Prabhakar Kudva, an engineer by education and an investor by choice, chronicles his serendipitous journey in to the world of value investing and shares some useful insights on portfolio construction
Amit Arora is one of the founders and Chief Investment Officer of Eleven Dimension Funds. After two short stints in India he had the privilege to serve United Nations, based out of Europe from 2000 through 2007.
Since 2007 he has been rendering professional consulting services to a number of New Zealand Government organisations such as Ministry of Justice, Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment, Ministry of Social Development, Inland Revenue Department, Regional Health Boards as an Independent Consultant.
Amit started and managed an investment partnership registered in India under Indian Partnership Act 1932 with a selective total of nine partners out of one hundred and fifteen plus who evinced interest in joining, with a successful track record from 2012-2014.
He is passionate about spirituality, investments, technology and a need for well rounded and balanced life to realise human potential.
Safal Niveshak (SN): Could you tell us a little about your background, how you got interested in investing, and how you’ve evolved over time as an investor?
Amit Arora (AA): I chose Commerce in 11th standard and did MBA in Finance. I landed a below-mediocre first job with Peerless General Finance and Investment Company which felt like 10 years, though it lasted only for 10 months. In 1999, I saw IT folks earning more money, much more than me. So, I was working for money, not passion, I chose to go into software development. I trained in C, Java and got sacked along with rest of the team in 2000. I then stayed at home for 4 months. Then, thanks to luck, I got a few months consulting job in United Nations in Italy in 2001 after a brief unemployment period. This contract kept extending every 3-6 months from 2001 until I got bored by 2006.
I was 30 years old in 2006, no social circle, I preferred being alone by nature, I was twice as old as a teenager, so my hormones started to kick in by now, no girlfriend ever by this time, so I decided to get married in arranged marriage manner in India through our parents, and then thought of moving to an English speaking country like the New Zealand, US, England, Australia or Canada. I wanted to try consulting for Indian companies like Wipro of Infosys for some time, but my better half did not, so we moved to New Zealand in 2007.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
After I got my first job in 1999, I invested some money in 1999 in Prudential ICICI Technology Fund. This investment by the close of 2000 shrunk to 30% of what it was. Bitten by this loss in 1999, I stayed away from investing in stock market until 2008. After my father retired from work in 2006, I strongly dissuaded him from dabbling in equity markets, yet he went headlong and did well for a couple of years. I wondered if those returns were possible. So I invested 100% of my liquid savings in Northern Rock Bank of the UK, which went to zero in 2007-2008. It was nationalised and later sold out at a nice profit to the government. Investors in Barclays and Royal Bank of Scotland were diluted as the government infused equity but investors in the 3rd biggest British bank, i.e. Northern Rock were left holding lemons. I am still not sure how a government could sell someone else’s property at a profit. The terms of the valuation were rigged, the case moved from stages of High Court, Supreme Court, European Court of Human Rights, none of whom wanted to hear, thus private property of shareholders was confiscated and sold to Virgin Money at a nice profit to the government.
Anyways, I decided that to make more money than what I was earning by consulting, my money must compound more than 3% per annum which is what you get in Term Deposit in the US or New Zealand, and decided to learn about how to go about becoming an investor and avoid another wipe-outs.
My life has been an unplanned series of events, although I understand that we attract circumstances we will for.
Anyways, I started by investing in New Zealand and Australia in large caps. Then I moved to small cap quality businesses in India. I was foolish enough not to pay 25x P/E for a 25% growth, a mistake I hope I have rectified. But there are very few companies growing that fast. So, I still stick to quality or unknown story which has had high return on equity. I am fairly satisfied with 16% CAGR. 20% is great.
In life, if you have defined your “more than enough” figure, and are not chasing every greater sums with more zeros, and continue to have simple lifestyle, that kind of growth (10% above inflation) is more than enough.
SN: Wonderful! What you just talked about is ‘satisficing’, which is a great mental model to adopt to cut a lot of risk-taking from investing. Anyways, even as it seems that a lot of you your training in investing was a result of serendipity,how did you actually built up on that? Did any particular books or investors inspire you?
