine in 1988, Ruane said he was neither bear nor bull. “I have always thought of myself as a meek little lamb who is afraid of being fleeced,” he wrote.
4. Buy Cash Generators
Cash earnings are more important than reported earnings.
Cash earnings are those earnings which are truly available for further capital allocation like investment in additional earning assets, or for returning back to stockholders.
A business may earn a lot but if it’s required to plough that money back into business for continued operation, then it’s like running on treadmill. Even if you run faster, you don’t go anywhere. A business which is forced to reinvest the profits just to maintain plant and equipment and present earning power, is a poor candidate for long term investment. The reported earnings of many such companies overstate their true cash earnings significantly.
Amazon is a great example of one such business which has negative reported earnings but generates tons of cash, with negative working capital. It funds its entire balance sheet from the interest free debt it receives from its vendors and customers.
It pays to find those companies which have the ability to generate a large portion of their earnings in cash.
5. Do Your Own Research
Ruane believed in Buffett’s famous advice, “Be fearful when others are greedy and be greedy when others are fearful.”
That’s a great contrarian advice. But to follow it one needs to have a confidence in his or her own research. Doing your own research gives you the courage to occasionally make contrarian bets and be right about those contrarian bets.
If you agree with the crowd you can’t expect to generate a market beating performance because market is a reflection of what crowd thinks. If you are going to outperform the crowd you must have a view occasionally that is different than the crowd. But when you’re reading and listening to the same stuff that crowd does, how can you expect to have superior insights?
You don’t need inside information. Don’t need charts and mumbo jumbo,” wrote Ruane. “It isn’t about momentum. It isn’t that guff the talking heads give you on CNBC…Truth is in the details and this intensive research on stock ideas is of immense importance in avoiding big mistakes and developing the positive convictions required to own and hold concentrated investment positions.
When the research behind a given investment is intensive it helps make you brave enough to buy when others are fearful and sell when others are greedy. There is no replacement for doing your own work.
6. Humour and Humility
A big factor in Sequoia’s success is long term ownership of Berkshire’s stock. Had it not been Berkshire, Sequoia’s long term record wouldn’t have been so great. And Ruane remains humble about this. He wrote in in Sequoia’s 1997 annual report –
While we have long known that Mr. Buffett had no peer in the investment field, it took us far too many years to do something about it and buy his stock on the theory that if you can’t beat him, join him. As they say, age is a heavy price to pay for insight, but we are pleased that we did get there eventually.
Ruane used to joke that the only difference between himself and Buffett was billions of dollars and 100 points of IQ. He has described his relationship with Buffett as being like “the caddy for Tiger Woods.”
Owning Berkshire, according to Ruane, not only gave him a high quality business but it came with the finest security analyst in the world i.e. Warren Buffett.
Conclusion
During his search for a candidate to succeed him as chief investment officer of Berkshire Hathaway, Buffett said, “I’m looking for another Bill Ruane.” That speaks volumes about Ruane’s character and his investment acumen.
Ruane built a reputation on Wall Street as an old-fashioned value investor who belonged to the camp of Buffett and Benjamin Graham and as an expert at delving into a company’s business and books to discover hidden worth.
Ruane passed away in 2005 but his great achievement and his philosophy of investing will live on as long as investors keep learning from his principles and create long term wealth.
Also Read:
- A Dozen Things I’ve Learned from Bill Ruane about Investing
- The Superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years