• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

InvestorInsights: Gaurav Jalan

February 20, 2016

Gaurav Jalan, an enterprising and inspiring young value investor shares his invaluable insights and experiences in sensible, long-term investing.

Gaurav has 14 years of experience in management consulting and investment management. He manages investment portfolios for high net worth individuals and companies as Chief Investment Officer at Avant Garde Wealth Management. Previously, he was an Investment Analyst at Fidelity International in Mumbai and also worked as a Senior Associate Consultant at Bain & Co., New York. Gaurav completed his MBA from Columbia Business School, New York in 2006 and his B.A. in Economics and Computer Science from Amherst College, Massachusetts in 2001.

In his interview with Safal Niveshak, Gaurav shares his wide investment experience and how small investors can practice sensible investment decision making.

Safal Niveshak (SN): Could you tell us a little about your background, how you got interested in value investing?
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Gaurav Jalan (GJ): I graduated from a small liberal arts college called Amherst College in the US with a B.A. in Economics and Computer Science. Subsequently, I worked for a few years with Bain & Co., which is a management consulting firm. While I was at Bain, a friend happened to hand me a copy of One Up on Wall Street by Peter Lynch (which remains one of my favourite books on investing till today) and I was hooked. The book helped me appreciate that, with the right framework and effort, it is possible to methodically make money in the stock market even for a lay person. The concept was both intellectually and financially appealing. So I started investing in stocks and began to voraciously devour writings by other well-known investors. Not surprisingly, books about Warren Buffett and his letters played a big role in shaping my early views as an investor.

After Bain, I joined the Columbia Business School MBA program. CBS has a strong value investing legacy from the days of Graham and Buffett, which is now being carried forward by Prof. Bruce Greenwald, who I was lucky to have as my teacher. I was unfortunately not selected to be part of the famed value investing program but managed to talk my way into sitting in all of the classes anyway. As part of the curriculum, we had multiple successful investors come in and share their experience and approach, which I found to be immensely useful in evolving my own framework on investing.

Out of Columbia, I joined Fidelity as part of their India research team. The five years I spent at Fidelity were incredibly valuable in helping me increase my breadth and depth of knowledge across a range of companies and industries. I was also able to appreciate the institutional constraints and incentive structures facing analysts and fund managers on the buy side (mutual funds) and the sell side (institutional brokerage). I left Fidelity in 2011 to start my own investment management business, which I have been running since.

SN: It’s good that you mentioned about the constraints of the stock market job. Can you mention a few of them (the constraints)? Were they the chief reason you quit your job and started on your own?

GJ: I would say the primary challenge of working in an institutional setting is managing the time horizon. To be fair, this will vary by institution, but in general you don’t get a very long rope in terms of time horizon. This is not because people are not smart and don’t understand the advantages of long term thinking. It is simply that the end clients tend to have limited tolerance for bad performance or under performance, and therefore the institutional imperative is to maintain good short term results in order to not lose business.

This brings me to a related point. There is an increasing tendency, especially with the proliferation of social media, to criticize and make fun of calls made by sell-side analysts and even mutual fund managers. I find this attitude quite distressing as these are often smart, hard working people who are forced to cater to certain client expectations and therefore tailor their analysis accordingly. There is usually significant value to be gained from reading research reports if one focuses on the content and facts rather than the inferences and the buy/sell recommendation. You obviously have to keep in mind the behavioural biases that the analyst may suffer from in order to best interpret the analysis.

I quit my job to start managing money on my own primarily because I always wanted to be an entrepreneur and also because I wanted more flexibility to invest in the manner that I thought was appropriate. So yes, the institutional constraints did have a role to play in my decision.

SN: How have you evolved as an investor and what’s your broad investment philosophy? Has your investment policy changed much through the years?

GJ: Being conservative and risk averse by nature, I was naturally attracted to value investing. I emphasize the phrase because it has come to mean different things to different people. I started out as more of a Graham and Dodd investor, with a focus on statistically cheap stocks, which is how value investing was traditionally defined.

Over time, with some tough lessons dispensed by Mr. Market, I came to better appreciate the importance of the quality of a business and its management as drivers of business value.

Simplistically, my investment philosophy entails determining the intrinsic value of a business and buying the stock at a discount to that value. I seek to build in a margin of safety both in my evaluation of intrinsic value, by using conservative assumptions, and then buying the stock at a significant discount. I prefer to use scenario analysis when computing value rather than arriving at and anchoring on one particular figure.

I am most comfortable in a contrarian’s clothing. If you do what everyone else is doing you will make the returns everyone else makes. In order to make superior returns, it is necessary to be different and be right. In order to be contrarian you have to be sceptical, which means questioning the status quo when others are too optimistic and when others are too pessimistic. This is not to say that consensus expectations (not just analyst expectations but price implied expectations) are always wrong. In fact, it is quite the opposite, and the consensus is right most of the time. But there are times when the consensus is wrong, and often very wrong, which throws up the big money making opportunities.