AA: Yes, training was mainly by making mistakes, then licking the wounds and reading and participating in equity forums and books, I did not know that a stock could go up 50 or 100 times. Peter Lynch introduced that in his book One Up On Wall Street based on which I picked Symphony, not the profits, just the stock. Too depressing to talk about stocks that went up 50-100 times from my initial purchase price like Relaxo and Symphony, which I sold at 50% gain. Peter Lynch had a chapter Flowers in the Desert, a single dominant company in the industry, especially a shrinking or no growth industry that keeps competition at bay. That was one model to keep in mind. Cooler is one such industry in India.
Warren Buffett, Joel Greenblatt, Mohnish Pabrai, and Peter Lynch were my initial inspirations. Then I learnt about few investors from India who follow similar philosophy like Sanjoy Bhattacharya, Prof. Sanjay Bakshi and Ramdeo Agarwal. They are all inspiring.
Warren Buffett himself made 100 bagger or something of the sort in GEICO when he bought second half for US$ 2 billion, but he never said so openly. Peter Lynch was the one to openly speak about it, which made a big difference to me. So rather than labouring over next 50% returns, I was sparked to imagine about next 500% returns over next X years.
So, all those investors provided a lot of models in investing field, which a successful investor should have. A good architect should draw a solution from various vantage points, or show different dimensions of solution. A good programmer must be aware of new tools to produce minimalist code. They call in DRY Code1, use a library or someone else’s utility for some problem that has been solved before. Similarly a successful investor must have checklists, processes, models and portfolio management. It may not be written down, and can all be in the head. Finally, as Buffett says, it is not maths, you need to see losses in short term and yet be patient.
In spirituality they call it mind over matter, will over mind, spirit over will. In investing, it’s gut over intellect.
SN: You talked about models in investing that you learned from the legends you just mentioned. Are there 2-3 models from any other fields that have influenced you as an investor?
AA: Scarcity and Law of Large Numbers are the models I like.
The scarce the resource, the more its value (if it has any utility). Gold has zero value for me because a huge mine can be discovered tomorrow. Amethyst lost its value 100 times over when a huge mine was discovered. It was used to be valued at par ruby and emerald, and was part of Queens Tiara, that is no longer the case. So, the more scarce the equity of company, the better for investors, other things being equal.
Law of Large Numbers means in investing it is harder to achieve exponential returns. So, looking at a company vis-à-vis the GDP of a country is important. Many companies in Africa have one leading monopoly in Beer Industry which account for 8-10% of GDP, for example Bralirwa in Rwanda, and Zimbia, Namibia Breweries, East African Breweries etc. Investing should be done in context of the small and the big. That 10% of GDP is a huge problem for long term compounding. It follows by contrast that other areas of economy in Africa must do better.
Frugality is a good Indian trait to have, that helps investor.
When I wanted to improve my vocabulary, I used to read editorials in Times of India and refer to dictionary. I was still finding new words after years, so I finally sat down with a dictionary and a Thesaurus and went through all the words. Same way, that model can be used to go through companies A-Z on the stock exchange.
SN: That’s a great thought indeed! Anyways, in your experience, what characteristics or attributes are advantageous for a value investor to have?
AA: Here are a few of them –
• Ability to be patient for months and years;
• Ability to think alone independently and make decisions without group consent;
• Enjoying reading annual reports;
• Reading about companies, business models;
• Openness to learn;
• Introspection to see one’s own faults, limitations aka biases; and
• Passion for material wealth
I think investing is a strange field where you can end up on top simply by living a very long life, rather than focussing on finding fastest growing companies. You can do well by compounding for a long term by avoiding mistakes. That is, by not focussing on breakthroughs, but by focus on elimination of mistakes.
SN: You seem to be focused on investing in other emerging markets apart from India (like Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, and Kenya). How has been your experience there vis-a-vis India? What are the specific challenges a multi-country investor faces?
