Chetan Phalke is the founding partner at Alpha Invesco, an investment advisory firm based in Pune. Chetan is actively involved in the financial markets for the last 13+ years. He prefers to look at undervalued investment opportunities that offer a reasonable risk-adjusted return over a period of time. Chetan received his masters in Economics from Fergusson College, Pune.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]Safal Niveshak (SN): What are the key factors that shaped your life as an investor and money manager? What inspired you in your early career and how have you evolved over the years?
Chetan Phalke (CP): I come from a middle-class family with no stock market background. I started observing stocks right from my graduation days in 2003-04 after I accidentally landed up at a local stockbroker’s office, thanks to my friend, who had to hand over his father’s documents. This was the time when Indian markets were abuzz with excitement led by the global commodity boom and crazy moves in stock prices across the board. Power stocks were trading at multiple times of book value. India’s infrastructure story was a big rage, and there were at least half a dozen next L&T’s in the making. Then the global financial crisis happened. Markets crashed ferociously during 2008-09.
How you evolve as an investor is also a function of when you start the journey. I saw the entire boom and subsequent bust as a small-time individual investor. My college library had a small investment book section and I ended up reading everything on the shelf during those years, including One Up On Wall Street by Peter Lynch, The Warren Buffett Way by Robert Hagstrom and few others. I used to follow market developments, company announcements, annual reports and note down the observations. By the time markets crashed and settled in 2009, I had just finished my graduation.
I was heavily influenced by Peter Lynch’s ‘buy what you see’ philosophy. By mid-2009, many B2C names were trading at low single-digit PE on normalized earnings, extremely low cash flow multiples, EV to Sales, etc. Decision making was relatively easy. It was more of P&L driven investing. i.e., I would look at growth, P&L, margins, cash flow, low debt, simple capital structure and easy to understand / predictable business. I was relatively new. As they say, the less you know, the more confident you are. Markets bounced back in the following years, the strategy paid off. I was plain lucky to have begun my journey as a full-time investor when valuations were extremely attractive, and I had a lot of room for error.
Paying up for valuations was never known to me and 20 P/E was a perfect time to sell, forget about buying. That opened up my mind to explore opportunities in balance sheet driven investments i.e., underpriced growth, de-leveraging led by cash flow and subsequent increase in the market cap, asset-heavy/capital intensive businesses trading at multi-year lows and so on. To date, I’m driven by attractive entry valuations. I am open to switching between earnings-driven investments vs asset-based investments depending on the entry valuations. However, due to this approach, I have missed out on a few great opportunities either due to selling out too early or giving a pass to stocks that appeared to be richly valued.
SN: How do you find your ideas? What are the necessary conditions that you would look at before you invest in a company and the additional conditions that that will just go about reinforcing your confidence in the company?
CP: There are multiple ways to skin the cat. Over the years, we have built a team of really bright minds within the firm. And everyone has their own way of looking at things. We run various screeners from time to time. Gross margin/contribution margin trends, peak PAT (profit after tax) to current market cap, capacity addition vs earnings growth, insider buying, growth rates, etc.
If any interesting name pops up, we do a deep dive and study the business, management, unit-level economics, cost structure, etc. We do a lot of thematic or top-down reading. Once a theme is shortlisted, then we study individual stocks in the entire value chain. We have a universe of underpriced ideas on the watchlist. If we spot some symptoms of change, or valuations getting into a zone where uncertainty is priced in, such ideas find their way into the portfolio.
Capital allocation and promoter history are important for us. But the opportunity landscape is equally important. If you have a great capital allocator, clean promoter making a niche product in a small addressable market, then one may not benefit even if the investment ticks all the boxes. The sector matters a lot. Quite often investors tend to confuse sectoral tailwinds for management brilliance. At the end of the day, we want to bet on the organization. So the opportunity size, ability to scale, the longevity of the management, enough delegation within the organization is important. Leadership within the segment is critical. Ideally, you don’t want to bet on a fringe player in an industry.
Cash flows, capital efficiency is important, but it is equally important to look at the source of present earnings. Where are the earnings coming from? For example, if it’s an asset-light model, which is thriving at the cost of its suppliers or vendors, is it really sustainable? Especially in times like these when there is a liquidity crunch. Also, what will drive future earnings? Is it the supply side, change in the business profile due to better distribution/selling more high margin products, business entering into newer geographies, new product launches, etc.?
