• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Investor Insights: Amit Mantri

October 30, 2018

Amit Mantri is the co-founder of 2Point2 Capital, a SEBI-registered Portfolio Management Service (PMS). Previously, he was a Vice-President at Hornbill Capital, a Mumbai based hedge fund. Prior to Hornbill, he has been part of the private equity investment team at IDFC Alternatives and Zephyr Peacock.

Amit has a Post-Graduate Diploma in Management from IIM Bangalore and B. Tech in Computer Science and Engineering from IIT Kharagpur. He is also a CFA® charter holder.

In this interview, Amit shares his thoughts on investing, his process, and the key lessons he has learned over the years of being an investor.

[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Safal Niveshak (SN): Could you tell us a little about your background, what got you to value investing, and how you have evolved as an investor?

Amit Mantri (AM): I am a failed techie who at a very early age fell in love with the world of business, finance and investing. This was largely due to my family background – both my elder brothers have careers in the markets as well.

I became a value investor after I came across books on Buffett and Munger (originally bought by my brothers). I then ended up reading most of the investing classics. Buffett’s annual letters had a big influence on me. When I started investing I tried to use the value investing principles to make investment decisions. I made several mistakes initially – clearly just having read about investing was not enough. I am trying to learn from the blunders and still evolving as an investor.

SN: You manage other people’s money. Please talk more about your investment philosophy here and what you are aiming at while taking money from your clients.

AM: At 2Point2 Capital, we have a very simple investment philosophy. We are looking to invest in good businesses run by ethical entrepreneurs which are available at a reasonable price. This is very similar to what every Buffett/Munger follower does.

We have a very high focus on corporate governance as we believe governance risks are significantly underestimated in India. We believe that if we just do sensible investing and avoid major blunders, we should be able to deliver good returns for our clients without taking large risks. So far this has worked quite well for us.

SN: What kind of fundamental analysis do you do, or the process you use, while selecting businesses you invest in? What is your broader checklist like?

AM: The focus is just on understanding the business and industry that we are looking to invest in. We spend a lot of time trying to understand why a company can make profits and why it is likely to do so in the future as well. Sometimes this is obvious but often we must talk to customers/competitors to get a better understanding.

Once we have understood the business, we then try to understand the future potential of the company. The focus is on trying to understand what the demand for the company’s goods and services would be over the next couple of decades. This is probably where we make many errors as a difference in 10% and 20% growth potential could lead to 100% difference in the price we would be willing to pay for a company. To ensure that these errors don’t lead to big losses, we try to be conservative in our projections leading to some margin of safety.

We are not highly growth focused and are very happy to invest in companies which are good businesses with high ROE and cash flows but have a lower growth trajectory.

SN: As I read about you, and some of your work, you have built a competency in forensic analysis of financials, which is unique. What made you delve deeper into this specific area of expertise? Did it start with a mistake?

AM: Yes, some of my early investments turned out to be massive duds as I had blindly relied on audited financial statements and management guidance and got defrauded. These were some costly lessons.

As I tried to learn from my errors and those of other investors in India, I realized that the Indian equity market has many crooks seeking to become rich by conning shareholders.

A weak legal and regulatory system and lack of investigative journalists/short sellers who are incentivized to expose such frauds has allowed fraudsters to thrive without any consequences. These are not just one-offs like Satyam but broader systemic problems.

As the system is unlikely to protect you from such landmines, it was important to build capabilities to ensure that we don’t become victims.

Over the last few years, we have spent a lot of time trying to understand the games conmen play and their methods (in India and other markets). This has allowed us to build capabilities to identify frauds at an early stage. While we don’t think it’s possible to completely eliminate corporate governance risks, we can definitely avoid major blunders.

SN: That’s great! So, what kind of a checklist do you have to identify tricks managements may be using to cook their books? Please share some real-life examples of what you saw in companies that put you on high alert regarding the quality of their numbers.

AM: Our checklist to identify cooking of books has largely been formed by studying other frauds. Most managements end up using similar tricks, so it helps to know the tricks used by others in the past.

We should be wary of companies reporting exceptionally good numbers. If the numbers are too good to be true, they rarely are. I often refer to a Harry Markopolos’ quote – “Assume fraud until genius is proven.”

When we find extraordinary performance, we should demand extraordinary proof to be able to justify the performance. For example, it is obvious to even a layman that a Royal Enfield (Eicher Motors) or Jockey (Page Industries) must be extremely profitable businesses. However, a B2B textile manufacturer making 35%+ EBITDA margins and pre-tax ROCE of 80%+ is difficult to digest considering such businesses rarely make even a 15% margin and lack a strong moat.

Then, a common trick used by managements is to report opex as capex thus showing very high profitability which also leads to a high stock price as investors apply a P/E multiple on fictional profits. The P&L of such a company gives a very rosy picture. However, the cash flow statement paints a very scary picture. We should treat a company’s inability to generate positive Free Cash Flow over long periods as a red flag.

