• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Investor Insights: R.K. Chandrashekar

July 30, 2019

Mr. R.K. Chandrasekhar (RKC to his friends), is not your typical money manager or professional investor, but one amongst us retail investors whom I first met in 2011. Our bond has grown stronger since then, especially with RKC opening up his investment life in front of the Safal Niveshak tribe over the years, via his comments and feedback on my posts.

RKC started investing when I was born, so it’s quite a lot of years that he has been there, seen that. As a formal introduction, he is 67 years old and is an MS (O.R) from Case Western Reserve University and BSc (Mathematics) from Loyola College, Chennai. He is now retired from work after winding down his placement business in 2013.

In this interview, RKC talks about his long investment experience, his evolution as an investor, key lessons learned, his investment process, and how he tries to minimize decision making mistakes.

Disclaimer: Stocks/Examples quoted below should not be construed as recommendations.

[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]Safal Niveshak (SN): Before I pick your brains on investing, please share about your life, family, and career.

R.K. Chandrashekar (RKC): I was born in an upper-middle-class family – the youngest in a family of 5 children.

Our parents gave us good education, not wealth, made us stand on our feet, taught us that money needs to be shared, set examples in philanthropy – I am told that my father gave a donation of Rs 10,000 in the 1940s to Acharya Pathshala, an educational institution (Bangaloreans are familiar with) when the school was going through tough times. Rs 10,000 was a princely sum those days.

My father also gifted his full share of agricultural land in favour of his younger brother, who was saddled with a large family. It’s another matter that no gratitude was shown.

In those days, our house was like a choultry and my older cousins who are now dead and the ones in their 80’s, recall very fondly. Some of them stayed with us for years doing their graduation and had great regard and respect for my parents, particularly my mother who looked after them like her own children.

They say charity begins at home and today, I am proud to say that my wife and I have taken under our wings an aunt of mine for many years and another aunt with polio was provided financial support by my brother and me till her death.

HCL’s motto has been “Employee First Customer Second”. My mother practiced this for years! As a child, I used to wonder why my housemaid/servant gets his breakfast before me at times. We had servants who stayed with us for generations and even today my wife follows the same, having learned the trick from her mother-in-law!

On the professional front, I quit the rate race even before IT became fashionable and work-life balance not thought of. I set up my placement services business from home and hired a Business Center – part-time to meet and interview candidates after office hours.

I was clear from the very beginning that I would not be a volume player, but build the business on niche skills, trust and timely delivery of service.

My friends used to envy me, as I went off on holidays twice a year. While all of us in the Technology hiring business got affected during the dot-com crash and post-2008 Recession, I was less dented due to the low-cost model of my business. Then, having spent 20 years in this business, I closed shop, put my feet up to pursue my passion for holidaying, traveling and becoming the family historian.

SN: What got you into investing, and how did you begin to learn about the market and investing in general?

RKC: From an early age, at home, I was known as someone who is careful with money. Pocket money saved to buy books and not splurge on partying/friends. So I got into the savings habit once I started earning with no financial commitment.

I had a colleague in Kirloskar Electric where I worked, who gave me an introduction to stocks by selling 25 shares of HUL @ Rs 25/share (FV10, year: 1977-78).

It also coincided with FERA Dilution of MNCs. A real lottery, since the price of IPO was fixed by CCI very low to the intrinsic value.

I got allotments in Colgate, and Warren Tea. These were exciting times and we used to apply in multiple names to increase the chances of allotment.

I had a fair knowledge of Finance and Economics, having taken a course in Managerial Economics as part of my MS(O.R) and exposed to DCF (discounted cash flow).

But honestly, I never applied that before investing!

There were no investment magazines back then – Capital Market and Dalal Street came in the mid-1980s, so it was broker and the gossip on the market floor!

SN: What would you say is one of the most important lessons you learned early on?

RKC: It was that the daily price movements of stocks are not based on company fundamentals alone but more to do with human emotions, greed, demand and supply.

Another important lesson learned early on was – never borrow and invest in stocks. As a corollary, which I learned very bitterly much later – never lend money to someone who invests in the stock market (I gave a few lakhs to my co-brother in 1989-90), to invest in stocks with guaranteed 2% per month. Unfortunately, he died in an accident, his father had a heart attack a few months later, his partner ran away, and his family who had assets washed its hands-off.

SN: How would you describe your investment philosophy?

RKC: Invest in a portfolio of businesses (high degree of moat, market leadership, top-class management, sound business ethics) to generate wealth over the long term with the power of compounding.

