In this special edition of InvestorInsights, we pick the brains of a few experienced value investors and money managers on how they deal with uncertainty like what is seen in the markets currently.
Safal Niveshak: Uncertainty is not a new thing for the Indian economy, companies and the markets. But people still get spooked. Even otherwise, when a lot of people know that investing is important, they are often either too scared, too intimidated, or too uncertain when such situations arise.
You have been in the markets for a long time and may have experienced multiple such periods of high uncertainty with respect to the markets, companies, and the economy. What advice do you have for new, inexperienced, or young investors on how they can deal with such situations?
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Abhishek Basumallick (Founder & Chief Investment Advisor at Intelsense Capital): I think our problem is with setting our own expectations and also a sort of social media driven short-termism. If you take a longer time horizon you will see that roughly 3-4 years in a decade markets are either down or sideways and the remaining years are good. During the bull phase people are happy and start expecting that good times will continue forever. Like any cycle, seeds of the down cycle are sowed during this period of optimism. Same thing repeats when the cycle turns around. Right now, people are thinking that the bad times will continue forever. That is never the case.
I think it is very critical for investors to read financial, economic and market history. That will give them a sense that these cycles are perpetual, and one bull phase will precede a bear phase. As long as you are invested in good companies and have a sensible asset allocation and you are keeping things simple, you will probably end up well. The biggest challenges come because people try to do fancy things.
And lastly, buy when you are absolutely certain that you want to sell everything. Use your own gut feel as a contra indicator.
Ashish Kila (Director, Perfect Group): If one wants to be in equities one must accept the volatility part that the asset class brings. Howard Marks beautifully captures the essence of volatility in the below lines –
While volatility is quantifiable and can be an indicator or symptom of riskiness or even a specific form of risk – I think it falls far short as “the” definition of investment risk. In thinking about risk, we want to identify the thing that investors worry about and thus demand compensation for bearing. I don’t think most investors fear volatility. In fact, I’ve never heard anyone say, “The prospective return isn’t high enough to warrant bearing all that volatility.” What they fear is the possibility of permanent loss.
Anyways, here are my thoughts about market volatility –
- In the long run, the stock price follows the business performance, so you don’t need to bother with short term volatility. In fact, you can add more or exit depending upon the irrationality of business valuation.
- Stocks are volatile and fluctuate and one needs to stomach it like one does not check prices of their houses or real estate investments periodically or close one’s business or shut one’s shop because of recession. We need to think like an owner of the business.
- If earnings of the business aren’t being influenced a lot by the macro, then the only thing market crash can do is compress the valuations of the stock. If one is sure about the earnings growth, in the long run one is bound to make money. In fact, as discussed earlier, one can add more if the valuations become enticing.
- Most difficult thing is developing the temperament/patience/attitude required for investing, as great things don’t happen overnight. The investor must have ‘patience to hold the stocks’ for long time rather than booking short term profits. As is widely known, many businesses have grown multifold in the past one or two decades.
- Risk is probability of permanent loss of capital and not temporary mark down in asset value due to volatility.
- Loss occurs only when you sell the stock.
I would advise your readers to read these materials on the subject –
- Sanjay Bakshi – Roller Coaster Investing
- Microcap Club – Ian Cassel – No Pain No Gain
To conclude, Peter Bernstein has put forward beautifully the advantages volatility brings with itself and if one embraces it, one is ready for future wealth creation –
A smart contrarian might see it differently: volatility — surprises — are a feature of markets. Expectations are often wrong, unexpected things happen, prices adjust sometimes dramatically, which creates opportunities for those less fearful of volatility. In other words, embracing surprise leads to opportunity.
Gaurav Sud (Managing Partner at Kanav Capital): Returns in the markets are never linear. While they are positive in the long term, the journey is filled with all kind of gyrations, pitfalls and speculations.So, when you start your investment journey, you are quite optimistic about the prospects and your investing skills. If you are lucky enough to ride the wave, you get overly enthusiastic and divert more of your savings into investing and then get wrong footed when the bullish sentiment changes.
