As an eventful 2018 winds to a close, it’s a good time to reflect on the investment principles/lessons that turbulent markets this year have once again reminded us of. Towards this, we picked the brains of a few experienced investors on these two questions –
- With respect to your own investing experience, what was the biggest lesson you drew out from or learned in 2018?
- Which is the best book you read in 2018, and why?
Let’s read out their replies below.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Morgan Housel
Partner, Collaborative Fund
Lesson from 2018 – This lesson isn’t necessarily specific to 2018, but this year again I was reminded that unsustainable things can last for years, even decades, longer than you think.
The bull market we’ve had over the last decade has been amazing, but there’s been too much attachment to the idea that it must end soon. It’s been “obvious” that the market would contract in the year ahead since, I don’t know, 2010 now. Anything can happen and often does.
Best Book – Rocket Men. It shows, better than any book I’ve read, what people are capable of if they put their minds to it.
Prabhakar Kudva
Investor and Co-Founder, Samvitti Capital
Lesson from 2018 – This year as I reflected on my errors, one recurring theme stood out – the idea of circle of competence. We have read about it several times; however, I am not sure how many of us really imbibe it with sincerity and follow it with discipline. As I went through my errors of judgement, I realised how immensely powerful the idea is and how it’s a huge factor in making returns.
Let me explain. The key to making money in any investment is not the idea but the execution. Identifying, say Amazon, is not enough. The ability to sit through the painful drawdowns and negative news is the real key to making money.
Now if a given company is not in your circle of competence or even if it’s at the edge of your circle, the market will shake you out too soon due to various factors. More importantly, unless you understand the business dynamics and the management well, you will always be second guessing during every small crisis and lose your position.
Similarly, when the stock is falling, you will not be able to buy more if you’re not sure. So the key to making big money in the markets is to ensure you only look at stuff
that’s in your circle of competence and ignore all else – because while it may look like you’re missing out on many opportunities, the reality is that even if you buy those you won’t be allowed by the market forces to make anything meaningful out of it.
Your circle of competence will define your conviction, your allocation, your temperament and eventually your return. It’s a great idea that I believe isn’t taken as seriously as it should be.
Best Book – Direct Truth by Kapil Gupta. It’s not a book for everyone and not everyone should agree with its premise. But it’s a radical approach to how one should look at the world and life in general.
Ian Cassel
Microcap Investor & Founder, MicroCapClub
Lesson from 2018 – Here are a few key takeaways from the year gone by –
1. Predicting vs Adapting – Twenty-two chief market strategists at major banks predict the S&P 500’s annual performance at the start of every year. The average difference between their forecast and what the market actually does is 14.7 percentage points per year (source). These strategists are paid millions of dollars to predict the future and they are very wrong every year.
If we are being honest, our own predictions and expectations are equally horrible. If I were to try to predict where my own portfolio will be in 12-months, I would probably be off by a similar amount. Predicting prices is impossible. You can’t control the wind. You can only control the sail.
Focus on the business, not the stock. Keep a pulse of the company and industry. The stock might go in and out of favour, but if the business keeps growing and earning more money, the market will come back to it. If your maintenance due diligence senses things have changed for the worse, you sell and redeploy elsewhere. Do all the work that you can but also accept you aren’t going to be right all the time. Leave your ego at the door.
Your success as an investor has less to do with predicting the future as it does adapting to the future. This is true of the positions in your portfolio, as well as your overall strategy.
2. Evolve or Go Extinct – “I think one of the frustrations you hear with a lot of value managers today is, what I did 20 years ago isn’t working anymore. I think that’s always been the case…” – Bill Nygren
I think it is crucial now more than ever to evolve as an investor. You need to be open to killing bad beliefs and convictions. To do so you need to be continuously learning from the successes and mistakes of others.
The best way to kill bad investing beliefs, theories, and convictions is studying great investors that invest differently than you. At first it can be unsettling and uncomfortable, but it’s an incredible tool for taking your investing to the next level.
For example, I put a lot of emphasis on trying to find intelligent fanatics early. But then I’ll talk to a great investor that puts no emphasis on management or even looks for bad management teams.
So, what do they look for? What is their thought process? In addition, I now read more books and articles on non-value investors than I do on value investors. It allows me to find holes in my strategy and belief systems while applying techniques and nuggets of wisdom I’ve learned to help me think different and better.
3. Slow Down – The biggest impediment to long-term wealth creation is your desire to get rich as quickly as possible. I find that far too many microcap investors would rather have a 5% shot at a 500% return in the next in 6 months rather than an 85% chance at a 100% return in the next 36 months. I get caught up into it as well. It’s our human nature.
The way I slow myself down is asking myself: “Where can I conservatively double my money in 3-years?”
