Gaurav did his BTech from IIT Delhi and completed his MBA from IIM Calcutta in 1999. He started his career at KPMG’s Corporate Finance division and since then has worked at Wipro BPO, Keane Consulting, WNS Global Services and Asian Oilfield Services Ltd. In 2006, he quit his job to become a full-time investor.
He has over twenty-one years of experience in investing, M&A, investment banking and financial consulting. Currently, he is managing partner at Kanav Capital and runs his family office. His investing focus is in listed small and mid-sized Indian companies. He also works on event-based arbitrage situations. He lives in Gurgaon with his wife and two kids.
In this interview, Gaurav shares his thoughts on investing, his process, and the key lessons he has learned over more than a decade of being an investor.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]Safal Niveshak (SN): Could you tell us a little about your background, how you got interested in value investing?
Gaurav Sud (GS): I was born in Shimla and spent my early childhood there. I was an introvert to some extent and an avid reader. Our gang used to wander in the forests below our colony and I spent some of the most thrilling moments of my life climbing trees, daydreaming and planning what I wanted to become when I grew up.
Many a time, I would run out of books to read and so would grab whatever I could get my hands on. My grandfather had a whole cupboard full of Readers Digest, and I for many years cherished this reading treasure. Some of my most enduring memories are of me lying on the carpet reading through an engrossing tale of survival or heroism.
My grandfather owned a ticket to the Delhi Stock Exchange. He was not an active member but had leased it to another broker. This broker would visit our home 1-2 times every year and he would have these anecdotes of how one of his clients made huge returns or lost money big time, which I found very engrossing. My grandfather had invested in some shares of bluechip companies and so every year he would get some annual reports. I would browse through them and gradually that sparked an interest in investing.
During my early teens, I used to look forward to reading these reports and get a flavour on what was happening in companies like Tata Steel, TELCO (Tata Motors), L&T and ACC. I did not understand the balance sheet numbers then but read through the Management Discussion section to understand how the companies were envisioning their future.
There was an opportunity in late seventies when the Janata Party government came to power and it asked all foreign companies to divest at least 60% of their shareholding in favour of the Indian public. Many companies like IBM refused and left the country. Others gave in to the government fiat and came out with IPOs at dirt cheap prices. There was frenzy for these shares and, in a way, this kicked off the IPO boom in India. Any shares allotted were through lottery and my father was lucky enough to get shares in Hindustan Unilever and Castrol. He always used to say that he would never sell these shares and his faith paid off in a big way. The significant money made on this small quantity of shares made me realise the power of compounding, and attracted me towards investing.
SN: This sounds like a dream story, Gaurav! Not many people benefit from such positive influence as far as investing is concerned in the early part of their lives. What about your education, generally and in investing?
GS: I did well in my studies and joined IIT Delhi in 1993. It was great fun there and many of my most enduring friendships were formed during that period. In the third year, I got hold of a book at the IIT library titled The Warren Buffett Way by Robert Hagstrom and I was totally hooked on the concepts of part ownership of businesses and margin of safety.
I opened a brokerage account in my name and invested whatever money I had saved in the cheapest stocks I could find.
Subsequently, I did my MBA from IIM Calcutta and worked as a financial consultant across various companies. All this time I was investing small amounts in companies that I found cheap and were expected to grow fast. There was plenty of value in the market in 2001-03 post the dotcom crash, and as luck would have it, in 2002 I invested in a Gurgaon based real estate company called Unitech Ltd.
I was living in a project of theirs, South City 2 in Gurgaon, and so had an idea of the scale of their operations. At Rs 58 crore market cap, it was trading at a huge discount to its book value and the expected cash flows it could generate. After going nowhere for a year, the stock took off and I had a 100 bagger in my hands.
That early success was key element of my decision to get full time into investing in 2007.
SN: Wonderful! How have you evolved as an investor and what’s your broad investment philosophy? Has your investment policy changed much through the years?
GS: My journey as an investor has evolved quite a bit. Initially I was inclined to buy the cheapest stocks. When I did my internship at UTI during the IIM Calcutta days, I discovered the Capital Market database and ran queries on it. I tended to look for statistically cheapest stocks based on parameters like price-to-earnings, price-to-book, and price-to-sales. I would then buy a basket of the cheapest stocks and wait for them to get rerated.
SN: How well did this strategy work?