AA: I found India expensive, hence decided to invest in other countries. But I still invested in India for personal funds.
India has several thousand stocks but other countries like Kenya have only 60, Bangladesh 200, Nigeria again couple of hundred, out of which only 10% may be worth investing in at any point.
We are invested in known names, so they are mostly discovered with exception of 2-3 companies in our portfolio of 12-13 stocks. So, returns may be moderate ~15% in USD terms.
The bad part is Kenyan Shilling and Nigerian Naira have depreciated 10-20% in the past 6 months which has impacted our returns, as we do not hedge. INR saw similar devaluation between 2011 and 2014.
Other risk is investing through custodian, solvency risk of custodian, shares may not be in your own name. But if you find custodian like HDFC Bank equivalent in India, then you may do fine. However, as we know now, nobody is too big to fail.
To overcome custodian risk, one can open 30 accounts in 10 countries. Three accounts in each country, one broker, one bank, one demat, that is a lot of admin work. Then dividends may not come in time due to absence of electronic clearance, you have to send a person to collect dividend warrant from the company.
SN: Given so many risks and efforts required to invest across countries, has it ever occurred to you to focus only on India? Or does the risk-return equation justify exposure to these other markets?
AA: We are quite optimistic about these emerging countries. There are several companies in Bangladesh, Nigeria for example which compounded topline/bottomline at around 20% and stock price compounded at 30-32% over past 10 years. That already tells you that these companies have been re-rated. That happened after 2013. There will be more small caps we will spot in those countries eventually, some of which we are hopeful of even now.
Our fund is invested only since 9 months as at August 2015, and USD returns in Kenya are Minus 15%, USD returns in Nigeria are Minus 40%, in Bangladesh the returns are +15% over this 12 month period ending August 2015. Our returns over past nine months were Plus 13.5% despite commissions (which are huge ~1% of trade plus currency exchange fee ~2%). We are open to investing anywhere including developed countries or China as well. Time to research is the only constraint.
Quality of companies we hold is par-excellence. These type are selling above 60-80 times earnings in India…like Asian Paints, Blue Dart.
Lastly, correlation with India is low, so that is valuable for someone who remains fully invested at all times.
We are quite positive about emerging countries. They will get more listings, they are few years behind India. In some cases, they are ahead of India…like Botswana has per capita of US$ 8,000 (compare to India’s US$ 1,800). India will do very well, especially due to the misunderstanding and information dis-equilibrium. My name is Amit, yours is Vishal, and there are more than one company on BSE starting with my name, more than five companies starting with your name. Although I don’t know their names, I am almost certain between your wife, mother and father, at least one out of three, possibly all three, there will be company listed on BSE with their names. With 1,000s of such unknown companies, there will always be opportunities.
SN: That’s a nice way to look at things, Amit! Anyways, what’s been the most difficult part of being a value investor, as per your experience?
AA: Pain of loss is more than pleasure of gain. So losing even 10% of portfolio still feels bad especially if it is due to a permanent mistake in one single idea, however, if overall the portfolio is down 10% or 30%, it feels normal.
SN: Okay so how do you overcome this part i.e., dealing with the pain of loss in individual stocks? Do you sell out if the stock falls below a certain percentage loss, or do you average down, or do you just avoid acting?
AA: I sell at first sign of trouble whether it is losing 20% or 40% or 60% of the principal capital. One can take consolation from future compounding in a better idea. I sell when I know the company is unlikely to deliver due to management issues, stealing, or permanent change in thesis.
SN: As mentioned on your fund’s website, you and your team believe in doing thorough research on businesses. What are some of the characteristics you look for in a high-quality business? What puts you off in businesses?
AA: We are investing mostly in businesses that takes Warren Buffett’s five minutes to analyse, for example, Unilever India, with a few exceptions in small caps space that need more analysis due to information gap.
