Swanand Kelkar, a professional money manager talks about his journey into the world of investing and shares his insights about picking great businesses.
Swanand Kelkar is Executive Director at Morgan Stanley and portfolio advisor for Indian equities. He joined Morgan Stanley in 2007 and has 10 years of investment experience. Prior to joining the firm, he worked in the equity investment department at HSBC Asset Management. Swanand received his Bachelor’s degree in commerce from the University of Mumbai and an M.B.A. from the Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad. He is also an associate member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India. Swanand writes a regular column for the Mint newspaper on investing and markets.
Safal Niveshak (SN): Could you tell us a little about your background, how you got interested in investing, and how you’ve evolved over time as an investor?
Swanand Kelkar (SK): I was born and brought up here in Mumbai and my parents were teachers. I am a Chartered Accountant and then went on to do my MBA from IIM Ahmedabad.
Ever since I was a kid, I had this fascination about seeing money grow. Most of my friends used to spend their pocket money but I used to save as much as I could and lend it within my family at usurious rates of interest. My family would playfully indulge me and this bug of seeing a hundred rupees become hundred and ten bit me for life.
My career choices, as you can see, have been related to this. I personally started investing in the equity markets as a twenty year old at the peak of the TMT bubble. Like a classic novice investor, I got sucked in at the top, invested based on hearsay and lost my shirt (two months’ worth of articleship stipend, which seemed like a fortune then). It was baptism by fire really.
It was during my MBA days that I began to figure out the method behind the madness and started understanding the difference between investing and speculation. My tiny portfolio started doing well (it was 2003) and I gained some confidence. I wanted to get into something related to equities after MBA which would convert my passion into my day job. Luckily, I got into the buy side and have now been a professional investor for over ten years, of which eight years were at Morgan Stanley Investment Management.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
SN: Great! How did you train yourself to be a value investor? Did any particular books or investors inspire you?
SK: To be fair, I don’t think of myself strictly as a value investor. The term has different connotations for different people but I think of investing as an exercise in finding disconnects between collective expectations and your own judgement.
I read Burton Malkiel’s Random Walk Down Wall Street while in college and the sections on Madness of the Crowds (Tulip bulb mania, South Sea bubble etc.) left an impression on me.
Michael Mauboussin’s Expectations Investing was impactful in teaching how to “read” market prices. I have also been partial to reading books written by practitioners like Howard Marks and Anthony Bolton on how they successfully plied the trade of being professional money managers.
Lot of investing insights came from non-investing books as well, especially on the behavioural side. Kahneman, Taleb, Malcolm Gladwell and James Surowiecki are names that come to mind.
SN: In your experience, what characteristics or attributes are advantageous for an investor to have?
SK: I will answer this for an investor in general. I think the most important attribute is discipline. One should have the ability to articulate one’s investing philosophy, be clear in one’s mind what type of stocks one will gravitate towards and what one will avoid and then just religiously stick to that philosophy through different market moods.
At times, your investing style will be in favour in the market and that part is easy, the tough part is when the market does not reward your style. The temptation to jump ship is immense at these times and that’s where your investing fortitude is really tested.
SN: That’s very true, especially the part about jumping ships. Anyways, what’s been the most difficult part for you of being an investor?
SK: It might sound like an oxymoron but I think the most important attribute of being an investor is the ability to do nothing. I like Paul Samuelson’s quote – “Investing should be more like watching paint dry or watching grass grow. If you want excitement, go to Las Vegas.”
One needs to have the ability to ignore all the blinking lights and people around you exhorting you to do something.
We wrote about this in one of our newsletters and gave the example of a football goal-keeper. Research shows that the best option for a goalie looking to save a penalty kick is to stand still and not jump but the goalie invariably jumps. The reasons can be many, not wanting to look foolish or just protecting one’s career.
SN: What are some of the characteristics you look for in a high-quality business?
SK: I spend a lot of time understanding what the moats for different businesses are. Return ratios, cash generation etc. will nudge you in the right direction but that by itself does not signify the existence of a moat with longevity. Technological disruptions or muddle-headed thinking from management team can quickly make the moat shrink or disappear.
The interesting thing is that different markets have unique business models that are shaped by the landscape and local context of that country. So what is a great business in one country may not be so in another or may not even exist in a third. There is no fixed answer to this, understanding the local context of a country as well as the DNA and evolution of a business is very important.
SN: How much weight do you put on the quality of the management versus other quantitative or qualitative factors? Also, how do you assess a management’s quality?
SK: Over long term, the quality of management is possibly the single most important determinant of stock performance.
We have held stocks for decades in our portfolios and when I go through the old investing rationales, those were all mainly written with next 12-18 months in mind. What made us keep on holding the stock for years was management quality and the team’s ability to keep generating great returns for shareholders.
We run screens on stock attributes that are important to us (superior growth and capital self-sufficiency) to generate ideas but that’s the starting point of the hunt. If that were all that is needed, investing would be the first profession to be eaten up by bots.
Having a long memory in the markets is important, which is not to say managements cannot turn a new leaf but we are generally sceptical of managements with history of misadventures (to use a euphemism) in the past.
SN: Wonderful! Talking about valuations, how do you think about the same? Do you have a preferred valuation framework to assess the attractiveness of an investment?