GS: It worked for some time, but I was not beating the market by a big margin. Over time, I found that the single biggest metric that the market rewards in companies is the growth in sales and profit. So, over time, my strategy has shifted from buying the cheapest companies to buying reasonably priced companies with decent growth, good quality of business, competent and honest managements.
These companies may not be statistically the cheapest, but they are not priced like the expensive growth stocks. This strategy is broadly called GARP (growth at reasonable prices).
Another aspect that has developed over time is that I focus a lot more on the downside. I had made decent money in the 2003-07 bull market, but did not have the brains to understand that I was just plain lucky and that the market was getting so overvalued that one should turn cautious. To top it, I had virtually no money outside the stocks I owned. The crash of 2008 wiped out a big part of my gains and made my behavior very erratic and contrary to what a rational investor would do.
So now I have a habit of moving into cash when I feel that the market is getting overheated. I have been sitting on 30-40% cash since 2016 and continue to hold that stance till date. I had got great returns in 2014 and 2015, which were much better than expectations.
I sold some of the shares but found it difficult to find stocks which were at reasonable valuations and fulfilled my other criteria. Gradually, the cash started getting built up in my portfolio. While this cash made me underperform in the upside of 2016 and 2017, it is now helping me weather the sharp correction in midcaps and smallcaps that is being currently witnessed in the markets.
The other aspect of my investing strategy is deploying money in risk arbitrage and special situations. These are strategies build around specific events like Open Offers, Buybacks, Right Issues, Mergers, Demergers, Convertible bonds, Delistings etc. The defining aspect of these trades are that the returns are low (in the range of 2-10%) and they have a defined timeline. Within that timeline, you will know how much money you have made or lost in the strategy.
Another aspect of these trades is that the probability of making a positive return is very high, and because of this high probability one can make large allocations to a single trade. Many investors simply ignore these strategies as the returns on one trade is not materially big. For me, these trades allow me to deploy my cash and get much better returns than a FD. Also, this portfolio is very stable and till date, I have not had a single year where I have lost money. I may have lost money in one trade, but as a portfolio these trades have given positive returns in any given year.
SN: How has it being managing money, especially during extreme situations – euphoria or market crashes? How do you keep yourself sane, especially when dealing with clients with undue expectations?
GS: I am currently not an active money manager or a SEBI registered investment advisor. I just manage money for my family. However, as a custodian of their money I do feel accountable for my actions to them.
I had a huge drawdown in the fall of 2008 and that had set me thinking about how to manage risk as investing has largely been my main source of income for the last decade. While it is easy to ride the bouts of euphoria since your portfolio is making easy money, it makes sense to track if irrational behavior is driving the market.
There are many signs of overheating – overpriced IPOs, dinner talks centering around the stock markets, new metrics being used to justify valuations, etc. It is difficult to pinpoint when exactly the euphoria will end. The current run peaked out in January 2018 and since then there has been a decent correction in the small and midcap indices.
For me, one of the big risk mitigating strategy is the ability to sit on cash. So, the philosophy that I follow is that I have set a rate of return for my portfolio. Say I have bought a stock that I expect will double over the next 3 years, but due to bullish sentiments the stock doubles in less than a year. I then sell the stock and if I don’t find any reasonable stock to buy I will sit on cash.
SN: Most investors I talk to, even experienced ones, find it difficult to sit on cash. So, it’s good to know that you manage to do that. What benefits have you experienced applying this strategy?
GS: I am ready to sit on cash till the valuations for stocks that I am tracking come to a level where I am comfortable buying. This ability to sit on cash when valuations are high helps me reduce the volatility of my portfolio. As long as I am achieving my long-term goals of generating a minimum return, I am not bothered about the underperformance of my portfolio that is caused by sitting on cash.
The best way to handle your own expectations is to keep a journal around your investment thesis and what kind of returns you are expecting from that stock. If you get the returns fast enough, then you should have the ability to sell when you feel they are getting overpriced.
I work on moderating the return expectations of my family members by highlighting the long term returns of the stock market and reiterating the mean reverting nature of the same. Talking to them on this also helps me keep my thought process more rational.
SN: What has been the best and worst times in your experience as an investor? You talked about getting hurt in the 2008 crash. How did you handle the situation?