This statement might sound aggressive to some investors, but to most microcap investors this sounds very boring. If you double your money in 3-years, it is a 26% compounded annual return. If you can do that over the long-term, you are one of the best investors on the planet.
The point of the statement above isn’t the return as much as it is to force you to slow down with emphasis on the word “conservatively.”
A big misperception is when people think “multi-bagger” means ascending quickly in a short period of time. Just like a fine wine, they often take their time to mature and develop.
Instead of focusing on where you can make 500% in the next 6 months, invert that and find situations where you can’t lose over the next few years. The latter is often where you will find the next great winner.
Best Book – A book that stood out to me this year was The Search for God and Guinness. The book tells the story of Guinness Brewing Company, which has dominated brewing for over 200 years. Much of its success has been due its founding values and incredible amount of social good the company has injected into the community.
Ankur Jain
Investor & Investment Advisor
Lesson from 2018 – The need to contain optimism. As investors, we get carried away with the mood around us. Exercising discipline in valuation, price and position size is what I would assess as the most important lesson. The same would hold true when the overall environment is gloomy.
As Buffett said, “Be fearful when others are greedy. Be greedy when others are fearful.”
Best Book – The Outsiders by Will Thorndike. It contains case studies on eight unconventional CEOs. There were two most important things which I learnt from the book –
- In the acknowledgements section, the author mentions that he worked on the book along with students at Harvard Business School. Each case study took one full academic year to complete. One full year to research one case. That was an amazing amount of depth explored and it showed up in the quality of cases. The key takeaway was that depth of work and quality of output are often closely co-related.
- Each of the CEOs was not hesitant to take actions which at some point of time were quite large in relation to net worth of the businesses (~30-40% of the net worth or even larger). They did that only when they were sure about the actions and when the prices (buy or sell) were very much in their favour. So, a large part of their outstanding results was dependent on a few large actions they took. That remains true for businesses and for investments. That was the second takeaway for me.
Samit Vartak
Partner & CIO, SageOne Investment Advisors
Lesson from 2018 – This year’s learning (reiteration of past learning) has been about how quickly data reverts and how price movements drive investor confidence.
In my January 2018 memo, I had presented the divergence of small/mid-cap universe (vs large caps and historical averages) in terms of their historic valuation levels and especially how their returns had completely decoupled from the low earnings growth. It took barely 6 months to revert those levels to mean. It’s astonishing how mean reversion finds reasons which seem so simple in hindsight but extremely difficult looking ahead. It’s even more amazing how exact opposite divergence is now getting created in large caps vs the smaller universe. There is no bigger confidence booster than the price action and that’s what large caps and especially consumer oriented consistent stocks have provided this year. Lessons learnt as recent as this year are easily overthrown by confidence generated by performance.
When crude was hitting highs and INR hitting new lows, no one was willing to believe that these kinds of volatile macros can easily reverse, and one should not base their investment decisions on such macros. Again, easy in hindsight but difficult to fight the price action when you are in midst of the price action.
Best Book – This year has seen swings to extremes of market levels as well as investor confidence. It’s easy to get confused and question one’s investment philosophy in such times. If I had to list one book that helped me this year, it would be Strength in Stillness: The Power of Transcendental Meditation by Bob Roth. Having a calm mind to ride through such volatile times is crucial and this book definitely helped. Other reading (not a book, but few of the most powerful pages) that has been even more helpful for me is Ashtavakra Gita. It has helped me focus on the right things in life rather than worry about just the outcome, which is out of one’s control and unpredictable in the short run.
Gaurav Sud
Investor & Managing Partner, Kanav Capital Advisors
Lesson from 2018 – Ever since 2008, I have been wary of a sharp downward correction in the market, when it is trading at rich valuations, which was the case in January 2018. I was 40% in cash then.
While it looks that I was well prepared for the crash we saw this year, the fact was that I have been between 25-40% cash since 2015. If anything, given the frenzy in late 2017 and early 2018, I should have sold more but didn’t. So, while I lost out some of upside of 2015-17, I did not really benefit out of my caution even though I felt the market was really overvalued in January 2018.
The other big lesson for me was that in my hunt for reasonably priced stocks, I started ignoring the quality of management. In mid-2017, I made a big allocation to a stock that was much cheaper than the leader in the sector and had announced a restructuring. I ignored the past corporate governance issues in the company. Since then, that stock has corrected over 60% and made me realize the folly of ignoring corporate governance and management quality.
Another lesson was that since I was sitting on cash when the correction started, I was able to observe and act much more dispassionately than what I did in the earlier corrections. I have now realized that as I age, my risk appetite has gone down and reducing the volatility in my portfolio (more specifically in my net worth) is important. So, for me, capital preservation is as important a goal as return on capital.