SN: How do you typically find ideas and what is your selection process before an idea gets added to your portfolio?

RKC: I find ideas from day to day experiences – while shopping, watching the TV-particularly the advertisements – remember the fishing net and Fevicol jingles, Hamara Bajaj and Desh Ki Dhadkan, reading and observing what is being bought/sold. Painters first choice – Asian Paints. Plumbers swear by Fevicol. Children love Maggie and Kit Kat.

Growing incidence of diabetes and sugar-free substitutes lead me to Zydus Wellness, Knowledge of the IT industry where I have worked zeroed me to Infosys. Pedigree while investing in an IPO gave me HDFC Bank.

Another important idea I have looked at is MNCs who have technology leadership/ strong roots in India/delisting potential/buybacks. This has led me to Bosch, HUL, GSK Pharma and iFlex.

The single most important factor I consider important is the return on equity (ROE), which indicates how efficiently the company is in using the shareholders’ money. I look at consistency over many years. I have noticed that higher ROEs command a higher price in the market, a reason why MNCs like Colgate and Nestle are at high valuations.

These days, I look for companies which return a large amount of cash back to the shareholders, since I live on dividends. My largest holding company recently announced that they would return 75% by way of buybacks and dividends.

As a starting point, here are ratios I look at before investing –

  • Cash EPS – Positive and high
  • ROE – 20%+
  • Dividend Payout Ratio – 25-30%.
  • Debt/Equity – Nil or Very low, depending on the industry

SN: How do you take care of ‘risks’ while investing?

RKC: One, I diversify. In fact, my weakness has been over-diversification!

I have spread across direct equity, mutual funds, ETF, gold, real estate, venture capital funds, and an art fund.

Two, invariably I buy stocks in small quantities, spread over many months, like a SIP in mutual funds.

This way, if the initial picking was wrong, I would exit and my loss would be minimal. If the subsequent investments (SIP) were at a higher price, it would reinforce that my original pick was a good one, though my average purchase price would have gone up.

SN: What have been the most challenging investment lessons you have learned?

RKC: Well, here are some of them…

  • Not to fall in love with your stocks, even the bluest of blue chips – they can’t love you back! As in life, so in stocks, detachment is a must-have attribute. As a corollary, never chase stocks that are on your wishlist and timing exits of winners is a real challenge.
  • Never speculate, do not go short in the market. Buy if you are sure of taking delivery and you have sufficient funds in your account.
  • You can never predict exactly or with a fair amount of success the future price of a stock/index/market – so don’t be obsessed with the price if you like the stock and all other factors are in your favour. Many may not agree, but if that was not the case, I could never have picked a Nestle, CRISIL, Bosch or HDFC Bank.

SN: How has your approach toward investing changed over the years?

RKC: My basic philosophy hasn’t changed.

I have always been a buy-and-hold type of investor, but the process and the system has changed for the better.

In the olden days, I would say the price discovery was inefficient – the company could manipulate the price by simply calling for a book closure!

Share certificates would get stuck for months with the company. We had a host of problems then – storage and loss of certificates, signature mismatch, transfer deed validity, odd lots, et al.

Again you needed to find a trustworthy broker since they could easily cheat you with the price since the trade details would be given at the end of the day. We were more bothered by these problems and hardly any systematic research was done on the companies we chose to buy!

There were no FIIs or business channels on the TV with stock experts sprouting their Buy and Sell recommendations. Biggest investors back then must have been LIC and UTI.

In those days, we could get away by investing with minimal research and more common sense, as we were a closed economy and markets were not efficient. That is not the case today – we are saddled with data and all and sundry give their expert opinion. Today, we need to shut the noise and do our own homework before investing.

I have been fortunate that my buy and hold has turned out winners once India opened to FIIs and our GDP expanded from a Hindu growth rate of 2% to 8%+. However, it was not always hunky-dory.

There was a period for many years when I chose to shut myself from investing in the stock market – this was when I lost my shares and the money deposited with my co-brother. Soon after, the Harshad Mehta frenzy and his crazy “replacement cost” theory took over. I bid my time and started nibbling in stocks.

Having tasted success with the MNCs back in the 1970s and 1980s, I picked companies like Glaxo, Atlas Copco, Carrier Aircon, Bata, Castrol, and ITC…and also took small bets systematically in BHEL and L&T.

Gaining confidence, I started picking larger quantities of companies like TTK Prestige (around Rs 35 per share), Tata Steel and LIC Housing.