GS: The best time for me were the heady days between 2003 and 2007. My portfolio was generating more than 100% returns every year. I had a 100-bagger in Unitech and many of stocks I invested during moved up 5-20 times during a period of 1-3 years. Anything you picked up would go up and so then it was a matter of focusing on stocks that hadn’t moved in the past 12 months and just invest.
This strategy itself generated huge returns. There was no need to focus on the quality of the business or cashflows. As long as growth was there, one was rewarded with extraordinary returns. I saw a similar thing playing out in 2017.
The worst experience in my investing life was the 2008 Lehman crash. Given the heady rise in the bull market of 2003-07, I was totally blinded to the risks that were building in. I had made some good money and quit my job in 2006. I strongly felt that I had made the right choice and the path to riches lay in front of me.
I had read that 99% of Warren Buffett’s net-worth was invested in the Berkshire Hathaway stock. So I thought that if he could put his entire net-worth in the stock market, I too should try to do the same, given that I had a long investing career ahead of me. I went ahead and put 85% of my net-worth into stocks. The only asset I held besides stocks was the home I was living in. What I didn’t realise was that with Buffett’s net-worth at US$ 20 Billion then, the 1% that was not invested was US$ 200 Million whereas my 15% which was not invested was just my house. Buffett could easily enjoy his life on his non-stock savings but in my case, I depended on my investments to fund my next month’s household expenses.
When the 2008 crash came, my portfolio had a drawdown of 75% plus and my net-worth plunged by 60%. It was a huge psychological blow for me and the entire event paralyzed my thinking. I was stunned by the events of October 2008 and every day I would just watch the stocks go down, too shocked to do anything about it. Neither did I buy nor sell or churn my portfolio. All I did was watch the screen and hope that this would get over soon. I obsessively read the newspapers and watched the news channels to see what was happening.
By November 2008, I was so despondent and driven by fear that I sold 50% of my largest stock holding, converted it into a Bank Fixed Deposit and decided how I would keep making FDs so that I could try living off their interest. I still haven’t redeemed that FD. It serves as a stark reminder to me of what a serious bear market can do to your portfolio and your mind.
I did not buy shares in the huge stock recovery of 2009 and it was only in 2nd half of 2010 that I started buying shares again. This crash of 2008 has so many learnings for me that I think I matured as an investor after taking a huge hit on my portfolio. My return expectations are much lower now and I am quite focused on the downside to an investment.
SN: Apart from lowering your return expectations and increasing focus on the downside, what other key lessons did you learn from the 2008 crisis, that has stayed with you? How has your thinking on financial markets and investing changed over this past decade?
GS: Well 2008 bear market was a defining episode in my investing career. Before that I was always bullish on things. I would always take all the announcements made by companies at face value and assume that growth will continue ad infinitum.
After that event, I truly realised the concept of “margin of safety.” No matter how good a company is, how big an opportunity that lies ahead of it, at a certain price it is overvalued. As an analyst, one of your key jobs is not just to decide when and what to buy but also when to sell. So, I have started maintaining a journal and my investment hypothesis on a company also has a price at which I am willing to exit my position.
Another lesson for me was to focus on asset allocation. I have decided that at no point in time will my investments in equity exceed 70% of the net-worth. So, I actively review my asset allocation on a six-monthly basis and if the allocations to equity look high, I shift part of my holdings into debt or real estate. I have been doing this since 2016 and gradually built a debt and real estate portfolio also.
I also realized that I am dependent on my returns to take care of my day to day household expenses. So, I wanted to focus on strategies that would give consistent positive returns even if they are lower. That thought made me read a lot, and over time I have built a risk arbitrage investment strategy that has given good steady returns over time.
SN: Let’s delve a bit on your investing process. Let me start with asking you about the characteristics you look for in high-quality businesses. What are your key checklist points you consider while searching for such businesses?
GS: Over the years I have been lucky enough to have some high-quality businesses in my portfolio, like Ashiana Housing, Astral Pipes, Cera Sanitaryware, Suprajit Engineering, and Gulf Oil Lubricants. I have been able to buy these stocks before they were considered high quality and effectively was able to buy them cheap. Subsequently, the earnings growth and rerating worked together to make these stocks multi-baggers.
Anyways, the aspects I look at in searching for above-average companies are –
- Track record of the management – Are they executing whatever they have committed to doing?
- Capital efficiency of the business – Does the business require low capital to grow, or is it capital intensive?