A key quote of Ben Graham that has helped me is this –
In the short run, the market is a voting machine but in the long run, it is a weighing machine.
So, depending on valuations in the market, one should be ready to take some money off the table.
My portfolio had a serious drawdown in the meltdown of 2008 and ever since then, I have been focused on how to handle the gyrations and accompanying psychological impact on our thought process. Here are a few insights I have gained and implemented over these years –
- Investing fulltime is not for everyone. There are a few aspects that need to be taken care of. There should be enough revenue stream to take care of your day to day living. Your capital should be large enough, that even lower than expected returns can take care of the opportunity cost of not having a job. Finally, you should be passionate about what you do. You should enjoy reading balance sheets, meeting managements and tracking industries. If you are in it only for making money, then sustaining yourself for long becomes difficult.
- When you start investing, first learn the asset allocation principles. Be very clear about how much of your net worth you want to put at risk in the stock market. Different people will have different thresholds and understanding how much drawdowns you can take on your net worth, is very important for long term success. People who are open to seeing a stock they invest in, correct 50% or more, and still be fine with it, should only focus on the small and midcap stocks. If people cannot accept this kind of volatility, they should focus on the large cap blue chips or invest in mutual funds.
- Learn to take money off the table when market valuations start moving up. It was clear in December 2017 – January 2018, that valuations had become frothy. Now there are many ways that one can say the market is expensive – one can look at the multiples the index is trading at, the valuations at which IPOs are coming in, or the big moves in the lower quality stocks. In my case, I track the P/E and P/BV of the Nifty index. When they move to the 70 percentile levels, I start moving to cash. So, by end-2017, I was on 40% cash, and that has been a big help for me in handling this sharp down move since January 2018
- Always invest thinking about the downside. Try to model the worst-case scenarios. Many times, we invest thinking about the upside if our hypothesis plays out but forget about the downside if it doesn’t. When you start thinking about the negatives, you will make more informed decision
- Finally, you should be aware about one big fact. Luck has a big role to play in your investing success. No matter how much effort you put in, no matter how much diligence you do, there is always the element of luck in the success of an idea. That is why investing is an art more than science.
Naresh Katariya (Full-Time Investor): I will take a cue from the investment errors which I have made over the years, and how I have tried to adapt and improve –
Need for diversification: Considering the frequency of high-volatility events in global and domestic macros, it may be to be prudent to be diversified across investment styles, asset classes, growth drivers. Also, you may consider cash as an asset class, considering the very generous real yields which we are lucky to be enjoying in India.
- Investment styles: Large caps have done better recently, while small/mid-caps did relatively better in 2014-2017. So, being diversified should protect against wild swings in any pocket of the market.
- Asset classes: Gold can play a good counter-cyclical role in terms of portfolio returns. Growth scare globally is pushing rates lower, and that’s acting as a tailwind for gold. Similarly, bonds (or bond funds) have done well recently due to lowering of G-Sec rates, and that has had a positive impact on a portfolio’s risk-adjusted returns.
- Growth drivers: The theme around Indian demographics played very well over the years (Autos, Appliances, Realty, Education, etc.), but these themes have been under-performing. On the other hand, financialization of savings as a growth driver has done exceptionally well recently.
Measure investment returns across a cycle, rather than over a year: Investments returns are volatile in the short-term. I prefer to evaluate 3 and 5 years CAGR returns on the portfolio, rather than a year-on-year performance. If such longer-term returns start trending up sharply (compared to trend), it may be time to look at some portfolio re-balancing. Also, having a longer-term horizon to measure portfolio performance helps in making more rational decisions, in the face of market spikes and drawdowns.