High quality business also produces high quality experience more often than not. It’s hard to find high quality business producing ever cheaper products (eg: local quarry, buttons for T shirts, hangers). So, the countries that we are invested in, per capita income will go up significantly, risks are mainly political, not so much company specific as they are all leaders, whether they are 10 Million USD market cap or 300 Million USD market cap, we prefer leaders.
Second, we expect negligible or no debt with minimum return on equity of 20%.
Disclosures are not good in these countries, so we have to assess that from dividend payment.
If a company wants to take on more equity through rights or new issues at current market price, that puts us off. Debt in moderation is fine.
The company should value equity very preciously and if at all, offer at a very steep premium to private buyer. We don’t like companies issuing more shares, unless they are an accounting entry, as in bonus issue.
SN: How do you think about valuation? Do you have a preferred valuation framework to assess the attractiveness of an investment?
AA: No, we just like to buy into companies that we are confident that will be significantly bigger in next 4-5 years. We need growth of 14%+, 2-3% dividend yield, even then currency depreciation eats into the returns.
SN: But how do you justify whether you are “paying up” or “overpaying” for such an opportunity? And how big a role does dividend play in your decision, given that you mentioned dividend yield? Do you avoid businesses that don’t pay dividends?
AA: We are invested in companies from 5 P/E to 35 P/E, all of them are debt free, and all of them are market leaders in their industry. We don’t pay 100 times earnings or 60 times either. There has to be a better idea somewhere with less risk than investing in steep multiples. True, we will miss Infosys with that attitude, but on the whole will do just fine. If there is possibility of 15%+ growth for many years, then it’s fine to pay 30 times.
And yes, we do not invest in companies that do not pay any dividend.
I believe I can do just fine with a diversified portfolio of 40 companies or concentrated with 12 -14 companies, in my opinion and experience both will give more or less same returns, for an active investor willing to trade as well, currently in the latter camp, but very open move to former if there were 20s of investible companies listed.
SN: What are some of the tricks that you use to save yourself from behavioural biases? In other words, how do you minimize the mistakes of behaviour in your investment decision making?
AA: I am not sure of the tricks but living in the awareness of the biases is to avoid being trapped. Even then we all are trapped in behavioural biases.
For example, assume you have a portfolio you manage on behalf of someone, worth Rs 1 crore, and you have been managing it for past three years. Now, if another investor gives you Rs 1 crore of fresh funds to invest today, it will not look like what three year old portfolio looks like, assuming you had liquidity in all stocks. That proves bias.
Every morning we are making a choice to buy our portfolio fresh from equity markets, every investment is up for sale at right price.
Every investor in the world is already trapped with biases, not possible to completely overcome in my opinion
SN: Well, that’s absolutely true. Anyways, can you talk about your biggest real-life investment mistake, what caused it, and the lessons you learned from it?
AA: Well, some of them are –
1. Selling too early some of my investments
2. Not investing in equity market early enough
3. A portfolio position of single company
One of the other big lessons is to not have more than 25% position in a single idea. Other mistakes I believe I will keep making like selling too early.
But I actually live without regrets as I believe I am an eternal spirit.
SN: “Selling too early” is an Achilles Heel for most investors, and you have been honest to admit that it’s almost impossible to get over this mistake. But still, how do you try to take care of such a situation where you minimize the impact of such a mistake? I mean, if a stock has risen too far and too fast, do you sell a part of it instead of the whole?
AA: That is generally better in hindsight and a number of successful investors do that. They say, I am not buying CERA at 60 times earnings but I am not selling all of my quantity either. To me, if you are holding CERA at 60 times earnings, even if 20% of your original quantity, you actually bought it today in the morning from the stock market.
So, a stock that I am not buying more of, I am selling. So I sell 100% holding at once.
Only sometimes when an equity has become disproportionately large part of portfolio, like we bought Atul Auto at Rs 43 in partnership (adjusted for bonus/split) with 8% weight and it became something like 30% of portfolio once, so we cut it down to 15%. It is only a rare time I have sold partial quantity. Usually, the decision is to swap by another idea.
