Jiten is an entrepreneur and a passionate long-term investor. He has been investing in the market since 1993, starting with US equities and then Indian equities in 2002.
In this interview, Jiten shares his evolution as an investor, key lessons learned, his investment process especially in investing in cyclical industries, and how he tries to minimize decision making mistakes.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]Safal Niveshak (SN): Please share about your background and the key factors that have shaped your life as a business owner and investor? You have a business experience across industries like technology, real estate, and laminates. So, what inspired you into a full-time career in investing?
Jiten Parmar (JP): I come from a very modest background. I did my engineering in Computer Science from Mumbai University in 1990 and got the opportunity to work with HP in Mountain View, California in 1992. My father was an IPO investor and he still holds some of his investments like HUL, etc. I dreamt of having my own business from college days. And was also drawn to investing in other people’s businesses through the stock markets.
My first investment in stock markets (1993) was a software company in the US (a giant then too having a dominant share in PC operating systems). Over the next ten years, I invested in the US markets, especially in my domain of tech companies. Of course, it was not a primary focus, as I co-founded a technology consulting company in 1995 in the US. Our company grew very well as it was probably the first Java consulting company in the world. In 1998-99, we got an offer to be acquired by a Nasdaq-listed company, and we agreed. This made me financially-independent at the age of 30, which was my dream. Our timing turned out to be good, as the dotcom crash happened in 2000.
I returned to India in 1999. Post that, I started with other businesses like real estate development, and a packaging company. I also started giving more time to investing in the Indian markets and learning to understand companies and their financials. Reading financials and balance sheets didn’t come naturally to me due to my science background, but over time I learned it.
I also started understanding economics, market cycles, business cycles. Over the next two decades, I tried to learn as much as I can and my favorite topic has been investing in companies, understanding the business and market cycles. Investing has taught me to be a lifelong learner and I am fascinated in understanding new businesses and sectors.
In 2018, I started Aurum Capital, a SEBI-registered Investment Advisory firm.
SN: That quite a journey you have traveled, Jiten. Thanks for sharing! How have you evolved over the years as an investor? What part of your thought process has changed the most?
JP: Over the years, I have learned to be patient with my investments. Learned to keep rewarding the winners, accept mistakes, learn from them, and make fewer of them. I have realized that investing is a mix of art, psychology, history, and science (importance in that order).
SN: How do you find your ideas? What are the necessary conditions that you would look at before you invest in a company and the additional conditions that that will just go about reinforcing your confidence in the company?
JP: Ideas come from many sources. Lot of it through observing things and being alert. Since I have developed an understanding of sectors over the years, a lot of my ideas come from the business cycles of those sectors. I have a very flexible approach to investing and am always willing to learn and fine-tune my investment strategy.
What might have worked in the past, may not work in the future, so one needs to keep evolving. At the same time, simplicity is very important. I don’t over-analyze. Before investing in any company, I look at the history of the company, its past track record, read at least five years of its annual reports, if not more, and financials for last ten years, if available. I also look at cash flows, which I think are very important. Debt on books is also important to look at. And at some times, one can make great returns from highly leveraged companies, if you can get the cycle right. I always keep EV (Enterprise Value) as an important parameter.
Let’s look at a small example. A company has a market cap of Rs 500 crore and debt of Rs 4,000 crore. So, EV is Rs 4500 crore (market cap + debt). If one gets the business cycle right, and the company reduces debt of Rs 500 crore, the equity value doubles. Just want to add that is not easy as debt can kill you too, so your understanding of the business, sector cycle, and market cycle needs to be very good to do this.
SN: The sheer amount of irrelevant information faced by investors is truly staggering today. Today we find ourselves captives of the information age. Anything you could possibly need to know seems to appear at the touch of the keypad. However, rarely, if ever, do we stop and ask ourselves exactly what we need to know in order to make a good decision.
How can investors trapped by irrelevant information make independent investment decisions? What are the few factors investors can use to improve the quality of their decision making?
JP: Data overload is a big concern. It can be very distracting. Over a period, one needs to be able to look at data of relevance, as more than 90% of data is not meaningful for analysis. Same data is available nowadays with everyone, and so it’s the INFERENCE and INTERPRETATION of data which is more important, and which separates the men from the boys, so to speak. Understanding business is most important, and if one is able to understand that, a lot of things fall in place.