In many cases just studying the individual line items in a company’s P&L and Balance Sheet throws up some surprising information. We had studied a company which was incurring more than Rs 550 crore in capex on computers despite having only 700 employees! This comes to Rs 80 lakh per employee – an absurdly high number.

Another company’s senior management compensation was abysmally low and closer to that earned by freshers at IT companies. In both these cases, we found far more serious issues when we dug deeper.

SN: Yes, as they say there’s never just one cockroach in the kitchen.

AM: Right Vishal. Just studying the financials is not enough in many cases as fraudsters are becoming more sophisticated in dressing up the numbers. On-ground checks and talking to customers/competitors/ex-employees helps in identifying companies which only exist in the stock market but have no significant real-world presence.

SN: Your website suggests that your investment philosophy is guided by the value investing principle of buying a security at a discount to its intrinsic value. My question is – How do you think about intrinsic value? Is there a specific valuation model you prefer over other?

AM: We largely rely on discounted cash flow for estimates of intrinsic value. We don’t build a complex valuation model but rely on broad ranges of estimates. Even when we refer to P/E or EV/EBITDA multiples, we are largely using them as a heuristic.

A P/E multiple also implies a certain estimate of future cash flows. So, we don’t think multiples are inferior to DCF. You will have a wrong intrinsic value calculation only when multiples are used without an understanding of the underlying assumptions.

For example, if you are valuing a company at 100x P/E, it is not enough if the company has a high very ROE or cash flows. It also needs to have a very high earnings growth rate for many years into the future.

SN: When you look back at your investment mistakes, were there any common elements of themes? A real-life example would be helpful.

AM: The most common investment mistakes were when what I thought to be a great business with excellent prospects turned out to be a complete fraud. This happened a lot early in my career. These mistakes were particularly painful as the loss was near 100%.

Several years back I was part of the team that invested in an unlisted IT services company which was growing a rapid pace, had high ROEs and a visionary promoter. After our investment, the company continued to report some great numbers and the stock price doubled in a short period of time.

As the business was doing so well, we bought more of the company at 2x our initial price. At that time, it seemed like a no-brainer investment. A few months later we found out that this company was cooking its books and its entire profit history was made up. We had to write down our entire investment and our portfolio took a major hit.

The learnings from this mistake have made me a better investor. I don’t think over the last five years I have lost money due to fraud or a serious governance issue.

SN: How can an investor improve the quality of his/her decision making? What have you done in this regard over the years?

AM: Becoming aware of your limitations is very helpful in improving the quality of the decisions. We like to believe that we have the right answers to very complex decisions be it on RBI’s monetary policy or cricket team selections despite them falling outside most people’s circle of competence. If we take more decisions that fall in our circle of competence the overall quality of decision making improves.

I have increased my reliance on base rates for decisions on complex issues. For example, instead of trying to predict if a business can grow earnings at 20% per annum over the next annum, it is probably better to study what is the base rate of companies growing at such a pace and what are the typical characteristics of these companies. I believe understanding base rates will improve most people’s quality of decisions.

SN: That’s a nice point on using base rates in decision making. Anyways, which unconventional books/resources do you recommend to a budding investor for learning investing and multidisciplinary thinking? If you were to give away all your books but one, which one would it be and why?

AM: One book that I liked a lot but isn’t well known among the investing community is Scott Fearon’s Dead Companies Walking. Most investing books focus on identifying good companies and investment strategies. This book helps you avoid bad businesses which is an equally important part of investing.

I try to read stuff on technology because tech is increasingly having an impact across industries. Ben Thompson’s blog Stratechery is the best when it comes to understanding tech businesses. Shane Parrish’s Farnam Street blog is a must read on mental models and decision making.

I would hold on to my Calvin and Hobbes collection. These strips are timeless. Apart from being extremely funny, they deal with many moral, political, cultural, economic and environmental issues in a very simple way.

SN: I would second your choice of Calvin and Hobbes! Anyways, which investor/investment thinker(s) so you hold in high esteem?

AM: Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Howard Marks, Jim Chanos, Peter Lynch, etc. It’s a very long list. Among Indian investors, I read and listen to Sanjay Bakshi, Rajeev Thakkar and Manish Chokhani among many others.

SN: Hypothetical question: Let’s say that you knew you were going to lose all your memory the next morning. Briefly, what would you write in a letter to yourself, so that you could begin relearning everything starting the next day?

AM: Keep asking questions.

SN: What other things do you do apart from investing?

AM: A large part of the non-work time goes in playing with my one-year old son who is extremely demanding of my time. I read a lot. It used to largely read books earlier but now it is mostly on the internet. Movies and theatre are other favorite pastimes.

SN: Thank you Amit for sharing your insights with me. I wish you the best.

AM: Thanks Vishal![/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members

 

  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years

Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe

[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Interviews

Handcrafted with in India