- Return ratios – ROE, Asset Turnover Ratio, Free Cash Flows etc (Are these consistently better than the competition?)
- Balance sheet improvements – Reduction in Debt, Working Capital, Customer advances
- Scuttlebutt Feedback – Do their customers, suppliers have good things to say about them? Many times, their competitors also acknowledge their better performance
- Capital Allocation – Are they allocating capital judiciously? Is there any diversification that can divert management attention while generating lower returns?
- Corporate Governance – Here I look for related party transactions, dividend payout policies, board composition, communication in Annual Reports, auditor credibility, etc.
The real trick lies in trying to figure out which business will turn out into a high-quality business, and then buying the stock early. A great example for me was Gulf Oil Lubricants India Ltd. This company was formed out of a demerger from Gulf Oil Corporation Ltd. in 2014. The lubricants business was a very high ROE business, generating over Rs 800 crore in revenue, with a very asset light model. They sold lubricants under the brand “GULF OIL” and had high recall and brand recognition. They were growing at 3-times the industry growth rate.
At the consolidated level, this division only contributed one-third of the revenue and the remaining was coming from explosives and real estate. The other parts of the business were asset heavy, making losses and with revenue actually de-growing. This lack of growth, and negligible profits at a consolidated level made the market give the consolidated company very low valuations. Post the demerger, the standalone numbers started showing and, over time, the company got rerated, becoming a 10-bagger for me.
SN: Thanks for sharing this example to explain your process. What about valuations? How do you differentiate between ‘paying up’ for quality and ‘overpaying’?
GS: My investing style is hugely influenced by what happened to my portfolio in 2008. So, given that I focus a lot on valuations, it is rare that I buy high-quality companies for their future growth because their valuations are way out of my buy zone.
So, I wait for accidents to happen. Like a year back, when Rajeev Sikka episode happened in Infosys. The stock corrected by 20%, and I saw an opportunity to buy as I was getting a high-quality cash flow driven company at a P/E of 12.
The other areas I look for ideas is when promoters are buying their shares. That is just the starting point and I try to figure out what is driving the purchase. If I can connect the dots and valuations are interesting I go ahead and buy the stock.
Another area I scan is stocks at 52-week lows. Here I look for stocks that I have studied sometime in the past. If I happen to find one, I try to figure out what is driving the stocks to correct and whether these issues are temporary in nature.
As for valuations, I would always want to buy a midcap company at a significantly cheaper valuation than the market leader in the same sector. There are inherent risks in small and mid cap companies with limited track record and issues around corporate governance. I would not like to pay a premium for higher growth that these companies can generate.
SN: What kind of valuation models do you use? It would be great if you could run through a real-life example of valuing a business using a specific model/thought process that did well for you.
GS: I started my career by doing DCF valuation models at KPMG Corporate Finance. I did this for two years, but over time realised that these intricate models have basically 3-4 variables that can be tweaked to change the valuation that you deem is right. So it’s not that you discover the valuations by building the models, what is essentially done is that you build detailed models to justify the valuations that you had in mind. So, over time, I have stopped using excel based DCF valuation models.
I also do not like to predict too far into the future. There may be some visibility about revenues and margins 1-2 years into the future but beyond that even the management is not clear.
So, the metrics that I like to track are Price to Sales, Price to Earnings, EV/EBDITA, Dividend Yield and Price to Book, depending on the kind of industry it is. Price to Sales is a good metric to track in cyclicals to understand when the stock is cheap. Price to Book is a good metric for financial services companies.
Let me explain with an example. In September 2015, the stock of Manappuram Finance corrected to a price of Rs 22. There were negative views around the fall in gold prices, the NPAs in the gold loan business, the potential growth and to top it all a large institutional shareholder was selling shares in huge quantities. The way I saw it was that the business of gold loans was secured, and default risk was low. The other positives were that the company was paying a dividend of Rs 1.8 (Rs 0.45 every quarter). The promoter was buying from the market, and the largest institutional shareholder, Barings, came on TV and explained its investing hypothesis in the company, along with the various new verticals the company was planning to foray into. The only way the business could lose money was if gold prices fell by more than 20% in a year. I analyzed the risk reward situation and considering the dividend yield of 8%, I felt there was little downside to the investment. I made a big allocation and sold out within 18 months when the stock price crossed Rs 80.
SN: What about selling stocks? Are there some specific rules for selling that you have?