Entry barrier is another key criterion that we prefer to look at. Without entry barriers, there won’t be a big re-rating in the earnings multiples. Ideally, you want to play on a combination of earnings growth plus re-rating over a period. Entry barriers are not necessarily found in consumption or B2C space. It could be a logistic cost advantage due to location. Or for example, capital is scarce for the last 2-3 years. So, access to cheap capital can be a great entry barrier for existing asset-heavy businesses. Since new supply is not coming in, capacity utilization can go up and drive the earnings.
In the end, how much of the good news or the known bad news is priced in? Peak margins, peak profitability, and peak excitement can be a deadly cocktail. No matter how attractive the opportunity looks like, it’s the entry valuations which is more likely to decide whether the investment outcome will be superior or average.
SN: The sheer amount of irrelevant information faced by investors is truly staggering today. Today we find ourselves captives of the information age. Anything you could possibly need to know seems to appear at the touch of the keypad. However, rarely, if ever, do we stop and ask ourselves exactly what we need to know in order to make a good decision.
How can investors trapped by irrelevant information make independent investment decisions? What are the few factors investors can use to improve the quality of their decision making?
CP: The 80:20 rule applies here as well. We will get 80% of the information very quickly. It’s the incremental 20% information which is never enough. You always want to know more. But that’s not possible all the time. So, your ability to act without having full information is very critical. Try and arrive at those 3-4 key parameters that matter the most and track them very closely.
Also, do not get sucked into a broad narrative that is being discussed in the markets or individual stocks. Research yourself for minute details and work on one thing at a time. Look for hard data points from original sources and not for opinions from sell-side reports.
For example, consider the thermal vs renewable energy debate. If one looks at hard data points, baseload has to be supported via thermal power. There is no way that India can grow without thermal power. Once you have the data by yourself, then you can start exploring opportunities in the entire value chain irrespective of all the noise around you.
Most of the time, we tend to search for evidence or information that supports our thinking. To overcome this, try and search for discomforting evidence. That will give you a balanced view of both sides. It allows you to stop for a moment and think for yourself.
SN: A lot of long-time investors have said that they took concentrated bets during the initial phase of their investing life, and later they diversified. How has your journey been on this front? What are your thoughts on concentration vs diversification?
CP: There is no one answer to this debate. Size of the portfolio and your personality matters. In the early stages, your portfolios are small and you can be very nimble. But as the portfolio size changes, your time horizon also changes and so does the allocation.
Your personality is equally important here. If you are the kind of person who likes to stay on top of things with a lot of attention to details, then taking big concentrated bets maybe within your comfort zone. But on the other hand, if you are more of a big-picture investor, then diversification makes a lot of sense.
Sometimes, a large allocation might just tire you out. If your large bet underperforms for a long time, then a lot of self-generated pressure can build up, which may eventually lead to selling the stock exactly at the wrong time. So, it is important to take largely concentrated bets only in your high conviction ideas where you are seeing the hypothesis playing out. And conviction takes some time to build.
A 2% allocation idea might give you miserable outcomes if you make it 20% straightaway. So the idea is to start small and scale up as your conviction goes up. Once you are fully convinced, having done your homework, and having spent enough time with the idea, then underperformance despite hypothesis playing out shall not bother you much.
Also, whether to concentrate or diversify depends on the kind of money you manage. For clients, it is better to have a diversified set of ideas. If it is your own money, which is permanent in nature and you have regular cash flows coming in, then one may go for a concentrated approach. Personally, I have been a concentrated investor since the beginning. But I intend to diversify more as I move forward.
SN: What are your thoughts on investment cycles?
CP: I am a big believer in investment cycles. In every market cycle, you will have a new set of winners and losers. Infrastructure and capital goods in 2007-08, commodities during 2010-11, pharma during 2014-15, small caps during 2017, quality stocks in 2019, and so on.
For example, in India, we haven’t really seen an investment-led economic cycle playing out for a decade. Gross fixed capital formation has fallen from highs of around 40% in 2008. Presently it is around 32% and recovering only gradually. The net profit margin of BSE-500 companies is around 5%, while it used to be 9% in 2008. The margins have bottomed out in 2017 and they are improving now.
The much-awaited across the board earnings recovery hasn’t come through all these years. Earlier due to the global slowdown and policy paralysis during UPA-2. And then due to overcapacities / NPA issues / demonetization / GST implementation / liquidity crisis / slowdown over the last five years.
As a result, earnings are trading at a huge premium while assets are available at historically low valuations i.e., wherever there is earnings certainty with even slight growth potential, market participants are willing to pay a premium and hide in those pockets. But wherever there are solid assets, but no present earnings, investors have completely shunned them.