Employing multiple metrics to assess performance: It is an accepted norm to measure one’s portfolio performance in terms of CAGR returns on the portfolio. Apart from that, I also track and measure the growth in expected forward Owner Earnings (if I own 0.02% of a company earning PAT of Rs 1,000 crore, I would count Rs 20 lakh as my Owner Earnings from that holding). I also track the growth in dividends received. One has better control over the growth in Owner Earnings and portfolio dividends. Tracking these metrics also leads to better emotional handling of one’s investments. And, if earnings growth is good over a period, stock performance usually follows.
Taking a longer-term perspective: Most of us would have heard arguments in 2018 about the deep correction in various stocks, and how these were compelling. From a 2-3 years perspective, this may have been true. But if one had stepped back and seen 5 to 10 years charts/history, one could see that several stocks which appeared to have fallen nicely, had only corrected a small part of the gains made in the last 10-year’s bull run.
Acknowledge downtrends as a necessary ingredient for future out-performance: This has brought in a new perspective to my investment thinking. Investors enjoy bull runs and the portfolio returns which come along. But every bull run (whether in a sector or the market as a whole) usually has a corrective phase prior to that, which builds the base for the next bull run. We are having an ongoing downtrend currently in the Indian market. If a business was a good long-term candidate last year and is available at a more compelling valuation now (without significant damage to the long-term prospects of that business), it is likely to be more attractive now. Of course, I have significant concerns on the longevity of the ongoing global economic cycle, and so I am considering that as a factor in assessing the kind of businesses to invest in, and what valuations I term as compelling.
Back down a little when going gets too good: I have had a few occasions when the going got really very good 2007, 2010, 2017), as measured by multi-year returns. During such times, one needs to go a little easy,pursue re-balancing actively, and reduce the overall risk (of volatility) in one’s portfolio. During such times, it has helped me to take a contrarian approach, and stay away from the fads of the season. While market consensus is usually right (Efficient Market Hypothesis), at extremes, it may be prudent to bet against the consensus. While it’s never easy to spot an “extreme” while it is happening, if an investor’s 2 or 3 year portfolio returns are much above trend, reducing risk then (by moving to cash, alternate asset classes etc.) is not going to hurt too badly, even if one’s call on the bubble/extreme is not proven right.
Sunil Shah (Partner, Turtle Star Portfolio Managers): Stock market is a beautiful place. As they say beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder. So, for some it is an excellent place to make fortune of their life and for some it is gambling den and it should be kept away from. Stock market is never a linear price movement. The first and basic characteristic of stock market is its inherent nature of being volatile. So, my advice to young budding investors is to know that Rome was not built in a day, and if I can add, Rome was certainly built brick by brick over a period of time. Volatility of the stock market should thus not hamper the discipline of investing.
In fact, uncertainty creates fear and fear creates panic – the panic results in stock prices correcting to such levels that in hindsight we realize that we missed an opportunity to invest. Times change and after night there is a day and after every high tide there is a low tide. In stock market too – change is the only constant and as situation changes – the prices too change, and markets move in cycles. Bull market follow bear market and vice-versa. I have experienced this cycle from 1992 and have witnessed investors exhibiting similar behavior of greed and fear every time. This time is no different and this, too, shall pass.
So, my takeaways so far to remember are – markets are volatile, fear creates panic, time is the best medicine, markets move in cycles, and this too shall pass.
Now, given that stock markets are liquid markets and prices are visible every minute of the day, it does spook majority of investors and they succumb to the pressure of fluctuating prices. To deal with such a situation, adopt the simple process of SIP in either mutual funds or a portfolio of stocks. Keep away from the noise in the stock markets. Don’t aspire to make quick bucks by getting into futures and options. Don’t bet on companies where promoters have pledged shares. Don’t bet on companies that are sunk in debt. Don’t bet on a company just because the stock price has come down from Rs 400 to Rs 40 – remember at Rs 40, the loss can still be 100%. Don’t try to emulate anyone or clone another investor’s portfolio. You might clone his actions, but not his temperament.
Safal Niveshak: Given the rut that Indian companies find themselves owing to multiple factors like corporate mis-governance, widespread economic slowdown, decline in demand for their products/services, the disappearance of economic growth, risk of disruptions, and the overall weak investment sentiment, what kind of companies do you see coming out stronger from such an environment?