I read Peter Lynch’s book in 2001-02 and that influenced me to look at companies which are part of our everyday lives – companies with brand value, market share and professional management…the likes of Hero Honda, Nestle, Asian Paints, HUL, Pidilite, Bosch, Infosys, and Castrol.

These, along with L&T, ITC, HDFC Bank, LIC Housing, Tata Steel and BHEL, became my core portfolio.

One important lesson learned is that after all the analyses, invest in companies with sound and professional management with business ethics and long-standing in the industry – companies that can overcome short-term business downturns and emerge stronger.

While I invested in great companies with pedigree, I had my share of rotten apples – Pentafour, Silverline, Oswal Agro, United Diagnostics – which have vanished without a trace!

SN: The sheer amount of irrelevant information faced by investors is truly staggering today. Today we find ourselves captives of the information age. Anything you could possibly need to know seems to appear at the touch of the keypad. However, rarely, if ever, do we stop and ask ourselves exactly what we need to know in order to make a good decision.

How can investors trapped by irrelevant information make independent investment decisions? What are the few factors investors can use to improve the quality of their decision making? How do you do it?

RKC: “Keep it simple” is my philosophy. Certain behavioral traits which have helped me include the following –

  • Don’t be impulsive. Practice procrastination.
  • Believe that investing is not the be-all and end-all. Once you cultivate this attitude, investing becomes fun, and not stressful. You would then lay more emphasis on experiences than attachments. Let me clarify this. The joy of seeing children grow up or helping the needy and old will be more satisfying than seeing the price of my Asian Paints stock up.
  • Acting frequently doesn’t make you a successful investor. On the contrary, more you act, more will be the mistakes you are likely to make.
  • It is the information overload that makes one act frequently and hastily – the fear of losing out. So, to cut out all the noise, a few tips would help –
    1. Believe that the future is uncertain and can’t be predicted with 100% accuracy. As a consequence, you would eliminate or take a balanced view of the expert opinions voiced on media channels.
    2. Know what you need to know and cut out the rest. Ways of doing this would include preparing a checklist of factors to evaluate a stock, practicing discipline by way of autosuggestion and meditation. Sincerely believing that evaluating a stock is not esoteric and knowing and doing a few simple things is all to it.
    3. Know your competencies, limitations and work around them to your advantage.
    4. In the initial stages, you may wish to block business news channels and print media, though I do watch for time pass and even to take a contrarian view.
    5. Knowing how to read a balance sheet can be learned reading some simple financial books for non-finance people or from Safal Niveshak where Vishal also tells you what to look out for in the annual reports. Be aware of what is happening in the industry and any governance issue in the company is a red flag.

SN: As investors, one of the most difficult decisions we must make is with respect to selling stocks. What factors help you make “sell” decisions?

RKC: I sell if any one of these conditions is met:

  • If the initial decision to pick the stock was a mistake.
  • Market has changed dramatically for the company – competition, government policy, corporate governance issues.
  • P/E multiple is way too high and I see a good profit on the table.
  • Find a better opportunity elsewhere.
  • I need the money – personal expenditure.
  • Reduce exposure to a particular sector/industry.

SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements or themes? What investment process/philosophy you have changed/updated based on your past mistakes? Real-life examples would be helpful.

RKC: The common element in my past mistakes would be over-diversification, which in turn resulted that I couldn’t commit more funds when I was fully convinced in a stock. I never knew there is something called ‘circle of competence’ and that you need to stick to that. Since I had many stocks, 50+ in my portfolio, I couldn’t monitor them efficiently and invariably didn’t add more or sold early before realizing their true potential.

Given the price back then of Asian Paints, CRISIL, Nestle, Bosch, L&T, Pidilite, and others, I could have bought tons but ended up buying a few hundred. Nevertheless, it is a pretty chunk by today’s value. I could have held on to Colgate (IPO), but sold it when I thought they were relying only on toothpaste and competition from Levers and others would kill them. Those 25 shares with bonus and splits would have been 25,000 shares today, and worth around Rs 3 crore! Power of compounding at its best.

Again, I lost patience in TTK and thought 100% appreciation in Page Industries (400 to 800) was good enough! Recently, while browsing through my old contract notes, I noticed that I had 250 MRF bought in 1989 and sold in the same year!