I am happy to buy any type of business as long as the reward is attractive versus the risk, be it high quality companies, cyclicals, special situations, etc. I don’t prefer buying high debt companies, but unless I believe the stock could go zero there is a price at which I may get interested. I generally take a long term view and am happy to own a stock for many years unless the thesis is broken, and as a result my portfolio turnover is very low.

I am a strong believer in cyclicality and mean reversion, and I evaluate all businesses and their potential in this context. As a result, I set a high hurdle to conclude that any particular trend in a company or industry or at an economy wide level is secular. From this perspective, with time I have come to incorporate macroeconomic thinking into my investment process, especially when it comes to portfolio construction. The value of any business, both in terms of cash flows and how those cash flows are priced by investors, is not set in isolation and is dependent on the broader context of the domestic and global economy. It is sometimes possible to reach intelligent conclusions about the larger economic picture and certain economic variables, which can then be used as an input into both stock selection and portfolio construction.

A portfolio is more than a collection of individual stocks. Most investment discussion is regarding stock selection, but it is important to spend meaningful time thinking about portfolio construction and how it can impact not just the total returns but also the path of returns. One needs to think about how to size positions and also how the portfolio as a whole could behave under different scenarios.

Being in the market has made me humbler. No matter how much work you have done and how much conviction you build, it is still possible to be wrong. Striking the right balance between conviction and humility is a tough challenge and a continuous learning experience.

SN: You mentioned about the rarely talked about but extremely important subject of position sizing. How do you look at that aspect while buying stocks? Are there any rules to position sizing that you follow?

GJ: My thinking on position sizing and portfolio construction is very much work in progress. I come at it from a top down and bottom up view. Top down, I know that I don’t want to have more than say 20 stocks in the portfolio because I would rather put more money in my higher conviction positions than simply keep adding stocks. Additionally, each position should be of some minimum size so that it is able to contribute to overall performance if the thesis plays out. So mathematically, if I have 20 equal size positions that would mean 5% in each stock. Since I know that some positions will be larger than others I generally work with a 3% “starter position” for a new purchase. Bottom up, depending on how the thesis plays out and how my conviction level changes in the context of price moves, I add to the position over time. So in that sense the position size evolves organically.

As an overlay, I think about the underlying drivers of each business I own and try and limit the overall portfolio exposure to any particular driver. So for example, I don’t want to be in a position where 40% of my portfolio will suffer if there is a bad monsoon year or if the rupee were to depreciate dramatically. This is also where my thinking on broader macroeconomic parameters acts as in input in determining the size of any overall exposure.

I don’t have hard limits on maximum position size. But I would only put 10% of the portfolio in a stock when my level of conviction is very high. Also, given my inclination to loss aversion I am more comfortable increasing position size when I view probability of permanent capital loss as relatively lower than other positions.

SN: What are some of the characteristics you look for in high-quality businesses? What are the key checklist points you consider while searching for such businesses?

GJ: A high quality business is one that can sustainably generate high returns on capital. Such a business tends to have high barriers to entry, which allows the business to generate good unit economics. My checklist for identifying such businesses includes, but is not limited to, (1) Average of more than 20% ROIC over a 15-20 year period, (2) High gross margins, (3) High conversion of earnings to cash, (4) Low working capital needs, (5) Low leverage.

SN: What about the management factor? How do you assess the people managing the show? Or do you consider the numbers – like the ones you mentioned above – being reflective of the quality of management?
GJ: When evaluating any business, I like to study how it has evolved historically, over a 10-15 year period (in the Indian context older data is usually not available), and be able to tell its story and understand how it makes money. So starting from year 1 onwards, I look at how various financial parameters such as sales growth, margins, capital invested, cash flow, etc. have moved over time. Then I try to find explanations for those changes, through annual report MD&A, other publicly available information such as competitor commentary or news articles, research reports, and through conversations with management and other stakeholders like customers, suppliers, etc. I also compare the company’s historical performance to that of its competitors to understand the reasons for differences in relative performance. Going through this process generally gives me a good sense of management capability and the role they have played in the performance of the business vs. external factors.

SN: Let’s talk about valuations and the big confusion between ‘paying up’ for quality and ‘overpaying’. How do you look at them?