GS: I keep an investment journal where I write down a thesis on my investment and what kind of returns I am expecting. If the stock achieves that goal, then I am ready to sell.
Experience has taught me that it does not make sense to sell the entire stake in one go. When buying interest comes in a stock or when some institution starts buying in a big way the stock can build momentum and the price can easily overshoot fair valuations and keep going higher. To capture this upside, I now sell my holdings in 4-5 lots. I will sell the first lot when my price target is achieved and if the stock keeps going higher I will sell the second lot when the price goes up further 15-20%. I will continue doing this as long as the price keeps moving up and so effectively I am able to exit my position at an average price which is 40-50% higher than my original sell price target. If say I have sold 2 out of the 5 lots and the stocks come down, then I am ready to repurchase the shares I sold as long as, fundamentally, financials are still the same and nothing has changed.
The other reason to exit a position is when I come to realise that my investment thesis no longer holds valid. This could be due to macro headwinds (rupee depreciation, oil price hikes, interest rates), changing sector dynamics or some decision taken by the management that you don’t agree with (doing an acquisition, unrelated diversification, corporate governance issue).
The final reason to exit a position could be when I find an idea whose business dynamics and valuation I find more compelling, and I feel I can generate better returns from that stock idea. I typically hold 10-12 positions in my investing portfolio and if I want to add another one, then first I have to decide a position that I am willing to sell. Without selling an existing position I cannot buy a new one.
SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements or themes?
GS: As I look back, there are many mistakes that I have made over the years. The one that impacted me the most was being carried away in the euphoria of the 2007 bull market and so having to the take the big hit in the 2008 crash.
There are also a few aspects that were common to the mistakes I made while picking stocks –
- Promoters’ Quality – This has been a recurring theme that has resulted in failure. Many a times I got interested in a stock because it statistically looked very cheap. I would buy it and wait for years and suddenly a bad action by the promoters would result in big losses. Like, the promoters would merge the company with an unlisted entity at a very unfavorable ratio, or there would be big write-downs in the balance sheet. Investing with unethical promoters is one of the worst things you can do as an investor, especially if you are investing for the long term.
- Focus on P&L over Balance Sheet – A company I had invested in started growing very fast and I got enamored with the entire story. Even though the stock ran up, I had no plans to sell as I felt it was still cheap given the growth. What I failed to realise was that the company’s receivables were growing faster than the revenue growth and in two years, the company’s debt had tripled. In the third year, they took a big write-down on their receivables and the stock declined 80% from the peak. Time and again, I have realized that due to my folly of focusing on the reported profits and sales growth I have missed out the deterioration in the balance sheet and negative cash flows, that ultimately impacted the company financials in the years to come.
- Feedback Loop – I studied a company that made specialized auto tubes and commanded margins upwards of 20%. The management made big claims around growth and claimed they will grow four times in the next five years. A friend whose father ran a steel mill, told me that the reported numbers were too good to be true, as it’s extremely difficult to make these margins in this industry. I ignored that feedback and finally it turned out that there was a big accounting fraud and the company was referred to NCLT. By the time I sold out, there was a 90% loss on my investment.
SN: How can an investor improve the quality of his/her decision making?
GS: One of the best ways to learn from your experience is to build an investing checklist. In my case, I have a checklist that tracks a company over the following aspects –
- Operating metrics
- Financial metrics
- Management track record
- Sector dynamics
- Valuations
- Capital allocation
I try to measure the investments across these metrics and see if they get a minimum score, and only then I choose to consider making an investment. Here is a great resource to build your own set of investment checklist.
Another great tool I have found to improve my decision making is keeping an investment journal. Every time you choose to invest in a stock, write a page highlighting the investment thesis you are making, what kind of returns you are expecting, what are key variables you will track to see if the hypothesis is playing out and the key risks that can make the investing thesis go wrong. Try to distill all of this in a page and keep on referring to it once a year.
Over time, this will help you see which decisions went right and which went wrong. You can analyse the mistakes you have made and what other points you want to add to your checklist.
One aspect I feel an investor should work on, is to build a good temperament. I strongly feel that a big determinant of your long-term investment returns is not high IQ or better research, but a better temperament. Time and again, I have seen that it’s my own behavior that is the biggest enemy of my investment returns. It’s the ability to control your fear and greed (two dominant emotions in investing) that will determine how you can reduce your mistakes, which in turn will help you improve your investment returns.