In other words, history has shown time and again that particular kind of companies make their way back from such crisis situations stronger. What characteristics should investors be focusing on to identify such companies?
Abhishek Basumallick: As someone said, right now we are having a “Swacch Bharat” in corporate India. My sense is that a lot of the problems are coming out in public now because the economy has weakened, and growth has turned down sharply. Companies which have good products or services, low debt, able to produce free cashflows and have reasonably clean management are likely to do well. India is a growing economy and both investment and consumption will continue to grow strongly when we take a decadal view. Look at companies also where underlying demand is strong and those which are benefitting from the underlying changes in the economy.
Ashish Kila: Great businesses are antifragile and come out stronger in such environment.
To illustrate over a period of time, we worked on developing a framework looking at major wealth creators historically in the Indian market. We have sought to distil common characteristics of such businesses and make a framework to identify future wealth creators.
We call this proprietary framework the ‘Ranking of Business Models’ framework. This framework helps us first select a good business model and then allocate higher to great businesses.
Selection of a stock is based on –
Essential qualities/characteristics of Business Models in order of preference:
- Management – check integrity, intelligence and energy
- Longevity – product should be required decades later also – Anti fragility
- No Structural Headwind/Long Term Tailwind
- Scalability – huge size of opportunity and below mentioned competitive advantage(s):
-
- Network Effect
- Scaled Economies Shared
- Intangible Assets
- Trusted Brands
- Positional Value
- Confer Legitimacy
- Switching Cost
- Management Bet
Favorable Industry Structure –
-
- Absence of Mindless Competition from well funded players
- No Regulatory Disruption
Selection is basically an elimination test; all criteria need to be satisfied.
Allocation is based on, other Desirable Competitive Advantages:
- Reasonable Valuations – calculating the implied growth rate in the current prices
- Annuity Revenues – repeat sales/steady and stable income
- Exceptions of low annuity if low base of penetration/market share and huge opportunity for industry growth
- High switching cost/pricing power – the higher the better
- Optionality – Low probability bets with Asymmetric Payoffs
- Capacity to Reinvest
- Own business/adjacencies
- Side Car Investing
- Ability to capture dominant market share
Allocation is a grading test, you may not satisfy all criteria, but the more grades you get, the higher the allocation.
[One can refer to Value Investing Almanack’s Issue 50, where I have covered this topic in detail.]
Further reading material:
- Sanjay Bakshi – Fragility and Optionality on Alpha series- Ep. 9 by IIC
- Lindy Effect
- For identifying corporate mis-governance
- Role of Management PPT (Perfect Research Blog)
- Amit Mantri – 2point2capital
- Vardharajan PPT – Alpha Series – Ep. 8 by IIC
- Safal Niveshak Courses and Blog
Gaurav Sud: In my 20 years of investing, I haven’t witnessed such a slowdown that seems to be playing out in the economy right now. Finding companies growing at 15-20% has become a big challenge. There are so few of them, and even with such negative sentiments, command very high valuations. So, in my humble opinion, a rebound from this situation will not happen quickly.
I feel that the current government is focused on cleaning up the system. Many past misdeeds and mis-governances are getting highlighted and this in turn has hit the valuations of many companies and soured the mood in the capital markets. At the same time, certain companies are trading at huge premiums to the market. When you analyse them, few things clearly come out –
- Their corporate governance standards are quite high. The promoters have great reputations and they communicate regularly and try to be transparent.
- They are largely in the B2C space with some kind of moat built around the business. This moat could be a brand, distribution network, R&D driven innovation, lower cost structures.
- They are leaders in their industry and are growing at rates better than the industry, thus gaining market shares.
- They are not leveraged and have great balance sheets.
So, while these business traits are easy to find, the challenge is that such businesses are still not cheap.