GJ: Since I view most businesses from a cyclical prism, I typically use two approaches to valuation – (1) a ROE/PE/PB matrix, and (2) a P/S or EV/S measure. In the first approach, based on my assessment of the business, I determine a range of sustainable ROE for the business and multiply it by a range of appropriate PE ratios. This leaves me with a range of PB ratios that I use to estimate intrinsic values. In the second approach, I estimate a range of normalized margins and PE ratios, which gives me a range of P/S ratios that I use to estimate intrinsic values. I also compare the range of P/B and P/S ratios I come up with against historic trading multiples over the last 15-20 years. This helps me understand whether the value I am placing on the business is very different from what investors have paid in the past, and if so I try to identify what has changed versus history.

I look at the price to intrinsic value ratios in the context of where the company is in its business cycle. So if I have conviction that the business cycle is improving and that the earnings growth trajectory will be strong I am willing to buy the stock even at a slight premium to the low end of my intrinsic value range. However, if I don’t have much visibility into when the cycle will improve or actually think it might get worse before it gets better I will require a much larger discount to consider buying.

Value creation is highest in a business with a high ROIC that has the ability to reinvest cash into the existing business. Depending on the growth runway, one can justify buying such businesses even at relatively high multiples. However, the quality of such businesses is generally well understood by investors and hence these stocks are typically quite expensive on current earnings and cash flows. Investing in such businesses is then essentially about betting that the growth runway is longer than what the market is pricing in, or in other words it ends up being about whether a 30-50x PE multiple still leaves room for generating returns above cost of equity. This is not an area where I feel I can get an edge and therefore usually end up not investing in such stocks.

While investors often focus on finding high quality businesses, it is the rate of change in quality that throws up the best money making opportunities. When a bad quality business transforms into an average quality business or when an average quality business transforms into an above average quality business, the increase in intrinsic value can be substantial. I try and focus on such opportunities.

SN: That’s a wonderful insight, Gaurav – the thing about the rate of change in quality. How do you assess that, because this is a qualitative aspect and is generally known in hindsight?

GJ: It is correct that rate of change in quality is very difficult to assess in real time. However, there are a few markers one can look for, both internal to the company and external. Internally, change in management (even if within the promoter family), shift in capital allocation strategy, new pricing strategy, and change in business mix are some things that merit further investigation. Externally, change in number of competitors or competitor behavior, change in government regulation, signs of step change in product demand, etc. are a few instances that may drive sustainable changes in business economics.

SN: How do you determine when to exit from a position? Are there some specific rules for selling you have?

GJ: I will consider exiting my positions in a few different instances but I don’t set any hard rules. First, when my thesis is permanently broken and I am forced to revise downwards my estimates of intrinsic value. Second, when the stock price approaches the upper end of my estimated intrinsic value band. Third, when there are other opportunities with clearly better risk reward propositions.

Historically, when I have sold stocks because I felt them to be fully valued, I have generally ended up selling my positions too early and missed out on substantial future gains and also had to deal with reinvestment risk. So while I still maintain a sell discipline on valuation, over time I have increasingly held on to my winners for a longer period of time.

SN: Can you please share a couple of real-life stock examples here, like when your thesis was broken, and where you ended up selling early?

GJ: I invested in a stock called Shakti Pumps. The product had good reviews from customers and competitors and the demand potential looked strong. A private equity firm had recently invested in the company and they seemed to be driving significant change as more professionals were being inducted in the management and the company appointed consultants to help redesign their supply chain and distribution strategy to reduce their bloated working capital. The stock was down substantially from the price at which the PE firm had invested and my thesis was that the business economics would improve substantially. However, when the company published its annual report I noticed substantial deterioration in their working capital internals. Although I knew receivable days were high at 5 months, what alarmed me was that the portion of receivables due for >6 months was at 39% of total (up from 14% prior year) and 2% of receivables were actually due for more than a year. When I did not get satisfactory explanations from management I sold the stock as I felt the poor receivable figures were possibly symptomatic of a deeper malaise. While I was lucky to be able to exit at a profit, this was a clear instance of my thesis being broken. Subsequent results seem to suggest that my suspicion was not unwarranted.

I normally do not invest in IPOs but had invested in the NBCC (a PSU construction company) IPO in 2012. The business had historically good economics with very high cash flow generation, good growth, and high returns on capital. All of this driven by almost captive order flow from government agencies, which seemed set to continue. The business continued to deliver and I held the stock for a couple of years, after which I sold for substantial gains when I felt it was fully valued. Since then the company’s order book has almost doubled and the underlying economics remain as strong as ever. As a result, the stock has also appreciated significantly. I clearly sold too early.

SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements of themes?

GJ: There have been many investment mistakes and therefore much to learn from. One common element has been inadequate emphasis on corporate governance and management quality. An incapable management team that allocates capital unwisely, or a crooked management team that indulges in fraud or does not give minority shareholders its due, can lead to value traps where the stock may look cheap versus intrinsic value but that value then declines over time.