SN: That’s a great advice, Gaurav. Thanks for sharing! Anyways, how do you think about risk? How do you employ that in your investing?
GS: The traditional definition of risk as defined in terms of volatility and beta is not something I agree with. That definition says that if an asset shows high volatility it is riskier. Say you live in a house whose value is Rs 1 crore and suddenly its price falls by 40% to Rs 60 lakh. Would you now see your house as riskier at Rs 60 lakh, because its price has suddenly fallen? Or would you see it as an opportunity for getting a bargain deal?
For me, the risk on an investment is the potential to permanently lose capital in it. Say you bought a 10-year bond at 8% yield for Rs 1,000. Now because the interest rates went up in the short term, the bond price may fall to say Rs 900. But you are not concerned because you bought the bond for 10 years and you expect to get an interest payment of Rs 80 every year. As long as you are getting the interest and you plan to hold the bond to maturity, the short-term movement in prices of the bond don’t mean anything. Similarly, in stocks, temporary markdowns in prices should be acceptable as long as the underlying performance is as per your original hypothesis.
For me, another aspect of risk is your ability to be patient. There is a famous quote of John Maynard Keynes – “The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.”
There may be times when your investment hypothesis in a stock may be right, but the price behavior does not reflect it. A stock doesn’t know that you have bought it and so it must perform. You must learn to have patience. As a corollary to this, one should not take debt to buy stocks. Leverage can increase risks in an investment exponentially.
To understand more about risks and leverage I strongly recommend reading the book When Genius Failed by Roger Lowenstein.
Over time, one of the key tenets that I have learned to follow on risk is to focus on the downside of the investment and that upside will take care of itself. The question I ask myself is if my thesis is wrong how much the stock can correct from these levels. This strategy has really helped me focus on investment ideas where the risk reward is my favour.
SN: What’s you two-minute advice to someone wanting to get into value investing? What are the pitfalls he/she must be aware of?
GS: Value Investing is a bit of a misnomer. Anyone who buys stock based on fundamentals, will try to buy stock if he thinks the market price is at a discount to what is the intrinsic value. His metrics for judging value can be different and that is what creates the difference in growth style as practiced by Philip Fisher vs value style practiced by Ben Graham.
Investing as a full-time career may sound very appealing especially when you are in bull market like between 2014 to 2017. But there are various challenges that one should be aware of. The lessons I have learnt the hard way and would like people to think before aiming to pursue investing as a fulltime career are –
- Investing styles – Different styles work at different times in the market. At different times in the stock market, different strategies like momentum investing, investing in cyclicals, or investing in quality will give the best returns. So, there is no one best strategy that can be called the holy grail of investing. One should not try to ape an investing style blindly. Read about strategies, apply them by investing and see what strategy temperamentally works for you. Find a style that is best suited to your temperament and circumstances.
- Maintaining your lifestyle – You should not be dependent on returns from investing to maintain your lifestyle. What I mean from this that you should either have other sources of income (eg. rental, professional income, spouse’s salary, business income) that allow you to maintain your lifestyle irrespective of what is happening in the stock market. Alternately, you should have enough savings in debt that the interest income on it allows you to maintain your lifestyle. Once you achieve this, your behavior will be a lot more rational in the stock market and you will have longevity that will then allow your investing style to generate above average returns.
- Learn to be patient – Value investing requires you to make a hypothesis based on fundamentals of a company. Now it may take years for the thesis to play out and in the interim your stock may go down instead of going up, or it underperforms the returns from other stocks. If the investment is performing as per your hypothesis, then you should have the ability to hold on your investment irrespective of whether its price is moving up or down. This patience and courage of conviction is very difficult to practice especially at a time like now in 2018 where small and midcaps are hugely underperforming large caps n midcaps.
- Discipline – Focus on absolute returns on your portfolio and do not be influenced by the returns generated by the best performer in a given year. Those best performers will be different people in different years and typically would be building their returns through leverage. As long as your portfolio is compounding at a rate that is better than you hurdle rate, you are doing a good job. This hurdle rate could be set high in the initial years when one is starting out, but as capital gets built, it is better to reduce your return expectations as besides generating returns one should also aim to preserve capital, which entails taking lower risks.
SN: Which unconventional books/resources do you recommend to a budding investor for learning investing and multidisciplinary thinking?