SN: How do you determine when to exit from a position? Are there some specific rules for selling you have?
AA: Earlier it was very simplistic 25 times earnings and I was out, or when I doubled my returns.
Then, I read Lynch who said that an investment can keep doubling, if not until infinity, till until the story is intact. We have nearly US$ 800 billion market cap company now, Apple.
I believe you must have covered this already in one of your writings about selling when:
• Original Hypothesis for investment was wrong;
• Another more prepossessing opportunity surfaced;
• Needed money for personal reasons; and
• Price was way above valuation.
I generally sell only when I find something much better than what I currently have. Sorry to put Buffett in a tight spot, but Coca Cola returned ZERO returns during 1998 – 2014, Buffett essentially lost to inflation on that opportunity for 16 years. So, selling will stay a harder part of investing.
SN: Hypothetical Question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?
AA: Unfortunately from where I see things, it is a fact that we are going to lose our memory within next 50 years at best.
Your question is more around short term memory loss, like story of Aamir Khan’s movie Gajini, a complete copy, sorry to say of Memento, Hollywood movie.
I will tell myself to get in touch with people who could help me, write a note to myself with list of books to read, but that will not be much useful if I continue to have the memory of Goldfish. However, if I continue to be functional with future memory that will not be further erased, then I have opportunity to learn and rewire. So, choosing people who could help me will be a better idea. So, one living role model in investing like Prof. Bakshi, one living role model in religion like Roy Eugene Davis, some books by living or eminent dead people like Vivekananda, Yogananda, Warren Buffett. Definitely a note on compounding.
SN: Wonderful! What’s your two-minute advice to new investors or students interested in a career in investing?
AA: Here is what I would ask someone starting out –
• Can you save well over 50% money from your salary?
• Do you have an exit plan from investing?
• Are you open to learning from your own mistakes?
• Can you sit alone in a room for 6 hours comfortably?
• Do you think you can learn from books and articles on investing?
If the answer to any of the above questions is No, then you should not be in investing.
SN: That’s simple enough, thanks! What are your interests and hobbies? What keeps you occupied outside of work and investing?
AA: I spend time with family and don’t socialise much outside. Looking for investing opportunities and reading and practicing some of what I read about religion takes rest of the time outside work.
I don’t like much physical work although I do lawn mowing, washing car, putting and taking off dishes in dishwasher, sometime laundry, vacuum cleaning the house, only sometimes cooking, drive my own car, clock 35 hours a week consulting in IT. That takes up all the time.
Now we have a kid on the way, so I feel that will leave no time in life. I already needed 48 hours a day. But I have postponed having a child as far as I could, I am 39 years old already and my wife is 37. Oh yes, having another wife could have solved that requirement, but it is too late. 😉
SN: In our past discussion, and from what I read on your blog, you read and contemplate metaphysical existential realities. Can you please explain more on this?
AA: I am mindful of the audience reading this. A thing should be given when needed, otherwise neither is it effective nor it has any value. Worst, it is mocked at. If all someone needs at this point in time is Rs 100 crore for example, it would be foolish on my part to be taking one away from that into say fighting for women rights, no matter what the possibilities are. There has to be a dying, burning and very intense longing to know the Truth. You want to know everything, the whole picture.
An example in India is story of person who was trying to find God for decades and yet he could not. Then he was taken to a shallow lake and his head was submerged by his spiritual preceptor under water forcefully for several minutes, nearly life force out of his body, he struggled one last time to come up, then he was allowed to come up and breathe. Upon asking how the disciple felt, “My only focus was only one gasp of air,” was his reply. His spiritual preceptor responded, that you will find God only when you desire Him even much more intensely than you wanted air to keep your body alive few moments back.
Also, spiritual path is not for weaklings, as Vivekananda said, “You need nerves of steel, muscles of iron and minds like thunderbolt.” Half-hearted effort will take one nowhere. If one is physically weak, Vivekananda asked him to play football instead and come back after he has muscles and toned body. To another who had no wife, money, job, he said, “Come back after you earn a few million rupees, you have nothing to sacrifice.”