One way to look at new ideas is to find businesses, which have an emerging division which is growing faster than the company and is more profitable. At some point when that division achieves scale, the business may choose to demerge it from the main company, and you may gain access to a high-quality business at reasonable valuations.
Another way is to focus on companies which are being run by good promoters, but the sector is facing huge headwinds, and the valuations have now corrected to way below replacement costs of the business. Those companies could rebound and give good returns when the business cycle turns.
Naresh Katariya: Let me list out my filters to identify attractive investment opportunities:
Structural industry tailwinds: I shortlist businesses with good demand tailwinds, to identify companies which require deeper analysis. Some of the multi-year trends which I am exploring are:
- Formalization of businesses: Better tax compliance is moving business from unorganized to organized players. This may explain the robust growth in several industry segments, in spite of a general slowdown. Sectors like Appliances, Jewelry, Luggage, and Money lending should see such a trend, where there is still a large unorganized segment.
- Rapid urbanization: India is urbanizing quite rapidly, and the spending pattern of urban households should open opportunities in Housing, Durables, FMCG, Entertainment, Transport.
- Rural electrification: Government’s push to bring electricity to all the villages and households should transform consumption expenditure at the bottom of the pyramid. Apart from direct beneficiaries involved in creating this infrastructure, electrification should open new markets for appliances.
- Water: This is going to be a major theme in India, as our population and water usage are increasing, while our water sources are finite. And government initiatives to supply water to all households should drive a lot of investments in the next decade. This should throw interesting opportunities in years to come.
- Financialization of savings: Indians are gradually moving away from traditional avenues of savings like Real estate, Gold, Chit funds etc. This is leading to sustainable growth momentum for asset management, insurance, capital market infrastructure institutions.
- Boom in travel: Indians have taken to travel very fast. Cumulative travel spends, especially travel abroad, is growing north of 25%. While there may not be many direct companies in India to play that trend, proxies like airlines, luggage could be possible sectors to benefit from the travel boom.
- Ban on single-use plastics: With increased environmental awareness, demand for single-use plastics should decline. This is also a global theme. This should open up growth in recycling, and in sustainable packaging.
- Softening interest rates: With pressure on growth globally, central banks are in softening mode. Indian government is also on a tight control on the fiscal. Additionally, impending transmission of earlier rate cuts should lead to a downward trend in overall interest rates. Lower rates, with a lag, lead to boost in several sectors of our economy.
- High-end employment creation: Contrary to perception of slowdown in IT employment growth, there is still a massive move towards offshoring of high-end jobs in research and automation. At 15 million square feet, Bangalore has added more commercial office space in 2018 than any other global commercial capital. While IT may be slowing, Research, Pharma etc. are driving a lot of employment generation. Around 15 million square feet space should lead to at least 100,000 high-end jobs added in one city in just one year. They should lead to cascading effect of downstream economic activity and resultant consumption growth.
Best place to ride a business trend: While business trends may unfold, the most obvious companies may not be the best places to ride that trend. Electrification of villages is a big theme. But power producers may not be the best way to play that theme, considering their own demand-supply situation, DISCOMs’ financial health and related payment delays etc. On the other hand, future demand for appliances/consumer durables could open large markets for established brands. So, I do spend time on assessing the best way to play an economic theme. It helps to remember that during the California Gold Rush of 1850s, the best returns were raked in not by the miners, but by the suppliers of mining equipment, food etc. to the miners.
Management quality: The key variables I look for is management integrity, and alignment of their interests with those of minority shareholders. Unreasonably high salaries for promoters, hoarding of cash with no end use justification, unrelated or un-remunerative diversifications are all red flags which I watch out for. Insider buying is an indicator which I track closely. If a management is buying its own stock, it usually means two things: a) they see value in the company vis-a-vis the current market capitalization, and, they treat only their part of the shareholding as their ownership in the company. You could see a lot of companies going very cheap, but promoters may just not be stepping up to buy. They treat the whole company as their own, and, hence, may not be seeing any point in spending money to acquire additional stake from the markets.