It presents a great investment opportunity in presently untouchable sectors like PSUs, capital goods, etc. As the broad-based recovery happens, the pendulum should swing the other way and we will see the definition of quality changing as well. Wherever there is growth and earnings, certainty becomes the quality. And the capital flows may move from safety to new areas of growth.
While most of us do bottom-up investing, I think it is very important to be aware of the external environment and the landscape that we are in. In markets like India, there are very few secular growth opportunities available at reasonably good valuations. Irrespective of your investment philosophy, you must be aware of the money supply and broad macro picture, especially if you are a money manager or advising third party money. 2018-2019 has taught us lots of lessons. What you think is trading at 10 year low, can drop to 20-year low despite improving fundamentals. And what you think is expensive at 40 PE, can also go to 80 PE with no change in growth rates. Investment cycles can surprise us and give extreme outcomes almost all the time.
SN: These are wonderful insights. Thanks! Anyways, how do you think about valuations? Are there specific valuation models you prefer over others? If yes, which ones and why?
CP: We don’t really do any financial modeling or DCF or elaborate excel sheets. The earnings assumptions vary depending on the nature of the business. Whether the investment premise is based on capacity utilization, market share gains, import-substitution, entry into new geographies or new categories, etc.
For example, if it’s a tire company, then what’s the number of units it is selling across categories, how much it can sell in the future, and at what price point. Which are the channels through which they are looking to expand i.e., dealers, franchise stores, replacement markets, OEMs, etc. Based on these inputs, you have a broad sense of capital intensity for growth, from where the incremental growth should come from and how the margin profile/cash flows should move. That will give you an idea of peak profits when capacity utilization hits the roof.
Also, we do a cumulative cash flow analysis i.e., in 3-5 years, what can be cumulative cash flow from operations, incremental working capital and how much cash will be left for debt reduction, expansion or dividends. This gives a broad sense of how the balance sheet, ROCE and ROE profiles will look as we move forward.
While checking the capital allocation history, we take cumulative cash flows over the last 3 to 5 years i.e., from where the cash came in and how it was spent. Looking at this exercise in isolation may not be helpful. It is important to study what factors led to those cash flow movements. Whether it was the industry upcycle/downcycle, conscious change in business strategies, asset sale, etc.
It’s a pure common-sense approach based on qualitative factors. Even the promoters don’t know how the business will look like over the next 5-7 years. So, the point is to start with certain assumptions and re-assess whether it is fructifying or not.
SN: What are your thoughts on selling stocks? How does one get discipline into the selling process because there are more biases at work here than when one is buying? What selling rules do you follow?
CP: There is no cardinal rule here. The exit/selling decision depends largely on the original investment premise. If the premise was market share gains, then one can keep holding as long as the market share gains are happening. If the premise was on the undervaluation of a commodity, then one can sell when the valuation reaches fair levels or when there is optimism all around.
If the original investment hypothesis is not playing out, then it is better to just sell and get out. After making a few dumb mistakes, I’ve realized there is no point in giving a long rope to promoters based on their guidance. If the data suggests otherwise, sell despite whatever the guidance, or street excitement is.
Selling is also dependent on the allocation you are okay with. A 10% position might become a 40% allocation once it outperforms. Or there could be a point where you feel, now enough money has been made on this idea, and it’s time to get out. Just like buying, selling is never a perfect or rule-based decision. There will be lots of regrets either way.
A very good investor friend of mine has decided to adopt a rule for selling. Whenever he thinks enough money has been made on a stock, he is going to put a trailing stop loss at 20% and ride it all the way till it gets hit. His idea is to let the market decide where the stock price will go, rather than trying to time the exit.
SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements of themes? What investment process/philosophy you have changed/updated based on your past mistakes? Real-life examples would be helpful.
CP: Well, there are many! But when I look at the source of these mistakes, I would say the allocation mistakes have been a single biggest pain point for me. No matter what level of research you do or the information / analytical edge you have, you can always go wrong.
New, unprecedented things may happen due to international trade, geopolitics, disruption, political cycles, liquidity cycles, competitive intensity, etc. Even if you are highly convinced about an idea, take time to build your position. Build your positions gradually as you get more evidence. The discovery of an idea is not everything. Over a period, you get to know your stocks better. Whenever I’ve rushed in to buy stocks as if there is no tomorrow, I’ve burnt my hands in both buying and selling. The biggest winners have always been the positions that were bought slowly, and accumulated over the years.
