This isn’t your typical VIA interview, but a collection of wisdom from a few investors we have interviewed in the past. The topic is – lessons from the 2008 crisis. A decade has passed since this crisis (time flew, again!), and most lessons would have been forgotten (we have short memories).
As we see around, investors – especially new than old – are practicing speculative behavior. Not many investors who felt the pain in 2008 would possibly think this is a good idea even if no major crisis may be lurking around the corner. And this is exactly what came out from the questions we asked a few seasoned value investors, who were close witness to the crisis in 2008.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Below are their lessons from the crisis, how has their thought process changed (if it has) in this past decade, and their advice to new investors on dealing with similar such crisis in the future.
Samit Vartak
Samit is the founding partner and Chief Investment Officer at SageOne Investment Advisors.
SN: Ten years have passed since the 2008 financial crisis. What was the biggest lesson you learned from this crisis, that has stayed with you?
SV: The pain that you experience when you helplessly see your portfolio stocks just endlessly lose value day after day and month after month is 10 times bigger than the joy that you experienced for years by watching your portfolio grow multifold in the bull market preceding that crash. Years of gain just vanish in a matter of months and when the stocks fall so fast, very few have the ability to get out of the market. Many more who join the last part of the bull phase take the painful ride down compared to ones who enjoyed the ride up.
SN: How has your thinking on financial markets and investing changed over this past decade? What has changed in your thinking and why?
SV: In a bull market the sentiments are so positive that the perception is that most companies will fundamentally do well in future and that too for a long period. Hence a rising tide lifts all boats. In reality, my analysis have shown that over a business cycle (peak to peak or trough to trough) only 5% of the companies grow their earnings by > 20% CAGR. Most others disappoint. Hence my focus has more and more changes towards making sure that the portfolio has as many of these 5% winners as possible. You can’t ensure all of your portfolio to be made of these, but even if you are able to do it for 30% of your portfolio and stay away from lemons, you will outperform most. In my experience, earnings growth is what will save one from
permanent capital loss and limit the downside during a crash.
SN: Most investors have weak memories, plus many who have done well in the recent past were not there to experience the pain of 2008. What advice would you offer to such investors to help them prepare for dealing well with a crisis of such magnitude in the future (when that happens)?
SV: Bull markets are the worst teachers. The lure of quick gains is so strong that most can’t resist it and they end up losing discipline in investing. The rising tide hides all sorts of mistakes and many end up compounding those. Investment success that is achieved due to luck is rarely replicable and sustainable. Many end up crediting self and skill for such success.
I would advise investors to evaluate success considering business performance and price performance rather than just stock price performance. Focus on identifying great businesses and read books/material that would enhance your understanding of businesses consistently over a period of time. Superior businesses will do the best job in relatively protecting your capital during a market crash.
Prabhakar Kudva
Prabhakar is a value investor and the founder of Samvitti Capital.
SN: Ten years have passed since the 2008 financial crisis. What was the biggest lesson you learned from this crisis, that has stayed with you?
PK: The biggest lesson has been to really internalize the fact that it’s not the stock ideas or analysis that eventually matter the most, but your behaviour.
The tragedy, however, is that you can’t really predict or prepare how you’ll behave under various circumstances, especially stressful ones. It is, therefore, imperative to design your systems and portfolios so that you’ll minimize the chances of reacting incorrectly under stress.
This may mean different things to different people but primarily it means fixing your asset allocation and/or portfolio sizing before everything else to ensure that you’ll not panic and make unforced errors when things go wrong.
As an example, I think the primary reason why Warren Buffett owns so much cash is that he likely wants to minimize the possibility of having to act forcefully under duress than because of not having enough ideas.
This may seem sub-optimal to many aggressive investors, but without having enough behavioural cushions markets will (not may) scare you out at exactly the wrong time. This needs to be fixed before everything else.
SN: How has your thinking on financial markets and investing changed over this past decade? What has changed in your thinking and why?
PK: My thinking is that markets are very benevolent and if you are honest, disciplined and willing to learn from your errors, any and every strategy will work.
I know very successful deep value investors, intraday traders, positional traders, momentum traders, high growth investors, concentrated investors and diversified investors. So, there is no point really dissing someone’s strategy as long as it works for them.
Having started very early, I have experimented extensively in my initial years with various styles. What I think works best for me is the simple strategy of trying to buy strong and growing businesses, run by smart managements and own them as long as they continue to remain strong and growing businesses, run by smart managements.