Industry cycle: In a bull run, even cyclical industries start getting considered as secular growth stories. Almost every sector undergoes multi-year business corrections/downtrends. We start realizing this maxim, once actual downturn hits. NBFCs were considered as secular businesses till last year. Optic fibre companies were considered the secular growth proxy to ride the telecom/data boom, but that industry too has been affected by global demand-supply disruption. Being aware of such cyclicality allows one to not be swayed by the fads of the season, and also to acquire great businesses, when we see the industry cycle turning up.
Temporary challenges: This has been a major theme for me to identify good companies, which have faced some temporary challenges. Let me list some examples:
a) GOCL: Prior to demerger in FY15, GOCL had a mining explosives division, large real estate holdings, and a Lubricants subsidiary (since then, hived off as Gulf Oil Lubricants). The lubricants business was doing very well, but a conglomerate structure meant that not many investors were interested. Even after the demerger and listing of lubricants business was announced, GOCL was trading at substantially less than what the lubricants business itself should have been worth. Of course, post the demerger, the markets recognised its true value, and the two demerged companies combined were up more than 5X in a year.
b) Demonetisation: Liquidity scare during Nov/Dec 2016, created interesting opportunities in several long-term growth stories.
c) During FY15 and FY16, gold finance companies (GFCs) suffered interest reversals (reversing interest which got accrued in earlier quarters, once NPA loans were auctioned) due to steep correction in gold prices. Such reversals were temporary and would only occur during steep price corrections. Even after gold price had stabilized, markets were giving a sub-10 PE, on reported earnings (after hit from interest reversals). Without the interest reversals, GFCs were trading at sub-7 PE, with very attractive retail lending franchises and financial ratios.
d) The current slowdown in automobile sector is hurting automobile companies and their ancillaries. Auto ancillaries not affected by EV adoption should throw some interesting opportunities in coming months. Of course, automobile market has degrown in last few quarters. But the current narrative is far too negative for the 5% degrowth in actual retail sales/registrations.
Sunil Shah: There is a tripod on which the investment rationale rests – Business, Management and Valuation. To my mind, in the context of India, it is the management that is most important. We have companies in same line of business, but one emerges winner and the other disappears with time, clearly the reason is of management (Eg. HDFC Bank v/s GTB Bank). Likewise, one of the key things we must study is the ability of the management to withstand the previous bad markets. In case of India, we have to observe how the company fared during 2008-2009 and again in 2013 second half. In case the management focused on their core business even during trying times, we have every reason to believe they will emerge stronger. And in case they faltered and went off-course to unrelated areas of diversification or had margin compression or went into debt spiral, they will falter.
Bear markets throw us opportunities, but we need to be prepared to capitalize on the same. One of the things I have observed is that B2C (Business to Consumer) companies emerge stronger through such trying times as compared to B2B (Business to Business) or B2G (Business to Government). One of the things I would like to observe in any company is the ability and willingness of the customer to pay from company’s product. If the customer is paying the company cheerfully for the value that he obtains (Brands, Entertainment, E-Comm, Online shopping etc) then such companies will be first ones to fly from the flock and would be rewarded when the market cycle changes.
Next will be ones where a customer pays the company on compulsory grounds (Pharma, FMCG, Healthcare, Telecom, Electronics) – these are basic needs of the customer and they are must have for him. Next will be some business that are gruesome – in these the customer has lot of choice and the company has no pricing power (Commodities, Banks, Services, Metals etc). Last would be companies in which the customer is not directly benefitting but is an indirect beneficiary (Infra, Power, Engineering, Oil and Gas etc).
To my mind, when the stock market turns, the companies benefit in the order mentioned above. However, each company is a study in itself, and it will not be fit to all formula to find emerging winners in the next leg of bull markets. The above is a directional view on how the thought process should be carried out. The idea is to follow this process religiously and hold on to such winners in even trying times. Creation of wealth is an outcome of patience over long periods of time.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years