In 2013-14, I had built a large position in a poultry stock. Around 50-55% revenue of the company came from poultry, while the other 45% came from animal healthcare, SPF eggs, processed food, refined oil (a by-product after making de-oiled cakes for poultry feed). The company is a market leader in western/northern India, with a secured supply of breed from its parent. The capital structure was tight with no tinkering. Poultry prices were at multi-year lows due to oversupply in the industry. In poultry, almost 70% of the cost is raw material i.e., soya and maize. Raw material prices were high because of rain deficit, lower production. Margins went for a toss and the balance sheet was bloated. However, the business was available at a throwaway valuation of Rs 300 crore market cap. Unit level workings were showing a possibility of this company doing Rs 180-200 crore PBT (profit before tax) once things normalized. A company with extremely high entry barriers with the parent controlling early 75% of the breed supply in the country was available at less than 1.5x PBT. Also, as incomes move up, dietary preferences tend to shift from carbs to proteins. It was a bet on rising income and consumption going up.
We bought the stock aggressively. The stock didn’t go anywhere for almost 3 years. There was no major improvement in the earnings, but volumes were moving up and the supply side was getting adjusted. A major part of the hypothesis was still intact. Broader markets were doing really well during that period. A sense of frustration set in. I literally ‘chickened out’ & sold early. The company did Rs 200 crore PAT in FY18, market cap went all the way to Rs 5,500 crore. Even after the present fall across mid and small caps, the company trades at a valuation of Rs 2,500 crore. When I look back, I got tired and frustrated due to the large allocation. Had it been a small position, it would not have bothered so much.
The key learning here was to buy small on hypothesis and scale up on evidence or symptoms of change. Also, starting small leaves room to add more when valuations go to unreasonable extremes on the downside.
Fast forward to 2018, I forgot to apply the key lesson that I had just learned two years back. After studying the sector for almost a year, we were finally convinced that the Indian steel sector is poised for a 5-7 year upcycle. New supply is just not coming in, while the demand continues to go up by 5-6% per year. Supply-side will continue to remain extremely tight and access to capital remains a huge entry barrier in this industry. Also, given the industry dynamics, greenfield plants are not feasible, so players with brownfield expansion capabilities and underutilized capacities are poised to do really well. Our steel consumption is poised to hit ~200 mn+ tons over the next decade and it takes at least 4 years for a new plant to come up. High entry barriers + high terminal values + decade-low valuations! An ideal combination. We bought the stock aggressively.
However, the industry is facing temporary headwinds due to domestic slowdown and global price correction. The stock price fell from decade-low valuations to two-decade lows. After having learned the lesson from the past, we are not selling the stock too soon as the underlying hypothesis is still intact and is only getting stronger given the industry dynamics. But ideally, we should have been patient with the stock. Buy small and scale up on evidence approach would have allowed us to build positions gradually without having to go through the pain of large drawdown.
Similar things have happened in a couple of other ideas as well. Even if your investment style is concentrated, starting small, scaling up, leaving some room for adding more on downsides makes a real difference.
Also, wherever there is a combination of capital misallocation + no evidence of de-leveraging in the past + business highly dependent on the government + no respect for equity, if the stock ticks all the boxes, no matter what the odds are, just stay away.
SN: What are your thoughts on disruption and its impact on businesses and industries? How do you think about investment risk in a world that’s highly disruptive?
CP: Disruption has always been a part of the real business world. In the early 19th century, horse carts were replaced by cars. Then fiber optic replaced copper wires in the 1970s, causing a huge disruption in the copper industry. Internet disrupted various industries including print media. The cell phones killed wristwatches, digital cameras. The list can go on. As you rightly pointed out in the earlier part of the interview, we live in an era where too much information is floating around. This idea of disruption has got a very high mind share in our day to day lives.
As for the impact of disruption on businesses and industries, I just don’t know! So rather than pre-empting disruption in certain segments and trying to find a winner, I would prefer to bet on businesses that are less likely to get disrupted. I just want to make sure that odds are in favor when I start and then improvise, keep on re-assessing on the go.
For example, take television media. The market cap of Indian TV media companies is ridiculously low. As consumption grows, television is one of the most effective mediums for advertisers to reach out to a billion people. There are 800+ entertainment and news channels in India. The number is just not sustainable. It may not be a 20% growth industry, but consolidation is inevitable. Under the new tariff order, it becomes very difficult for standalone channels to survive due to carriage fees. Television networks with the ability to create great content, have multiple genres across languages that are likely to get even stronger due to the sheer scale, reach and their ability to monetize content. After all, it’s the content owner who controls the game. OTT, Television, Internet are merely pipes via which you distribute and monetize the content.