Best Book – Misbehaving by Richard Thaler. Thaler has been a pioneer in behavioural economics and was awarded the 2017 Nobel Prize for Economics. This book has helped me understand my behaviour as an investor.
The concept of “homo economicus” (one who is always rational and driven by self-interest) and a core construct in classical economics, has been debunked in a very humorous way.
It has clearly highlighted that investing is more driven by temperament than IQ. As humans, all of us have biases, many of which have developed as part of our evolution. We must first learn about these biases and then try to overcome some of them, to be truly successful in the long term.
Shyam Sekhar
Chief Ideator, iThought
Lesson from 2018 – Let me start with a disclaimer. I don’t regret the business of regretting. It is a part of every one of us. We shall learn to regret and move on. Regret is after all a form of grief. And, unlike in grief which comes to us in ways beyond our control, regret is largely from something we did not control. But regret is a good thing if we know how to channel it.
I recall channeling my regret very effectively in 2009. So, let me go back to trying it all over again. Looking at it objectively, I have little choice as an investor. So, one might as well enjoy it. Learning to becoming better at control is the only way to deal with regret.
If you live in regret on what you failed to do in a year, you don’t live to do what you need to in the next. What I learnt in 2009 came back to haunt in 2018. Unlike in 2009, when the regrets had to do with my buying, this time, the regrets are mostly to do with selling. There were three kinds of them. The selling I didn’t do fast enough. Or, the selling I didn’t do enough. Or, the selling I never did.
When you don’t sell enough, or fail to sell fast enough, or fail to sell at all, it is just your personality that stands out. You simply fail to move yourself beyond your core personality. And often, you are a complex mishmash of all three stereotypes.
Dealing with each has to be different. When you don’t sell enough, you just decide whether you still want to sell and move on. This is something I did in the later part of 2018 to satisfaction. How can I do this differently in the future?
My key takeaway is to start looking for the #BigSellDay. As an investor with more to sell, the only time one can sell a lot is when there are more people willing to buy even more than I want to sell. If I sell a few thousand shares every day, I was never going to sell enough.
If I don’t sell enough, I still can sell whatever I am left with and move on. I only need to not remain price anchored. Look at the decision afresh. If the facts are looking different now, the decision must be changed. The mistake most investors do is they believe that they shall remain steadfast in their conviction even when the facts change drastically. This is not about us. It is about the facts. So, when they change, we are free to as well.
On the selling I never did, there is no excuse. I just put my hands up, start afresh at the decision and do whatever it takes. Sometimes, we are not hungry enough for profits, so we fail to take them. Or, we don’t even think about taking them. There is no escape from this.
When the markets are too generous, we don’t really have an escape from this trap. How do you remain hungry for more profits when the markets are raining profits on you in a year? You are bound to let a few slip by. Actually, the best thing you can do, and it is the toughest thing, is to accept your fallibility, start afresh to sell and go away. I don’t think I am left with more options. So, I shall slowly learn to reach some middle point on this.
As I write this, the best middle point is to not repeat the same mistakes in the next cycle. As for now, treat every such total-miss opportunity as a fresh decision. Life goes on.
Best Book – The book I loved reading this year was The Sleep Revolution by Arianna Huffington. The most underrated aspect of life is sleep and I believe investors think it is a virtue to be awake for hours and hours just reading. The book is a wake-up call.
In the quest for holistic development, sleep is the most underrated thing. We live under the belief that we can do with less and less of sleep. What time is for investing, sleep is to health. If it is beyond your sleeping time, stop reading this, put your lights out and pull your rug over. Happy sleeping!
Jae Jun
Investor & Founder, Old School Value
Lesson from 2018 – Here are a couple of lessons –
- Just as how a rising tide lifts all stocks, a choppy (or bear) market can sink any stock regardless of quality or valuation. To many investors, this is the first time they have experienced turbulence and have seen their year to date gains disappear within a few months.
- Valuation and portfolio management plays an important role in order to weather the storm. Buffett said to be fearful when others are greedy. Rather than being fearful, being sceptical of high prices, knowing roughly what a stock is worth, and being more active in managing my portfolio by either cutting positions, selling or adding to positions has helped keep my portfolio in positive territory (so far).
Best Book – Narrative and Numbers: The Value of Stories in Business by Aswath Damodaran.
- Fundamentals are important, but many times, value investors get too trapped in the details of working out the perfect discount rate or next year’s growth rate. Damodaran helps to expand your horizon and think bigger when valuing companies. The stock price is always reflecting a certain story and it is up to you to decipher whether that story will become a reality and the current stock price is justified.
- An easy example is Amazon. Value investors (I included) shunned the company because it lost money. By overly focusing on the current financials and not truly understanding the story, value investors missed out on a huge run. Now we know the extent to which Amazon can challenge and dominate any market it enters.
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years