GS: Some of the books that I find very interesting and have made a big impact in my thought process as an investor are –
- Misbehaving (Richard H Thaler) – This is the best book I have read in the last five years. The author is a pioneer in behavioral economics and won the Noble Prize for economics for 2017. It delves into the role of human behaviour in decision making and backs its analysis with numerous studies and anecdotes from the author’s life. It’s witty and the author doesn’t shy away from questioning the basic tenets of the established economic theory. It has had an enormous influence on how I think about my own biases, and what can be done to minimize their impact.
- Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (Robert B Cialdini) – This is a great book to read on the science of persuasion. The starting point is that we have mental shortcuts that trigger almost automatic responses. This book highlights the various tools that sales guys, marketers, news anchors and politicians use to subtly influence us, so that we take the actions they desire. To understand these biases in yourself and how you can act to minimize their impact, can make a big difference in your life. Alternately, one can use these insights to manage expectations and drive results within our own workplaces and families.
- When Genius Failed (Roger Lowenstein) – This is a vivid tale of failure of one of the most sought-after hedge funds in history – Long Term Capital Management (LTCM). It tracks the hubris of some of the most recognised intellectuals and star Wall Street veterans and their blind faith in mathematical models, that were never supposed to fail till they did. It also highlights the huge risks that can come with any strategy that uses leverage to generate returns. It is a great story for any practitioner of investing to read and take lessons from. As an add-on, the author does a great job of explaining many financial jargons and hedge fund nomenclature for the novice readers.
Besides these books, a great resource for building your critical thinking and ability to see through the haze is the Farnam Street blog.
Your own site Safal Niveshak is very informative. The section on Mental Models is amazing.
SN: Thanks Gaurav! That means a lot. Which investor/investment thinker(s) so you hold in high esteem?
GS: I personally hold Seth Klarman, Charlie Munger and Howard Marks as investors par excellence. There is so much to learn from them not only around investing but also how to live your life. Poor Charlie’s Almanak has been a defining book for me and has been a go-to reference book. The concept of mental models is amazing and allows you to distil your thoughts and many a times – connect the dots.
Seth Klarman has been a big proponent of taking lower risks and being patient. He has the ability to sit on huge amounts of cash if he sees no interesting deals in the market. Despite playing safe, he has one of the best risk-adjusted returns in the last 25 years. From him I have learnt not to be boxed in any one style like growth or value but learn to be opportunistic and to do deep research.
Howard Marks is an excellent communicator, with his quarterly letters eagerly awaited by many in the investment world. His Oaktree funds largely focus on distressed debt and structured transactions, but his insights around market cycles, behavioral biases and analysis of risks have really influenced my investing style.
SN: Hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?
GS: This is a tough one. I have never thought on something like this but will give it a try.
My letter would cover the following points for me –
- Remember that all things good or bad, pass. The only constant is change and learn to live this motto.
- Compounding is the 8th wonder of the world. Learn the true power of compounding and apply it in your life.
- Read through the 50 books that have made the most profound impact on earlier version of me.
- Your world is incomplete without family and friends. Learn to value them and do take out time for them.
- Focus on your health. As you age, your ability to change your body for the better diminishes dramatically.
- Learn to invest in yourself. Strive to put your best effort in whatever you set out to do.
- Above all understand your place in the world and do your bit to make it a bit better.
SN: That’s beautiful! By the way, what other things do you do apart from investing?
GS: I am a big movie buff. My son and I look forward to watching all the big Hollywood blockbusters in the full glory of the movie theatres. We really enjoy discussing the intricacies and nuances and the potential future storylines of the imaginary worlds that are created at such a huge scale. I have lately developed a big interest in standup comedy and I am lucky to be in Gurgaon where there are quite a few gigs happening every week. It’s a great way to chill out with friends and learn to laugh at yourself.
I am an avid reader and like reading biographies and travel books. My wife loves to travel and over time has driven a wanderlust in me too. As I get older, I look forward to traveling around the world and keep ticking off items on my bucket list.
SN: Well, that was great. Thank you, Gaurav, for sharing your insights with me. I wish you the best.
GS: Thank you Vishal for giving me this wonderful opportunity to share my experiences around investing. I have seen Safal Niveshak’s evolution over the past few years and you guys are doing a great job in educating people around investing and understanding risks through your newsletters and workshops. Keep up the good work and best of luck for your journey ahead.[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years