SN: Can you please share a real-life stock example where you made this mistake of putting inadequate emphasis on management quality and corporate governance, and your lessons from the same?

GJ: I invested in a stock called Manugraph India, which manufactures web offset presses used by the newspaper industry. The company is almost a monopoly in the segment in which it operates with a 70% domestic market share and similar high share in overseas markets. The company also had a strong balance sheet with 50% of its market cap in cash. I was initially negligent in my analysis of the company and missed the fact that the management was indirectly paying itself huge sums of money via commissions as a percentage of revenues to a shell company. After my purchase the business went through a soft demand environment and given the high fixed cost structure of the business cash flow generation declined substantially. Even while revenues and profits were plummeting management chose to give themselves pay raises. In my subsequent interactions with management it became clear that they had no interest in taking any shareholder friendly actions like returning surplus cash via dividends or buy backs simply because they were continuing to earn sufficient cash flow even if the business was suffering. An inadequate emphasis on management quality cost me dear.

SN: Well, thanks for sharing that, as I believe a lot of investors suffer at the hand of unscrupulous managers and thus studying management quality is of great importance. Anyways, how can an investor improve the quality of his/her decision making?

GJ: I would suggest two ways to improve quality of decision making. First, a focus on the process of investing rather than outcomes. This will ensure that the right lessons are learnt from outcomes. Investing is about probabilities and following a good process will ensure good outcomes on average over time. Second, an emphasis on facts versus forecasting. At any given time, the future can have a wide range of outcomes and therefore investments made on specific forecasts have a high probability of being wrong. It is better to focus on historical facts which are knowable and amenable to analysis to make intelligent guesses about a range of future outcomes.

SN: How do you think about risk? How do you employ that in your investing?

GJ: The best definition of risk I have heard is – “Risk means more things can happen than will happen.” Risk cannot be measure ex-post based on outcomes. At any given time, there are multiple future states of the world that are possible. At a company level I account for this risk primarily by building in a large margin of safety in my purchase price and also not buying businesses with high leverage, where an extreme negative outcome could lead to significant impairment in intrinsic value. At a portfolio level I manage risk by thinking about how different positions in the portfolio will behave in any given state of the world and how that will impact the overall portfolio.

SN: What’s you two-minute advice to someone wanting to get into value investing? What are the pitfalls he/she must be aware of?

GJ: My advice would be to put in place a good investment process and follow it diligently. Most importantly, while it is important to learn from other investors and their actions, especially as a novice investor, it is absolutely critical to develop your independent framework and investment style, which can only come with experience. Ultimately, a lot of investing success is tied to psychology, which is unique to each individual.

SN: It’s great that you mentioned about psychology. Is there a checklist or process that you follow that helps you minimize the mistakes of behaviour? It’s impossible to eliminate such mistakes, but have you been able to minimize them?

GJ: I don’t really have any checklist of hard rules that drive my buying and selling process. In focus on really understanding a business as that allows me to rise above prevailing sentiment (as reflected in the price) and make an informed investment decision. I can’t say I have been successful in minimizing mistakes driven by psychology as there is always room for improvement, but I do feel I am going in that direction.

SN: Which unconventional books/resources do you recommend to a budding investor for learning investing and multidisciplinary thinking?

GJ:Fooled by Randomness by Nassim Taleb offers some good lessons on the role of chance and makes a case against overconfidence. Influence by Robert Cialdini offers some great insights into the psychology of persuasion. The Goal by Eliyahu Goldratt is an excellent read on operations management and how to actually improve business performance. The Checklist Manifesto by Atul Gawande makes a compelling case for use of checklists and a defined process in most professions.

SN: Which investor/investment thinker(s) so you hold in high esteem?

GJ: There are many good investors, each with their own style and successful in their own way. Peter Lynch is one such investor, whose writings helped me develop my passion for investing.

Investors like Peter Thiel have shown the ability to successfully identify tomorrow’s innovators. But I have increasingly come to the realization that it is only independent thought and hard work that lead to success.

SN: Hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?

GJ: I am going to make the response specific to investing. The letter would read something like…

A stock is a piece of a business and you need to understand the underlying business in order to make money on the stock. The market is often right but sometimes very wrong, and it is in identifying those times that the big money can be made. Identify your strengths and shortcomings and develop your independent investment process accordingly. Develop conviction and yet be humble and open to the possibility of being wrong. Risk means more things can happen than will happen, so determine whether good outcomes were caused by good process and bad outcomes by bad process.

SN: Wonderful! Well, what other things do you do apart from investing?

GJ: I like reading, running and playing squash.

SN: Great! So that’s all I have. Thank you so much Gaurav for all the insights and your time.

GJ: You’re welcome Vishal.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Interviews

Handcrafted with in India