SN: A lot of long-time investors have said that they took concentrated bets during the initial phase of their investing life, and later they diversified. How has your journey been on this front? What are your thoughts on concentration vs diversification?
JP: I have always been a diversified investor. Though my top 20 stocks would be about 90% of my portfolio, I might have another 20 stocks which make 10% of my portfolio, but they are there for a reason to track sectors. They are there to be scaled-up or cut from the portfolio. I think when one’s portfolio becomes bigger, diversification increases. I have seen many concentrated investors also diversifying once their portfolio becomes bigger.
SN: You have done some work on business cycles. Can you please help us through your work in a couple of specific sectors and what lessons you implemented and learned out of the same?
JP: Yes, I have done a lot of work on business cycles and market cycles. My approach to cyclical investing essentially makes me more diversified, as I use a basket approach. I would invest in multiple companies in a sector. This is all explained in my cyclical investing presentation on CNBC and on my blog.
I also want to emphasize that I am a value-oriented investor. Cyclical investing is nothing but value investing. It’s about buying an asset or business as distress valuation, after understanding the cycle and possibility of the cycle turning.
Cyclical investing is very counter-intuitive and highly contrarian. You are buying when companies are making losses or low profits, return ratios are bad, and so on. And selling when companies are making huge profits, return ratios drastically improving, etc. These turn out to be lonely trades. No one is looking at the sector. Once the cycle turns, it comes in focus, and research reports start pouring in. That’s the time to be alert.
Also, my belief is that more than 70% of listed companies in India are cyclical. The cyclicality may vary, but it does remain cyclical. A recent example is autos. Till recently. market participants were buying and awarding FMCG-type of valuations to companies of this sector. If you end up buying at obscene valuations, you might have to wait for a long time to even get your invested price back.
Over the years, I have been lucky enough to get cyclical turnarounds well. Some of them are, 2009-10 – Polyfilm sector, 2015 – Sugar and Paper, 2016 – Steel, end-2018 – Cement.
SN: That’s quite a track record, Jiten! Anyways, how do you think about valuations? Are there specific valuation models you prefer over others? If yes, which ones and why?
JP: I am essentially a value investor. I am from a camp that howsoever good a company is, one needs to buy only at the right price. Buy at value. Have patience.
I use the PEG (price to earnings growth) ratio a lot. Of course, that would require understanding the business and its growth potential. I will invest only when the ratio is in my favor. People often don’t give importance to margin-of-safety and risk-reward ratio. I diligently look at these. I have always believed that error of omission is far better than the error of commission.
Based on PEG, I will arrive at intrinsic value and exit valuations. Markets don’t behave linearly. Results always differ than your thesis. If one has a conservative approach at valuations, these results often turn in your favor. Arriving at the intrinsic value of a company is an art.
For example, let’s say, my thesis is that a stock should triple in 5 years. And let’s say, if I get a 2x in 1 year, I will pause, re-assess. See if the company is doing better than my expectation and has a significant chance of over-shooting my expectations. Then, maybe, I will stay invested. But, if the company’s performance is in line with your expectations, maybe it has become overvalued. And based on your theory, it will only give another 50% in the next 4 years. So, basically, even if one’s investment horizon is 5 years, one might exit earlier, if other opportunities exist.
If the story is not playing out, which means it’s a mistake, one needs to be brutal in cutting it. For me, business performance is more important than price performance, as the market prices depend on market cycles. You just have to bide your time.
SN: What are your thoughts on selling stocks? How does one get discipline into the selling process because there are more biases at work here than when one is buying? What selling rules do you follow?
JP: I think selling is even more important than buying. I keep it very simple, buy when it is under-valued, sell when it is in over-valued or in blue sky zone. In cyclical investing, selling at the right time is of utmost importance.
SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements or themes? What investment process/philosophy you have changed/updated based on your past mistakes? Real-life examples would be helpful.
JP: Mistakes are the best teachers in life. And best learning is from one’s own mistakes. Investing mistakes often happen, when there is greed on the street. And in raging bull markets. One needs to be able to control greed and fear.