However, there is a disruption narrative here. Investors fear media getting ‘Netflixed!’ But if you study the Netflix model, you will realize the game is moving away from content distribution platforms to content owners. 70-80% shelf life of Netflix content gets over within the first two years. But they are amortizing the library over 10 years. This inflates their accounting earnings. Also, Netflix will have to keep on burning US$ 3-4 billion every year to keep the content library updated. While we remember House Of Cards, Sacred Games, Narcos, how many other Netflix originals have you binge-watched? And how many others have been discussed within your friend circles? They may not even recover the production costs.
The point is, given the business model and necessity to keep on investing billions of dollars to create content, Netflix may not be able to offer content at lower prices to price-sensitive Indian customers for a very long time. In India, the average monthly DTH connection bill for a wide variety of content is less than Rs 250. The same thing applies to other content distribution platforms. Ultimately, it’s the content owners who stand to benefit by leveraging the online ecosystem.
SN: What are your thoughts on the issue of corporate governance in India? How does a minority investor assess governance that is such a tricky subject? Are there thumb rules you follow to test governance levels?
CP: Unlike their global counterparts, Indian companies are run by promoters with extended families, government officers (for PSUs), and not by professionals. Most of the businesses need to engage with various government departments for permissions, approvals, etc. You are a part of the system. Red tape culture in the bureaucratic set up is well known to everyone here. We must keep that in mind. Expecting a perfect promoter is like expecting idealistic things in a non-idealistic world. Let say there are 10 shades of grey. Are you okay till 3rd and 4th shades, or are you willing to go down till 6th or 7th in your quest to find value? It really depends on your tolerance level.
Very few companies in India are run with a gold standard corporate governance. Perhaps that’s how we see them trading at such high multiples.
SN: Which are some the books on investing, behavior, and multidisciplinary thinking that have inspired you the most over the years? If you were to give away all your books but one, which one would it be and why?
CP: Recently I read ‘Masterclass With Super Investors’ by Vishal Mittal and Saurabh Basrar. It’s a compilation of interviews with various investors who have successfully navigated through Indian markets over the last few decades. It is one of those very few books which gives you insights on investing from the Indian context. While reading the book, one may realize that there are no standard rules in investing and your investment style is driven by your personality. Also, one can notice how almost all investors changed their investment styles as they moved from one cycle to the next.
On similar lines, I will highly recommend reading ‘India Uninc’ written by R. Vaidyanathan. It gives you some fascinating insights into how diverse the Indian economy is and the way it is structured.
SN: Who are some of the people – inside or outside the value investing circles – who have inspired you the most over the years, and why?
CP: From inside investing circles, there are quite a few friends, mentors who have influenced my investment approach and inspired me over the years. I’m lucky to have mentors who are approachable, give their feedback and are willing to share their knowledge with me.
Outside investing circles, I admire ‘Subhash Bose’. He is a great example of how perseverance can make you aspire and achieve the greatest things in life. Just be at it, and you can create wonders even if you begin with no resources. I’m a great fan of Indian history and spirituality. There are so many inspirational personalities, tales and learnings from our own history.
SN: Hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?
CP: Well – instead of a letter, I would write few pointers and keep them with me –
- It’s okay to make mistakes. Be in life or investing. Even if you made one, wipe your tears and move on. Your best is ahead of you.
- Understand that India is a different market. It’s like a country within a country. Don’t get carried away with the size of the opportunity narrative alone.
- Most things are cyclical in nature, be it business cycles or corporate governance.
- Find good mentors and peers, with whom you can debate, seek alternative views.
- Don’t be a victim of your own image. Be flexible in your investment approach. Unlearning is more important than learning.
- Discovery of an idea is not everything. Start small and scale-up. Be patient.
- Prepare yourself for investment performance which is not in line with the markets.
- Be humble. Worst investing mistakes happen in the best of the time.
- Randomness and luck play a big role in the world of investing.
SN: What other things do you do apart from investing? What’s your daily routine?
CP: There are benefits of being a Punekar (resident of Pune). There are lots of options around the city if you just want to go for long walks, short treks, or for a run. I’m trying to catch up with meditation now. Recently, I attended a 10-day vipassana course. Let’s see how it goes from here on. I’m a big fan of good music and good food.
My day starts early with a short run. My daily routine is pretty random. Depending on the priorities of the day, I may be reading something or working with my colleagues on several assignments. [/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years