I have deliberately left price out of the equation because it gets way more attention than it deserves. I was recently reading some research and sure enough over a five-year period the multiple makes up just 15% of the return and over a ten-year period it makes up just 5%.
If we can focus on finding the right businesses in their growth phase with good jockeys managing them – leaving aside extreme in-your-face valuation errors – the returns in aggregate will be above average.
The second part of the equation is minimizing errors and allowing compounding to do its job (magic!). While this was always known to me right from the beginning, I truly internalized this only gradually. There is a huge difference in just reading something and really understanding the core of it.
Charlie Munger is right. It’s simple but with so many distractions and compulsions around us that it’s not easy – which is why it probably continues to work. Also, the words strong, growth, smart, valuation and long term are very subjective terms, which makes the whole exercise more challenging than it looks.
SN: Most investors have weak memories, plus many who have done well in the recent past were not there to experience the pain of 2008. What advice would you offer to such investors to help them prepare for dealing well with a crisis of such magnitude in the future (when that happens)?
PK: I don’t think the emotions one went through can be explained in words. This is why true investing can’t be taught – because it’s a battle against your own self.
How you react to a given situation won’t be the same as how someone else does – given their finances, their education, their background and their prior experiences.
You must experience things first hand to really see how you’ll end up behaving and then learn from that. No matter what most of us say or do we are not Charlie Munger and we can’t apply vicarious knowledge consistently.
Sean Iddings
Sean is co-founder of the Intelligent Fanatics Project and member of MicroCapClub.
SN: Ten years have passed since the 2008 financial crisis. What was the biggest lesson you learned from this crisis, that has stayed with you?
SI: Thou shalt not hold a loser if another better opportunity is available. I started investing in 2007 right before the financial crisis. I had no clue what I was doing. A good chunk of my money was in a horrendous business. I wanted to “get my money back” in that stock before investing in something else. I held that company way too long. I could have taken the hit and gone heavy on some of the best companies at ridiculously low valuations. Instead, I used an eye dropper.
SN: How has your thinking on financial markets and investing changed over this past decade? What has changed in your thinking and why?
SI: I read Graham’s analogy of Mr. Market in 2008. That will always be relevant. I just didn’t really understand it to utilize it. Of course, I’ve gone from unconscious incompetence then to what I hope is conscious competence. I still have a long way away from unconscious competence in investing.
SN: Most investors have weak memories, plus many who have done well in the recent past were not there to experience the pain of 2008. What advice would you offer to such investors to help them prepare for dealing well with a crisis of such magnitude in the future (when that happens)?
SI: Don’t listen to me. I made it through 2008-2009 with my spirit intact and a hunger to learn, but I have not successfully “made it” through a bear market performance wise. Listen to those who have.
Ian Cassel
Ian is a full-time microcap investor and founder of MicroCapClub, the MicroCap Leadership Summit, and co-founder of the Intelligent Fanatics Project.
SN: Ten years have passed since the 2008 financial crisis. What was the biggest lesson you learned from this crisis, that has stayed with you?
IC: The luckiest part of my investing career is that I’ve been old enough (37) to have invested through two bear markets (1999-2001 and 2008-2009) and still young enough to take advantage of the lessons learned.
From 1999-2001, while I was in college, I worked part-time for a brokerage firm. I was the “Marketing Administrator” which means I was the secretary who answered the phones. When the dotcom bubble burst, I heard from a large percentage of our 1,200 clients. They called our office in every emotional state you can imagine. And here I was, an inexperienced 18-19 years old, trying to calm them down and hold their hands.
I thought I wanted to be a broker when I started this job. After that experience, I knew I didn’t want to be a broker. Investing is hard enough dealing with your own emotions let alone the emotions of others.
In 2008, I had just made the leap to becoming a full-time private microcap investor. Simultaneously the markets went into freefall. Great timing, right?
During the crisis I realized two things. First, the worst place to be invested during a crisis is in liquid, institutionally held microcaps (i.e., the large microcap segment). I found that when the economy or markets show signs of weakening, institutional capital takes risk off. One of the first areas they look to liquidate is exposure to microcaps.
The second thing I observed was that small microcaps that had great businesses that weren’t institutionally held did fairly well. Why? Institutions couldn’t sell what they didn’t own. This is a big reason why I try to invest in the least institutionally owned best businesses I can find.