SK: Our ideal investments are companies with demonstrated moats that are going through some transient issues which has made the market shift focus away from the moat to the near-term wobble. We haven’t constrained ourselves into buying stocks only with a low P/E ratios etc. but our approach is to take valuations / prices as the odds that markets offer us. I actually spend a lot of time figuring out where we differ from the market’s assessment of the odds and then bet accordingly.
So when we write an investing rationale, a lot of time is spent in describing the moat and where do we differ from market expectations.
SN: What are your thoughts on the concept of a “value trap”? How long will you hold onto a non-performing position?
SK: I think every investor absolutely must write an investing rationale before he/she commits money to any stock, ideally with numerical targets in terms of expected operating parameters. This helps in maintaining objectivity against all the noise that engulfs stocks and markets. Thus, after every quarter, one can re-visit the rationale to see if the original thesis is still intact or needs a re-assessment.
This helps in avoiding value traps and one should have the objectivity to concede that this is a thesis gone wrong and one needs to sell and it also guards against holding on to things longer than required.
SN: Do you believe in investment checklists? If yes, what are the most important points in your checklist?
SK: I don’t have a checklist the way Atul Gawande would have but there are certain things that are compulsory in writing a rationale. I am not a big fan of the idea that investing can be made “idiot-proof” by using screens and checklists. Whatever you do, to paraphrase Buffett, investing involves a leap of faith and the most you can do is try and narrow the jump that you have to make.
SN: What are some of the tricks that you use to save yourself from behavioural biases? In other words, how do you minimize the mistakes of behaviour in your investment decision making?
SK: I think the biggest advantage we have at MSIM is that we have a team of successful investors and it is always a help to have an independent, competent and objective opinion that you respect. It helps weeding out biases or behavioural patterns.
Again, I cannot over-emphasise the value of writing a “hand on your heart” rationale. One comes out of a management meeting and sometimes you have really skilful presenters who can create that halo effect.
Many times, I have tried to dig through numbers and write a rationale for these eloquent orators only to tear up sheet after sheet of paper like a jilted lover.
SN: Can you talk about your biggest real-life investment mistake, what caused it, and the lessons you learned from it?
SK: As I mentioned earlier, I made many rudimentary mistakes as a novice investor including what I think is a sacrilege – investing based on a tip.
I have made many mistakes as a professional investor too and without naming names I can talk of broad mistake patterns. Some of the biggest mistakes were made when a big part of investing rationale was mean reversion – “things are very bad and can only improve from here” – without spending too much time on what the catalyst could be. The learning has been that mean reversion does not happen automatically, it needs a catalyst.
Now I think about it in Newtonian terms – “A thing at rest remains at rest unless acted upon by an equal and opposite force.” One must spend time on arriving at what the equal and opposite force will be.
The other recurring pattern has been not being merciless on rationales that have gone wrong because by the time you realise the rationale is not working out, price has corrected as well. Again from hindsight, the best thing to do is bite the bullet but it’s not easy and things linger on.
SN: How do you determine when to exit from a position? Are there some specific rules for selling you have?
SK: Normally when we initiate a position in a stock, we also talk about a price at which we will reassess the position – this is typically based on our expectation of a forward earnings and cash flows.
When we actually reassess the situation, we try to see whether the earnings came through as we expected or is much of the stock performance due to re-rating. Based on that, we again try to write a 12-18 month rationale from that point on, as if we are putting in new money and then see if we can we hold on to the stock; else we opt to sell it down.
SN: Hypothetical Question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?
SK: That’s an interesting question and I am assuming this is related to investing. I don’t think investing can be learnt by just reading a secret code of investing or something, it is just an accumulation of experiences and learning over a long time. I find it interesting that there are no investing prodigies – self-made billionaire investors who are twenty years old, the ones that we have, have a fair degree of grey hair.
So it would be really a setback if I lost all my memory overnight but I don’t think leaving back a secret code or something would help.
SN: What’s your two-minute advice to new investors or students interested in a career in investing?
SK: I see a lot of young people getting attracted to the profession with $ signs in their eyes. I think that’s just a wrong starting point. To use a line from Munger, investing is simple but not easy.
Also, I would advise them to get their hands dirty as soon as possible, start early, and learn on the job. Investing is not a spectator sport.
And keep learning, nobody can claim to have attained investing nirvana so everyone is really a student and that will remain so for life.
SN: Who are the investors/investment thinker you hold in high esteem?
SK: I like to read the practitioners of money management than theoreticians so Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Howard Marks, Peter Lynch, Anthony Bolton have all helped me further myself as an investor.
I think there are bits and pieces that I have picked up and emulated from each of them but in the end it is about developing your own style.
SN: Which books/resources do you recommend to a budding investor for learning multidisciplinary thinking? Any other recommendations of books to read?
SK: I would suggest that you surround yourself with an eclectic mix of people.
We in markets sometimes live in an echo chamber where we end up meeting and interacting with people from similar backgrounds but it’s important to carefully avoid this.
Keep the curiosity ante up, read voraciously and as far as possible, read with a purpose. I will desist from making specific recommendations but always read with an open mind.
SN: Great, Swanand! Thanks a lot again for sharing your amazing insights with Safal Niveshak readers.
SK: It was my pleasure, Vishal. Thanks!
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years