I don’t want to point out any person, but there are apparently 99.9% crooks in this field, possibly even 100%, hence one is better choosing an eminent dead person in this field and following what he/she has taught.
It starts with this question: Who am I, how did I appear, isn’t my awareness of myself as human itself isn’t a miracle in itself. Einstein said,
There are only two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle.
Also, the questions could be: Does something in me lives on after this body dies?
One of the greatest Theoretical Physicists of our time, Max Planck who received Nobel Prize in Physics in 1918. He is the father of Quantum Physics. I will quote him:
I. “All matter originates and exists only by virtue of a force which brings the particle of an atom to vibration and holds this most minute solar system of the atom together. We must assume behind this force the existence of a conscious and intelligent mind. This mind is the matrix of all matter.”
II. “There can never be any real opposition between religion and science; for the one is the complement of the other. Every serious and reflective person realizes, I think, that the religious element in his nature must be recognized and cultivated if all the powers of the human soul are to act together in perfect balance and harmony. And indeed it was not by accident that the greatest thinkers of all ages were deeply religious souls.”
III. “Science cannot solve the ultimate mystery of nature. And that is because, in the last analysis, we ourselves are part of nature and therefore part of the mystery that we are trying to solve.”
Einstein adds –
A human being is part of a whole, called by us the ‘Universe’ – a part limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts, and feelings, as something separated from the rest — a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest us. Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circles of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in its beauty.
Now “contemplating metaphysical realities” on my part is a complete waste of time and mental sex if you will. Just as beliefs, it has no value. Beliefs are stepping stone which must be further progressed by faith and concrete steps. Same way contemplation should progress until a tangible experience has been gained.
It is probably beyond the scope of this discussion, but, there are higher realities than what most of the scientists are aware of, even leading scientists, and fortunately they are available to even a poor peasant. How hilarious it is that we have only four forces of nature accepted by Harvard or MIT or IIT for that matter2.
Science in present day is completely silent on the subject of mind, intelligence, ego and consciousness subject, so far. In Indian scriptures they are called Mann, Chitta, Buddhi and Ahankaar.
A few pointers for further reading and thinking:
• Baby is actively kicking and moving in mother’s womb, yet not breathing air, inside a water bubble, proves we can live without breathing.
• One can extend that hypothesis to prove that one can be conscious without body as well, several books have been written by atheist American MDs who documented complete recall by patients on operation theatre as they moved to the ceiling and recalled detailed medical procedure performed on them.
• When you die in a dream, you can never eliminate “I am”, that you exist. Same happens when you die not in a dream.
• When your state changes from dream to waking, both feel real, neither that is real nor this, to an open mind there could be possibility now of many states of mind other than waking, sleeping, dreamless sleeping.
Einstein said, “Space looks very suspicious, everything comes out of it and disappears into it again”
Finally, just because we are dead, we will not get any answers, because we do not become deserving, just by the transition out of material body, we have to work for the answers here and now while living.
To a lot of people, earning money and spirituality is contradictory. Take example of Steve Jobs, who had only “one book” downloaded on his iPad, he gave that book as gift during his funeral to all attendees, and he used to read it once a year. Today, he has gone where currency does not work, but his company is worth 800 Billion USD. The book is Autobiography of a Yogi3. So, one must have long and short term plan in life.
SN: Which books – which are not very popular – would you recommend to a budding investor for learning investing and multidisciplinary thinking?
AA: Two books that I liked were Just One Thing4 by John Maudlin, and The Mind of Wall Street5 by Leon Levy.
SN: Great, Amit! Thanks a lot again for sharing your amazing insights with Safal Niveshak readers. Thank you so much!
AA: It was my pleasure, Vishal. Thanks!
References
- Don’t Repeat Yourself
- Fundamental Interaction
- Autobiography of a Yogi
- Just One Thing
- The Mind of Wall Street
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years