During the crisis I got lucky. I say lucky because It was one of those handful of times during an investment career when I timed something perfectly. One of my largest positions hit its inflection point during the crisis. No institutions owned it, and it went up 280% while the markets were down 52%.
The lesson I learned was capital still flows into new ideas even during a crisis. Institutions are moths and the flames they are attracted to are growing profitable businesses that they don’t own.
Another lesson I learned is that quality bounces back first near the end of a bear market. When capital is finally redeployed it floods back into quality businesses first. One of my holdings was down 65% peak to trough during the crisis. Two months after the market bottom, the stock was up 200% from its low. In just two months it had recouped all its losses.
My 2008-2009 experience is burned into my memory, and the result is productive paranoia. As preparation for the next crisis, I constantly reflect upon my portfolio and ask myself the following questions:
• Can the businesses I own grow through a recession? How will they be impacted?
• Are the products and services they sell a luxury or necessity?
• Are their products or services so relied upon that if they didn’t exist it would cause their customers a lot of pain?
• Do the businesses I own have good balance sheets, so they can be aggressive and take advantage of opportunities during a downturn?
If I can answer the questions above favorably, then I’m doing my job and can sleep at night. If I can’t answer those questions favorably with any position, then I need to make some changes to the portfolio.
The bottom line is the best defense for a crisis is a quality business. Once your portfolio is properly defended with high quality businesses, you’ll be able to view the next crisis for what it is: an opportunity.
Today in the United States, there are around 70 million Americans between the ages of 19-34. This is roughly 21% of the population. A majority of this age demographic are now investing and have never emotionally experienced a bear market. This age demographic spends a lot of time on social media.
Just think of how bad the 2008 crisis would be if it happened today. 70 million people emotionally and financially terrified on social media. This is what I think about and it could be a huge opportunity for those that can disconnect from the crowd.
Max Lucado said, “A man who wants to lead the orchestra must turn his back on the crowd.”
Huzaifa Husain
Huzaifa is the Head of Indian Equities at PineBridge Investments based in Mumbai.
SN: Ten years have passed since the 2008 financial crisis. What was the biggest lesson you learned from this crisis, that has stayed with you?
HH: The biggest lessons learned are that uncontrolled leverage is poison and one should be ready to act big on opportunities presented during such crisis.
Amidst the flurry of distracting headlines are timely opportunities, if one knows where and how to seize them. Moments are fleeting, whether they be good times or bad.
An example of how we’ve captured timely opportunities: We used to own a cement company before the 2008 crisis and had seen a four-fold rise in its stock price rise between 2005-2007. Since hitting its peak in October 2007 the stock fell by 70% by mid-2008.
In the midst of the crisis, we decided to buy a significant amount of this stock as we saw that the company’s fundamentals had not deteriorated and were in fact improving due to the push by the government on Bharat Nirman. Post our purchase we saw the stock decline another 30%.
Such drops in stock prices are not uncommon during such periods – and while maintaining equanimity is hard, it is very important. Today, the stock is up fifty-fold from the low it hit during the crisis.
SN: How has your thinking on financial markets and investing changed over this past decade? What has changed in your thinking and why?
HH: Time horizon is extremely important, and opportunities may be greater over a longer time frame. And moreover, success in investing over the longer time horizon requires a little bit of imagination.
A decade is a long time for India which typically sees its economy nearly triple in dollar terms. Sixty seven percent of what India’s economy will be after ten years may not be a replica of today’s India.
Imagining what it will be and allocating capital prudently is important rather than getting lost in the daily onslaught of news and views.
SN: Most investors have weak memories, plus many who have done well in the recent past were not there to experience the pain of 2008. What advice would you offer to such investors to help them prepare for dealing well with a crisis of such magnitude in the future (when that happens)
HH: The best way to learn how crises unfold is to learn from the past and not be complacent to the possibility of them occurring.
I remember attending a manufacturing company’s annual general meeting which was held in a five-star hotel. Before the meeting began, the company’s safety officer briefed us about the emergency exits and nearest hospitals. What were the chances of an emergency happening? Probably miniscule. But the loss, if it happened, would be significant.
Hence when you multiply the probability of loss into the magnitude of loss, it becomes meaningful. That is the reason why airlines do a safety demonstration before every flight. All investors should mentally be ready to see their investments go down by 50% rapidly and be prepared to act rationally when that happens.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years