On the flip side, I have been lucky holding on to shares which I wouldn’t buy today (not competent to understand the industry), like HDFC Bank and Shree Cement. Another weakness of mine is not taking advantage of special situations since I am cool-headed.😁

I didn’t add to my existing holding when Satyam presented itself in the form of Ramalinga Raju’s disclosure (I was busy telling all and sundry), and then again when Nestle melted like Kit Kat chocolates during the Maggi fiasco. No one talked about Warren Buffett, moat and value investing in the late ’70s and early ’80s. Rumors, gossips and broker advice ruled the roost.

Had Safal Niveshak been around and we followed its value philosophy, I would have been a billionaire by now, seriously; thankfully no regrets!

Today, I am weeding out stocks and whatever I buy, which is very rare, is only if I understand the industry and it passes the simple financial ratios test that I have mentioned elsewhere. Most of the stocks in my folio today have been with me for over 20 years and I am proud to say my longest holding is the first stock I bought – Hindustan Unilever, going strong at 40 years.

This reminds me of the iconic ad of the legendary watch – “You never actually own a Patek Philippe. You merely look after it for the next generation.” Just like the good old HUL, I own an Omega since 1973 (I didn’t pay for it though). While HUL is working, my Omega is not! 😁

SN: What is the best investment advice you have ever received?

RKC: Time in the market is more important than timing the market.

SN: What is the worst investment advice you have ever received?

RKC: This is from a relative, who said that every stock that has fallen will one day wake up. Incidentally, he borrowed money from his colleagues, promised them high returns and invested in the stock market. He vanished after running huge debts. (His family, wife, and children disowned him). He died recently, a lonely dejected man.

SN: What has been your favourite investing-related book and why?

RKC: It has to be “One Up on Wall Street” by Peter Lynch.

It is built on the premise that so much of information is around us, if only we observe our immediate world – shopping malls, the workplace, etc. We will discover a wealth of investment opportunities. We can easily beat the professional analysts on Dalal Street.

Following this philosophy, I have gained from picking these stocks early (purchase price in brackets) – Asian Paints (955), Bosch (4768), Infy (302), ITC (62), Nestle (1444), Pidilite (62), Zydus Wellness (180), and not to speak of HDFC Bank (IPO) and HUL (3.50 after adjusting for bonus and rights). (Note: Some of the prices quoted may be misleading as there may have been bonuses/stock splits after the purchase)

SN: If you had one piece of advice to share with other tribesmen, what would it be?

RKC: Buy right and sit tight. Think Colgate and what it would have done to me!

Patience and time in the market can cover up a lot of sins while creating wealth. So even if the initial price was a bit on the higher side, or the company was going through a difficult phase in the short to medium term – over the long term that would get ironed out, provided of course that you have picked your stock correctly. With P/E expansion over time, your cost of acquisition would look pittance as the above examples show.

Also, do not neglect companies which are liberal with dividends – you can build a retirement nest of regular pension in the form of tax-free dividends (now up to 10 lakhs). It could to some extent protect your investments during a market downturn.

SN: Who are some of the people – inside or outside the value investing circles – who have inspired you the most over the years, and why?

RKC: My mother has been the greatest inspiration, not just me but for a whole lot of our large extended family. She blended her conservative village background with modern thinking which was truly amazing for someone born nearly 100 years ago. She was interested in stocks, knew that they would be wealth creators and motivated me to apply for the juicy IPO’s back then. She herself held a few.

SN: A hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning? Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?

RKC: I have a very good memory and I am the family historian. That’s why this is a frightening prospect and an interesting question. Having said that, first and foremost, I would tell myself who I am and chronicle my relationship with my immediate family, sibling, and in-laws with photographs. This would matter the most. I will talk about the family albums which will showcase all the near and dear ones from birth, growing up, marriage and beyond. I will direct myself to my blog, which will rekindle funny incidents, happenings, and events in the large extended family, right from my childhood to the present day. Rest is easy, thanks to technology and the internet. All critical and financial data are stored in soft copy on the smartphone or on the cloud. My family is my biggest strength and I am sure they will be patient and help me recoup. I have brought them smiles through my blogs and this should be their payback time!

SN: Wonderful! Thanks a lot, RKC, for sharing your thoughts, insights, and experiences. Very valuable, indeed!

RKC: Thanks Vishal for putting me in the spotlight and making me use my grey cells. I only bring it out to play Sudoku, and…now! 😉

For all the readers out there, a simple final word of advice. Don’t take life too seriously, neither be exuberant or paranoid. Strike a balance. Always remember these words from Helen Keller — “I cried because I had no shoes until I met a man who had no feet.”

Cheers and God bless.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members

 

  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe

[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Interviews

Handcrafted with in India