Buying on just hope is also a common mistake I have observed amongst market participants.
I have made all kinds of mistakes in the markets. Over the years, my endeavor has been to reduce them and make them small. Understanding cyclicals has been the result of mistakes of the past. For example, it took me eight years just to get my price back in a sugar stock from a previous cycle.
The thing I have changed is that I will not repeat the above mistake. One needs to cut mistakes as soon as one realizes it has happened. Don’t wait in hope. Booking losses have been a bugbear for many investors. Many just have a psychological issue in booking losses. One must overcome that.
SN: What are your thoughts on disruption and its impact on businesses and industries? How do you think about investment risk in a world that’s highly disruptive?
JP: Business cycles are getting disrupted much faster now. Disruption is a real threat to many businesses. Look for managements and companies, who can adapt to these. I essentially see investment horizons shortening and one must be aware of that. What worked for my father may not work for me. And what worked for me, may not work for my children. One has to evolve their own style of investing.
SN: What are your thoughts on the issue of corporate governance in India? How does a minority investor assess governance that is such a tricky subject? Are there are thumb rules you follow to test governance levels?
JP: Corporate governance is a real issue in many Indian companies. That makes it more challenging. And that’s why I always say, what may work in the west may not work in India. The dynamics are different. If one diligently reads annual reports, exchange filings, builds a profile for company and managements, one has a better chance. History shows how managements have treated minority shareholders. Of course, one must build a new profile when management changes and keep tracking that.
SN: What are your thoughts on position sizing? How do you do it?
JP: Position-sizing is very important. I might start small in investment and gradually build-up as the story progresses as per my thesis. I would not mind paying a slightly higher valuation if the story is progressing well.
In cyclical investing, my first bets are small (which might affect my portfolio much) and at “point of maximum pessimism.” When everything is wrong for the sector. The investment helps me track the sector more closely. I position-size, as turnaround becomes evident. Sometimes, it’s fast and sometimes it’s slow. One needs to be patient. Key is to position-size at the start of the turnaround. At the same time, I have sectoral limits of 25% of portfolio and 15% in individual stocks.
SN: What’s your advice to someone wanting to get into value investing? What are the pitfalls he/she must be aware of?
JP: The biggest advice is “understand self.” Everyone is made different and have a different temperament. What works for me, may not work for others. And what works for others, might not work for me. Evolve your own style. Develop your own conviction. Conviction can never be borrowed. Have a good “trust network,” people with whom you can bounce off ideas. Keep investing simple. Don’t over-analyze. Excel-based investing rarely works. It’s important, but scuttlebutt is far more important. Contrarian investing can often be rewarding. Think contrarian. Of course, it needs to be coupled with patience.
SN: Which are some the books on investing, behaviour, and multidisciplinary thinking that have inspired you the most over the years? If you were to give away all your books but one, which one would it be and why?
JP: I am a big fan of Benjamin Graham. For me, The Intelligent Investor is the bible of investing. I like to read Howard Marks, as his thoughts reverberate with what I think about investing. I also like to read Farnam Street blog. I like to read psychology, history, spiritual books too. Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman is a very good book to read. Yuval Noah Harari’s books are must reads. I read far lesser books on investing and more on psychology and history.
SN: Who are some of the people – inside or outside the value investing circles – who have inspired you the most over the years, and why?
JP: It will be unfair to name any. I have been inspired by many. I try to learn from all. I am someone who practices “Pranayama” and “Yoga”. Pranayama has really helped me a lot. Over time, I have observed that clear thinking is the most important benefit. It helps in decision-making. Human beings are making decisions all the time. If you make a majority of them right, you are all good in life.
SN: A hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?
JP: Learning never stopped and should never stop.
SN: What other things do you do apart from investing? If you were not an investor, what other work(s) would have been occupied with?
JP: I like to read a lot. As mentioned above, I read a lot of multi-disciplinary books/articles. I like to be observant. I like to play different sports. Badminton, tennis, and cricket are my favorites. I might have been a teacher in psychology, if not an investor.
SN: Thank you Jiten for sharing your insights!
JP: Thanks Vishal.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years